This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The State As One Actor Amongst Many

2387 words - 10 pages

The sovereign nature of states is a topic that has come into question towards the end of the last century. Many advancements and changes, both within and outside borders, have brought into some doubt whether the state is indeed as strong an actor within its borders as it once was. By analysing internal and external influences on the governments of the UK and USA in the twentieth century, it is possible to judge how the nature of power has changed. I will argue that a gradual progression of events, in particular marketisation of the economy and growing dependence on supranational bodies such as the EU and the international economy, have clearly reduced the state to an actor that still retains some control, but is struggling for sovereignty against external interference and internal competition.
There are two competing schools of thought at work, each with underlying principles and answers to the aforementioned question. Postmodernists agree that the state has become “one actor amongst many”. Postmodernism “depends upon a radical rejection of the past and of all attempts to use the past to understand the present,” and rejects “that history can be interpreted as moving towards a definite goal.” (Gamble, 2000:20-21) Postmodernists also see the decision-making process as pluralistic, spread across departments and organisations with different goals and specialisations, and no one group having absolute power. This means that they see the state as increasingly “hollow”, with recent political changes, due to the delegation of responsibility and use of multiple actors. Late modernity, on the other hand, is the theory that we are still in a state of modernity; that society is developing in a unilinear and purposeful way with clear hierarchy. Modernists are of the belief that history of the state is evolutionary. They believe that states and individuals had, and still retain, the power to intervene and influence society. From the perspective of modernists, change can be seen as “new forms of state power developing on the existing structures and institutions.” (Smith, 2009:90)
It is also necessary to define what is meant by a modern liberal democracy. According to Schumpeter, democratic society is one that has the “institutional arrangement for arriving at political decisions in which individuals acquire the power to decide by means of a competitive struggle for the people’s vote.” (1950:269) On top of this, the modern state has the key features of legitimacy, sovereignty of one territory, bureaucracy and a monopoly of legitimate force (Smith, 2009:91). There is a balance between control of citizens and protection of liberty, and recent domestic and global changes have shifted this ratio.

Firstly we will look at internal challenges to the sovereignty of the state. In the 1980s, Britain and America were heavily influenced by neo-liberal philosophies, spearheaded by Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, and continued under the Major administration in the UK...

Find Another Essay On The State as One Actor Amongst Many

One of the Many Human Characteristics

1606 words - 6 pages spiritual crisis for Donne…” It seems certain events occurred in John Donne’s life that led him to feel complete hopelessness which led him to desperation. One major event that seriously affected him and drove him into deep depression, hopelessness, and desperation was the loss of his identity and role in life. “In 1602 he had been dismissed from his post as secretary to Sir Thomas Egerton, Elizabeth’s lord keeper, on account of his unauthorized

The Defeat of Many by One

1564 words - 6 pages The Defeat of Many by One In The Moor’s Last Sigh, Salman Rushdie uses the complex and changing character of the Moor to represent a complex and changing image of India. By making the eclectic family history of the Da-Gama Zogoiby family the central theme in the first two parts of the novel, Rushdie portrays India as a culturally and religiously pluralistic society. This pluralistic society is layered by violence caused by the corruption

The People as One

2284 words - 10 pages nation’s welfare and relations followed suit, all in good intentions and most yielding positive results. Many endeavors and innovations have been pursued by the Marcos administration and with these projects the country has been able to progress further into achieving growth in the economy and recognition in the world. As many as these ventures are assuring not all of these proved to have the effect that is desired, for one some of the projects

The Nation as One

706 words - 3 pages The Nation as One Celebrating the death of a person usually starts with a lamentatious mood and grief. “Celebrating”, perhaps, is a misleading word as in today’s society, celebration is linked with parties and events of fun and joy. In Walt Whitman’s book “When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom’d” (“Lilacs”), he describes the “celebration” of Lincoln’s death throughout the country. Whitman conveys the glum mood of America after their beloved

The massacre at My Lai is one of the many

927 words - 4 pages ) This is no parallel to the tragedy that was My Lai, but it represents the same sort of personality disorder that was shown in My Lai.A different perspective on the My Lai incident does not even indirectly blame Calley for the atrocities that went on, though many soldiers directly blame Calley. Instead one could blame the Vietnam War, or the army or even society as the army is just a reflection of it. The My Lai incident can be analyzed until its

