The State's Role In The Development Process

1224 words - 5 pages

What should be the state's role in the development process? Why has there been a neoliberal backlash against government involvement in development?

In theory, the role of the state in development should be a small one. Instead of following outmoded socialist central planning policies akin to those of the Eastern bloc in the twentieth century, poor countries should emulate the West and open up its markets to international trade; encourage the development of a vibrant and dynamic private sector; ensure that government spending is kept to a minimum; privatise all manner of inefficient and wasteful state-owned industries and overall, let the free market do its job. At least, that is the theory.

But it may not be that simple. Many historians correctly point out that the West was hardly the epitome of the free market and small government back in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries when it was first industrialising.[1] If anything, government intervention was the norm for quite a long time. The state played a role in shielding domestic manufacturers from the corrosive effects of trade, which (in their eyes) kick-started the Industrial Revolution in Great Britain; channelling capital to budding industrialists to invent and improve upon new and existing technologies; funding long-range expeditions to faraway lands like India and China to open up trade links, which, in absence of a guaranteed profit, would have turned away private investors; and finally, regulating and standardising all manner of industry as to ensure efficient and organised operation.

However, it takes negligible intellectual effort to simply use the post hoc ergo propter hoc logical fallacy and cherry pick evidence to suit one's world view. The same line of reasoning was used by racists in the 1800s to argue that Western Europe developed because it was made up of whites and Africa stagnated because it was made up of blacks. Such a position is, of course, absolutely ludicrous, and yet the same thought process is used by many who would argue that the state was the main reason that poor countries are now rich. It is one thing to say that the state intervened during the development phase of these countries, but it is quite another to say that its intervention caused such development.

Therefore, historians must pinpoint a single trend within the developed economies that led to the initial development phase. The United States, Great Britain, South Korea and Japan all had state intervention and have been highly successful nations, but there were plenty more failed states, like the Soviet Union, pre-revolutionary France, Argentina and countless African basket-cases, in which the state also heavily intervened, but destroyed the economy instead of invigorating it. Hence, the successes throughout history of state intervention leading to economic development are sporadic at best and hardly vindicate the causality arguments put forward by many of the historians mentioned earlier.


Find Another Essay On The State's Role in the Development Process

The Role of Immaturity in Human Development

581 words - 3 pages The prolonged juvenile period provides humans with the physical, social, and cognitive capabilities that are unmatched to any other species. The slow maturation process allows the human species to live longer and live smarter than any other mammal of comparable body size, and is the mechanism responsible for producing modern day humans. Immaturity has resulted in many benefits to the human species and can be directly linked as a

The Role of Perception in the Decision-Making Process Essay

2065 words - 8 pages Robbins, S. (2005) "Perception is a process by which individuals organize and interpret their sensory impressions in order to give meaning to their environment". The role of perception in the decision-making process goes beyond the five senses (1) sight, (2) hearing, (3) smell, (4) taste, and (5) touch. The representation of perception in decision-making is based on a person's internal understanding and personal analysis of environmental

The Effectiveness of International Aid in the Development Process

2049 words - 8 pages The Effectiveness of International Aid in the Development Process If an individual was having trouble in some way, wouldn’t one’s natural instinct be to help him or her out? This does not merely apply to persons, but also on a larger basis. All over the world, countries are suffering from many problems. The majority of these sufferers are ELDCs (Economically Less Developed Countries). Whether their crises may involve

The Process of Adolescent Development

2124 words - 8 pages process of growth and shedding takes place over the course of several years. It is hypothesized that the overgrowth of synapses prepares young children to adapt to their environments. Once it is determined which synapses are used and which are unnecessary, the excess connections disappear, allowing the brain to work more efficiently. A process known as myelination also begins early in a child’s development. In this process an insulating layer of

The Research and Development Process

5062 words - 20 pages Jeep Grand Cherokee; others manufacturers including Ford, Acura, and Mercedez have countered with luxury sport-utility vehicles of their own. In each of these cases, innovation has led eventually to widespread imitation-that is, diffusion. IMITATION AND RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES IMITATION PROBLEM A firm's rivals may be able to imitate its new product or process, greatly reducing the originator's profit

