This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Subjection Of Women And Slavery

1185 words - 5 pages

In this first unit, one of the readings that really caught my attention was John Stuart Mill’s The Subjection of Women. In his essay, Mill’s presents a very compelling argument that the subordination of one sex to another is wrong and that there should be instead, perfect equality amongst the sexes. Having previously studied about gender inequality issues from another class, I have a broad understanding of how and why gender inequality has been perpetuated through various historical, political, and social contexts. Incorporating this knowledge as well as information learned through the readings and lectures, I hope to share my thoughts on the subjection of women and its relationship to slavery in this personal response paper.
As an advocate for women’s rights and suffrage, the Utilitarianism view of Mill had a profound influence in his writing and it is very much evident in this essay. Mill felt that the oppressions of people of any kind cannot possibly bring about the greatest benefit to society (which is the central point to the Utilitarianism theory). The subordination of the weaker sex to the stronger rests upon theory only. There is no evidence to support the idea that one sex is superior over another as Mill expresses in the quote below.
The adoption of this system of inequality never was the result of deliberation, or forethought, or any social ideas, or any notion whatever of what conduced to the benefits of humanity or the good order of society (Mill, 1995, pg.11).
This idea of gender superiority/inferiority is just a social construct of oppression. There are no significant differences between man and women (besides biologically) that signifies their superiority/inferiority other than what only society believes them to be.
Instead, according to Mill, the subjection of women arose from the fact that since the earliest days of human society, “every women (owing to the value attached to her by men, combined with her inferiority in muscular strength) was found in a state of bondage (Mill, 1995, pg.16). Women were always seen as being inferior or “weak” to men; that they couldn’t do the same things men did because they lacked the physical strength to do so. Because women were physically inferior, it became easy to oppress them due to this difference in power.
Throughout history, women were “conditioned” to believe that it was their duty to be obedient to men. That it was their “nature to live for others….and to have no life but their [men’s] affections” (Mill, 1995, pg.16). Thus, it seemed natural that women were to be subservient to the needs of the men in their lives. They gave up their lives in order to serve and be accepted by them. Mill, however, claims that this was not the case. The subjection of women was not brought upon by natural development, but rather, through customary power relationships that went on to become institutionalized in the same way that slavery was.
Although the subjection of women arose the same way as...

Find Another Essay On The Subjection of Women and Slavery

The Impact of Slavery on Black Women

1179 words - 5 pages The Impact of Slavery on Black Women “Only by experience can any one realize how deep, and dark, and foul is that pit of abominations.” (Jacobs, 120). These words are spoken by Harriet Jacobs (also known as Linda Brent) and after reading about her life experience as a slave, I have come to believe that slavery was far worse for women than it ever was for men. Jacobs never states that black slave men had it easy during the slave years, in

Comparing Slavery of the South and North

1785 words - 8 pages ……………………………………………………………………………...6   Comparing Slavery of the South and North Introduction: The Americas (north and south) was referred to as the new world since they had recently been discovered by the Europeans. The Spanish, Portuguese and the Dutch resolutely instituted slavery in the Americas by the 1600s. Slavery refers to the practice of holding a person in bondage for labor. Nonetheless, slavery was not new to the Native Americans; it was a common practice

Slavery and The Narrative of Frederick Douglass

778 words - 3 pages Slavery and The Narrative of Frederick Douglass In 1845, Frederick Douglass told his compelling story of life as slave and as a free man. Through the words of somebody who endured slavery, we can only get a taste of what it was like, for we will never truly know the feeling of the severe physical punishment and the cruelty the slaves endured. Whippings, beatings and lynchings were all too common during the era of slavery. However, not only

Frederick Douglass and the Abolition of Slavery

748 words - 3 pages Frederick Douglass and the Abolition of Slavery There were many influential people who fought for the abolition of slavery in the 1800s. Among these people are Harriet Tubman, William Lloyd Garrison, and our sixteenth president, Abraham Lincoln. Frederick Douglass is one of these people. As a former slave, Frederick Douglass believed he could not enjoy his freedom while the rest of his people suffered under the burden of slavery. Therefore

