This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Transformation Of Roman Catholicism Essay

3762 words - 15 pages

The Transformation of Roman Catholicism Hans Kung presented a possible major retransformation for Roman
Catholic Christianity. He believed that

'the renewal of the Catholic Church willed by the Second Vatican
Council has come to a standstill.'


The transformation of Roman Catholicism both by the councils of Trent,
Vatican I and II was believed to have been needed in order to look ay
the way in which the Christian tradition encapsulates the truth of the
religion. Both the Vatican councils attempted to transform Roman

Before I can first look at Kungs objections to the concept of an
infallible church, I believe I need to establish what the Roman
Catholic church meant by the concept of 'infallible' and thus the
basis of Kungs arguments.

The doctrine of papal infallibility is the impossibility of the church
falling into error. It is believed to have begun with the council of
Trent (960) and the First Vatican Council (1828), both of whom
believed that the bishops are the successors of the apostles. Due to
their role as pastors and teachers of the 'faithful' they are also

'agents of the infallibility assured to the ecclesiastical teaching
office; their active infallibility in teaching is the cause of the
passive infallibility of the faithful in believing and ascending.'


The main elements of Kungs enquiry according to Haring and found
within Kung's book 'Infallible? An enquiry' are 1. The serious problem
with the biblical basis of infallibility; 2. Objections on principle
from tradition of the whole church; 3. The massive questions about the
representative character, course and freedom of the council which made
the decision of infallibility; 4. Criticism of the legalistic,
centralistic and rationalistic narrowing of the concepts of faith,
doctrine and infallibility. In addition Kung questioned whether faith
depends at all on infallibility statements or on infallibly true

In this essay I am going to look at the questions raised by Kung and
attempt to critically analyse these against the doctrine of
infallibility. In order to do this I will take each of Kung criticisms
of the Roman Catholic concept of church infallibility, as outlined
above and examine them.

The theological concern therefore of Kung is the reform of the Roman
Catholic church

'against a Biblical and an ecumenical horizon'


under minding the

'stability and immutability of doctrinal statements as guarantees of
truth- especially when they are obligated to Vatican I's rationalistic
and legalistic concept of faith.'


For Kung the discussion about infallibility is a discussion about the

Find Another Essay On The Transformation of Roman Catholicism

The Transformation of America Essay

1347 words - 5 pages The transformation of America is often discussed in both popular media and academic dialogue. Each generation has a name, new technologies define new eras, and events seem only notable when they are “historic”. While major events catch the interest of a broad spectrum of the public consciousness, subtle interactions between actors and slight shifts in beliefs are constantly changing the realities of the world. When the twin towers fell in

The Transformation of Gdansk Essay

826 words - 3 pages The city of Gdańsk has played an important role in the transformation of Europe. But the same thing that today makes us proud about our past, could very well be what makes us a monument in the future. A legacy enacted solely through commemoration does not constitute a creative starting-point for adapting to contemporary challenges. Gdańskian, Polish, or European. Gdańsk needs to transform. And Europe will play an important role in the

The Transformation of Macbeth

1227 words - 5 pages of the consequences for his actions. Ensuing the first meeting, Macbeth’s personality underwent a significant transformation resulting in a character of increased anxiety and paranoia. A true symbol of feminism in the Elizabethan era, Lady Macbeth is one of the various catalysts that propel Macbeth into murdering those around him for the sake of gaining the crown. Before the banquet Macbeth and his wife had set up for Duncan at their castle

The Transformation of Liberalism

2879 words - 12 pages Liberalism is a force that has produced change from the birth of this nation to the politics of today. Liberal tenets have been a basis of thought and action in American politics since well before the signing of the Constitution. Certainly, liberalism has had to transform in order to remain a legitimate force throughout the years. When considering this transformation, one may ask whether or not the ideas and goals of classical liberalism have

The History of Catholicism an How Its Depicted

1543 words - 6 pages The History of Catholicism an How Its Depicted The series of events which form the history of Catholicism in the mid sixteenth century are most often depicted as follows. A violent shock causes the very foundations of Christendom to tremble, and whole sections of the Church's ancient edifice are swallowed up in heresy. Her rulers then drag themselves from their lethal indifference; they determine to oppose the Protestant menace, and