Understanding The Software Development Process

1285 words - 5 pages In our modern society, software has become a very critical component in all kinds of systems and software failures have become the most vital factor that terminates the service and proper function of the whole system. Therefore, it is very important and urgent to understand the software development process and eliminate as many potential problems in software as possible. Software reliability is defined as the probability of failure-free

Role of Language and Diversity in the Critical Thinking Process

707 words - 3 pages the heart of language, then metaphors are at the heart of our understanding of the world” (Kirby & Goodpaster, 1999, p. 109). Now let us examine some of the questions about language and thinking critically. What role does language and language diversity play in the critical thinking process? Language helps us make sense of our thoughts. “Language is the ‘software’ that allows our brain to think the way it does; without language the cerebral

Role of Language and Diversity in the Critical Thinking Process

712 words - 3 pages Language and language diversity play a significant role in critical thinking and its processes. Language is the main device we use as humans to communicate through symbols what we think, experience or feel. Language is also one of the primary methods of transmitting culture. Language diversity is important to critical thinking because of the close relationship between language and culture. Language is used diversely by different cultures

Managing the development process with security in mind

619 words - 3 pages with the modification of data without authorisation of the owner. Some examples of that can be: when an employee accidentally or with malicious intent deletes important data files, when a computer virus infects a computer, when an employee is able to modify his own salary in a payroll database, when an unauthorized user vandalizes a web site, when someone is able to cast a very large number of votes in an online poll. Availability Availability

The Role of Edward Teller in the Development of Physics

1531 words - 6 pages the effect of what brought about the Hiroshima bombing has been more popular to many. It is my intention that in this paper, I will present his role in furthering the development of Physics (Goodchild, 2004).Teller belongs to the group of one the most brilliant physicists in the world. He was born in the year 1908 at Budapest, Hungary. He is a trained chemical engineer who attended the University of Leipzig in Germany where he received his Ph.D in

The Role of Stress in the Development of Bulimia

2412 words - 10 pages The Role of Stress in the Development of Bulimia During the past few decades, Western culture has witnessed an enormous explosion in the number of eating disorders reported among young women. One such type of eating disorder is Butimia Nervosa. According to the DSM-IV criteria it is characterized by recurrent episodes of binge eating, in which the person experiences a feeling of "loss of control",and recurrent compensatory behavior in order

Similar Essays

The Role Of Media In Globalization Process

1062 words - 4 pages media in process of globalization has definitely got a lot of positive and negative aspects, but however the advantages are way more and therefore there is a remarkable progress in development in all-economic, social, political, cultural and traditional aspects. Moreover it is grateful to say that the world as a global village has come to stay and mass media have played special role in this.

Role Of Appearance In The Hiring Process

2516 words - 10 pages Looks and appearance have always dominated Hollywood culture and the actors and actresses that play roles in movies; also the popularity contest among teens in high-school. Bulimia and anorexia plague women and men throughout the United States. Today’s society is dominated by the obsession of appearances. But how far has this fixation gone? Has this Hollywood mentality taken over the otherwise standard way of running a business and the process

The Policy Development Process Essay

1409 words - 6 pages also determine the severity of instituting the change and the probability of getting the change. “The appropriate level of action and type of advocacy strategy will depend on the political, social and economic situation prevailing at a given point in time” (Rietbergen,-McCracken, J., n.d.). It is important to include and identify stakeholders in the policy development process. By doing so, the stakeholder can be recruited to help in the effort

Forced To Fight: The United State's Envolvement In Vietnam, And The Anti War Movement

3181 words - 13 pages ranging from two to three years in jail.In 1969 a lottery system was introduced to make the selection process fairer. Selective Serves representatives drew a ball from a bin with a day of the year on it. These balls were then numbered in the order taken out of the bin. All eligible men with that date as their birthday then had as their draft number the number of the ball. In December of 1969, the lottery results were aired on TV and radio.In 1971, a