This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Universe: The Design Argument By William Paley

1423 words - 6 pages

In this paper I will present two differing views on the topic of the design argument. In particular, I will explain William Paley's view supporting the design argument and Bertrand Russell's view against the design argument. After a presentation of the differing views, I will then evaluate the arguments to show that William Paley has a stronger argument.
There are several forms of the design argument. The general form of the design argument starts with the basic idea that certain parts of the universe are such that they indicate that they have been designed and have a purpose. The argument uses this fact to prove the existence of an ultimate designer, in particular, God.
William Paley develops his view of the design argument through an example of a wristwatch. He has the reader imagine themselves coming across a watch on the ground. He then asks the reader how they think the watch came to be there or came to exist in the first place. Looking at the watch, Paley says that one will notice the intricate design of the watch and notice that all the parts were put together in such a way to serve a purpose, namely, to tell time. Paley believes that from looking at the watch we will be lead to think that the watch has a clever designer. The watch displays a certain evidence of its own design.
Many of us know that a watch indeed does have a designer, but what if we had never seen a watch made before or known of anyone capable of such design? Lacking this knowledge, Paley argues, should raise no doubt in our mind that the object must have a designer. Even if the watch told the wrong time most of the time, Paley says that the intended purpose of the watch to tell time is still obvious. Paley says we should still conclude that the watch has a designer even if we didn't discover all the parts of the watch, the watch was broken, or the watch was a product of another watch. The watch in and of itself displays an evidence of its own design, regardless of all these possibilities.
Just like the watch, many objects in the world display an evidence of design. Paley believes that there is evidence of the design of the whole universe. Also like the watch, the whole world has many unique features that all work together to make up the whole thing. For example, the watch has a clear overlay so you can see the time without opening it and the earth is just so far from the sun to be suitable for life. Based on this evidence and relationship, he concludes that there must be an ultimate designer and that this ultimate designer is God. Therefore, God exists.
Turning to Bertrand Russell's view of the design argument, he says the basic idea of the design argument is that "everything in the world is made just so that we can manage to live in the world, and if the world was ever so little different, we could not manage to live in it" (Russell, 57-58). He sees the design argument as very unusual. He points out that the when you apply the argument, untrue conclusions...

Find Another Essay On The Universe: The Design Argument by William Paley

The Argument from Design Essay

861 words - 4 pages efforts of those below it, or else nothing else would work, as stated by Paley. The conclusion as stated before but more simplified is, nature has a design, and that the architect of this design is God himself. This is the purpose of the argument as a whole. His entire drive for this argument seemed to convince others that there is a higher being with a higher power. Paley attempted to convince and bring the atheist and the agnostic to believe that

The Design Argument Essay

2595 words - 10 pages directing the arrow. Then if a simple arrow cannot go and hit a simple target then how would a universe as complex as ours come in to being by accident? But one of the main people during the past millennium to argue for the existence of god was probably William Paley (1743-1805). He is well remembered for using the analogy of the watch. He says that the watch has many little mechanisms working together in tandem, at

The Argument From Design

1035 words - 4 pages time, so too do the small parts of the world work together in perfect harmony to sustain life. The argument goes on to describe the many conditions which must exist in order to keep life thriving, such as the tilt of the world which causes the seasons to change, or the distance of the earth from the sun which is just perfect to keep us from getting scorched or freezing up (p. 120-121). The Argument from Design suggests that such conditions were by

Why the Design Argument Fails

1792 words - 7 pages Why the Design Argument Fails The Design Argument does fail due to its weaknesses, it is lacking in factual and substantial evidence to prove its theories. It puts forward a lot of ideas and claims however they are not justified well enough; the only true fact is that you have to believe them. I feel it is correct to claim that it fails due to the amount of criticising evidence against the theories for the

The Inadequacy of Paley's Argument from Design

1423 words - 6 pages that design occurred. William Paley’s argument relies on the assumption that one could substitute the idea of the universe in place of the watch. By asserting that because a watch is designed, and therefore the universe must also be designed, is an inductive argument. An inductive argument is based on observing something and applying this observation to something else. Although this type of argument is practical at predicting patterns of re