Slavery and The Making of America

1536 words - 6 pages learn. The field slaves were usually uneducated and were restricted by law from being taught. The final inequality between the classes is exposure to ideas. The exposure ideas are summed up by this passage from another of Frederick Douglass’s book, “I had not long been a reader of the Liberator, and a listener to its editor, before I got a clear comprehension of the principles of the anti-slavery movement” (Douglass: L 215). The city and town slaves

John Woolman and The Abolition of Slavery

1148 words - 5 pages John Woolman was born in a Quaker family in New Jersey and lived from 1720-1772. In 1756 he began to write his journal where he spoke out in a piece entitled "Some Consideration on the Keeping of Negroes". His writing is exceptional because of the simplicity and lure. Woolman's attraction is his clear motive and sympathy toward the African-Americans. I will maintain in this paper that the Quakers, and specifically the abolitionist

Slavery and the History

2035 words - 8 pages holding forts, shackled together impairs with leg-irons and carried to the ships in the dugout canoes. Once they were aboard, they were branded with red-hot iron, like cattle, to show who owned them and their clothes removed.Slaves were housed in the ships as if they were cargo. Men were kept in chains while women and children were allowed to go free, they laid on specially built shelves with about 0.5 meters of vertical space. As long as the

Slavery and the Constitution

762 words - 4 pages join a union forbidding the slave trade. Many abhorred it. A slaveholder himself, Jefferson’s draft Declaration charged the King with its introduction. Slavery was a five hundred pound gorilla the Founders accommodated, constructing a “house divided,” in the hope it would strategically enable independence and endure until slavery withered. But twenty additional years of the trade and invention of the cotton gin delayed that hope for more than

Slavery and the Constitution

777 words - 4 pages Slavery was widespread in the southern economy at the founding of the American colonies. Consequently, the framers of the Constitution wrote the Articles in pro-slavery ways to motivate the southern colonies to ratify the Constitution. In doing so, the framers compromised democracy in the hopes of obtaining greater national security. Thus, the text of the Constitution protected and facilitated slavery in the following ways. The Preamble

The North and Slavery

573 words - 3 pages The North and Slavery Slavery was deeply entrenched in the lives of Americans from both the north and the south. Plantation slavery and the Deep South is typically what comes to mind when the benefits of slavery are considered. However, northern states also benefited substantially from slavery even after it was outlawed in most northern states. Northern states specifically benefited from the shipping of slaves in northern ports, the

Slavery And The Constitution

530 words - 2 pages Slavery and the Constitution The constitution was crafted as a series of compromises to replace the articles of Confederation. If our nation was to remain free it would have to stay united and this meant no one state or group could dictate to another state what the conditions would be under the new government. One of the compromises that the framers made was on the issue of slavery. The northern states were opposed and the Southern states wanted

Similar Essays

The Subjection Of Women: In Today’s Context

1339 words - 5 pages the political rights and powers, progression of social equality, and improved economic conditions of women in countries with high education indexes. The education index is referring to the statistics on literacy rate, gross enrollment ratios, and other factors compiled by the UN that determine which countries have exemplary education. In Mill’s analysis, he likens the subjection of women to the relationship between a master and a slave

John Stuart Mill’s The Subjection Of Women

2396 words - 10 pages There is a prevalent desire in history to determine the right place for women in society, especially as the modern period ushers out the end of the Victorian era, though women have existed as the counterpart to man for all time. John Stuart Mill’s The Subjection of Women as a pedagogic composition will be used for better understanding the nature and predicaments of Thomas Hardy’s Sue Bridehead as she determines her place in society in his novel

Comparing John Stuart Mill's The Subjection Of Women And Florence Nightingale's Cassandra

1081 words - 4 pages Comparing John Stuart Mill's The Subjection of Women and Florence Nightingale's Cassandra For thousands of years, women have struggled under the domination of men. In a great many societies around the world, men hold the power and women have to fight for their roles as equals in these patriarchal societies. Florence Nightingale wrote about such a society in her piece, Cassandra, and John Stuart Mill wrote further on the subject in his

Theme Of Inequality In The Subjection Of Women By John Stuart Mill

576 words - 2 pages In the essay, The Subjection on Women, the author John Stuart Mill describes his views on the inequality between men and women. He gives his opinion on why men have so much power over women and why this occurs. John Stuart Mill describes a principle and system that regulates the social relations between women and men. The principle Mill proposes is the legal subordination of one sex to the other. He is referring to the dominance that men