The Tsarist System Of Government Of Russia

1392 words - 6 pages

The Tsarist System of Government of Russia

I believe that throughout history, the Tsars felt threatened. They
then reformed in order to stay in power, and to stay in for power
alone. However, this mindset only had an effect when the Tsar's power
was threatened. Nevertheless, I believe that to find the factors that
had an effect on the Russian system of government, one must look for
the reason why felt threatened. Here war was an important factor,
however it was not the only factor. Otherwise reform would not have
occurred without war. I believe that if these other aforementioned
factors were important enough to cause political change, then they
must rank alongside war in terms of importance.
However it was not "the locomotive of history". i Together with
discontent in the populace, and its manifestations (strikes,
revolutionary activity, and assassinations), I believe War invariably
changed the Russian political system.
I believe war had an impact for several reasons. Throughout the period
described Russia took part in three wars, in which they were crushed.
Firstly, when a country fails in war, some would see it as being a
sign that the country is less advanced in general. Firstly, the
realisation that one's country was backward and prone to invasion
threatened the Tsar's power, which then induced political change. He
realised that if something was not done to improve and modernise that
external enemies could be more of a danger than internal ones.
I have chosen an example to illustrate this. After the 1854-6 Crimean
War, Alexander II initiated the emancipation of the Serfs, the
creation of the Zemstvos, the Dumas, and the independent judiciary. He
was even compelled to consider relinquishing a sizeable proportion of
his power to the populace, but died before being able to implement
these ideas. This was as a direct result of Alexander having the
aforementioned realisation.
Secondly, war has the inevitable effects on the populace. Unlike
Bismark, the Tsars did not have the political clout necessary to
ensure that a war was properly prepared for. Subsequently, the long
drawn out wars slowly demoralised the Russian people and resulted in
discontent. Aside from destroying any pride they had in the "system",
they were subjected to witnessing the death of their comrades and the
draining of their country.
However, war when carried out swiftly and with success can have
positive benefits for the popularity of a ruler. Bismarck's foreign
policy showed this. But the wars in which Russia was involved in only
served to weaken the resolve of the people, and the power of the Tsar.
The floundering war effort was a factor in the Bloody Sunday, the
October Manifesto and the first revolution of 1917.
Yet there were other factors in these political upheavals and others,
as I have said...

Find Another Essay On The Tsarist System of Government of Russia

The Fall of Russia Essay

1301 words - 5 pages eight political parties, fired several high-ranking government officials who had failed to support him, and suspended Russia’s regional and town councils, many of which had sided with his opponents (Kort 421).” Therefore the Supreme Soviet had refused to support the new constitution, Yeltsin then issued a decree dissolving both the Supreme Soviet and the Congress of People’s Deputies. Furthermore, neither system wanted to view or listen to

The Origins of Russia Essay

1575 words - 6 pages The Origins of Russia The country of Russia: enormous, expansive, wide-open. The words that describe this Euro-Asian country can be attributed to its origins from its Slavic inhabitants and the takeover by the Varangians. Kievan Russia, as it was called, started its own civilization in the year 862. The problem with the origin of the Russian State is that it is exceedingly complex and many theories are based on circumstantial evidence

Comparison of the Government of Japan and Australia Legislative System

856 words - 3 pages party (or coalition) with a majority of members in the House of Representatives is invited by the (by Governor General (Queen's representative in Australia) or in Japan by the Emperor) to form the Government. The Leader becomes the Prime Minister and the other elected members of the ruling party in both the Upper and Lower House become responsible for the administration of Government departments. Figure 1 Semi-Proportional System used in Japan

The Democratic System of Government is appropriate for Pakistan

904 words - 4 pages Certain countries in the world have been ruled by the military dictators as well as the democratic leaders. Pakistan is one of the finest examples of such a system. In Pakistan, military and democratic government exchange hands time and again and this chain goes on. This is evident from the past experiences. This is also evident from current economic crisis of the country after a long period of dictatorship. It seems that the democratic system

Democracy - " A System of Government for the Ages"

716 words - 3 pages likely produce rational policies because it can count on the pooled knowledge and expertise of a society's entire population”. Numerous opinions were voiced about democracy being the better system of government to promote a stronger economic growth or a better system for material well being and expression of natural talents because the people are actually free to pursue what ever path in life makes them the happiest and gives them the most

