This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Transformation Of Civil Military Relations In Turkey

1657 words - 7 pages

Thorny Road of Change
The Transformation of Civil–Military Relations in Turkey

Ronald Iane

Subject: Political Cultures and Economies in Transition
Instructor: Dr Edoardo Monaco
Submitted on: 20 May 2014
Before Abdul Fattah al-Sisi’s sudden rise to fame, the renowned example of civilian-military relations anomaly in the Middle East is Turkey: elected officials run routine government business under the watch of a powerful military, and they are ready to be deposed if things go awry. Today, we see a different image of the civilian government gaining ground and senior commanders of the military willing to concede.
The central question that this paper seeks to answer is what factors have enabled such a transformation to take place. There are multiple variables coming into play, the understanding of which may not be completed and well-informed without taking into account the politics and society since the forging of the Republic of Turkey. The changing status of the Turkish military should be construed from nature and practice of the military itself, and the broader scope of the Turkish society, which put external pressure on the structure reform of fading the military from civilian governance.
Therefore, in the literature review section, two major strands of understandings pertinent to civilian-military relations are examined. A review of the Turkish history of military dominance over civilian-military relations follows thereafter. Then, the paper highlights factors that underlie the fundamentally refreshing initiative to alter what was then the status quo.

Literature Review
American, British, and Soviet militaries are seen as classical examples of civilian controlled militaries that do not meddle with domestic politics. On the other hand, there are praetorian militaries, not conforming to civilian rule, which may take opportunities to obstruct civilian governing bodies. It is nonetheless observed that most militaries are in the middle of the spectrum.
One strand of civilian-military theory focuses on the internal and external threats confronted by a state and its military. The changing mores of international affairs and technological advancement are exposing the military to external threat at increasing pace; therefore ‘the functions of the officer become distinct from those of the politician and policeman.’
In his book Civilian Control of the Military: The Changing Security Environment, Desch uses two variables, internal threat and external threat, to explain four types of civilian-military relations. When high external threat and high internal threat co-exist, the civilian-military relations tend to be poor or chaotic. But when both threats are low, the civilian government and military are neck and neck. Praetorianism is likely to prevail when there are high internal threat and low external threat with the military having the upper hand. Low internal threat, coupled with high external threat, can...

Find Another Essay On The Transformation of Civil-Military Relations in Turkey

An Illustration of State-Society Relations in Turkey

2133 words - 9 pages long-term anti-religious policies would always characterise republican Turkish politics, especially after the 1961 constitution following a military coup (Grigoriadis, 2009:1197). Different forms of secularism The concept of the public sphere is crucial to situate the debate on secularism in contemporary Turkey and to analyse the role and place of the female body in this context. But before, it is important to situate laiklik in relation to

An Illustration of Sate-Society Relations in Turkey

1757 words - 7 pages sparked a major political and constitutional crisis in the country – not over Gul's track record in the executive, but over his wife's veiled head and neck. The military immediately threatened to take action against the government should his candidacy be maintained; a move supported by the main opposition party, the Kemalist CHP, and the judiciary (Grigoriadis, 2009:1205). Ensued a debate over the self-representation of Turkey and Turkish society (in

Foreign Relations in the Civil War

2549 words - 10 pages that the Czar wanted to extract revenge if the time allowed, and the American Civil War gave him that chance. "Since pure altruism is seldom or never visible in any country's foreign relations, the business was not quite that simple. Russia at the time was in some danger of getting into a war with England and France, for reasons totally unconnected with the Civil War in America; to avoid the risk of having his fleets icebound in Russian ports

Turkey and the Syrian Civil War

2682 words - 11 pages Turkey and the Syrian Civil War Turkish-Syrian relations have almost always been soured and hostile in some fashion, dating back as early as the 1500’s. With a perpetual tit-for-tat policy and retaliation method that has been in effect between the two nations, it wasn’t until around 2003 or so in which Turkish relations to Syria had turned mostly friendly in response to the United States’ invasion of Iraq and Assad growing concerned over Syria

Sociology of race Relations: A Transformation

942 words - 4 pages While comparing the sociology of race relations beginning in the 1920’s with the first Chicago School period and ending in the 1960’s with the development of the civil rights movement, one will find an era where the dominant sociological thoughts are rooted in what will eventually show to be a flawed perspective. Also, these sociologists begin this new thinking in an era that appears to be full of great enthusiasm as their discipline is

