The Suffocating Good Old Days Revealed In Girl

863 words - 3 pages

The Suffocating Good-Old Days Revealed in Girl  

 
    Jamaica Kincaid’s story "Girl" allows readers a glimpse into the strict, demanding manner in which parents reared their children almost twenty years ago. Through Kincaid’s careful structuring of "Girl," readers capture the commanding tone of the story. The relationship between the mother and the girl also reeks of empowerment and distance, as best seen through the girl’s short-lived speech in the story. Most important, "Girl" shows readers how particular the lessons taught to the children two decades ago were.

The mother in "Girl" expects a great deal of her daughter, and she does not hesitate to let the girl know it. The fact that the two-page-story is entirely one sentence – and almost all of that emanating from the mother – gives off a powerful message: the mother demands a lot of her daughter. From the very beginning, the mother commands her daughter to perform tasks. Kincaid writes that the mother dictates "Wash the white clothes on Monday and put them on the stone heap" (1190). The mother’s reluctance to speak gently or even use the word "please" strongly suggests that the mother is in full and overwhelming control of her daughter.

With strict instructions such as the mother’s to her daughter, it is easy to see that the daughter is intimidated by her mother. Kincaid’s sentence structure again demonstrates the meekness of the girl whose thoughts and questions are represented a mere two times in the story. The first phrase the girl mutters represents the distance in the relationship between the girl and the mother, as the girl interrupts her mother with "but I don’t sing benna on Sundays at all and never in Sunday school" (1190). The mother, however, continues with her lecture. Jacqueline Austin views this relationship as very mechanical. Austin points out that the conversation between the mother and daughter was almost "in a rhythm so strong it seemed to be hypnosis, aimed at magically chanting out bits of the subconscious" (250). The girl’s comment is truly evidence of the mother’s expectation that her daughter be quiet and listen to the lecture, regardless of whether the girl knows the lessons already. Because the conversation between the mother and daughter is one-sided, it can be concluded that the entire relationship between the two is the same.

Undoubtedly, Kincaid’s most startling insight in "Girl" is the tremendous amount of detailed information the girl is being told. From proper table-setting to correct cooking methods to "womanly" walking, the girl’s lessons are many and extremely precise. As critic Wendy Dutton proclaims, "The reader gets the impression that the story is about a girl...

Find Another Essay On The Suffocating Good-Old Days Revealed in Girl

A Short Story--The Old Days Again

912 words - 4 pages BACK IN THE DAYGrandpa was sitting down on his favourite chair telling us about the old days. Boy it was boring. He'd be sitting there saying, "Jimmy back in the day we were very respectful to our elders, not like you lot." He'd then go on saying how we all deserved a flogging. Tell you now it was boring.Grandpa, he's an old bloke in his nineties, but still had life left in him, boy did he pack a punch, my dad told me about this one time last

A Taste Of The Old Days

1124 words - 5 pages Go the same pace long enough, and it becomes customary. Achieve a distance from something, no matter how near it once was, and all it takes is a sufficient while before the space begins to feel standard. Extreme opposites of a spectrum can swap. Even the Earth changes polarity every two hundred and fifty thousand years. And Six is very adaptable. He was once comfortable using firearms, back in his trainee days; it was in the set orientation

Hypocrisy Revealed in The Scarlett Letter

1340 words - 6 pages Chillingworth rather than healing and only cared about revenge. Most of all the Puritans showed themselves to be hypocrites because they acted as if they never sinned. They judge Hester extremely harsh for her sin and yet were still willing to associate with her for the sake of vanity. Everything in The Scarlet Letter is covered with a layer of hypocrisy and evil. Both Hester and Dimmsdale knew that the secret they had should be revealed. However

The Universal Inner Struggle Revealed in Hamlet

864 words - 3 pages The Universal Inner Struggle Revealed in Hamlet       Life is defined by the struggles it presents us.  Without these constant tests of our fortitude, we would never grow as mature human beings.  This is the one common denominator linking all people, past, present, and future.  It is no mystery why our literature and art reflect this characteristic.   The creation of a character is a mirror-image of a human.  Shakespeare perfectly

Around the World in Eighty Days

1215 words - 5 pages In the nineteenth, it seemed impossible to circumnavigate the world in only 80 days. That is, however, exactly what Phileas Fogg did in Jules Verne’s Around the World in Eighty Days. This novel follows the journey of the eccentric Englishman Phileas Fogg as he races around the world on a bet. Accompanied by his faithful servant, Passepartout, and a scheming detective, Fix, he encounters many challenges he must overcome in order to return in