Russia: The State of Alcoholism

3600 words - 14 pages of Kazan, began to establish special government taverns-cum-distilleries of his own. Kabaks soon appeared in most major towns, and their profits went straight into the royal treasury.Alcoholism began to rise in Russia when the state applied the method of tax farming to alcohol consumption. In order to protect the revenues earned by the kabaks, the government adopted the simple but effective device of forbidding potential rivals to distil or

The Last Tsar of Russia

2389 words - 10 pages the manifesto were enough and denounced the plan. In December 1905, after the arrest and imprisonment of Trotsky and the executive committee of the St. Petersburg, Nicholas was able to take back control of the situation and his government.2 Nicholas – The Last Tsar of Russia In April 1906 Nicholas forced the resignation of Sergei Witte, replacing him with Peter Stolypin, a conservative and former governor, to find some

The Human Government System

980 words - 4 pages The Human Government System As the Human Race enters the new millenium we have created a somewhat organized and affective society. This society consists of many states that govern their people by allowing them to go about their daily activities and providing them services without a large amount of chaos interfering in their lives “Human beings usually do not venture out of their caves (or the modern counterpart) unless there is a reasonable

Lycurgus and Spartan Government- With reference to Ancient sources you have researched, explain the Spartan System of Government

1608 words - 6 pages historians show the common account of the Delphic Oracle. This demonstrates that the Oracle must have played some role in the law-making process, even if it may only have been by the blessing of the laws written by others.The Spartan government was the earliest city-state to involve the participation of citizens. This was a time in which city-states had either an aristocratic government (a government system where a few people rule), or a monarchy (a

The Fall of Tsarism in Russia

4077 words - 16 pages The Fall of Tsarism in Russia Some sources suggest that autocracy is outdated and the reason for the collapse of Tsarist Russia. However, other sources suggest that without the complications of war, Russia may have prospered. Tolstoy and Kokovstov both have conflicting views. Tolstoy the pessimist, believed that autocracy was an outdated form of government not

Why did the provisional government [of Russia before Communism and Lenin gained control post-WW1 after the fall of the Tsar fail?

1227 words - 5 pages Why did the Provisional Government fail?One of the main reasons that Russia's provisional government failed and why the Bolsheviks were able to gain power is the First World War. The war was a disaster for Russia- people were already very discontent at the failure of the war and the shortages it caused- it was a major cause of the March revolution to overthrow the Tsar. The war was already going badly when the June-July Russian offensive was a

Similar Essays

Nothing Short Of War Could Have Any Effect On The Russian System Of Government." How Accurate Is This View Of The Tsarist System Of Government From 1800 To 1917?

1155 words - 5 pages I believe that throughout history, the Tsars felt threatened. They then reformed in order to stay in power, and to stay in for power alone. However, this mindset only had an effect when the Tsar's power was threatened. Nevertheless, I believe that to find the factors that had an effect on the Russian system of government, one must look for the reason why felt threatened. Here war was an important factor, however it was not the only factor

How Far Was Nicolas Ll Personally Responsible For The Problems Of The Tsarist Regime In Russia?

1078 words - 4 pages -traditional upper-class- had lost a lot of their power and influence. The new upper-class of bankers, merchants and intelligentsia wanted reform to the system of government, the creation of a parliament (Duma). But Nicholas, blind to the threat of a united elite and lower class-they were already protesting over shocking working conditions- wanting reform refused demands, as a result Nicholas' government nearly fell and if not for the shrewd political

Impacts On The Russian System Of Government

2403 words - 10 pages reform at this stage may have made little difference to the eventual outcome. However, from statements made by the Duma and by the request of the generals to the Tsar's brother, it was not the Tsarist system they wished to overthrow, their objective was simply to remove Nicholas II from power. Perhaps, had the Tsar realised that the Russian system of government was in desperate need for reform in order to make Russia a

Globalization And The State System Of Government

2554 words - 10 pages When answering the question “Who am I?” or “Who are we?,” more thought needs to be put into the response then ever before. The past 350 years have been characterized by the state system, which has provided the only answer one could possibly need to respond to the ‘identity question’. Everyone has identified themselves as a member of a state; a state being defined as a stable population with a government, a monopoly over the legitimate