This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Reputation Of Christopher Columbus Essay

2360 words - 9 pages

The Reputation of Christopher Columbus

When judging a person's importance in history it becomes hard not to
judge that person without characterizing their achievements as either negative
or positive. It becomes even harder when all of the facts are not known and
when a reputation has already been established. Christopher Columbus is such
a person. Through history, from the time he sailed to the present, debate as
to whether this man should be deemed a hero or a villain has raged. Facts
about his life have been tainted by embellishments and myths have been
accepted as truths. So how does one come to a conclusion about this man?
History has hardly taken a middle ground on Columbus, from his own sons
writings to present day students in classrooms. Historical debate of
Columbus will always continue. His life has been scrutinized by his
contemporaries, the hero makers, the historical progressives and especially
now in the times of multi-culturalism.

The story of Columbus is one of misunderstandings and embellishments and
the myths of his voyages begin with himself. For it was he who reported to
the monarchy of his efforts and achievements and it was he who took all of the
glory. The first to establish Columbus as a classical hero was his own son
Ferdinand. He took the life of his father, as told to him by his father. The
true background of Columbus is one of mystery as of today because the only
writings by Columbus himself have been proven false. Ferdinand used the
documents of his father's voyages that give the first real account of Columbus
and his times.

But early on Columbus was not without his detractors including his own
patron Isabella. Even though Columbus gained the backing from the Spanish
Monarch it was not a friendly relationship. Columbus tried to play the King
and Queen as if he was doing a favor to them with his voyages and when he
returned to the Court with 500 Arawak Indians the Queen was not a happy Queen.
Her assessment of Columbus was that he was an arrogant, megalomaniac.5 She
and some others did not agree with the ideals that Columbus passed on in the
New World. The other major critic of Columbus during this time was Las Casas.
He, however, was not necessarily opposed to the actions of Columbus as far as
his adventures. Most of his complaints dealt with the treatment of the
Natives by Columbus and his men. What actions Columbus accepted his men doing
was what Las Casas wrote about, but at the same time praised Columbus for his
Christian beliefs. Las Casas stated, " He it was who gave the light by which
all others might see how to discover."4 It is safe to say that Las Casas was
one of the first to see that the accomplishments of Columbus were of terrific
importance, but that they should be weighed against the consequences of his
actions against the natives.

The reason for the lack of information about Columbus can be attributed
to the...

Find Another Essay On The Reputation of Christopher Columbus

The True Importance of Christopher Columbus

659 words - 3 pages way the other Europeans treated the natives of the land that we cherish so much! Columbus was a hero, he discovered the New World. I don't think so, the man may have had ideals before he set sail, but from the looks of it he was just another greedy, sick little man who found his pleasures in the suffering of the others. Man of courage or man of cruelty, the choice is yours to decide, but I've already made my choice.Work Cited: Loewen, James W. "The True Importance of Christopher Columbus." Lies My Teacher Told Me. Simon and Schuster. New York: New York, 1995.18-36

The True Importance of Christopher Columbus

636 words - 3 pages Columbus is considered by most Americans to be the courageous man who discovered the new world and the man who would transverse so much difficulty to do what he holds dearest to his heart, discover! Now that I'm done with the cute version of the lies that most children must be taught in order to become an active person in society, I'll tell you the truth about what that man that we hold so dear was really doing on those Islands of the New World

Day in the Life of Christopher Columbus

536 words - 2 pages A Day in the Life of Christopher ColumbusLogbook of the Santa MariaCaptain's Entry August 3, 1492I cannot believe it! After being turned down repeatedly by King John II of Portugal, the Spanish monarchs, and the King of England, my hard work and persistence has finally paid off. King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella of Spain have agreed to finance my expedition after I spent eight years trying to convince someone that it is possible to find a direct

Christopher Columbus: The Villain

507 words - 2 pages many reasons why people think he is good as well there are many reasons why they think he is bad. Personally I think Columbus is a villain, he did a lot of bad things that most people don’t know a bout. However if they know them, it would make them think a little bit deeper if Columbus is the Hero that we all thought he was once in our lives. Christopher Columbus can in no way, be considered a hero. A hero is someone who performs good deeds

Christopher Columbus, the Conquerer

1145 words - 5 pages Christopher Columbus, the Conquerer Depending on how you look at it, Christopher Columbus was either a great man of adventure and achievement Or the kind of person that does not see shame in killing and enslaving thousand of Native Americans. Christopher Columbus came to America in hopes of finding new land, new opportunities, and gold. On the view of the Spaniards side he was helping them expand a money thirsty empire. He was helping route

