This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Undeserving And Deserving Poor Structure

1212 words - 5 pages

Having only recently permeated the public and political lexicon, there are few debates that evoke such passion as that of the underclass. Karl Marx tabled the idea of the lumpen proletariat, yet in the modern era, the concept did not take hold in Britain until 1989. Today, the debate focuses on whether frictional forces create a continuum of inequality, or whether a defined underclass does exist. The question asks if 'poor people' belong in a separate underclass, which is a vague definition. There will always be 'poor people', but whether or not this automatically qualifies them as a separate underclass is tenuous at best. Even the most radical proponents for the existence of the underclass stop short of declaring all those below the poverty line as 'the underclass'. This essay will analyse the arguments from either side of the debate, looking at definitional issues, the undeserving and deserving poor and structure versus agency. Overall, it will be argued that Murray’s classification does not hold for the majority and that frictional forces mean the poor are part of a continuum of inequality.
A key thinker, Charles Murray argues for the existence of a separate underclass on the basis of three social phenomena; extra marital births, crime and unemployment. The more prevalent these phenomena are, the larger the underclass. He argues that these individuals are of a separate class, having different social norms and what he classes as deviant behaviours (Murray, 1999). Murray’s key point is that the underclass find themselves in their position through their own choices, that those comprising the underclass are demarcated as such through their behaviour. He believes his evidence shows a quickly growing underclass in the US, and an emerging one in the UK (Murray, 1999)
Murray’s underclass argument rests on the premise that the individuals involved are to blame for their situation. However, many scholars argue that individuals are actually the victims of societal structures. This is another key area of discussion, termed the structure versus agency debate (Alcock, 2006). Agency proponents, such as Murray argue that individual choices are key to explaining this trend, and a growing underclass is the result (Alcock, 2006). It is fairly easy to dispute this point, on the basis that incomes are more polarised and the economic downturn has caused increases in poverty as wages fall whilst inflation rises. These are arguments tabled by structural advocates, who believe social structures such as the labour market, welfare system and education system are key in re-enforcing social exclusion (Alcock, 2006). They believe such structure enforce intergenerational exclusion and directly account for those at the bottom of society, and are part of a continuum of inequality.
The implications of Murray’s argument comes down to another of the key sociological debates; are the poor deserving or undeserving, of which he believes the underclass are very much an undeserving...

Find Another Essay On The Undeserving and Deserving Poor Structure

Christianity and helping the poor--Sara Vee

1379 words - 6 pages Christianity and Helping the PoorIn Deuteronomy 15.11, God says to the Israelites, "I command you to be open handed toward your brothers and toward the poor and needy in your land." (New International Version) God commanded the Israelites to help the poor and intended for Christians to take this as an example and follow it. The Israelites were God's people in the Old Testament and Christians, including those from Israel, are God's people. As

Automobile Dependency and the Working Poor

949 words - 4 pages Automobile Dependency and the Working Poor David Shipler briefly mentions in The Working Poor that lack of access to a car is one of the factors that make finding and holding a job difficult. A person in need of a job may be unable to afford a car, since car ownership is so expensive, but they may need a car because of urban sprawl and inadequate public transit networks. But just how serious is the burden of car ownership, and how exactly

The Crucible - Form and Structure

805 words - 3 pages The Crucible - Form and Structure Arthur Miller uses various different techniques in the form and structure of ‘The Crucible’ to create suspense and maintain the audience’s interest. Of course, one of the main factors of the form and structure of the play is its genre. ‘The Crucible’ can be described as being a symbolic play, a tragedy, a political play, an historical play and a narrative play in naturalistic form. It is symbolic

Financing and the Capital Structure

950 words - 4 pages Once one decides to start a business, there are a lot of things to consider. One of the first things that will be needed is capital. There are several options when raising capital, some are high risk others are stable. How a business owner chooses to raise capital will depend on what type of risk they want to take and how much capital the firm needs. Raisings Capital for Business Whether you are just starting out, or you have been in business

India's Rising Gap between the Rich and the Poor

1483 words - 6 pages One of the main issues India is facing right now is the rising gap between the upper and lower classes. India is not alone in this struggle, however; several other countries are also fighting this same battle. In the past, India has always had its upper/middle classes; however, it has also always housed some of the world’s most poor. Yet today the country is filled with opulent, private gated communities that face the destitute

