This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Tension Between Formal Conservatism And Experimentalism: Flann O'brien's At Swim Two Birds

2187 words - 9 pages

Published in 1939, Flann O’ Brien’s At Swim Two Birds is regarded as the high point of his literary achievement. It is a novel of satire and pastiche, which uses narrative embeddings to depict a multi levelled story based in a postmodern Dublin. The unnamed narrator, a student attending University College Dublin, acknowledges “the importance of being at all times occupied with literary activities of a spare time or recreative character” (O’ Brien: 32). There is a definite tension between formal conservatism and experimentation evident throughout the novel. The use of metalepsis was at the time extremely daring and experimental, even though the structure of a frame narrative is one that forms part of the literary tradition. There is also the political element of the novel to be analysed. Although most obviously a postmodern (experimental) novel, there is also a strong postcolonial element which reveals a more traditional and conservative influence. (3) It can also be argued that O Brien’s novel was a reaction against the literary Ireland of the 1930’s, where the modernism of Joyce and Beckett was ubiquitous and had itself become the established, and by extension conservative, style of its time. (4)Finally, the issue of Irish culture and nationalism is one which is addressed in the novel, and O’ Brien’s rejection of a romanticised Ireland while still being influenced by old Irish texts also illustrate the tension between the old and the new.
Embedded narratives are part of the literary tradition, and have appeared in many different periods and genres. Some of the better known examples include The Canterbury Tales, The Man Who Would be King and Arabian Nights. Traditionally the inclusion of an embedded narrative was done in such a way that the ‘realness’ of the story was not compromised, for example through the discovery of a diary or manuscript. Frame narratives were still used in the modernist and postmodernist periods, but the previously solid narrative framework, which contained the story within the story, became more indistinct, and boundaries became more blurred. In the case of At Swim Two Birds the boundaries separating the various frames, and the whole narrative text and the real world are extremely vaporous. The form of the novel allows the text to discuss it’s own existence. O Brien uses the three levels within the text to reflect on the validity of the structure of the novel itself, thereby using an old, conservative literary construct to perform a postmodern task. Aldous Huxley, in Point Counter Point, writes:
Put a novelist into a novel. He justifies aesthetic generalisations. He also justifies experiments. Specimens of his work may illustrate other possible or impossible ways of telling a story. And if you have him telling parts of the same story as you are, you can make a variation on the theme. But why draw the line at one novelist inside your novel? Why not a second inside his? And a third inside the novel of the second?

Find Another Essay On the tension between formal conservatism and experimentalism: Flann O'Brien's At Swim Two Birds

Comparing relationship between man and nature. 'Porpoises' and 'Two look at Two'

595 words - 2 pages The poems "Porpoises" by John Gurney, and 'Two look at two" by Robert Frost both involve Humans encounter and their feelings towards nature and vice versa. Robert Frost looks at an experience two trampers have with nature, and nature's response to them, while John Gurney shows how nature have acted towards man and man's reaction to that. Although the two poems look at similar relationships, the tone in each poem is very different to the other

Comparative commentary: Flann O'Brien's novel "The Third Policeman" and "On the Road" by Jack Kerouac

801 words - 3 pages The texts in question are in a way very alike; they are both extracts from fictional novels and they were both written in the mid-twentieth century. Text B is an extract from Flann O'Brien's novel "The Third Policeman", and it deals with an old country road and ponders the role of different kinds of roads and where they might lead. The text is probably meant for adults, because it is quite philosophical, something teenagers might even consider

What connections have you found between the ways in which Duffy and Pugh write about social problems? In your response, you must include detailed critical discussion of at least two of Duffy’s poems.

2115 words - 8 pages Amy Asher AS Poetry Mrs LawrenceWhat connections have you found between the ways in which Duffy and Pugh write about social problems? In your response, you must include detailed critical discussion of at least two of Duffy's poems.Education for Leisure, ridicules the government and education. Writing during the 1980's employment rates were exceedingly high and Duffy talks of society in a critical way. Another poem by Duffy, Making Money, is a

The Relation Between Birds and Dinosaurs

993 words - 4 pages is that there is no connection between the two species. Their main reasoning for this conclusion is based on the belief that the two do not have any similar characteristics. I too believed that there was no correlation between the two animals. However, after extensive research, I have completely changed my mind. I believe that birds are dinosaurs because they have similar bone structures, and they both possess feathers. Bones are the major

The Birds: Comparisions between story and movie

670 words - 3 pages quite similar, in the aspect of birds attacking people andliving near water. There are many differences though, ranging from the charactersconnections to one another and reasoning for the birds attacks.There are some similarities between Hitchcock's film and Daphne du Maurier'sstory. The main similarity between the two is probably quite obvious. No, I'm not talkingabout how birds in both stories entered the house through the chimney.¹ I am

