The "Stand Your Ground Law" Should Not Be A Law

755 words - 4 pages

Seventeen years ago, in a small town towards the southern part of Oregon, Springfield, a well-known mechanic went into a fast-food restaurant, walked behind a man who was eating lunch, and shot him in the back of the head. There had not been any sign of altercation that the man who was shot was carrying a firearm. But the shooter thought that the dead man had threatened his daughter. A local lawyer said that the dead man was in fact “a violent man, a drug dealer by trade.” Some people believe that the shooter should have left the case to the police, the local lawyer said, but the victim should also have “moderated his behavior.” George Zimmerman, a neighborhood-watch volunteer/wanna-be cop, ...view middle of the document...

"

The section that is most talked about of that law relates to the fact that there is no "duty to retreat," which means that in “non-stand your ground” states one must first attempt to get as far away as possible if they can. In Florida, however, the law does not require that and the shooter may "stand their ground" when shooting a firearm in self defense. But the “duty to retreat” was not an issue at all in either Zimmerman or Dunn. In both cases the defendants argued that deadly force was used because they "reasonably" believed that it was necessary to prevent serious accidents such as death or severe body injury. That is no different than the law in almost every other state.

“The U.S. Commission on Civil Rights is investigating the enforcement of Stand Your Ground laws because there is not enough data on how effective they have been.” Michael Yaki, a commissioner, said: “There is an absolute lack of real data or information about how these Stand Your Ground laws have been or are...

Find Another Essay On The "Stand Your Ground Law" Should Not be a Law

stand your ground Essay

1649 words - 7 pages stand-your-ground law needs to be improved. “Florida’s law is not clear to those who must apply it as to what constitutes provocation by an aggressor. If law enforcement does not know when following someone, using harsh language or physical contact arise to the level of provocation, they have no way of knowing who is the aggressor and who is a victim in a situation where both parties eventually resort to force.” (Thurston Jr.) Thurston’s

Stand Your Ground? Essay

1047 words - 4 pages in answering them. At the center, of the controversy surrounding the shooting death of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin is a Florida law that changed America's definition of self-defense. Florida has a "stand your Miars 2 ground" law that allows residents to use deadly force to protect themselves no matter where they are. This event is proof that this law goes too far, but yet in this article it is not mentioned once. The shooter, George

The Fight Part 3 Stand Your Ground

1915 words - 8 pages , you mean the one you murdered in cold blood. Yeah, Alex told me what you did. I don't need to explain myself to you, you're a subordinate. Yes you do you arrogant bastard, you don't just get to kill a child and then do a run through on your own daughter's mind to stop her because she is the only one who even tried to stand up to you. The only one even aware what you were up to with the backbone to stand up to you unlike Alex even now my brother still admires you too much to confront you not just about this but about what an arse-hole you've been since your friends died.

Should English Be the Law?

1175 words - 5 pages advocacy group. La Raza strongly agrees that english should be learned and this is why they have helped many immigrants learn english so that they are able to go out into the world and have a successful life. Cecilia Muñoz, vice president of La Raza states “you cannot pass a law declaring English the national language and magically expect everyone to know the language overnight.” Muñoz has a point, there are steps the government must take before

Should There Be A Law Against Paparazzi?

509 words - 2 pages be famous. The glitter would fade away into gray mist like a fog. The famous gave up a large measure of privacy for the brighter, larger world of glitter. It’s living globally, everyone knows where you are and when and also every gritty little detail of your personal lifestyle. Privacy is not part of language. Photographers do have the right to follow public figures, newsmakers, and celebrities in order to snap their photos. A line should be

Criminal Law: Should there be a crime of corporate manslaughter?

2580 words - 10 pages INTRODUCTION.The evolution of corporate criminal liability perhaps reaches its apex in the prosecution of manslaughter. The criminal law, although designed to determine the responsibility of natural persons is remodelled when the employer is not a person. Presumably this predicates the dilemma, which legislators confront in determining the limits of the criminal sanction and whether or not a corporation can be ascribed guilt in

Should The Voter Identification Law be in Place?

