The Things They Carried & A Soldiers Sweetheart

1203 words - 5 pages

Difference Between Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong & A Soldier's Sweetheart

Once a successful novel hits the market, producers are inclined to adapt the story into a movie. Since imagination, symbolism, and character psyches are explored in a novel, the movies tend to lack the luster of the original text. Using their imagination, readers are able to conjure up characters and scenes that are unique. This is the case with Tim O’Brien’s, “Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong.” This is a story where love and war collide after a soldier brings his sweetheart to his Vietnamese post. On the whole, this chapter in The Things They Carried is far superior to the film, The Soldier’s Sweetheart, because it has thorough descriptions of characters’ feelings, including symbolism concerning objects and important events. When the audience is able to draw it's own story around an author's narrative, the experience is more satisfying than when every detail is presented through the cinematic medium - an active audience is happier than a passive one.

Stark contrasts exist between the description of the characters and emotional content between the book and the movie. This may be mainly due to the limited length of the movie. In the movie, Rat Kiley who is telling the story seems gentler. In the book they make it seem like everything Rat says is exaggerated, but the movie does not stress that fact. “Among the men in Alpha Company, Rat had a reputation for exaggeration and overstatement, a compulsion to rev up the facts, and for most of us it was normal procedure to discount sixty or seventy percent of anything he had to say” (O’Brien 89). Also, the movie emphasizes the fact that Rat Kiley fell in love with Mary Anne Bell. He himself says he loved her towards the end of the movie. A character that people may tend to have sympathy for is Mark Fossie. In the book, one may not feel for Fossie. The movie shows the character having more feeling especially after he couldn’t find Mary Anne. A third character that is portrayed differently in the movie than in the book is Mary Anne, who is the main female character of the chapter. The movie stressed the fact that Mary Anne wanted to learn more about the Vietnamese way of life. There was a scene in the movie where Mary Anne spent time with the Vietnamese soldiers learning their language and how to cook their food. They also show her going to a Vietnamese village trying to communicate with the children. In the book it says, “The guys sometimes liked to kid her about it-our own little native, they’d say-but Mary Anne would just smile and stick out her tongue.” She was not only into the Vietnamese way of life, but she was also into the life of a soldier in war. She wanted to learn more about how to shoot a gun. She wanted to be like one of the guys. The novel installs all these ideas, but it also allows the reader to use their creativity. It also gives more emphasis on little traits of the character that make the character more...

Find Another Essay On The Things They Carried & A Soldiers Sweetheart

The Things They Carried Essay

1707 words - 7 pages )”. They also carried various things that they came upon that they thought could help them survive until tomorrow. The weight that the men carried was only partly physical, the mental and emotional ‘weight’ was almost as much to carry as the physical objects the men trudged with. In fact, the mental weight and the stress of having to maintain a facade that they were not afraid were the heaviest weighing upon the deepest parts of the soldiers

The Things they Carried Essay

1053 words - 4 pages afraid of retribution from Strunk for not sticking to their pact. Strunk though the bitterness of being a cripple and the whole might confuse compassion for weakness. Most of the stories in `The Things They Carried' start off with descriptions of rugged, strong, silent, fighting soldiers. However the stories reveal that the soldiers are individuals with different experiences which influence the way they react to tragic and violent situations

The Things They Carried

1581 words - 6 pages Running Header: The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien 1The Things They Carried by Tim O'BrienENG 1300 W5A2Andrea CarrSouth University OnlineThe Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien "The Things They Carried" is one of several short stories written by Tim O'Brien that brilliantly portrays a squad of young American soldiers in the Vietnam War. Each of the short stories builds on the last but in The Things They Carried the author places focus on how

The Things They Carried

641 words - 3 pages The Things They Carried by Tim O'BrienIn the short story The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien, the author explores human nature and the emotions that are carried with them. This emotional baggage is represented by the love that a soldier feels towards a girl back home. It is contrasted by the everyday things they carry while at war. Ultimately this story deals with the theme of growing up and taking responsibility.One of the clever aspects of

The Things They Carried - 2795 words

2795 words - 11 pages emotion associated with combat” (Van Ells 1). The fear of war begins for a soldier before they even get deployed. Every soldier hears the horror stories of war but never really understands till they are in war themselves. In the short story, “The Things They Carried” all the soldiers are constantly dreading every second. For example it is not good news when a high command orders the soldiers to search the tunnel before having to blow them up. No one