The Transformation of Russia's Government

1812 words - 7 pages done in 2010. (Bureau of European and Eurasian Affairs) The culture is highly diverse with multiple religions. The religions that are most viewed in Russia fall under Russian Orthodox, Islam Judaism, Roman Catholicism, Protestant and Buddhist. Other cultural aspects to take into consideration are forms of government. (Bureau of European and Eurasian Affairs) The transformation of Russia’s government is highly expansive. Mikhail

The Out of Sight Transformation

653 words - 3 pages The Out of Sight Transformation Travel has always been associated with relaxation and enjoyment. People travel to explore new or revisit favorite places. The idea that travel could also be a conduit for self growth and awareness,as discussed in the article Transformative Travel,is a very new concept but old tradition. Various religious groups send people across the world as missionaries. Missionary work was identified as a group

The Transformation of Slavery's Defense

640 words - 3 pages The Transformation of Slavery's Defense During the early 1800’s the demand for cotton had risen and it was now “King” of plantations in the southern region of the United States, where the climate was best suited. Now more then ever, slavery had become an essential component of most every cotton producing plantation. The Southerners knew slavery was wrong, but made justifications for it; within a span of 30 years these justifications had

The Transformation of Hong Kong

1336 words - 5 pages The Transformation of Hong Kong A drastic change came over Hong Kong during my supposed three month long business trip. This was not my first time in Hong Kong since I work for Walt Disney Imagineering and my team of engineers had been spending years planning the creation of the fourth Disney resort in Hong Kong. I had arrived in Hong Kong in mid-February 2003. My coworkers and I were staying at the Island Shangri-La which is located in

The Transformation of Shakespeare's Macbeth

922 words - 4 pages The Transformation of Macbeth        From the beginning of the play, Macbeth undergoes a complete change in character--from a virtuous nobleman into a monster. He has a tragic weakness--ambition--which, when released, draws him into a web of evil and corruption that finally leaves him with none of the noble human qualities he possessed at the beginning of the play.        Before being transformed into a murderous monster, Macbeth

The Analysis of the Transformation of Eliza

1223 words - 5 pages The play "Pygmalion" describes the process of the transformation of Eliza, who appears in three images in the story: Eliza begins as a flower girl, then she transforms into a lady with noble accent and in good manners, then an independent woman with self-respect and dignity. By naming his drama "Pygmalion," Shaw reminds people of the ancient Pygmalion Myth. Pygmalion, a sculptor, makes a beautiful statue and falls in love with his own

Similar Essays

Why The Dedication Of Saints In Roman Catholicism?

881 words - 4 pages During my catholic youth group, one of my friends told me he was disappointment to all Roman Catholics because he says that we are just worshipping to the Saints. He seemed that he is under the influence of thinking too deeply into our religion, even though he is catholic too. I tried to explain him that we, Roman Catholics, do not worship to anyone but God but my words weren’t enough to make him understand more about the Saints. Someone gave a

Comparison Of Roman Catholicism To Pentecostal Christians Faith

2055 words - 8 pages SummaryIn this report I will inform people about the faith of Roman Catholicism and what centers around thisWay of worship, also in this report I will summarize a interview that I done with Alicia Prokasky a15 year old girl, that goes to the Lady of the Highway Catholic Church in Thomasville, North Carolina.In the interview I asked her a series of ten question concerning about the Roman Catholic ways ofWorship and lifestyles and from these

Catholicism In The Life Of Shakespeare

1491 words - 6 pages In Shakespeare’s time, 1564-1616, practicing Catholicism was illegal in England. Some historians have claimed that William Shakespeare was Catholic and hid this fact out of fear of persecution. Others go as far as to say that Shakespeare shaped parts of his plays after his own Catholic beliefs. Between Shakespeare’s youth upbringing, education, and the availability of Catholic literature, William Shakespeare had a basis if not a belief in the

The Transformation Of Othello Essay

693 words - 3 pages TRANSFORMATION OF OTHELLOIn Shakespeare's play Othello the transformation of the main character Othello "the moor", both in terms of attitudes towards life and the state of mind he is in, is the main axis by which various types of other contrasts are worked up. In this play readers are ended up with a final where a respectful and strong general turned in to a weak person that is manipulated by the vicious plans of Iago, the "evil" character of