Christopher Columbus: The Hero

1410 words - 6 pages It is thought by many that Christopher Columbus was a skilled sailor on a mission of greed. Many think that he in fact did it all for the money, honor and the status that comes with an explorer, but this is not the case entirely. Columbus was an adventurer and was enthused by the thrill of the quest of the unknown. “Columbus had a firm religious faith and a scientific curiosity, a zest for life, the felling for beauty and the striving

Voyage of Christopher Columbus

1307 words - 5 pages As some of you may already know our very own Spanish- Italian navigator, Christopher Columbus, is planning to embark on an impeccable journey in search of a shorter route to Asia. I, Martín Alonso Pinzón, being one of the most prominent sailors and navigators of Spain, strongly encourage you to accompany us on this world changing expedition. We as Europeans in the fifteenth century, are beginning to embark on a series of global explorations

The Navigation of Christopher Columbus and the Age of Discovery

5022 words - 20 pages presented by those who, for their own reasons, attempt to present him as some sort of insane idiot, or, at best, an extremely lucky savant. What is true about Christopher Columbus is that, for the times in which he lived, he was a well read and learned geographer. Columbus was a student of navigation and sailing, and as such, his understanding of the world in which he lived was based on works previously completed by others. Given this, it

Another Side of Christopher Columbus

757 words - 3 pages . However primitive these people were, they were very organized. In a much busier world (Spain), lived a very adventurous, religious, and loyal man named Christopher Columbus. Born in Genoa, Italy, Christopher Columbus was the son of a very skilled weaver. He was an expert sailor, thus earning the title of “Admiral of the Ocean Sea” for himself after his successful expeditions. He had a favorite ship, Santa Maria although he had two other ships (Nina

A Brief Biography of Christopher Columbus

1161 words - 5 pages Little may one know about Christopher Columbus, other than the fact that “Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492”. Even though he was claimed to have discovered the Americas, he was never the first to arrive there because (according to historians) the Vikings were there first. But, his discovery led other people in Europe know about the Americas therefore changing the world. Columbus shaped the world as we know it today. Columbus was born

The Debate about Honoring Christopher Columbus

506 words - 2 pages Thru history studies in grade school and secondary school students are taught of the great explorer who discovered America, Christopher Columbus. Tales of his many voyages and the names of his ships the Nina, Pinta, and Santa Maria are engrained into the minds of children through rhyme and song. For many years the history written in text books have been regard as fact however information provided by Howard Zinn excerpt has shed new light on the

Similar Essays

The Voyage Of Christopher Columbus Essay

1513 words - 6 pages American History I Christopher Columbus' Voyage to North America Spanish exploration first began with a series of revolutions. First, the Commercial Revolution generated economic stability. Second, the Intellectual Revolution generated interest in the Earth's composition and the pursuit of exploration. Europe then called for a political revolution to end the disorganized and disorderly rule of its government. This revolution returned

The True Story Of Christopher Columbus

1096 words - 4 pages He discovered the Americas. He started the first colony in the new world. He thought he was in Asia. Who is this brave explorer? Christopher Columbus. Smart and Wise Christopher Columbus was during his voyages. Christopher Columbus’s birth date is unknown but believed to be between August 25 and October 31, 1451 in Genoa, Italy (Columbus, “Early Years of Boyhood” par 1-3). His parents were Domenico Columbo and Susanna Fontanarossa

The Dark Truth Of Christopher Columbus

1042 words - 4 pages Christopher Columbus was an Italian sailor and explorer who travelled across the Atlantic Ocean in 1942, in search of a quick route to India Spice trading, which was at the time the largest industry in the world. Columbus made a total of 4 trips between 1492 - 1504 Columbus throughout time has been revered to as a hero, and the reason that many of us are even settled on this land, but there are many dark truths that will be touched upon

The Discovery Of America By Christopher Columbus

716 words - 3 pages Perestrello and married her. Shortly after their marriage his wife Filipa gave birth to their son Diego in 1480. In 1485 Columbus’s wife died. For a better life, Columbus and his son went to Spain. After receiving approval from the King and Queen of Spain, Columbus set sail on August 3, 1492. He used 3 ships on his voyage, the Pinta, Nina, and the Santa Maria. After 2 months at sea, a ship member, Rodrigo de Triana, spotted land on October 12