The Trouble With History Essay

1080 words - 4 pages

Our history is what defines our character, shapes our social views, and gives us a sense of pride in how far we have come. The trouble with history is that it is presented to us as children through the interpretations of historians and textbook editors. This means that every few generations school children are introduced to "their particular version of America", they focus on different events and ideas from the past, and develop their own way of thinking about our history and the world in general. In "Rewriting American History" Frances Fitzgerald describes the differences between history books from her childhood and the newer ones from the nineteen-seventies; the examples show how the changes in content and perspective of junior high school history books affect the student's view of the country and it's annals. The message behind this comparison is that our image of history is shaped by the way it's presented to us early on, which is why different generations of school children develop "their particular version of America."The first step in understanding this essay is to analyze the points of contrast and similarity that the author concentrates on. His focus is on the political views, pedagogical approach, presentation and content of the two generations of schoolbooks.In the fifties American history was taught with "weighty volumes", which "spoke in measured cadances: imperturbable, humorless, and as distant as Chinese emperors." It seems like the textbooks were collections of generally agreed-upon facts with an emphasis on glorifying American heroes such as Columbus, John Smith and Daniel Boone. This choice of content reflects the conservative ideals of a united, postwar America in the fifties. It's easy to see how the views of society can influence the interpretation of history in contemporary textbooks.In contrast to the older books, the author gives examples of content from some of the more modern texts. The focus has shifted from old American heroes to modern leaders and ideas like conservation and the Civil Rights Movement. Newer books also "hint at a certain level of unpleasantness in American history." This is of course the writers personal opinion, but it sparks the question: Is this unplesantness a form of bias or just the result of a change in content? Aren't the modern books just focusing on a different, less flattering part of our history, which was not mentioned in the fifties? That would mean that publishers have gained more freedom in what they can include and discuss in their textbooks. This could be the result of a more liberal attitude in our society.Another point of contrast made by FitzGerald is in the physical appearance or presentation of the textbooks. The books of the fifties, when compared to the modern ones, "look as naive as Soviet fashion magazines." They were simple in design and had conventinal, unprovacotive photos and drawings. Newer books have sophisticated design and high detail pictures with historical...

Find Another Essay On The Trouble With History

Television's Effect on Families as Expressed in Marie Winn's Article "The Trouble with Television"

880 words - 4 pages It may be hard to admit, but television has become an intricate part of our everyday lives. People children often find themselves sitting in front of the television screen for a longer period of time than before and this has evolved immensely over the past few years. In this article, “The Trouble with Television,” by the author Marie Winn, mentions that addiction of television is negative effects on children and families. It keeps the families

The Trouble with Wet Seal {introduction, history of the retailer,identify a problem, make a plan of action, and then find ways to implement your plan, and conclusion}

1316 words - 5 pages . They brought in an overly eclectic assortment of clothing that included styles varying from urban to skater and eventually led to customer confusion. That particular mix of merchandise does not identify with one customer and became confusing as to what kind of a store Wet Seal is and what demographic they were and still are seeking to obtain. They acquired and placed too many dissimilar trends in the store, thus abandoning their target customer

Dining with the presidents of U.S history

1157 words - 5 pages In the United States of America, the president has served as the leader of his nation (serving as the executive branch out of the three branches of government). Three of these presidents have inspired, spurred, and supported major causes and event throughout history. First, George Washington, the patriotic war hero and the first presidentof the United States of America during the American Revolutionary War against Great Britain. Second

The history of television with MLA format and works cited!

883 words - 4 pages beam. The beam moves from the top left corner and moves to the right. Then it moves back again and down to the next line. The first cameras could only read 13 lines. By 1941 the television cameras could read 525 lines. This provided the television with a much clearer picture (Riehecky19-20).Colored television wasn't available to the public until 1953, even though this was a concept that was in the works since before televisions were available. In

Beer: The Production History and Consumption Of Beer with Ref

4454 words - 18 pages tensions and stresses of daily living in a hostile world. (Buhner 35)Beer was a driving force that led nomadic groups into village life. Ten thousand years ago barley was domesticated and worshipped as a god in the highlands of southern Levant. With the creation of writing, using a stylus on wet clay tablets, beer, its history and mystery, became a large part of an ancient literary repertoire. Beer was considered a valuable foodstuff and workers were