The Two Love Birds

712 words - 3 pages In William Shakespeare’s drama Romeo and Juliet, he writes about an unfortunate love between two adolescents in Verona, Italy, during the Renaissance period. In the film West Side Story, Robert Wise and Jerome Robbins direct two characters into a hopeless romance during the 1960s in New York. Even though Romeo and Juliet and West Side Story are distinct due to dissimilar settings, they share an almost identical plot. The personalities of the

Microraptor: The Missing Link Between Birds and Dinosaurs

1367 words - 5 pages is believed to have had true feathers, it is not likely that Microraptor took fight, but it is assumed that the species that evolved from him did. There are two other structural details causing the scientific world to claim that the discovery of this species may help to close the gap between dinosaurs and birds, the bird’s size, and the sharpness and strength of its digits, or fingers and toes. The Microraptor is the smallest known dinosaur

Conservatism vs. Liberalism between 1886 and 1906

1160 words - 5 pages In the following essay I will consider the two questions; why were the liberals out of power for so much of the period 1886-1906 and how do historians explain Conservative success in the period 1886-1906.At first glance it seems a simple answer why the liberals were out of power for all but 3 years (as a minority government) out of 20, the simple answer is that the liberal party was weakened, seemingly beyond repair when in 1886 ninety-three

Conflict and Tension Between The Proctors in The Crucible

1461 words - 6 pages How Does Millar Create a Sense of Tension and Conflict Between John and Elizabeth Proctor at the Beginning of Act 2? Arthur Miller was borne on the 17th of October 1915 in New York City. Miller believed that tragedy was not confined to the rich and important but that the ordinary man’s failure was just as moving and terrible. The play ‘The Crucible’ was first produced in 1953 in the middle of the McCarthy political witch hunt in America

The Tension between Beauty and Virtue in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95

1229 words - 5 pages The Tension between Beauty and Virtue in Shakespeare's Sonnet 95      "Sonnet 95" of Shakespeare's "blond young man" sonnets depicts a tension-filled variation on the classic blazon. The poet seems torn between the "shame" (1) that taints his subject and the "sweets" (4) of the subject 's beauty. The initial imagery of a "canker" (2) within a "rose" (2) serves to set up the sexual overtones that dominate the poem, as well as to

The Causes of tension Between Hinduism and Islam

1226 words - 5 pages While analyzing past interactions between Hinduism and Islam, we can see some outstanding tensions that arise from territorial conflict between India, a predominantly Hindu country, and Pakistan, a predominantly Muslim country. The primary focus of this tension arises from a common area – Kashmir/Jammu. The conflict in this region can be accredited to the differences in religion. The conflict in Kashmir stems from 1947. This was the year the

Similar Essays

Conservatism As A Tension Between Paternalism And Libertarianism

929 words - 4 pages Conservatism as a Tension between Paternalism and Libertarianism There are many different strands of conservatism within the ideology, the most significant of which in modern terms are paternalism and libertarianism. This conflict can be illustrated by the rival traditions of one-nation conservatism and New Right, or in particular neoliberal, conservatism. The basic idea of paternalism is to have authority over people

How Does Miller Create Dramatic Tension Between Marco And Eddie At The

810 words - 3 pages How does Miller create dramatic tension between Marco and Eddie at the end of Act One? So far in the play Marco and Rodolfo have illegally immigrated to America, seeking shelter with their cousin Beatrice and her husband Eddie. Living with them is Catherine, their niece, who falls head over heels in love with Rodolfo. Eddie is not happy, as he is incredibly overprotective of Catherine. This overprotectiveness turns to jealousy, which

A Tension Between Two Ethnic Groups

1095 words - 5 pages Cain 1 Summer Cain Ms. Heather McIntosh Pre-AP English 10 23 May 2014 A Tension between Two Ethnic Groups Some battles go completely unknown, the Battle of Fallen Timbers is most likely one of those battles; to keep it from being one, explore your history horizons. Between August of 1794 and August of 1795

Compare How The Two Prescribed Texts, "Bladerunner Directors Cut," & "Brave New World" Explore The Tension Between Humanity And The Natural World

837 words - 3 pages The relationship between humanity and the natural world is an important factor of life. The quality of this relationship has changed over time and with different cultural values. The novel "Brave New World" and the film "Bladerunner - director's cut" are two texts that hold a deteriorating relationship between humanity and the natural world. This relationship is quite different in the context of both composers' realities. To us, nature