The U.S. Constitution And Slavery How The Framers Of The Us Constitution Avoided (And Allowed) Slavery Through Carefully Worded Clauses

1050 words - 4 pages

The framers of the Constitution of the United States chose not to prohibit slavery but to instead address the issue via carefully worded clauses. This provided a compromise for the states that were clearly divided on the issue. A close look at the document shows ambiguity in the language pertaining to the holding of slaves as the Framers debated over the extent to which slavery would be included, permitted, or prohibited. Slavery was an important part of the economy, but it had to be dealt with tactfully. The Framers chose to do this not explicitly using the words, but by creating several compromises that represented the interests of the nation as they knew it and predicted it to be in the future. Three clauses deal with the issue: the three-fifths compromise, the slave trade clause, and the fugitive-slave law. All point to the Framers' intentions in the creation of the Constitution and prove that it neither authorized nor prohibited slavery.Though slavery was frowned upon in many parts of the country, most of the leaders of the time owned slaves. Thomas Jefferson, George Washington, and other founding fathers owned slaves but at the same time publicly condemned the practice as morally and ethically "repugnant." They did not want to appear in support of slavery or to perpetuate its practice, but as an undeniable part of the economy they could not simply prohibit it. For one, the anticipated union of states would include Slave-produced crops were beginning to windfall and the south was gaining power. The Constitution had to include and protect the southern states as a large percentage the new legislative branch of government would be represented by this area. Thus the mention of "slave" was purposely neglected.By failing to question slavery, the nation benefited economically. If the Framers had outlawed the practice, southern states would have not joined the union and almost half of the size of the anticipated United States would be lost. This would mean less revenue from taxation and an overall poor economy. By allowing the slave-trade to continue, the cost of slaves (this benefited all, not just the south) was considerably less as slaves were cheaper when imported from Africa. Making concessions such as the three-fifths and slave-trade clauses were compromises-meaning they benefit both sides.The first indication of slavery in the Constitution, the Three-Fifths Compromise, appears in Article I, Section 2. As a means of counting the population for taxation, it states (by implication) that slaves are to be counted not as a whole person, but as three-fifths of one. The ambiguous language implies this by naming "whole" people as those who are free or bound by service for a limited time (indentured servants) and those who are not free, or, " all other Persons" as slaves. It acts as a compromise between the north and south by allowing the federal government to collect more taxes from states with many slaves (as slaves occupied almost forty percent of...

Find Another Essay On The U.S. Constitution and Slavery- How the Framers of the US Constitution avoided (and allowed) slavery through carefully worded clauses

Why The Issue of Slavery Was Avoided in the Drafting of the Constitution

1078 words - 4 pages When the Constitution was drafted, the men who drafted it were very particular in the way they approached the issue of slavery in our country. They carefully avoided it by only mentioning it or referring to it indirectly. They did not use the term "slave" but referred to everyone as "persons". It is rather ironic that neither the Constitution nor the Declaration of Independence, the two documents most known for establishing and declaring freedom

Comparing the Iroquois Constitution and U.S. Constitution

747 words - 3 pages States government is very similar.      A bicameral legislature means that there are two different houses that everything has to go through. In the Iroquois system of government they have two sets of Confederate Lords: Mohawk and Seneca Lords; Oneida and Cayuga Lords. Any questions will first be passed through the Mohawk and Seneca Lords, and then it will be discussed by the Oneida and Cayuga Lords. When comparing this to the U.S. constitution we

Slavery, Civil Rights, and the Constitution during the 19th Century

1864 words - 7 pages their freedom in the St. Louis Circuit Court. This suit began an eleven-year legal fight that ended in the U.S. Supreme Court. The Supreme Court issued a landmark decision declaring that Scott and his wife are to remain a slave, that they are property, and the Constitution made no distinction between slaves and other types of property. The judge reasoned that the Missouri Compromise deprived slaveholding citizens of their property in the form of

Human Rights and the Savings Law Clauses of the Jamaican Constitution

905 words - 4 pages Though slavery was abolished in 1838, as a mark of continued colonial imperialism, the framers of the Jamaican Constitution (and other CCS) blindly preserved much of their colonial legacy when Jamaica gained independence on August 6th, 1962. Most notably, Jamaica retained the Westminster Style parliament (which dominates the CCR) and the Common Law legal system. Having mirrored their colonial masters, these constitutional documents of the CCR

