This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Unethical Nature Of Operation Iron Triangle

1062 words - 5 pages

The 3rd Brigade, 101st Airborne Division, a unit known as the Rakkasans, were conducting Operation Iron Triangle in 2006 in Iraq when soldiers killed eight unarmed Iraqi men. The US military severely reprimanded the Commander of the Rakkasans, COL Michael Steele, for the unethical command climate his leadership allowed to exist within the unit at that time. This unit will need a new commander that can set and maintain an effective, ethical command climate through his leadership. That new commander should resolve the issues that led to the reported war crime in order to establish a culture that perpetuates an ethical command climate.
According to MCRP 4-11.8B, War Crimes, there are a number ...view middle of the document...

Second, COL Steele designed fighting tournaments that led to a platoon on platoon brawl with some soldiers sustaining injuries. This action is not good for unit cohesion and order and represents a breakdown of proper discipline. Third, COL Steele offered trophy knives as a reward for killing insurgents or exemplary service. Offering an award for exemplar service is a good idea but a reward based on insurgent kills is not. It further dehumanizes Iraqis and places an emphasis on killing over other mission objectives. Fourth, COL Steele did not communicate the Rules of Engagement (ROE) very well with his unit. His speeches emphasized his core principles of “be precise; be lethal; be safe,” but that caused his soldiers to believe that COL Steele wanted them to shoot instead of capture potential insurgents. Fifth, at the company headquarters, soldiers had posted a kill board that tracked the number of Iraqis killed during operations. This kill board represents the degree to which COL Steele’s soldiers were dehumanized the Iraqis and were confused over the ROE. These issues would eventually lead to the war crime being committed during Operation Iron Triangle.
A new commander taking over the unit following COL Steele’s departure will have to establish a command climate that overcomes the current culture within the Rakkasans. The new commander must confer with his leadership team to determine what the issues are within the culture that leads to the unethical command. The first step should be to disseminate command climate surveys. The results of the command climate survey would help judge the extent to which soldiers assess the ethical situation within the command and further help to identify any other problems that may exist. This paper will focus on the five issues identified in the article as if the leadership team discussion and the command climate survey had identified them.
In order to overcome the negative effect on the command climate resulting from the first issue, the dehumanization of the Iraqis; the new commander must immediately institute Arab cultural awareness and place an emphasis on ethical interactions with the local population. This will help the commander lay out a vision and strategy that defines success for the...

Find Another Essay On The Unethical Nature of Operation Iron Triangle

The Unethical Treatment of Animals Essay

1870 words - 7 pages “Man is the highest rated animal, at least among all the animals who returned the questionnaire (Brault, 2009).” For years humans have been using animals for experimentation, food, clothing, sport and entertainment, manual labor, and let us not forget man’s best friend. The unethical treatment of animals can best be resolved by deontology contrasted with ethical egoism. Being human indicates the feeling of pain, pleasure, fear, and love; if

The Impact of the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire

1491 words - 6 pages During the early 1900s industrial fires or accidents were common place; injuries and the loss of life may have outraged a few people but like all tragedies the outrage would pass quickly and it would back to business as usual. One such tragedy occurred on Saturday, March 25th, 1911, it was closing time at the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory and hundreds of employees were preparing to leave when a fire broke out on the 8th floor trapping Jewish and

The Mystery of the Bermuda Triangle

2342 words - 10 pages Planes, ships, and people seem to vanish into thin air without a trace. They leave behind no wreckage, no oil slicks, and no clues. But what is to blame? With thousands of miles of unexplored ocean floor, the odd and deadly accidents in and around the Bermuda Triangle may never be truly explained. The Bermuda Triangle is a mystery to mankind because of its inexplicable incidents of mysterious disappearances, its never ending list of possible

Explaining the Mysteries of the Bermuda Triangle

2312 words - 9 pages Travel to the Triangle"Control tower, this is an emergency," the worried voice said. "We seem to be off course. We cannot see land...repeat...we cannot see land." What's your position?" the tower asked. "We're not sure of our position," replied the patrol leader. "We can't be sure where we are. We seem to be lost." "How could that be?" the tower operators asked each other. Flight conditions were ideal. "Head due west," came orders from the tower

Tobias Mayer, Inventor of the Color Triangle

681 words - 3 pages printed work at the age of 18. Astrology In 1753 he had begun calculating lunar and solar tables. He created a method of determining longitude by lunar distances and a formula for correcting errors in longitude due to atmospheric refraction. This method was published in 1770 after he had passed away. The Color Triangle Tobias Mayer’s Color Triangle was published in 1775, (more than twelve years after his death), by a Gottinger physicist named Georg

