This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Federal Government Has Reduced Individual Rights

2641 words - 11 pages

What do transportation laws, public education, and welfare programs have in common? All of them are not instituted solely by the state governments but by the central government. These are just a few examples that show the power of the central government has dramatically increased from when it was first instituted (Nosotro). There are many factors that have fueled this increase, but one major cause is the Seventeenth Amendment. The Seventeenth Amendment was added to the Constitution in the early 1900’s and called for the direct election of senators. Ironically, this amendment, which was sold as an expansion of democracy, greatly increased the power of the United States federal government.
In order to understand how this amendment has increased the power of the federal government, one must have a good understanding of the background to this amendment. It was not proposed and ratified due to a fanatical last minute whim of a few senators. Rather, a combination of bribes, scandals, electoral deadlocks, malapportioned legislatures, and the changing of the political tastes combined to make direct election of senators a popular option at the turn of the century (Schiller 2). At the time the House of Representatives was the only body directly elected by the people, and senators were elected by their respective state legislatures rather than by straight vote from their constituents (Keesee 51). The idea for the direct election of senators was not a new idea. Reformers as far back as the 1800’s were interested in limiting the role of state legislatures in Senate elections. Even Andrew Johnson, the seventeenth president of the United States, proposed an amendment that would elect senators through popular election (Levin 44).
The direct election of senators originated on depression party platforms. These depression parties were a number of small parties that sprung up during economic depression. They usually gathered strength in the rural pockets of the south and mid-west. One of the more well known depression parties was the Populist Party (Keesee 174). Depression parties, progressive influence, and democratic participation all influenced the creation of the Seventeenth Amendment. Several patterns have been observed from these influences. As progressives grew in influence, so did the federal government (Levin 30). As democratic participation expanded, the limitations found in the Constitution, such as the indirect election of senators, were viewed as too restrictive. The final result of the democratic view during this time was the Seventeenth Amendment (Keesee 105).
Consequently, on May 13, 1912, congress proposed the Seventeenth Amendment. This amendment called for the election of senators directly through popular vote. It stated “The Senate of the United States shall be composed of two Senators from each state, chosen by the people thereof, for six years; and each Senator shall have one vote” (Keesee 51). On April 8, 1913, almost a...

Find Another Essay On The Federal Government has Reduced Individual Rights

Telecommuting in the Federal Government Essay

7304 words - 29 pages United States and throughout the world. (Kraut) Also, telework is emerging as an important and attractive work option for the Federal Government and its employees. It has the benefit of providing employees with the flexibility to better manage their work and personal responsibilities. For agencies, it provides another flexibility that makes Federal service attractive to prospective employees and a tool to encourage employees to remain in Federal

The Federal Level of Government Essay

1985 words - 8 pages candidate the checks all at once” (Cigler 2002:124). The federal level can get away with their own corruption a lot easier than anyone else in society can and that is why it does not matter that they do not encourage diversity with race, and people with different financial status (being only a few of the many examples of minorities). Money plays such a huge part in the federal level of the government. Whichever candidate has the most money to fund

The Purpose of Individual Rights

1666 words - 7 pages segregation in the United States, and were the implied protection that the founding fathers put in the constitution to destroy any oppression attacking these rights of individuals. Individual rights were given to the people so that governmental control and leadership is not up to one person and up to who is worthy of the people. The people’s right to an opinion and the ability to express that opinion has been major in the development of our county today

Limiting the Power of the Federal Government

2297 words - 9 pages which controls every aspect of their lives. “Where are our (sic) Men of abilities? Why do they not come forth to save their Country?” George Washington once inquired to his fellow man, now, many Americans may find themselves asking this same question as the country continues its spiral downwards (Mizell). The overall expansion of the federal government in the past decade has proven to be detrimental to the welfare of the same American citizens

The People v. The Federal Government

1057 words - 4 pages The Jacksonian era proved to be a trying time for all, from the plantation owners of the South, to the politicians of the North. They were all fighting for what was important to them. A select few were actually fighting for the people, including President Andrew Jackson. The continual conflict during Jackson’s presidency, regarding citizens’ rights and exactly how much power should be delegated to the government and to the people, proved to be