The Power of Nature Revealed in The Open Boat

935 words - 4 pages The Power of Nature Revealed in The Open Boat     In 1894, Stephen Crane said, "A man said to the universe: 'Sir, I exist!' 'However,' replied the universe, 'The fact has not created in me a sense of obligation.'" This short encounter of man and nature is representative of Crane’s view of nature. However, he did not always see nature as indifferent to man. In 1887, he survived a shipwreck with two other men. "The Open Boat" is his account

Power of the Mind Revealed in Albert Camus' The Guest

697 words - 3 pages Power of the Mind Revealed in Albert Camus' “The Guest” In “The Guest”, a short story written by Albert Camus, Camus uses his views on existentialism to define the characters’ values. Camus’ effective use of descriptive words and individual thoughts and actions allows the reader to understand and sympathize with the characters’ judgments of one another, predominantly pertaining to the characters Daru and the Arab. Daru’s responses to the

The Power of Individualism Revealed in The Fountainhead

2877 words - 12 pages The Power of Individualism Revealed in The Fountainhead       Imagine power as a form of free flowing energy, a source found within every one and for each individual. Assume that to gain power, one has to tap this resevoir of immense proportions and relish upon the rich harvest to their hearts desires. Consequently, when there is such a dealing of concentrated materials, nature takes charge and similarly to other physical abstracts

Society's Beliefs Revealed in Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong

883 words - 4 pages  Society's Beliefs Revealed in Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong   One steamy, humid afternoon in 1961 the first United States helicopter landed in Vietnam dispensing immature boys onto the soggy marshlands. Some would return to that same helicopter one day, whether it be wrapped in a poncho about to be taken to the morgue, lying strapped to a stretcher about to report to the hospital, or standing tall holding their heads high because they

Inevitability of Change Revealed in Cry, the Beloved Country

1158 words - 5 pages Inevitability of Change Revealed in Cry, the Beloved Country   Things grow old and die.  Change is inevitable:  a candle will eventually burn out, trees will fall to the ground, and mountains will crumble to the sea.  This inescapable process is clearly illustrated by the character Stephen Kumalo in the book Cry, the Beloved Country, by Alan Paton.  The Kumalo seen in the beginning of the book is a completely

Themes and how their revealed in “Inherit the Wind”

1016 words - 5 pages The story “Inherit the Wind” holds many themes which are revealed in many ways throughout the story. It is important to know the different themes of a story so there is a better understanding of the book. Appearance vs. reality, the importance of free thought, and man vs. society are few of the major themes that are revealed more than once throughout the story. Appearance vs. reality is shown in “Inherit the Wind” through Brady and

Similar Essays

The Good Old Days. Essay

3659 words - 15 pages IntroductionWhenever you go over your grandparent's house, your bound to hear one of those stories about the 'Good Old Days'. Grandparents love to talk about how good life was in the 'Good Old Days'. But what was so good about the 'Good Old Days'? In this report you are about to find out.I will be making a questionnaire including the subjects of food, education, clothing, recreational activities, discipline, housing and transport. I will be

The Good Old Days! To Help Bring Out The Message

1043 words - 4 pages The Good Old Days! To help bring out the message in a poem, the author will use many literary devises. Often the author will write about real life situations or maybe they will write about fantasies. A poem is a fascinating style of writing. It can tell a story or just get a message across. There are different kinds of poetry, and the level of understanding differs greatly depending on the poem and poet. In the case of Gwendolyn Brooks, her

Hasek's Anarchist Beliefs Revealed In The Good Soldier Svejk

1248 words - 5 pages Jaroslav Hasek, one of the most famous Czech authors from the late 19th and early 20th century, created one of the Czech Republic’s greatest novels in The Good Soldier Svejk. Throughout The Good Soldier Svejk, Hasek not only tells the story of Svejk, but also tells multiple stories through the voice of Svejk. Clearly this is no coincidence and Hasek is using the stories within a story to make comments upon each other, but what exactly are these

Short Story The Old Days Again. Essay

1151 words - 5 pages THE OLD DAYS AGAIN!!My grandpa was sitting slumped and comfortable in his favourite chair telling me about the old days. It was always the same story with the same moral, "Jimmy back my the day we were very respectful to our elders, not like you lot." These were his exact words. Of course this would lead up to the magical solution, "All you new generation deserve a bloody flogging." Tell you now it was boring.My grandpa, an old bloke in his