The Two Lives Of Charlemagne Essay

931 words - 4 pages


The two lives of Charlemagne as told by Einhard and Notker are two medieval sources about the accounts of the life Charlemagne. Modern sources by Matthew Innes and Rosamond Mckitterick discuss how history was recorded during the medieval period and how it was suppose to be viewed in the early ages. Observing each of these sources helps get an understanding of how the writing of history is important in recorded history and how it affected how the history of Charlemagne was recorded.

Writing history in the early Middle Ages "was not intended to be simply a matter of keeping a record for posterity." It was to help make the past more presentable and comprehensible to the present, "whether as support for contemporary political ideology or to explain God's purpose for humanity." Works that is widely read and follows these guidelines is writings Einhard and Notker did on Charlemagne. The writings of these two men can be looked at many different ways to decide how they wanted the history of Charlemagne to be perceived. "These histories can function both as a record of the past and as the exploitation of a different world in order to make particular political or polemical points."

Critical questions can arise about Einhard's work for the simple fact he was a palace official of Charlemagne. Einhard was a minister of his Royal Majesty. He was highly respected for his knowledge, intellect, brilliance, integrity and character. He shared a personal relationship with the King and his family. It can be believed that his book was to make sure that the greatness of Charlemagne was recorded for history and maybe not the facts. The way he recorded the history of Charlemagne could have been more in the political and loyalty sense. Einhard wrote his book from the historical perspective and his personal relationship with Charlemagne.

Notker wrote his book seventy years after the death of Charlemagne in the form of a series of anecdotes about Charlemagne from the stories he heard as a child. Some of these anecdotes go more in-depth on basic information provided by Einhard. In other cases, the anecdotes tend to be exaggerated, therefore, making it hard to give Notker a lot of credibility. Yet, his work is widely read and studied as one of the works that describes the accounts of Charlemagne life.

Although it is difficult to compare these two books they both possess differences and similarities to one another. For example, in Einhard's book Charlemagne's first wife was the daughter of Desiderius, the King of the Longobards. It goes on to say that she was dismissed and never gave a reason why. In Notker's book, he says that Charlemagne had just defeated the Longobards and in order to keep them from...

Find Another Essay On The Two Lives of Charlemagne

the lives of introverts Essay

1854 words - 8 pages Every human being has a unique personality, but for the most part, people tend towards being either extroverts or introverts. Extroverts are outgoing and adventurous, while introverts enjoy spending time alone and are thoughtful. However, America’s culture values extroverts more than introverts instead of valuing the two personalities equally. In schools, students work together and must take part in discussions. In businesses, employees often

Why Charlemagne is the most influential person of the middle ages

601 words - 2 pages CharlemagneCharlemagne is the most famous ruler of the Medieval Ages and a key figure in all of European history. Charlemagne's greatest impact on European history is the Carolingian Empire (751-987), an empire greater than any known since Ancient Rome. By 800, his empire included two-thirds of Italy, all of present-day France, a small part of Spain, and all of German Saxony. In 800, Charlemagne was crowned emperor, a historic coronation

The Lives of Athenian Women

2413 words - 10 pages .' (Lacey: 1968, 151). Studies concerning the lives of women in classical Athens have sparked much controversy because, despite the apparent fascination with femininity manifested in art and drama, we have no evidence voicing the opinions of the actual women themselves. This presents a paradox between an Athenian woman's everyday life and her prominence in art and literature. (Just: 1989; Gomme: 1925, Gould: 1980; Pomeroy: 1976). The

Lives of the Lower Class

3255 words - 13 pages The lives of the lower class people as depicted by Apuleius are different in a multitude of ways. There is a "lower class" status as many people are correctly labeled throughout the story, but there are many different types of lower class citizens. There are slaves, freed ex-slaves, farmers, and just really poor people who are forced to fight for survival. All of these types of people can be correctly identified as "lower class." Some lower

the game of our lives

931 words - 4 pages Sharon Kim20/11/14"The game of our lives""They were of us, playing the game of our lives" In the story "The game of our lives" Gzowski talks about his boyhood interest in ice hockey, he describes his childhood in a very cheerful, positive and passionate way. He uses a lot of imagery to capture the reader's thoughts. He clearly states that he very much enjoys ice hockey in the story. "Weekends were the best. I would wake early Saturday morning

The Greatest King of Franks: Charlemagne, is about the hitorical significance and what led him to such a significant reign.