Politics of the Federal Government Budget

1134 words - 5 pages argument is what the duty of the federal government is. The government’s spending of hard working citizen’s money to assist those already ensured equal opportunity of success is a problem many Americans have with SNAP benefits and other entitlement programs. Food stamps, or SNAP benefits, spending has more than doubled from thirty billion dollars to seventy two billion dollars in just a four year span, 2007 to 2011. Still more interesting

The Federal Government Small Business Development Program

779 words - 4 pages The Federal Government, with its agencies, aims to provide equal opportunities for people who wish to become entrepreneurs and make their living by running a business. In the world of businesses, many companies and owners face disadvantages brought by many factors. To counter these disadvantages, the US government created the 8(a) business development program. The program is administered by the Small Business Administration (SBA). The main

The Federal Government Should Regulate Fracking

3310 words - 13 pages populations. Hydraulic fracking or hydrofracking is a highly controversial and charged topic. It has a lengthy list of supporters, as well as vehement opponents. Fracking has provided economic opportunity and security for many individuals, and at the same time cost in terms of environmental impact. Although the flurry around this topic seems fairly new, the actual process is quite dated. Fracking has been around since the 1940s, but the harmful

'To what extent has corporate governance reduced the separation of ownership and control?'

2837 words - 11 pages 'To what extent has corporate governance reduced the separation of ownership and control?'Corporate governance in its simplest form can be defined as 'having good management to run a company'. (Financial Institutions, Intangibles and Corporate Governance, John Holland, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability, Journal, Vol. 14, Number 4, 2001, p. 13). Unfortunately corporate governance is not that simple, and includes much more than just 'good

Individual Liberties and the Command of Government

1622 words - 7 pages prevent the state of war is one of the primary reasons individuals part from the state of nature by contracting together to form a civil government. The civil government established to bring about justice has its genesis rooted in the natural want for legal protection of property rights. As an extension to self-preservation, Locke affirms that every man not only owns his own person, but also, “the labour of his body and the work of his

Revenue Sharing between the States and the Federal government

572 words - 2 pages Federal grants have become more common over the last 60years, due to the expansion and retraction of the size of thefederal government. The federal government began expanding inthe 1930s to deal with the Depression. It used federal agenciesto directly deal with problems. As time went on, the tasks wereturned over to the states, but the federal government stillremained involved through the use of federal grants to statesand localities. In the

Similar Essays

To What Extent Did The Federal Government Contribute To The Civil Rights Movement

1358 words - 5 pages his strong southern connections in order to persuade the Dixiecrats to side with him on the four acts that he passed.During his time as president, Johnson explicitly outlawed the segregation of any public facility or public place, gave the Commission on Civil Rights the power to enforce segregation and made the FEPC permanent in 1964; he also outlawed any "tests" that prevented African Americans votingand gave the federal government to regulate

Native American Rights, Federal Government Plenary Power And Land Takings

5441 words - 22 pages Native American Rights, Federal Government Plenary Power and Land Takings Abstract Native Americans are entitled to the same Constitutional protections that guard other citizens from federal government infringement. Plenary power and the accompanying seizure and use of indigenous land bases have violated the rights of Native Americans and demonstrated the inability of the federal government to manage Indian affairs. The United States

Why The American Government Has The Authority To Take Away Our Rights During The Time Of War And That National Security Supercedes The Rights Of The People

1394 words - 6 pages aided the Union in winning the Civil War, which may not have happened if not done so. John W. Dean4 stated, "The U.S. Supreme Court made clear in Ex Parte Milligan, following the Civil War, that 'the government, within the Constitution, has all the powers granted to it which are necessary to preserve its existence." After the war was won, those rights were restored and the citizens now had national security and individual rights.An example of this

The Federal Government Essay

1285 words - 5 pages factors of government is a connection between what it does and what the public wants, policy making can be considered 60% legitimate. Furthermore, most of what the federal government does never reaches the public. Public opinion polls represent the small percentage of issues that people have heard about.Though the individual workings of the American government may not be particularly democratic, it must be somewhat legitimate overall because