This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Tribune Against Measure Q Essay

1091 words - 4 pages

The Tribune against Measure Q

The Tribune posted an editorial stating their opposition to Measure Q on Saturday, October 16th, 2004. It describes the debate over the measure “boiling down to one sentence: ‘It shall be unlawful for any person or entity to propagate, cultivate, raise, or grow genetically engineered organisms in San Luis Obispo County.” The Tribune claims that “Measure Q is a poorly written ordinance with unintended consequences of banning research on life-saving medicines.” It begins with an effective strategy of stating arguments of the proponents and responding to each, but continues with an unconvincing list of reasons to vote against Measure Q and a conclusion that weakly ties the article together.

To open the editorial, the author questions proponent’s credibility. “Proponents say the ban would give county farmers protection from GE crops until all risks are known,” is argued by the statement, “The farming community by and large says that the ban will hurt them competitively if or when they decide to use GE seeds.” The supporters of Measure Q are questioned as to where they are getting their information if the people they are “protecting” feel the ordinance will hurt them. This is a successful strategy to convince the reader that advocates of the ordinance are untrustworthy.

The article supports its claim that Measure Q is a badly written ordinance by discussing the use of the broad term “organism” in the measure. It includes arguments from two credible sources, San Luis Obispo attorney Robin Baggett and the Washington D.C law firm of Arent Fox. The two agree that the use of the word “organism” implies both laboratory research as well as crops, therefore both would be banned. Baggett, a lawyer and president of the San Luis Obispo Vintners and Growers Association sent a letter to the Health Commission which stated “that the term ‘organism’ is defined as ‘any living thing, exclusive of human beings and human fetuses…and courts will enforce that definition.’” Adding strength to the argument that GE crops and GE medical applications are inseparable is that the Health Commission “has voted 7-3 not to take a stance on the issue.” Fox writes that, “all genetically engineered organisms are biological systems; a prohibition on growth or propagation is a prohibition on production, regardless of whether that growth or propagation takes place in a field or in a factory…Measure Q-04 unambiguously prohibits all commercial research and production of genetically engineered organisms.” The credentials of these sources solidify the claim.

In addition to the central controversy about the term “organism,” additional reasons are given to vote against the measure. The first includes two issues concerning the Cal Poly agricultural department. It argues that the measure is discriminatory against local farmers by making Cal Poly exempt from it. In order not to turn Cal Poly students and faculty off, the article also...

Find Another Essay On The Tribune against Measure Q

Standardized Testing Essay

1538 words - 6 pages observations. And furthermore rating education and a student?s progress strictly through numbers is the wrong way to measure a process as complex and intricate as learning. Works Cited Brady, Marion. 'Not-yet-answered questions about standardized testing.' Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service 28 Jan. 2003: K. Clarke, Kevin. 'Why students are feeling so testy.' U.S. Catholic July 2000: 27. Gallagher, Tom. 'The Case Against

grachi tiberius gaius rome Essay

1864 words - 7 pages failure to get re-elected for a third tribunate in 121. As tribune Minucius Rufus proposed to repeal one of Gaius’ bills, he gathered support. In a minor disturbance, a servant of consul Opimius was killed. The senate was forced to pass a resolution that consuls should see to it that the Republic came to no harm. Opimius summoned to arms senators and equites against Gaius and Flaccus who had occupied the Aventine hill. After failed negotiations

the one of great well

7100 words - 28 pages these indices: quality changes: Assumption of identical items.) Topic 3-Econ 245 Page 11 How to Choose the Weights: ™ Q_______ of goods purchased. (Which quantity?) ™ Percentage of ___________ on good. (piqi) Both measure "importance", but may differ over time. So, when should they be measured? Topic 3-Econ 245 Page 12 Possibilities: (I) L________' Index: P p q p q t L it i i n i i i n0 0 1 0 0 1 100=   

Experimental Method

1297 words - 5 pages causation" and give examples of both.C) What do we mean when we say there is a statistically "significant difference" between the two groups?Tylenol vs AdvilMain Source:http HYPERLINK "http://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.medicinecabinetsafety.com%2F&sa=D&sntz=1&usg=AFQjCNFkoe8eILO8vMiq4CWzG0LIrA1JLQ":// HYPERLINK "http://www.google.com/url?q=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.medicinecabinetsafety.com%2F&sa=D&sntz=1&usg

The Cons of the Death Penalty

565 words - 2 pages society reforms them”(Singh). 54 Bibliography: WORKS CITED “The Death Penalty”, William Johnson 1996. “Capital Punishment”, Jacob Leibman April 1 2001. [http://www.about.com/search?/death+penalty] “The Chicago Tribune”, Feb. 21, 2001 “Capitol Punishment”, ACP-ASIM Weekly, American Association of Public Health Physicians, March 29 2001. “Against Death Penalty”, April 2 2001. [http://www.about.com/deathpenalty/against.html] USA Today, President George Bush, Jan. 24 2001

