This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Truth Of Democracy: Why Epistemic Proceduralism May Not Be A Cure All

2087 words - 9 pages

INTRODUCTION
In his book, Democratic Authority: A Philosophical Framework, author David Estlund proposes a method of democratic decision making that he calls “epistemic proceduralism.” In preparing to write this critique, I attempted to gain at least a brief but clear understanding of Estlund’s entire framework. Whilst for time and space reasons, I could not delve into all of the available materials, I did happily find that much of this book, including the chapter I will reference primarily in this paper, is very in-depth and well thought-out by Estlund.
The main premise of his argument is thus: democratic decisions must use intellectual, epistemic methods of arriving at any conclusion in order to be held as legitimate. By the very process of using epistemic methods, the decisions made are more likely to be the correct ones for the situation at hand.
In the following pages I will attempt to explain Estlund’s thesis and position for epistemic proceduralism. I will discuss the main ideas of his argument. I will then present a detailed critique of Estlund’s rational, and finally, I will offer a counter-argument that I believe will supersede the flaws in Estlund’s theory.
ESTLUND’S ARGUMENT
To begin with, let us break down Estlund’s phrase into its literal meaning. “Epistemic,” as we by now know, is the study of knowledge in and of itself. As for “proceduralism,” we can intuitively discern that it is the process of progressing toward something.
Ergo, at its most basic meaning, epistemic proceduralism concerns the use of knowledge to effectively employ a democratic method of decision making. In order to be a useful and legitimate method of democracy, the results of any procedure must inherently be “better than random.” That is to say, the results must have some epistemic roots at its core. A random outcome has no place in a system of democratic justice. For example, a well-known process of decision making is a simple lottery system, wherein an outcome is chosen completely at random, and it may or may not be correct. One playing card from a deck may be chosen at random, but if the purpose is to choose the “correct” answer – let’s say in this case, the Ace of Spades, there is of course the possibility of choosing correctly by chance, but it is very unlikely. You see then, why this method with regards to democracy and the justice system simply does not work.
Estlund’s theory addresses this problem directly: “Thus, rather than supposing that the legitimacy of an outcome depends on its correctness, I suggest that it derives, partly, from the epistemic value, even though it is imperfect, of the procedure that produced it. Democratic legitimacy requires that the procedure can be held, in terms acceptable to all qualified points of view, to be epistemically the best (or close to it) among those that are better than random.” (98)
According to Estlund, his theory combines two necessary elements that cannot work alone, yet complement each other...

Find Another Essay On The Truth of Democracy: Why Epistemic Proceduralism May Not Be A Cure-All

The cure for ills of Democracy is More Democracy

2850 words - 11 pages form associations, including political parties that may oppose the government; the right to run fro office, and the right to vote without intimidation and to chose from a slate of at least two candidates.The principles are very important and following them is essential for the success of a democracy. Furthermore it is vital to understand that they are part of an evolution and not the opposite. Trying to keep them static would be going against

A Summary of Epistemic Relativism Essay

1181 words - 5 pages necessary and sufficient conditions of knowledge? What are its sources? What is its structure, and what are its limits ("Epistemology ")? Epistemic relativism is when the facts used to establish the truth or falsehood of any statement are understood to be relative to the perspective of those proving or falsifying the proposition. While many people scoff at the very idea of epistemic relativism , what they are turning down is a way of thinking that

This essay is about teens and high risk behaviors (drugs) why not to do them and where they will bring you with three examples why teens may choose to try drugs

904 words - 4 pages were asked if we wanted to some "pot" nervously we all said alright and got high. Yes, I still smoke weed, and think nothing of it; I do not find it wrong in any way although it has gotten me into many other drugs.I think that some teens do drugs because of a bad childhood. They may use drugs as a means to escape from past pain and problems. Instead of sports, music, or other hobbies they decide to use drugs as a distraction. I for one have been

A bit about how Walt Whitman may not be the writer everyone says he is. He may qualify to be in the justice leage of writers, but if he does, he's Hawk Man

623 words - 2 pages is capable of being many things and in this proves that he can not be defined because no one definition could ever surface. He isn't A hunter or A maiden, He is The Hunter and The Maiden. These are not jobs, they are people. These are lives. These are Whitman. They are not part of him, they are all of him. This may appear to be transcending, but all poets bend the rules a little. Whitman was no a more a Transcendentalist than he was a Beat

“what am I without my Buffo’s face? Why, nobody at all. Take away my makeup and underneath is merely not-Buffo.” (Carter 122) To what extent do th

