The Application Of Justice And Then There Were None

767 words - 3 pages

If one's actions cannot be prosecuted under the normal proceedings of law, can one be considered innocent of any wrongdoings even though the actions in question are morally unjustified? In Agatha's Christie's And Then There Were None, the idea of justice is a major theme and is thoroughly explored through the context of the characters. Trapped on an island and distanced from society, the characters in the story are forced to come to terms with their past actions as they wait for their "death sentence". Justice Wargrave is the administrator of the law and the killings on Indian Island are merely prosecutions where the guilty are brought down in the name of the law and thus, enforcing justice.The administration of justice is a common theme in many murder mysteries. An individual commits a crime, and it is only a matter of finding that individual and punishing them through the law. Agatha Christie, however, departs from this formulaic approach by introducing the characters to offenses which are not punishable through any normal means. Wargrave's overwhelming desire to instil justice, therefore, leads him to deviate from the norm and punish those who he deemed guilty through his sick and gruesome way. He presents himself as the fighter of injustice and entrusts himself with the role of punishing those who had escaped the consequences of the law. The traditional sense of justice, however, remains the same. Wargrave, in his conventional role as a judge, enforces justice by sentencing the guilty to prison or execution in the court room. Similarly, Indian Island serves as a court room for Wargrave, and the ten "Indians" are the defendants who are waiting for Wargrave's pronouncement of their death sentence.It can also be argued that the murders of some of the characters are unjustified because their apparent "crimes" are petty and insignificant, thus the punishment inflicted on those characters were undeservingly received. For example, Anthony Marston had ended the lives of two children in a car accident. Similarly, Armstrong had killed one of his patients because he was operating while drunk. Surely, it can be argued that since these characters had caused the deaths unintentionally and had been legally allowed to continue operating in society, they are not guilty and should not be punishable through death....

Find Another Essay On The Application of Justice - And Then There Were None

And Then There Were None by Christie Agatha

2106 words - 8 pages wanted her to because she was responsible for his nephew death. The antagonist of And Then There Were None is Judge Justice Wargrave. He was also known as Issac Morris to hide his real identity from all the other characters. He was the judge of all of the characters cases and he found them guilty and thought it was right for them to die. He knew almost everything about all of the characters, how they would think, how they would react to certain

And then there were none by Agatha kristi

671 words - 3 pages Agatha Christie's, And Then There Were None is a chilling mystery about a group of people who were invited to an island and got killed off one by one via an unknown being during their stay. The group invited to this peaceful and tropical island all had one thing in common; they had each committed a deadly crime, which the court could not dispense justice upon. For example: One night, a lady was brought into a hospital needing a simple surgery

And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie

718 words - 3 pages . Consequently, the guests, one by one, are mysteriously murdered. The guests that remain soon realize that all of the deaths are linked to one thing: the nursery rhyme located in each of the bedrooms in the house. Unbelievable as that may be, the guests begin to turn on each other becoming very paranoid and suspecting everyone that poses a threat. And Then There Were None keeps the reader guessing until the very end when the unlikely subject, Justice

Title: And then there were none Author: Agatha Christie Setting:

846 words - 3 pages Title: And then there were none Author: Agatha Christie Setting: Indian Island Accusations: Edward George Armstrong, on March 14 1925 killed Louisa Clees Mary.Emily Caroline Brent on November 5th 1931 killed Beatrice Taylor William Henry Blore killed James Stephen Landor on October 10th 1928 Vera Elizabeth Claythorne on August 11 1935 killed Cyril Ogilvie Hamilton Philip Lombard on February 1932 killed 21 East African Men John Macarthur on

Then There Were None by Agatha Christie

1228 words - 5 pages Agatha Christie the Queen of Mysteries Novels and author of And Then There Were None, used both types of conflicts and irony to teach the theme that justice will be served. Christie became the first grandmaster recognized by the Mystery Writers of America. Born as Agatha Christie May Clarissa Miller in Devon of England. Agatha was born September 15, 1890. She was raised in a seaside town in Devon called Torquay. Christie was the youngest

"And Then There Were None", Film analysis of a modern film based on Agathie Chrisitie's Novel