Notes on The Crucible and Early American History Subject- History: Early American with Literature

1574 words - 6 pages Miller's Vision (The Crucible)A crucible is a contraption that changes low based metals into gold...They came to create a new Jerusalem.... the Puritans say that they have a new covenant and they will do again what history failed to do and they will do it right, to create a perfect community-- a new Jerusalem... they created Salem (Jeru-Salem)The Puritans new vision is to purfiy their new vision and that's how they start up, but by 1690 the

Trouble With Chechnya

3239 words - 13 pages relations with it.      “The Chechens are an ethnically distinct, traditionally clan-based group with a long history of resisting Russian expansion in the Northern Caucasus” (Yasin, 2002). The hostility existing between the Chechen people and Russia, however, predates both the Russian republic and the Soviet Union, going back to the late 18th Century, when Russia’s drive to the South, initiated by Peter the Great in 1722, “led

Trouble Maker

616 words - 2 pages the policemen took my statement about what happened. The policemen that took me statement recognized me from school and notice I was one of the trouble-makers. He told me that he had something to slow me down and his solution was a Youth Detention Center in Thomasville, Georgia, by this time my parents were there so he discussed it with my mother and he gave me another chance. From that point on, I don't think I got in anymore trouble while in

Double Trouble

850 words - 3 pages Christopher GreenInstructor Christina WoodsEnglish 10131 January 2014Double Trouble: Mrs. Penn and Mrs. MallardOvercoming adversity and disappointment and seeing a bright side to it can be difficult. In the story "The Revolt of Mother" and "The Story of an Hour" the authors Wilkins and Chopin wrote about two women who did just this. Wilkin's character Sarah was an older woman who had a disagreement with her husband over building a house. Louise

Lighthouse Trouble

1420 words - 6 pages was too busy trying to think what Mrs.Grace race was going to do when I arrived late without having my homework done. I started to sweat and my heart was beating faster. Mrs.Grace race hasn't been the nicest teacher to me this year. I was not good at impressing her with lack of studying. I had to be extra careful not to get in trouble.  Within fifteen minutes, my mom had arrived in front of the house. I started to prepare myself to a lot of

Big Trouble in Big Trouble

1970 words - 8 pages , and the confusion the characters feel when they are thrown from one situation to another adds to the amusement. More characters are constantly introduced, usually in pairs. Two misfit criminals, two grizzled yet playful cops, and two no-nonsense FBI agents enter the scene at various moments throughout the film. By the end the audience often has trouble keeping up with the multiple scenarios running at the same time, which the director uses to

Similar Essays

Trouble With The Tube Essay

2151 words - 9 pages many hours of television exploration, we need to be more careful with the jeopardy that is sure to follow. For instance some of the dangers that succeed superfluous amounts of television include; Health complications such as heart disease and obesity (which are the most common), developmental concerns for youth, which include education, behaviors and trouble focusing. When television is used as a pacifier on our youth, the outcome can be

The Trouble With Power Essay

1345 words - 5 pages untouchable in his position of power. Marcus Antony also had a problems with his management of power but the reason for his trouble was of a different nature. Marcus Antony was great military man, of the same caliber as both Julius Caesar and Coriolanus. He attained great recognition and glory because of his military accomplishments. Much like Coriolanus, he was thrust into a position of political power because of the fact that

The Trouble With Working It Essay

1603 words - 6 pages The Trouble with Working It Alison Hooker is a bright young woman. She is a middler communications major at Northeastern University and performing well in her classes. She has experience as a waitress and recently finished her first co-op at a broadcasting company in her native Chicago. She is friendly and outgoing, and carries herself with a confident, yet approachable demeanor. In all regards, she appears to be a capable and collected

The Trouble With Testosterone And The Biology Of The Human Predicament By Robert M. Sapolsky

1507 words - 6 pages Many behavioral biologists seek answers to the mysterious interactions between the human’s minds and bodies. Robert M. Sapolsky, American neurosurgeon, neuroscientist, professor of biology at Stanford University, researcher and author of the book The Trouble With Testosterone and Other Essays on the Biology of the Human Predicament. This book shows the reader why people act the way they do and what goes on when an event occurs. Sapolsky covered