Expansion of the piedmont Triangle International Airport

1148 words - 5 pages Ex, and the 200 million dollar runway constructed will be funded by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), Trust Funds, The Piedmont Triangle International Airport, and the NC Department of Transportation. ( Despite funding, there are many other concerns about this project. For instance, local residents and taxpayers feel that it is a poor transportation policy to locate a noisy nighttime operation in the midst of a

The Triangle Shirtwaist Fire of 1911

849 words - 3 pages The Triangle Shirtwaist Fire of 1911 What do we think of when we hear the word sweatshop? Many people associate that word with female immigrant workers, who receive very minimal pay. The work area is very dangerous to your health and is an extremely unsanitary work place. The work area is usually overcrowded. That is the general stereotype, in my eyes of a sweatshop. All if not more of these conditions were present in the Triangle Shirtwaist

What does this source tell us about the nature of the iron industry in Merthyr at this time? (sorry source unavailable in electronic form)

992 words - 4 pages personal diary of his travels and experiences which were then later turned into a book.His writing of this particular visit gives the reader an insight into a world that few in a rural location could have imagined. It would be an alien world to them, conjuring images in their heads of voluminous smoke, fiery furnaces and of thumping and hammering machinery that would be as familiar to them as an iron, fire breathing dragon.Manners writes in an educated

The Unethical Issues of the Tuskegee Study

2100 words - 8 pages " (Wynia, 2003). The doctors wanted the participants to die to have information for their research study. Throughout this study, there were many unethical procedures that were conducted. There was no informed consent in this study whatsoever. Informed consent is when one has full knowledge of a certain situation before accepting the treatment. The doctors never explained what syphilis was to the African Americans, instead they constantly used the

The Day of the Operation

1116 words - 5 pages Having surgery and going under anaesthetic in another country is bound to induce fear. My eagerness to have the operation and my realisation of my nose dream seemed to blot out most fear. It's amazing what we can overcome when faced with something we really want to do. Given events moved quickly I hadn't given much thought to the actual operation itself which was for the best. Having just had a look at where Iran stands internationally in terms

The Day of the Operation

1075 words - 5 pages Arriving to the clinic it was the usual procedures of not eating 12 hours prior. Although these were very rare moments in life, I enjoyed them. I am talking of the medical requirement not to eat. A lifelong ambition to be thin means your mind no longer thinks rationally upon food related issues. Accustomed to my perverse thinking I had calculated I could lose a pound, possibly two through the surgical procedure. And then there's the post

Similar Essays

The Unethical Nature Of The Tuskegee Syphilis Study

1396 words - 6 pages analyzed to determine why it was unethical and to prevent it from reoccurring in the future. According to Allan M. Brandt, the study “revealed more about the pathology of racism than it did about the pathology of syphilis; more about the nature of scientific enquiry than the nature of the disease process.” At the time when the study began, racism was still very prominent throughout the United States, especially in the South. As such, the fact that

Common Assessment: The Iron Triangle And Racial Profiling

741 words - 3 pages needs to learn how to have a balance between extreme strictness and lenience. Since politics was and continues to be a major factor in these cases, the iron triangle is involved. In the case of Shoshana Hebshi, the FBI is a bureaucracy, which is supported by the interest group of concerned passengers on the plane. They support racial profiling in an indirect way, and this helps like-minded congress members. Those congress members support and fund

The Enigma Of Bermuda Triangle Essay

1434 words - 6 pages One event can change the whole world’s perception. One day, approximately 58 years ago at 2:10 pm, December 5, 1945 (Bryner), five Navy planes, known as Flight 19, took off from their base in Florida, and neither the planes nor the crew were ever found (National Geographic). Thus, a legend was born. Being one of the most strangest and dangerous place on earth, Bermuda Triangle has achieved its nickname as the “Devil’s Triangle” and “Limbo of

Bermuda Triangle, The Triangle Of Death (Demonstration & Captivating Story, Explain The Bermuda Triangle, Conclusion)

576 words - 2 pages no trace of the 6 were ever found.When most planes crash in the ocean they always leave some kind of wreckage behind or an oil slick, but to quote the Naval board of inquiry "The vanished completely as if they had flown to Mars."In the past 100 years, over 100 ships and planes have been reported missing in the Bermuda Triangle, which has been known to claim over 1,000 lives. Even Christopher Columbus noted in his journal that his compass was not