The Universe

1283 words - 5 pages produced by the Big Bang. The Big Bang model predicts that the universe should still be filled with a small remnant of radiation left over from the original violent explosion of the primeval fireball in the past. The primeval fireball would have sent strong shortwave radiation in all directions into space. In time, thatradiation would spread out, cool, and fill the expanding universe uniformly. By now it would strike Earth as microwave radiation

The Universe

939 words - 4 pages According to the definition given by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration, or NASA, the universe is a system consisting of all matter and energy, as well as all of the contents of space as a whole. (Dunbar, Canright) The birth of the universe resulted in the creation of all of the things that we know today, yet, its true origin is unknown. I know what you’re thinking. “If the origin of the universe is unknown, then how do we know

"The Universe, And Everything" by Douglas Adams

925 words - 4 pages Arthur Dent, the protagonist in the story Life, The Universe, And Everything by Douglas Adams, is just an ordinary person who has to save the universe in his pajamas. This book is the third in the hitchhiker series and is one of the best. The best thing about Douglas's books is the way they are written. It looks like he had more fun writing the books than I did reading it. He also uses many literary devices such as simile and personification

A teleological argument for the existence of a supernatural designer of the universe

2746 words - 11 pages evidence for a purposive design: 'all the wheels, gears, and springs are made and adjusted so that by their motion the watch keeps perfect time' (Davies 1983:164). If one accepts the position that the watch is a product of design, the existence of a watchmaker becomes self-evident. This is because it would be illogical to have design without a designer.Similar to the watch is the universe. It is obvious to Paley that, since the universe is more

The Design Argument For The Existence Of God

1577 words - 6 pages a lot of different things helped William Paley to have a prosteriori argument that God was the creator of the universe. The second part of Paley’s argument for the existence of God, Paley pointed to the rotation of the planets in the solar system. How did the solar system know how the planets are situated? And how did the hold their orbits? The solar system orbits by gravity but there had to be some out of the universe

The Argument from Design, and the Problem of Evil

1547 words - 6 pages The Argument from Design, and the Problem of EvilThe teleological argument, better known as the argument from design, is one of the well-known arguments for the existence of God. It has arisen out of man's amazement at the intricacy and complex layout of many features of the natural world. Take, for example, the ability of honeybees to create honeycombs using the minimum amount of wax for the maximum amount of storage. This is possible by using

Similar Essays

Paley Vs. Hume This Is A Inductive Argument About The Origin And Nature Of God, Religion, And The Universe

1025 words - 4 pages Paley vs. HumeI read William Paley's, "The Argument from Design", and David Hume's, "Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion." What I established after reading these two arguments is that it is extraordinarily difficult to come to any conclusion about the origin of the universe and the world. Both are inductive arguments about the origin and nature of God, religion, and the universe; things that can never be proven true and absolute.In Paley's

Richard Dawkins’ Assessment On William Paley’s “Design” Argument

1080 words - 4 pages William Paley, who wrote The Watch and the Watchmaker, believed that anything organized for a function needed a special explanation. He concluded that these things must have been designed by some sort of designer and hence, the “design” argument was established. Paley used the example of a watchmaker as an analogy exemplifying a designer. “We think it is inevitable that the watch must have had a maker.” (Paley : 57) This specific example is an

Intelligent Design Of The Universe Essay

2099 words - 8 pages lighting the fuse: the big bang was God's way of creating the universe. Many people have gone in search for proof that the universe was created by a Supreme Being. The case for Intelligent Design was argued by Reverend William Paley of Carlisle, England in his 1802 book Natural Theology. Take, for instance, a rock and a watch. How old are the two objects? The rock has "remained more or less the same perhaps since the earth was formed"(Miller

Intelligent Design In The Universe Essay

10071 words - 40 pages theologian William Paley marshaled evidence for a designed universe from both the physical and biological sciences. However, his argument for design was called into question by Darwin's theory of evolution. But new discoveries in the latter half of the twentieth century in the fields of astronomy, cosmology, and abiogenesis (the origin of life) have provided extremely compelling evidence for a designed universe. These findings have been publicized