2222 words - 9 pages and analyzes her anatomy in a scientific manner comparable to Darwinism “by all the laws of evolution and human reason” . He represents the typical, Enlightenment masculine character who rationalizes any situation, no matter how bizarre or unreal it may appear, and Fevvers is no exception. He indicates that, biologically, she is impossible: it’s her arms that ought to be her wings! Put it another way: would you believe that a lady with four arms

Ego Tripping (There May Be a Reason Why)

889 words - 4 pages selves. Women were meant to be seen and not heard as some would say. In the poem a women suggests that there may be a reason why African American women are here by showing her power as a women through history by displaying herself as a gazelle, a mother, and a goddess. Giovanni writes about a gazelle in the poem. It says “with a packet of goat’s meat and a change of clothes/ I crossed it in two hours/ I am a gazelle so swift/ so swift you

Why the Federalists thought a larger Union would be better for democracy

1557 words - 6 pages sphere of a republic may be extended (Madison 50).Firstly, in a republic, delegates are chosen by the people in order to represent the good of the whole in government. Madison deems this more beneficial to that end than a democracy in which all people convene for that purpose. Although there can be no guarantee that the representatives will work solely for the common good, it is better than a congress of all citizens, each representing their own

Q 1. Briefly describe 2 survey examples where a census of all items of interest may be appropriate

776 words - 3 pages Ans.Census - this is when the entire population of interest is surveyed for the purpose of data analysis.A census is appropriate when:1) The population of interest is small, for example, a satisfaction survey for a new course (as the class is a relatively small number of people all can be surveyed).2) The relevant data for the entire population is readily available, for example government statistics, which draw on census data.Q 2. For each of

A breif history of the reasons in which the Israelites and Palestines have been waring and why peace may never be acived

953 words - 4 pages Oden 1Robert J. OdenMrs. RogersENG 4123.134 March 2003Israel: A Country in TurmoilIsrael, whose country has a rich historical background, is the center of much tension in the middle east. Since it's creation on May 14 1948, there have been hostile feelings between Israel and it's Arab neighbors. There has been many lives lost on both sides by terrorist and army regulars. And country is hard pressed on the economy to support its vast military

Parents May Not Be Licensed

1810 words - 8 pages intend to protect children’s life by abusing them, since parents do love their children and concern their safety almost all the time. Overall, the amount of harm from such parental abuse tends to be cancelled by the benefit of children learning to stay safe, and thus, one cannot claim such parental abuse to be harmful to children without a clear definition of harm. Similarly, it could be argued that parents may not harm children by neglecting them

Why The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn should not be banned

846 words - 3 pages as a sign of how much we have evolved(Dawkins 1). It is wrong to ignore the past simply because we don't know how to explain it. A large part of moving forward in the world depends on addressing problems and difficult situations. People have been reading "Huck Finn" and "Tom Sawyer for over a century and it has not stopped us from evolving and moving past slavery and racism for the most part. Why should we all of a sudden change Twain's book now

Similar Essays

Your Father Smells Of Elder Berries! Why It May Not Be An Insult After All: Analysis Of Sambucas Nigra

2249 words - 9 pages , increases cyanide levels which can result in a toxic build up and cyanide poisoning. The authors recommend if there is a toxic overdose, Ipecac should be used to stimulate emesis followed by gastric lavage. The study also warns if the berries, root and bark are not cooked properly, severe and uncontrollable GI distress (abdominal cramping, vomiting, diarrhea) occurs in addition to the risk of cyanide toxicity. A popular medication with liquid

Outline Why 'recorded Crime' May Not Be An Accurate Reflection Of The Actual Numbers Of Crimes That Take Place

887 words - 4 pages This assignment will outline why recorded crime may not be an accurate reflection of the actual crimes that take place. By using course materials it will discus the doubts raised about statistical evidence of crime.In Great Britain there are many crimes committed and when a crime is reported to the police it is then documented. Quantitive evidence shows that since 1930 there has been a large increase in crimes committed. Maguire (1997) suggests

Why All Men Are Not Created Equal

656 words - 3 pages Why All Men Are Not Equal As harsh as it sounds, not all men are created equal, especially in the United States. From the moment we are born, our lives may vary drastically from the lives of others. The types of lives we have may also determine our opportunities in life. People in America are based on their social standings and economic contribution. Some people are born into families that have a high social standing, others build up to become

We May Not Have Come From The Same Place, But We All Want To Move In The Same Direction

881 words - 4 pages about race. The speech captures the core unspoken issues that uproar in both the white and black communities. But also states that to move forward as a nation and be united as one, we must embrace the past and not become victims of it; learn from what has happened and strive to live above it.