Comparing the Military Leaders of the Civil War

1565 words - 6 pages When we compare the military leaders of both North and South during the Civil War, it is not hard to see what the differences are. One of the first things that stand out is the numerous number of Northern generals that led the “Army of the Potomac.” Whereas the Confederate generals, at least in the “Army of Northern Virginia” were much more stable in their position. Personalities, ambitions and emotions also played a big part in effective they

The History of Turkey

1575 words - 6 pages by the Mongols. This ushered in the Mongol Empire. However, the Mongol Empire quickly fell apart, allowing the Ottoman Turks to continue their influence on the people of Turkey. The Ottoman Empire remained from the mid 1400’s, until the late 1800’s, even though they faced many difficulties. After the Ottomans, Abdülhamit took control over Anatolia, and become the Sultan. The kingdom came to an end in 1908 when a group of students and military

The Influence and Role of the Islamic Tradition in Turkey

2574 words - 10 pages came to power in the 1920s, he wanted to liberate women from their oppressed role in society.? He gave them the right to vote, hold public office, and bequeath and inherit wealth.? The veil was outlawed (in official ceremonies, schools, universities, and public offices), and civil marriage and divorce were established.? Since the founding of the modern Turkey, they have had a female head of state and had a woman in the Supreme Court before the U.S

Treatment of Minorities in Turkey

1650 words - 7 pages for the proselytization process? and they are therefore wary of the growing Christian presence in Turkey.[xvi]?? Thus far the growth of the Christian church in this area remains stunted due to the population?s skepticism and the government?s hesitancy to grant Christians complete civil freedoms.? The Jewish Minority The 25,000 Jews that reside within Turkey?s borders have experienced their own hardships, despite their efforts to maintain a

The Progress of Human Rights Reform in Turkey

1901 words - 8 pages and literacy campaigns, in an effort to secularize Turkey and strengthen the Turkish government and people.[v]? Ataturk wanted to abolish religion as the cord that fastened all of society together, and instead chose to make Turkish nationalism the cornerstone on which he would build a country.[vi]? However, he also ushered in a lack of democracy, repression of the Kurds, and a heavy reliance on the military, and laid the foundation for similar

Constitutional Revolutions of Iran and Turkey in the 19th Century

1463 words - 6 pages The Young Turk and Iranian Constitutional Revolutions occurred during a period of transformation. Transformation not only from the nineteenth to the twentieth centuries, but also a transformation of society. For the Ottomans, the nineteenth century was the age of the European empires, many of whom influenced and manipulated the society. The result would be a Middle Eastern country emulating European society. This influence was not evident in

Similar Essays

Civil Military Relations Essay

1773 words - 8 pages Civil –Military Relations Civil military relations can be understood as ‘two hands on the sword.’ The civilian hand determines the timing to draw out the sword from its sheath and the military hand carries out the civilian government’s order to put the sword in combat. Civil military partnership is shared between the civilian government and the military establishment in order to run the state affairs. The paper examines the complexities of civil

Discussion On The Secularism Of Turkey In It's Politics, Culture And International Relations

3507 words - 14 pages the nations that were viewed as Soviet patrons (Egypt, Iraq, Syria). There was a difficult time for the two nations in the 1970's, when Turkey invaded Cyprus. Relations werere-established in the early 1980's, although many Turks resented the United States Congress trying to limit military assistance to Turkey due to the conflict in Cyprus. With the fall of the Soviet Union, and the end of the Cold War, the leaders of Turkey had to re-evaluate

State&Business Relations In Turkey Essay

1920 words - 8 pages tend to alienate the agriculture groups so they did not finance ISI by squeezing agriculture.Comparing the state's relations with the domestic business community we should mention the crisis of 70s. In 1970s Turkey faced with increased social demands, during those times turkish state was besieged by pressure groups and seemed incapable of dealing with increasing polarization and political violance in Turkish society. Turkish politics were

An Illustration Of State Society Relations In Turkey

2122 words - 8 pages association MUSIAD (religious branch of the secular TUSIAD) (Fuat Keyman, 2007:217). This empowered them at the political level. While Islamic parties have been systematically closed down by the judiciary since the establishment of the Turkish Constitutional Court in the constitution of 1961 (following a military coup), their transformation into conservative, centre-right parties, like the AKP, have enabled them to win elections with strong