The rich and the poor - class-conscious on income inequality

1393 words - 6 pages For the purpose of this essay this scholar will focus on an article that addresses population in the news. It is this scholar’s intent to discuss the subject matter in the article and specifically highlight the statistical information related to its findings. According to a January 12, 2012 New York Times article written by Sabrina Tavernise there is a rising perception of class tensions between the rich and the poor due to income inequalities

Money and banking the effect on the poor

598 words - 2 pages The exploitation of America's poorThe exploitation of the poor and elderly is an age-old social problem that is being taken to disturbing extremes by some of America's biggest conglomerate companies. In the article, "Fringe banks exploit the poor" written by Michael Hudson, Hudson reveals some of the United States larger corporations Ford, ITT Corp, Fleet financial services, Citicorp, And American Express have been the benefactors of aggressive

The Global Divide Between the Rich and Poor

2621 words - 10 pages The Global Divide Between the Rich and Poor For the last five centuries, there has been a growing split throughout the world; this split has been between the "haves" and the "have-nots". These two groups can be defined two ways. One, between the rich and poor in individual countries and two, between the rich and poor countries themselves. Both definitions have seen increasing polarization over the last 500 years, but the definitive

Why the Rich are Getting Richer and the Poor, Poorer

1836 words - 7 pages The report of Robert Reich: “Why the Rich are getting Richer and the Poor, Poorer,” is an eye opener and a warning for society regarding unemployment that it will be facing and is currently facing due to a lack of technology and education. It clearly articulates that the jobs of routine producers and in-person servers have vanished totally as modern techniques have replaced them. The author has stated that the only people whose jobs are on

the structure and culture of the Organisation

1615 words - 7 pages due to past events such as the loss of the former CEO due to illness and the new appointment of Tim cook in 2011. 2.1.3 ORGANIZATIONAL AND POWER STRUCTURE OF APPLE INC The organizational structure of Apple was almost non-existent and focused on placing decision making in the hands of the people in the field. Apple’s corporate structure is unique to the organisation and mystery to most organisations as they are sceptical to understand how it works

Women and the Poor in Victorian England in Jane Eyre

2105 words - 8 pages How does Bronte explore the position of women and the poor in Victorian England throughout her novel Jane Eyre? Jane Eyre was Charlotte Bronte’s first successful novel. Published in 1847, Bronte presents us with critique of Victorian assumptions regarding social class and gender. Way ahead of its time, Charlotte Bronte (or publicly none as Currer Bell), caused much commotion critically. In her novel Bronte explores many issues of

Similar Essays

The Mistakes Of The Undeserving Poor

705 words - 3 pages The poor have always been analyzed, criticized and examined. Also they have been identified and categorized. Two theories of poverty are the “Undeserving Poor” and the “Deserving Poor. I believe that poverty is global plague, that has been studied and analyzed to come up with a solution to put an end to poverty. The theory of the Deserving Poor, there were those whose inability to support themselves might be considered innocent and

Antiguan Paints: Lack Of Communication And Poor Organizational Structure

1061 words - 4 pages As this case analysis was thoroughly investigated we have discovered that the company Antiguan paints had some major problems, after careful consideration and collaboration it has been established that the core problems which hinders the success of Antiguan Paints are as a result of the lack of organization structure and Communication. The Satellite problems stated within this case study are management, leadership, role conflict and role

The Rich And They Poor Essay

1133 words - 5 pages Food is a basic necessity of life. Oftentimes , the poor don't have food due to the rich wasting valuable food. In A Modest Proposal, Jonathan Swift shows how the rich are the reason behind the state of the poor and how they treat them poorly. Swift used symbolism and allegory to portray these thoughts. Allusion is used to show how the rich consume the poverty-stricken. Swift leaves us with statements from which we can infer how the rich are

Population Growth And Feeding The Poor

1819 words - 8 pages , economic options for everyday survival become limited for the poor (Shah, Anup). In addition to the aforementioned problems, biotech firms promote crop uniformity. This will decrease genetic diversity, which will make crops more vulnerable to disease and pests. Consequently, more pesticides will be needed, which interestingly, are created by the same companies promoting crop uniformity. Essentially, these companies are creating the problem, and