1539 words - 6 pages because it was begun by his father, but continued past his death when Charlemagne took over. Charlemagne engaged in his longest and bitterest campaign against the Saxons, a pagan people in north-western Germany in 772. He subdued the Saxons after about thirty-two years of war and forced them to accept Christianity. No war was ever fought by the Frank nations like this one because they carried on with such persistence and severity, and cost so much

The Media Destroys the Lives of Women

1630 words - 7 pages Media is everywhere. From T.V commercials to popular magazines, media exist. It has created norms that people have adopted in their everyday lives. Women have been forced to believe that they are inferior to men and are incompetent individuals. Society has given women the short end of the stick. Woman have been led to a corner of insecurity and despondency due to the reprehensible effect of the media. There are many aspects that

"The Lives of a Cell" Analysis

661 words - 3 pages cells exist ecosystems containing living organisms such as the mitochondria. This argument forces one to think differently about themselves and other living creatures. Instead of single organisms people are collections of small, but very much alive, pieces each with, as Thomas put it, “ecosystems more complex than the Jamaica Bay” (p.37 line 56-57). This in turn shows two things to prove Thomas’ point. Firstly, “The Lives of a Cell” displays a view

Divorce in the Lives’ of Children

1040 words - 5 pages Divorce is becoming increasingly common among couples in today’s time. It is sad to know that most cases of divorce involve children. Divorce affects the parents but it affects the children much more. Divorce impacts kids greatly, often causing depression, rebellion, or inspiration/motivation, to develop and potentially end up a permanent aspect in their lives. When two parents decide to divorce, their children acquire a really tough pill to

The Role of Sexuality in Our Lives

1252 words - 5 pages The Role of Sexuality in Our Lives The word “sexuality” has been looked upon as taboo and for centuries many of us grow up being taught how this part of our lives shouldn't be expressed openly. We all experience the feeling as humans, we share this characteristic. Some of us are taught not to express any feeling that has to do with our inner wants when it comes to this topic. It could make us more loving or even at times some incidents

The Lives of Confucious and Guatma Siddartha

3046 words - 12 pages THE LIVES OF CONFUCIUS AND GUATAMA SIDDHARTHADariush NazemWorld Civilization 121September 19, 1996Professor: Helju BennettSection Teacher: Sara AboschThe Life Of ConfuciusThroughout the time span that man has lived on earth, there have been many religions in existence. Two very important and influencing religions that have been around for over two thousand years are Confucianism and Buddhism. The founders of these two religions, Confucius and

Similar Essays

The Two Lives Of Charlemage Essay

872 words - 3 pages Charlemagne, known as the father of Europe, is considered as one of the most powerful medieval rulers. The book The Two Lives of Charlemagne translated by Lewis Thorpe brings together Einhard's Vita Caroli and Notker the Stammerer's De Carolo Magno; two biographies that retell the life of Charlemagne. Einhard was sent to Charlemagne's court in the 790s where he became a close friend of Charlemagne and his family. He wrote Vita Caroli in 826-827

The Great Legacy Of Charlemagne Essay

1228 words - 5 pages Charlemagne also known as Charles the Great, created a legacy that is greatly honored still to this day. He is seen as one of the greatest conquerors ever because of territories he conquered, the diversity he created, and the building of one of the greatest empires known to mankind. Since the fall of Rome, most of the continent of Europe has not been ruled by someone, until Charlemagne came along. Charlemagne was the founder of the Holy Roman

Einhard's The Life Of Charlemagne Essay

1200 words - 5 pages The Relationship of Political and Religious Societies in the Age of Charlemagne, Based of Einhard's The life of Charlemagne sections 15-33 Matt Diggs III      "He was especially concerned that everything in the church be carried out with the greatest possible dignity."           Einhard, in his The Life of Charlemagne, makes clear the

Charlemagne, Bringer Of The Golden Age Of Europe.

2120 words - 8 pages sanctified by the Roman Catholic church. As soon as he was appointed King, he rushed to assist Pope Stephen II against the Lombards and protect the papal lands.When Pepin died in 768AD, the rule of his realms was to be shared between his two sons: Carloman and Charlemagne, who at first ruled the kingdom jointly. However, In 771AD Carloman died suddenly. Charlemagne then seized his brothers territories and was unanimously declared King of the Franks