This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Triumph Of Bundle Theory: A Lack Of Evidence For An Enduring Self

1270 words - 5 pages

I. Introduction
When thinking about the self, one is inclined to accept the idea of a personal identity that survives throughout time. This tendency is reflected in substance theory, the belief that the self is not just a collection of properties such as experiences and perceptions, but the vehicle for possessing these properties. The bundle theory makes the opposite argument. The theory claims that the inclinations for a personal identity are natural but flawed, as the self is simply a bundle of perceptions. Both theories have a large amount of support, but the bundle theory better explains the true nature of the individual. While the substance theory is lacking in real evidence for its viewpoint of the self, the bundle theory makes a clear argument through the account of perception.

II. Substance Theory and the Substratum
The idea of substance stems from the Latin word substansia, meaning “something that stands under or grounds things” (Robinson). Substance theorists believe in the necessity of a substance that is able to “stand under” the properties attributed to it. In Categories, Aristotle argued for the idea of a primary substance, which cannot be predicable to anything else (Robinson). Primary substances were “objects of predication” that could take on a number of contradictories; for example, they could shift from hot to cold. Without the substance, the properties would cease to exist (Robinson). Rene Descartes supported this idea, saying, “In general, no act or accident can exist without a substance for it to belong to.”
Locke also believed in this idea that properties must be held by something to exist. He argued for the existence of a substratum that could support these properties (Bennett). The substratum, also known as the thin particular, is the particular without the properties. It is the “bearer of properties”; it holds the self together (Benovsky 9). That is to say, in the views of substance theory, a person exists because the substratum binds together the properties that make up that person.

III. Bundle Theory and Perceptions
In opposition to substance theory, bundle theory maintains that the self is nothing more than a bundle of properties. David Hume argued for this viewpoint through explanations rooted in the idea of perception. In A Treatise of Human Nature, Hume wrote, “When I enter most intimately into what I call myself, I always stumble on some particular perception or other.” Examples of such perceptions include pain and pleasure, heat and cold (Hume). These perceptions are in constant flux; man’s perceptions vary with just the slight turn of an eye in its socket (Hume). Because man perceives only these perceptions, he is not able to conceive self or substance.
While the substance theory argues for a substratum, the bundle theory believes that when a particular is stripped of its universals and properties, there is nothing left (Sider). Hume illustrates this point with the example of death. Many believe death...

Find Another Essay On The Triumph of Bundle Theory: A Lack of Evidence for an Enduring Self

Evidence of the theory of evolution

809 words - 3 pages There is abundant evidence that evolution occurs-that some species change over time, that other species diverge and become one or more new species, and that still other species become extinct. Darwin's theory was that evolution progresses through natural selection. The synthetic theory of evolution combines natural selection with the influence of genetics. These theories, together with the evidence for evolution from population genetics

The Triumph of Words Essay

1331 words - 6 pages “[working] like a beast” (20) in the mines, trying to earn money to start a life for himself and Rosa. After Esteban hits Clara, she will not talk to him, and it drives him crazy. He “[pursues] her up and down the house, begging her with his eyes and drilling holes in the bathroom wall” (224), but she continues to ignore him. This shows the dominance of the power of words, or the lack of words, over physical power because in their struggle, Clara

The Enduring Allure of Tragedy

1233 words - 5 pages , witless, senseless, mad old man” (Sophocles 1216). Subsequently, Creon feels his wrath for having brought the man, although Creon seems to be a trusted advisor who is well intentioned and eager to help. Both Oedipus and Willy are too firmly entrenched in the notions which have defined their lives: anyone who challenges their sense of self is dealt with harshly. Lastly, as these truths are revealed, neither man is able to correct his course in

The Triumph Of Homosapiens

515 words - 2 pages The Triumph of Homo sapiens Man has been on this earth for a relatively short time compared to how long the earth has been around. In this short time, humans have changed the face of the planet irreparably. What caused the first Homo sapiens to change the environment to suit their needs rather than vise versa? The ability to communicate vocally in detail has advanced mankind further then other species that has ever existed. With every necessity

does evidence support the theory of an innate language acquisition mechanism?