1382 words - 6 pages “And Then There Were None” is an extremely successful novel written by crime story queen, and most popular modern author: Agatha Christie. An adaptation of the famous novel is “Ten Little Indians”, a moderately successful film by Allan Berkinshaw. The themes of both stories include Justice, crime, murder and fear .The novel is about 8 guilty criminals (Emily Brent, Phillip Lombard, Vera Claythorne, Justice Wargrave, Dr

Ten Little Indians (And Then There Were None) by Agatha Christie

684 words - 3 pages Ten Little Indians, published as And Then There Were None when it débuted in America brought a wonderful sense of mystery into the life of the American. Written by Agatha Christie, it was published in 1939 as a fiction murder mystery. The story is set on the coast of Devon, England during the thirties. Ten Little Indians is a classic murder mystery, which involves ten unsuspecting average people. While it seems that one of these people would be

Journal on Hamlet's quote "Why, then, 'tis none to you; for there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so: to me it is a prison." (Shakespeare, Hamlet, II, ii, 249)

497 words - 2 pages Hamlet is one of Shakespeare’s most discussed plays. The drama has a lot of figurative language to be interpreted in various meanings. Among the famous quotes taken from Hamlet, perhaps the one bringing a wide range of different opinions is the line Hamlet said to his friends Rosencrantz and Guildenstern “Why, then, ‘tis none to you; for there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so: to me it is a prison.”

Evaluate the existing appraisal system of any institution. If there is no appraisal system, then why isn't it there?

4957 words - 20 pages taken up to update us with what is going on regarding the teacher appraisal setup in out schools.It concludes by evaluating the data collected. Then the case study recommendations are suggested followed by practical suggestions for teacher development.Section # 11. Literature Review"Treat people as if they were what they ought to be and you help them become what they are capable of being."--- Johann W. Von GoetheThe ultimate goal in education should

The Knights of Now and Then

1013 words - 4 pages exhibited virtues of “chivalry, truth, honor, generousness, and courtesy” (p.96) as history has recorded for us over time which are characteristics that are admirable in an individual and worthy of striving for.The Knight is brave, courageous and prepares himself for battle and the crusades-“This same distinguished knight had led the van, once with the Bey of Balat, doing work” (p96). There is strengthening and conditioning

Capital Punishment Essay - True Justice Through Application of the Death Penalty

1104 words - 4 pages " victims are, yet the statistics just mentioned support the assumption that more heinous crimes will be committed if these criminals are not dealt with in the most permanent fashion - by execution.   The death penalty is not cruel and unusual punishment.  Authors of the United States Constitution's 8th Amendment related "cruel and unusual" punishment to methods used in ages past.   There were many ways of carrying out the death penalty then

Similar Essays

Justice Can Still Be Served: And Then There Were None

2352 words - 10 pages Agatha Christie, author of the murder mystery And Then There Were None, used foreshadowing and both external and internal conflict to portray the theme of her novel that justice can be served for the crimes that go unpunished. Christie used these elements because she enjoyed mystery and she liked to keep her readers engaged while reading. Agatha Christie is still considered one of the best, if not, the best murder mystery writer today because

'and Then There Were None' By Agatha Christie As A Representative Of The Detective Genre

646 words - 3 pages The novel 'And Then There Were None' by Agatha Christie is a good representative of the detective genre. The following criteria, that this novel fulfils, classifies it as a detective novel: There is a crime or mystery to be solved, One person (or a group of people) is either a detective or an adult or young person who has set themselves the task of solving the crime or mystery, Information about the perpetrator is revealed, discovered or

A Bookreport On Agatha Chrisie's "And Then There Were None"

938 words - 4 pages For my book report, I read the book And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie. The book is about a group of people who all get letters from an U. N. Owen, instructing them to go to a place called Indian Island. Once there, a recording plays saying that each of them is guilty of murder. One by one they are murdered, until there is no one left on the island. Since they are all dead, who could the murder have been?The book was a set of 10 murders

And Then There Were None By Agatha Christie

1183 words - 5 pages And Then There Were None by Agatha Christie  And Then There Were None, is an intriguing murder mystery novel that follows the lines of a poem called "Ten Little Indians".  The story is intricately written to keep the reader in absolute suspense from the beginning to end. The novel involves eight people being mysteriously invited to spend a summer holiday on "Indian Island".  Among the eight are a judge (Justice John Wargrave