"The Things They Carried"

2145 words - 9 pages the heart and the longing of the American soldiers across the battle lines of the war in a harsh tropical country - Vietnam.Works CitedO'Brien, Tim. The Things They Carried. 1st ed. New York: Mariner, 2001. PrintWells, Linda. "The Things They Carried: Character, Narrative, and the Liberal Arts". Journal ofEducation 182.2 (2000): 45. Web. 08 Apr. 2014.Volkmer, Jon. "Telling The 'Truth' About Vietnam." War, Literature & the Arts

The Things They Carried - 1000 words

1000 words - 4 pages "The Things They Carried," is a fiction story-telling book about the Vietnam War by Tim O'Brien that describes the physical and emotional burdens the men carry not only during their time in Vietnam but also years after leaving the warfront. The book is a series of stories told with O'Brien as the main narrator. O'Brien tells of the journey he takes alongside his unit, revealing his fight for courage and decision to commit to the serving in the

The Things They Carried

740 words - 3 pages Vietnam War a war that took many lives. A war that change the people,the nation and our views. In “The Things They Carried” by Tim O'Brien, symbolism is the key into getting the reader understand life behind the line. Tim O'Brien writing give the readers the vivid image through the fact the war has a deeper meaning than one can believe. In this story we see how everyday life through symbols are used in literature writing. In this short story

The Things They Carried

1646 words - 7 pages . Tim O’Brien accomplishes basically the same goal in The Things They Carried by giving the reader many brief stories about his time in the Vietnam War. These two books- though incredibly different on the surface - share a plethora of themes and symbology, as well as many similar events. They do not, however, emphasize or present these ideas in the same way. Each of these authors has a unique way of incorporating their own themes or values into

The Things They Carried - 755 words

755 words - 3 pages to aid in their struggle.Tim O'Brien's novel The Things They Carried is a novel set during the Vietnamese War. The author and narrator, Tim O'Brien was drafted into the war and survived to tell about it. He wrote this story to "bring back life" to many who had died in the war, yet this is not entirely a true story. In fact, Tim O'Brien wrote this in a very unique style, one that conceals any truth among a great deal of fiction.Several times

The Things They Carried - 1026 words

1026 words - 4 pages a sense of Jim's victory over his indulgence with Martha and he finally understands to put his priorities in order. Although the emotional attachment to Martha seemed to be the main burden carried, Jim begins to realize that the feelings are not mutual, thus making it easier to accept his duty and lead his platoon and say "Carry on" (378).Jim's obsession with Martha is stated in several incidents throughout the work. "More than anything, he

Similar Essays

The Things They Carried: Motifs Exhibited In "Sweetheart Of The Song Tra Bong"

1271 words - 5 pages There are many war stories written by many war veterans but The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien stands out from rest. Tim O'Brien communicates that the Vietnam War was about more than just battles. One story in particular, "Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong," captures this idea. In this story, Rat Kiley tells of the story of a soldier who brought his elementary school sweetheart out to Vietnam, but she fell in love with Vietnam, embraced it

The Things They Carried Essay

1515 words - 7 pages come back completely different, just like the case of Mary Anne. War is more then just a battle between waring nations, it's a psychological battle. People back in the states had no clue what the soldiers had to do and what effect it had on them. The Things They Carried is a great insight into what these soldiers experienced and how they dealt with the challenges are the Vietnam war.

The Things They Carried Essay

563 words - 2 pages in which he can sort through his emotions" (Friedlander 1). The story was not directly about O'Brien's war experience. However he was able to write with experience and make it have a lot of truth in what the soldiers experienced. He was able to blur the line between fiction and reality.O'Brien's war story The Things They Carried is a story of much more than what the men carried on their backs. The story is filled with emotion and relationships

The Things They Carried Essay

1095 words - 5 pages Wars tends to be the matter of historical record and soldiers are considered as emotionless machines just obeying the orders in the war. Nobody cares about the individual soldier who actually fights in a war. "The Things They Carried" by Tim O'Brien is about a soldier who is trying to communicate with civilians and tell them what he went through before and during the war. At times there is recitation of the uninteresting items