The Trolley Problem, By Judith Jarvis Thomson

929 words - 4 pages

The Bystander at the Switch case is a fundamental part of Thomson’s argument in “Trolley Problem.” The basis of her paper is to explain the moral difference between this case, which she deems morally permissible (1398), and the Transplant case, which she deems morally impermissible (1396). In the Bystander at the Switch case, a bystander sees a trolley hurtling towards five workers on the track and has the option of throwing a switch to divert the trolley’s path towards only one worker. Thomson finds the Bystander at the Switch case permissible under two conditions:
1) first, that the same threat is diverted from a larger to a smaller group of people, and
2) second, that the means by which this threat is diverted does not in itself constitute an infringement of anyone’s rights (1407).
However, in order for her thesis to be correct, the Bystander at the Switch case must always be morally permissible. There should be no situation in which it is morally impermissible to kill the one and save the five. If there were such a situation, where both parts of Thomson’s thesis remained true but it would still be morally impermissible to kill the one because of some outside factor, then Thomson’s thesis would no longer be the complete answer.
Let’s consider the Mother-Son case. The trolley is still hurtling towards five workers. Here, the bystander is a woman who has the option of throwing a switch to divert the path of the trolley towards only one person. In this case, however, that one person happens to be her son. Is it still morally permissible for her to throw the switch? I would have to say no.
However, in this case, the decision of flipping the switch to divert the path of the trolley still satisfies both of Thomson’s conditions. First, the threat of the trolley is being diverted from a larger to a smaller group of people, from the five to the one. And second, no one’s rights are being infringed upon.
It may be argued that the son has a stringent right not to be killed by his own mother, and by flipping the switch, the mother would be infringing on this right and therefore not satisfy Thomson’s second condition. However, Thomson does concede that even in the Bystander in the Switch case, the bystander does infringe a right of the one’s (1406), but she justifies this by distinguishing the outcome of the action from the means by which the outcome was achieved. In other words:
Turning the trolley onto the right-hand track is not itself an infringement of a right of anybody’s. The agent would do the one no wrong at all if he turned the trolley onto the right-hand track, and by some miracle the trolley did not hit him. (Thomson 1409)

Find Another Essay On The Trolley Problem, by Judith Jarvis Thomson

Stephen Kumalo and James Jarvis tied to a theme in Cry, the Beloved Country by Alan Paton

894 words - 4 pages the heart in the days of our distress" (123). Kumalo finally admits to Msimangu after his sermon that he has been touched by the strength that Msimangu had that allowed him to lead Kumalo out of the darkness that he had fallen into. Paton believes that even those that falter are able to redeem themselves. On the first day that Stephen is in Johannesburg, he works to restore something that those people had lost and it is stated that, "One day in

Comparing "The Killer" by Judith Wright and "The flowers" by Alice Walker

889 words - 4 pages Bibliography:Mainly took notes from teacher, used wikipedia to look at the writer "Judith Wright's" background: the poem "The Killer" by Judith Wright and "The flowers" by Alice Walker deals with death, but in different ways. "The Killer" outline an incident of a girl killing a snake, suggesting that us human beings kill things that we fear, that we believe is harmful. While Alice Walker's "The

Issues reflected in "The Precipice" by Judith Wright and "In the Park" by Gwen Hardwood

1271 words - 5 pages , as she has given everything she has to the children.Both poems have discussed important issues including motherhood, the environment and war. Both Judith Wright and Gwen Harwood have challenged the Australian stereotypical mother by displaying an extreme alternative to the conventional mother’s life. “The Precipice” challenges the idea that the decisions and actions of war are just and suitable as a solution to a problem, and likens war to suicide. The last stanza warns humanity to keep away from war, as it only brings destruction and tragedy.

"The Story of My Body" by Judith Ortiz Cofer, and "Never Just Pictures" by Susan Bordo

1275 words - 5 pages society: friends, place, and education. We reflect what we think it is correct in the opinions of others. This idea is expanded and explained in two essays: "The Story of My Body" written by Judith Ortiz Cofer, and "Never Just Pictures" by Susan Bordo.In the first essay, Cofer suggest that our body plays an essential role in our social life. The differences of race, color, and size can create many uncomfortable situations in our adolescence. She tells

Effect of Divorce on Children: What About The Kids? by Judith S. Wallerstein and Sandra Blakeslee

1051 words - 4 pages towards separation. Divorce does not signify separation for parents only; it also implies the consequence of a series of eternal effects for children if not treated carefully. Works Cited 1. “What About The Kids? Raising Your Children Before, During, and After Divorce” by Judith Wellerstein and Sandra Blakeslee. 2. American Academy of Child and Adolescent 3. 4. “Parenting After Divorce; Resolving Conflicts and Meeting Your Children’s Needs” by Philip M. Stahl, Ph.D. 5. “The Truth About Divorce” by Barry Youngerman and Mark J. Kittleson, Ph.D. 6. “Helping Your Kids Cope with Divorce” by M. Gary Neuman, L.M.H.C.