The True Story of Ah Q

1083 words - 5 pages democratic revolution against imperialism and feudalism. China had large gap between landlords and peasantry. Ah Q is a typically penniless peasant in that time. Ah Q is a wandering and simple farm laborer but sometimes he has hooliganism. For example, his name is Ah Q because he has uncertain name, “Ah Q had no family but lived in the Tutelary God's Temple at Weichuang. He had no regular work either, simply doing odd jobs for others.” The author

Theoretical Basis for Measuring Social Costs

2625 words - 11 pages Appendix B. Theoretical basis for measuring social costs In order to analyze cases where a change in environmental quality (q) affects individual preference and demand, a basic individual utility maximization problem is considered i.e., maximizing a strictly concave utility function subject to the compact (closed and bounded) budget set (Freeman 2003): Maximize┬(x_j )⁡〖u(x,q)〗 subject to y = ∑_(j=1)^n▒p_j x_j (B-1

Employee value proposition at NTPC

2378 words - 10 pages of 9 and 6 variables sets. The nine point set measures those factors that are favourable for the organisation and the six points are those which are against the organisation. The four point questionnaire refers to the employee commitment towards the organisation. For analysis, questions falling in these three sets are clubbed into three groups and their means in groups will be analysed. Set I Commitment on the positive scale: Q No.: 1 I

The Rise and Fall of Gaius Gracchus

1912 words - 8 pages from office, Tiberius received the support needed to pass the law. After the law passed, Tiberius’s term as tribune ended, but he desired a second appointment to secure his agrarian law and to prevent any prosecution the other senators willed against him. This second term was illegal during the time, but still occasionally allowed if enough support was gathered. On the day of the election, Tiberius’s opponents staged many arguments for the

The Right to Same Sex Marriage

1524 words - 7 pages that are against them. Gays might not have equal rights but they do keep trying to push the movement forward everyday. Works Cited Anthony, Cayman, Grand., Islands, Cayman.. “OPINION: ‘Court rules same-sex marriage constitutional!’ Not exactly…” McClatchy- Tribune Business News. 28 Jun. 2013 eLibrary. Web. 06 Mar. 2014. Head, Tom. “Lesbian and Gay Adoption Rights.” Lesbian and Gay Rights 101, 14 June, 003. Web. 13 March. 2014. Hudson

Private Politics, Corporate Social Responsibility, and Integrated Strategy

8658 words - 35 pages conclude that good Žnancial performance leads togood CSR, although for the most appropriate measure of CFP, returnon equity, the coefŽcient is signiŽcant at only the 0.10 level.7 Theyalso regress CFP on lagged CSP, but the coefŽcient on the return onequity is statistically insigniŽcant. Both GrifŽn and Mahon and Romanet al. conclude that Waddock and Graves found a positive relationshipbetween CSP and CFP. Yet, their

Similar Essays

John Q 1) Using Specific Support From The Movie 'john Q', Trace The Events That Led To The Extreme Measure Of Hijacking The Emergency Room

887 words - 4 pages The movie ‘John Q’ contains a lot of drama, suspence and is very emotional. This movie tells about a man who is desperate for financial resources to save the life of his sick son, taking staffs and patients of an emergency room as hostages in return for his sons’s sugery. ‘John Q’ allow us to understand some of the important facts of family life. John Q played by the actor ‘Denzel Washington’ handles a strong

House Id Jhgfle Essay

461 words - 2 pages former Confederate officeholders and the richest planters n  States nullify their acts of secession n  States abolish slavery n  Refuse to pay Confederate government debts q  How was the plan received in the South? Enthusiastically supported it q  How did Confederates continue to discriminate against African- Americans? They did not grant voting rights to freedmen q

Biology Movements Through Membrane Cell 12.34 High School And 5 Th Uyear Education

527 words - 3 pages uptake of minerals in a plant? A. Visking tubing Q. What is active transport? A. Active transport Q. What is meant by osmoregulation? A. Movement of molecules against a concentration gradient using energy Q. Name two substances that enter a human muscle cell by diffusion. A. Controlling the water/salt balance within an organism Q. Where precisely does water enter a plant? A. Oxygen; Glucose; Water; Amino acids; Phosphate; Iron Q. Suggest an

Bitcoin Essay

1031 words - 4 pages up from z blocks behindIdentitiesTrusted Third PartyPublicq ={ 1 if p≤q} z q/pz if pq6CounterpartyPublicGiven our assumption that p > q, the probability drops exponentially as the number of blocks the attacker has to catch up with increases. With the odds against him, if he doesn't make a lucky lunge forward early on, his chances become vanishingly small as he falls further behind.We now consider how long the