961 words - 4 pages The “Election and voting: Voter Identification” is a debate between three sides with different opinions about the voter identification law. Each side is represented by Chandler Davidson, Hans von Spakovsky, and Edward Foley. This debate is about whether the voter identification laws should be in place or not. Davidson is against the voting id laws stating its historical context and how it will affect the minorities, older and student during the

Religion, politics and the law should be allowed to mix

1264 words - 5 pages , resulting from a group's beliefs and practices. In summary, religion is a systematic theory that is esteemed worthy of respect or dedication by a congregated group of people.The topic 'Religion, law, and politics should they be allowed to mix' does not pose questions of the functionality of their union. According to the American Heritage Dictionary (2006), 'should' is used to "express probability or expectation." It is very probable that religion

Whyu The State Curfew Law Should Be Abolished

867 words - 3 pages Why The State Curfew Law Should Be Abolished I remember answering the telephone at 5:30 AM on a Saturday morning in November like it was yesterday. It was a policeman telling me that my brother had been taken to juvenile, he did not state that reason my brother had been taken there. So immediately thoughts began running through my mind; Was my brother in a fight? Did he shoot someone? Did he commit some kind of crime? When I told my mother that

The Glaring Problems Hidden in the Similarities of the Stand Your Ground and Castle Doctrine Laws

1080 words - 5 pages this notion. Persons do not have a duty to retreat or flee from their justified ground, and are lawfully permitted to defend themselves, if there is a perceived or believed threat. Under this law, the individual is justified to use the necessary force to protect their persons. “Twenty states, excluding Connecticut, have stand-your-ground laws. Generally, these laws require the person to (1) have a legal right to be at the location and (2) not

Law Should Be Influenced By Religion

3145 words - 13 pages freedom to manifest her religious beliefs under Article 9 was justified, as it was prescribed by law, and necessary for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others. While not a criminal case, it is contended that the Law be generally applicable. If a law prohibits a certain action, religious justifications should not necessarily circumvent it. This contention may be buttressed using Andrews . The appellant, a Rastafarian appealed against his

Similar Essays

Stand Your Ground Law Essay

2222 words - 9 pages one single category may fail to capture the overall impact of these other self-defense provisions well. An individual may argue that the rise in homicides found in our study may be driven by murders that are justified by the Stand Your Ground laws, implying deaths that occur while law-abiding citizens are protecting themselves from attackers and that this should not be seen as a negative result. It is possible, that some of the additional

Stand Your Groung Law Essay

2222 words - 9 pages one single category may fail to capture the overall impact of these other self-defense provisions well. An individual may argue that the rise in homicides found in our study may be driven by murders that are justified by the Stand Your Ground laws, implying deaths that occur while law-abiding citizens are protecting themselves from attackers and that this should not be seen as a negative result. It is possible, that some of the additional

The Laws Regarding Stand Your Ground Not Being Equally Applied

1871 words - 8 pages Trayvon Martin was shot and killed on February 26, 2012 in Sanford, Florida by George Zimmerman. Zimmerman was the neighborhood watch coordinator. The laws regarding Stand your ground was only applying to Mr. Zimmerman and he was acquitted on July 13, 2013. Why did this law only apply to George Zimmerman and not Trayvon Martin? Debate Final The night of February 26, 2012 Trayvon Martin was visiting with his father, he had been suspended from

Stand Your Ground Essay

1567 words - 7 pages allow people to protect themselves if and when their lives are in a danger, however people are only beginning to abuse it. I feel this law gives people the impression that they can start an altercation and then use deadly force once they begin to feel threatened. Furthermore, I feel the Stand Your Ground Law should be more regulated. In my opinion, there are too many loopholes in it. The Stand Your Ground Laws have not decreased the number of murders