Type of motivation used in the novel Ordinary People, by Judith Guest

712 words - 3 pages In my opinion, cognitive motivation best represents the type of human behavior that is evident throughout the novel, Ordinary People, by Judith Guest. Simply, this type of motivation, as defined by Webster, is "a need or desire that causes a person to act." Behavior reflects many influences besides cognition. For example, external forces have the ability to dictate a person's behavior. Plato believed that people "do what they perceive to be

"the problem of pain" by CS Lewis

1062 words - 4 pages The Problem of Pain answers the universal question, "Why would an all-loving, all-knowing God allow people to experience pain and suffering?" Master Christian supporter C.S. Lewis asserts that pain is a problem because our predetermined, human minds selfishly believe that pain-free lives would prove that God loves us. In truth, by asking for this, we want God to love us less, not more, than he does. "Love, in its own nature, demands the

"Sports Field" by Judith Wright: "Explore the distinctive qualities of the poem, explain how the poem reflects Wright's concerns and explain her literary styles and values implied"

1327 words - 5 pages Judith Wright once said in an interview, "I write poetry because it's one way to understand life". Being able to understand life and how it works seems to be Wright's intention in the poem Sports Field, a poem that she was inspired to write after going to a school sports day. The entire poem is a metaphor for a deeper understanding of children, in the ball games and races they participate in, representing their individual life-courses. In

The Domesticity Of Giraffes By Judith Beveridge

684 words - 3 pages The poem, “The Domesticity of Giraffes” portrays the agony of a giraffe confined in captivity. The concepts of power and powerlessness are evidently portrayed through the uses of several techniques such as metaphors, allegory, contrast and oxymoron. It is through these techniques that the concepts of power and powerlessness are conveyed to readers.The poet’s use of metaphor assists in conveying the idea of individual and social

Androids and the Mind/Body Problem by Rebecca King

840 words - 4 pages The Star Trek: The Next Generation episode “The Measure of a Man” makes a compelling argument on androids and the mind/body problem. The episode is about Lt. Commander Data who is an android who acts identically to human behavior. Data is put on trial to find out if he should have human rights or if he is considered property of Starfleet. The episode makes interesting points as to what qualifies a person of having a mind and soul. William Hasker

The Problem of Natural Evil, by Luke Gelinas

1264 words - 5 pages free-will, so in this case, natural evil is not justified by the value that free-will brings since there is none being exercised. Although Gelinas points out that Swinburne does not state that all natural evils can be explained, my argument questions whether Swinburne’s argument actually can explain all natural evil and it increases the improbability of the argument that natural evil is necessary for free-will for all cases of natural evils. Works Cited Gelinas, L. 2009. “The Problem of Natural Evil I: General Theistic Replies.” Philosophy Compass, 4/3, pp. 533, 540-542

Similar Essays

A Defence Against Abortion By Judith Jarvis Thomson

773 words - 4 pages In this essay I will be defending Judith Jarvis Thomson’s argument on `` A defence against Abortion``. In her argument she talks about how based on the situation a woman should be able to make a decision on her own whether she would want to keep the baby, or have an abortion, Thomson then stats that abortion should be legal, but only in some cases, she then stats her analogy. (Thomson, 1971, Page 48) “imagine this. You wake up in the morning

Judith Jarvis Thomson: A Defense Of Abortion Analysis

1491 words - 6 pages and we have to lie in bed for nine months. Thus Thomson's reasoning is it that a person may now permissibly unplug them self from the violinist even though this will cause his death. The right to life, Thomson says, does not demand the right to use another person's body, and so by unplugging the violinist you do not violate his right to life but merely deprive him of the use of your body to which he has no right. If a person allows the violinist

The Trolley Problem And The Morality Of Killing

1340 words - 5 pages II (Routledge, 2nd ed, 2001) 947-50. Ibid. Ibid. Michael J. Sandel, Justice: What's the right thing to do? (Penguin Books, 2009) 39 Judith Jarvis Thomson, The Trolley Problem, 94 Yale Law Journal 1395-1415 (1985) Ibid. Ibid. p. PAGE 1

The Two Brothers By Judith Beveridge

596 words - 2 pages How is the concept of power and powerlessness depicted in this text? "The Two Brothers" by Judith Beveridge portrays the perspective of a young girl forced to witness the horrific torture of animals by two brothers. The concept of power and powerlessness is presented in the poem. There are many techniques which assist in conveying this idea some include euphemism, simile, contrast and metaphor. Through these techniques readers gain a deeper