“Do problems of compliance demonstrate the utility of Robert Gilpin’s realist argument that the nation-state remains the central actor in global gover

2388 words - 10 pages egoistic power of countries and failure of the global governance to fall short with its authority and legitimacy. One of countries is the United States of America (USA), a country which is regarded as a `super power`, however was criticised in the last decade when the nation state had decided to invade Iraq and Afghanistan after the terrorist attacks in 2001. Although, the UN Security Council had decided not to support the invasion, USA sent its

One World, Many Colors: The Continuous Battle with Racism

919 words - 4 pages another race or races. We as a country tend to brush off racism and act as though the problem has diminished over the years but it is still very much an issue here in America. Our government and our people can pass as many laws as they want, but no laws will change us, the people. We the people as a nation need to be willing to change to better the world Americans live in. One needs to learn to be accepting of the others in this nation. It

Shakespeare's As You Like It - The Many Flavors of Love

1489 words - 6 pages dramatic irony in their situation -- she gets several good laughs out of that, one of them being her answer to Orlando's question "But will my Rosalind do so?" -- "By my life, she will do as I do." However, in spite of her self-assurance before Orlando, the audience is in total sympathy with her, knowing her true love for Orlando, which she unintentionally demonstrates many times. She reacts so romantically to Celia's teasing that she is comical

The Labour Government as The Creator Of The Welfare State

1502 words - 6 pages The Labour Government as The Creator Of The Welfare State A Welfare State is a system in which the government undertakes responsibility for the well being of its population, through unemployment insurance, old age pensions and other social security measures. In order to achieve this the Labour Government of 1945-51 introduced a number of reforms, including the National Insurance Act of 1946 and the Education Act. They

King Henry VIII: The Man With Almost as Many Wifes as His Title

1151 words - 5 pages as well as his many wives throughout the course of his rule. Throughout the span of King Henry VIII’s life, he obtained six different wives and had seven children in total that were named [although most of them died shortly after birth]. Two of his wives he divorced, two were beheaded, one died, and one survived because of Henry’s death. However, Henry’s first two wives had the greatest impression on the direction of English rule. These two

A text can be considered from many points of view and in many different ways. Appropriation is one of the ways of doing this

2507 words - 10 pages can also be viewed as a rites of passage genre text linked to ideas of idealism and realism and conformity and non- conformity or from a psychoanalysis view referring to the Freudian theory.An appropriated text is a text which has been taken from one context and translated into another. "Catcher in the Rye" was written in 1951, whilst the appropriated text of Igby Goes Down was produced in 2002. Both texts have parallel plots dealing with

Similar Essays

Realism The State Is The Most Important Actor

1926 words - 8 pages successfully incorporates solutions to the shortcomings of realism. Liberalism is often perceived as “the strongest contemporary challenge” to realism (Caporaso ctd in Kegley 32). Liberalism includes solutions to many of realisms shortcomings. It successfully incorporates an argument for the multifaceted nature of the state; it suggests that the state is not a unitary actor, and that domestic policies are important in shaping the actions of the

Does The Non State Actor Represent A New Challenge To Nuclear Proliferation?

865 words - 3 pages terrorist groups. In this essay, it will discuss whether Non-State actor represents a new challenge to nuclear proliferation by observing with emphasis the relationships between the terrorist groups and Non-State actor. Although nuclear weapons has been strictly controlled by the states, such as Russia and USA, and the nuclear weapons are hard to be built, terrorists group still have capability and possibility to build or steal nuclear weapons. In the

The Conflict: One State Solution Essay

1419 words - 6 pages Since 1920, about 115,000 people have been killed as a direct effect of the violence in Palestine and Israel. (2014 Index of Economic Freedom.) The One State Solution will only work if both sides commit to a democracy, separation of state and religion and an end to violence. They have to learn to do these soon because if they don’t everyone in Palestine and Israel will be wiped out. Making a One State Solution will make one strong economy

The Legal Profession: One Career, Many Avenues

1482 words - 6 pages The Legal Profession: One Career, Many Avenues Whether we are reading about the heroic small-town attorney Atticus Finch in To Kill a Mocking Bird, or watching in awe as Richard Gere portrays a smooth attorney in Primal Fear, it is apparent through culture and media that there is a power and prestige associated with the law in American society. This paper compares the training and education of such American lawyers with their English