1733 words - 7 pages children are biologically programmed to learn language.Another argument supporting this theory could be the fact that deaf children of hearing parents develop and use sign language without any adult input (Goldin- Meadow & Mylander, 1978). For instance, in 1970 the Nicaraguan government founded the first school for deaf children. Most students came from families with hearing parents and had no idea of an official sign language, nor was there a

The Effects of a lack of Sleep

1689 words - 7 pages . Insomnia; is also known as a deficiency of sleep or sleep deprivation. People with this condition are apt to suffer from inadequate sleep and be a candidate in the battle of depression. Other symptoms are having poor concentration, and can be involved in auto accidents; from a lack of focus. Having sleep deprivation issues for prolonged periods of time; can cause a person some sort of health dilemma, whether mental or physical. (Harvard Medical School

The Effects of a Lack of Sleep

1105 words - 5 pages Insomnia; is also known as a deficiency of sleep or sleep deprivation. People with this condition are apt to suffer from inadequate sleep and more likely to battle depression, have poor concentration, and be involved in an auto accident; from a lack of focus. These issues followed by prolonged periods of time; can cause a person some sort of health issues, whether mental or physical.(Harvard Medical School) Sleep deprivation alters the

The Triumph of the Bolsheviks

1837 words - 7 pages -Litovsk, which was an actual crisis for Russia, as it resulted in huge territorial losses. The Germans took all the land they had control of, including Finland, Turkey, Rumania. Poland, the Baltic States, Georgia and the Ukraine. Russia also suffered a vast loss of infrastructure; 26% population, 27% of its best farming land and 74% of its coal and iron ore. Lenin still insisted it was worth it because it gave the Bolsheviks

The Triumph of the Will

748 words - 3 pages The Triumph of the Will The movie opens with what seems to be a godly welcome. The images of the white clouds, the sun is shining , men, women, and children all smiling and rejoicing at the arrival of a god. As if he were a god Hitler descends down into Nuremberg to the awaiting people where he is exalted as the most high. There is optimism and enthusiasm in the air. However, this man who is receiving all this admiration and praise did not

A Lack of Authority

1448 words - 6 pages An essential aspect of the autobiography is the writer’s authority to tell the story. Thomas De Quincey believes that has this authority with his work Confessions of an English Opium-Eater. He writes about his personal experience taking opium in a two part serial. This experience is what De Quincey thinks gives him the authority to talk about opium and its effects on the “opium-eater.” The title of his work, however, shows that De Quincey does

Grete’s Violin And Dorotea’s Bundle As Symbols Of Humanity That Contrast With Pedro Paramo And Gregor’s Father’s Lack Of Humanity

1390 words - 6 pages connections, but through compassion for one another. Dorotea’s mothering instinct for a bundle of a rebozo represents humanity and parental love. Dorotea takes care her of the bundle of rebozo with an unconditional love, as if it was a baby. “I could feel him in my arms, my sweet baby, with his little mouth and eyes and hands. For a long, long time I could feel his eyelids and the beating of his heart with my fingertips” (Rulfo 60). She sees this

Similar Essays

The Lack Of Evidence For Creationism

877 words - 4 pages heartedly, Darwin himself was as devout Christian as was his wife as such the publishing of the book was a big decision for him, he put in masses of work into collecting proof of evolution; he even undertook a 5 year ship journey around the world collecting evidence for his theory. Unlike creationism which is based on stories written long ago, and we know that over time things change and are exaggerated. Creationism states that the earth and everything

The Constituion Is A Bundle Of Compromises

980 words - 4 pages impeachment.The evidence provided in the preceding discussion supports my belief of the statement; "the constitution is a bundle of compromises." for each problem that arises at the constitutional convention, a compromise was created to settle the disputes between the states delegates. An example of a compromise would be the "Great Compromise" which settled the arguments over the Virginia and New Jersey Plan.Nash, Gary B., and Julie R. Jeffrey, eds. The American People: Creating a Nation and a Society. 5th ed. Los Angeles: Priscillia McGeehon, 2001. 220-246.

The Obesity Epidemic: A Lack Of Self Control

1132 words - 5 pages The Obesity Epidemic: A Lack of Self-Control According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), “More than one-third of U.S. adults (34.9%) are obese” (“Adult Obesity”, 2014). Considering the wide amounts of freedom and choices that American citizens have, this number is startling. Americans have gone from being some of the most productive, hard-working people in the world, to ignorant, lazy citizens who take what they have for

A Finnish Bundle Of Joy Essay

2549 words - 11 pages countries around the world. It is intriguing that something as simple as a box can serve as a cradle, a closet, a stepping stone, a role model, and an overall statistic for the little country of Finland. In 1938, Finland, along with the U.S, and other countries, was suffering from the stock market crashing. Many people were left in poverty and lacked money to correctly raise and support their families. Though the flow of money stopped, the flow