Interpretation of the U.S. Constitution

1304 words - 5 pages correct way to interpret and enforce the Constitution. To understand how the Constitution works for the people of America, one must first understand about the Justices of the Supreme Court who have the power of enforcing the rules and regulations of Americas most prized document. Unlike the other branches of government, the Supreme Court does not have the same rules for appointing its members. The Constitution doesn’t go into lengthy detail about

Role of the U.S. Constitution

1070 words - 4 pages The United States Constitution, also known as the supreme law of the land, was established in 1788. The U.S. Constitution defines and outlines the powers of the three branches of the federal government: legislative, executive, and judicial; and "protects individual rights by limiting the government's ability to restrict those rights" (Cheeseman, 2007, p. 49). Although intended to protect the individuals' rights, the Bill of Rights and subsequent

The U.S. Constitution

1225 words - 5 pages and signed by 38 of the 41 delegates present on September 17, 1787. This paper discusses why the Founding Father’s designed the Constitution as they did and how this design has affected our system today. On September 17, 1787, the United States of America had a newly second Constitution. The constitution was designed to serve the interests of the people [Americans]—the rich and the poor, Northerners and Southerners, famers, factory workers

The U.S. Constitution

938 words - 4 pages . The differences between the states is something that was recognized at the inception of the Constitution and taken into consideration during its' drafting and revisions. Although all the states may be one nation under the United States of America, they all have very different needs and desires. Due to these differences the framers allowed for states to govern certain aspects of their laws and lives. This may seem like a brilliant solution and

Roles of the US constitution

812 words - 3 pages still the framework for which our nations' freedom is based upon. This document has remained an active governing force through all of the changes American society has faced since its creation. The Constitution is careful to define where powers lie, and power is an important as well as delicate element in business. This doctrine does a careful job of defining powers between state and federal governments.The nations' fundamental laws for business

Comparing the us constitution

1272 words - 5 pages provided for in the Russian constitution, many of which appear remarkably similar to freedoms provided for in the American Bill of Rights. Article 14 provided for freedom of expression, while Article 15 ensured "genuine freedom of assembly" and Article 13 guaranteed a separation of church and state as well as freedom of religious and anti-religious propaganda. All of these seem similar to the First Amendment of the U.S. constitution, but they

The US Constitution

1439 words - 6 pages The US Constitution states “We The People of the United states in order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, ensure domestic Tranquility, provide for more common defense, promote the General Welfare, and secure the blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.” The main purpose of the U.S Constitution is to establish the basic rights of all American

Similar Essays

Slavery And The Constitution Essay

530 words - 2 pages Slavery and the Constitution The constitution was crafted as a series of compromises to replace the articles of Confederation. If our nation was to remain free it would have to stay united and this meant no one state or group could dictate to another state what the conditions would be under the new government. One of the compromises that the framers made was on the issue of slavery. The northern states were opposed and the Southern states wanted

Slavery And The Constitution Essay

762 words - 4 pages Was the original Constitution a “pro-slavery” document? Did it do “more to feed the serpent than to crush it?” Was it Frederick Douglass’s “Glorious Liberty Document?” By accommodating slavery did it eventually crush its head through permanent union with economically dynamic free states and Civil War? Could slavery have been abolished at the founding? When would abolition have occurred if union had never been created? Three states would not

Slavery And The American Constitution Essay

632 words - 3 pages 700,000 slaves (18% of the population) in the United States of America. The idea of slavery in America was based on race and wealth. Patriots were talking about liberty and equality and it was one of the things the American Revolution of 1775 had set out to do as did the Constitution in granting American’s rights within the Preamble. However, African American slaves felt that they should be granted the same rights under the

The Pro Slavery Constitution Essay

753 words - 4 pages matter the fact that they were free or enslaved and, as a result, they could not sue anyone in a federal court. Another rule that was established by this case was that the federal government had no power to regulate the slave-trade in the territories acquired after the creation of the USA. This interpretation of the US Constitution, as well as other case-law delivered in a Taney Court style finally led to the Civil War, which settled the slavery