The Usefulness Of Functionalist Theories To Explain Crime And Deviance Sociology Essay

1327 words - 6 pages

Evaluate the usefulness of Functionalist theories to our understanding of crime and deviance (40 marks)
A functionalist analysis of crime and deviance begins with society as a whole. It looks for the source of deviance in the nature of society rather than in the individual. Durkheim argued that crime is an inevitable and normal aspect of social life. Crime is present in all types of society; indeed, the crime rate is higher in the more advanced, industrialised countries. According to Durkheim, crime is an ‘integral part of all healthy societies’. It’s inevitable because not every member of society can be equally committed to the collective sentiments (the shared values and moral beliefs) of society. Since individuals are exposed to different influences and circumstances, it is ‘impossible for all to be alike’. Therefore not everyone is equally reluctant to break the law. Durkheim went on to say that crime isn’t only inevitable, it can also be functional. Durkheim argued that it only becomes dysfunctional (harmful to society) when its rate is unusually high or law. He argued that all social change begins with some form of deviance. In order for change to occur, yesterday’s deviance must become today’s normality. Since a certain amount of change is good for society (so that it can progress rather than stagnate), so is deviance. If the collective sentiments are too strong, there will be little deviance, but neither will there be any change, or progress. Therefore the collective sentiments must have only ‘moderate energy’ so that they don’t crush originality: both the originality of the criminal, and the originality of the genius.
Unlike other major theoretical perspectives such as Marxism, no specific Functionalist criminology exists to speak of, with its own individual interpretations of criminal statistics, the source of criminality and potential policy solutions. Rather functionalism takes a passing look at the issues of deviance in general, rather than crime in particular, while in the process trying to explain whole social problems and patterns. The explanation of deviance is vital to this macro analysis but it does not contain the seeds of a ‘break off’ into the distinctive field of criminology in its own right. Nonetheless, while functionalist criminology, especially in modern times, does not have a large, organised or particularly popular voice, this is not to say that within the work of Durkheim the concept of deviance has been ignored. Far from it, Durkheim has served to generate a great deal of subsequent research and influence other sociological theories on crime and deviance. For example, control theories of crime and deviance. This suggests that Durkheim’s ideas have made a major contribution to the study of crime and deviance.
However, Durkheim doesn’t explain why certain people are more likely to commit crimes than others. He appears not concerned with this problem - he was most interested in the nature of the relationship between...

Find Another Essay On The usefulness of functionalist theories to explain crime and deviance - sociology - essay

Limitations of theories of sociology of deviance

2514 words - 10 pages Theories of Deviance are limited in their ability to explain deviant acts if one adopts the view that these theories are universal. There is no universal, right or wrong theory, rather each theory provides a different perspective which only "fully makes sense when set within an appropriate societal context and values framework" .The functionalist theories share a common structural explanation of causes of deviance . They assume that conformity

Sociology:Outline and assess Structuralist theories of crime and deviance

589 words - 2 pages All Structuralist theories of crime and deviance seem to suggest that crime is socially constructed rather than focused on the individual.Albert Cohen, combining Structuralist and sub cultural theories drew on Merton's idea of strain but criticized Merton's ideas of crime being an individual response and believed that he ignored non-utilitarian crimes such as vandalism and joy-riding. Cohen was particularly interested in deviance which was not

Write a sociological essay with regards to Crime and Deviance with a Functionalist perspective then critique it with a Marxist view

1156 words - 5 pages 'soft' as it isn't viewed as being as serious as street crime or burglary. Croall (1993) found that the definition and control of white collar crime was a political issue, therefore reflecting the power of those who control it, but it wasn't seen as a threat to social order or dangerous. These explanations may explain a lot about crime but it is based strictly along class lines so therefore is criticised for being too simplistic, deterministic and

Sociology: Outline and assess left and right realist explanations of crime deviance

711 words - 3 pages realists stress that attempts to explain the causes of crime should be abandoned and that sociologists should instead focus on finding practical solutions to slow the growth of crime. This developed the control theory.Hirschi argues that crime is opportunistic and anyone would commit crime if the situation was right and there was little chance of being caught. He says that sociologists should not focus on whypeople commit crime but why more people do

Theories That May Explain Crime in Germantown Avenue Communities in Philadelphia

2268 words - 9 pages that storeowners were attempting to make their stores less attractive. The adding of bars on windows and riot gates decreased the attractiveness of the target, even in the absence of a suitable guardian. As we can see, no one theory can explain all crime––maybe not even one crime event. Rather, we need multiple theories that overlap to explain most crime. The four theories noted above are not the only theories that may apply; actually, there are

Deviance in Society - The Sociology of Deviance

2215 words - 9 pages between deviance and social control. In conclusion, an evaluation on the strengths and weaknesses of two of the more dominant sociological theories and perspectives, strain and labelling theory, which are believed by sociologists to explain the connections between deviance and social control in a changing society, will also be explored.Lupton, Short & Whip (1992, p.133) define social control as 'the means by which societies are stabilised' with

Money is the Root of All Evil- Monetary Issues Leads to Crime and Deviance

1003 words - 4 pages to each of their members, was $24,000.” These people seem to be satisfied with their income. Then you come to those that make less than this or those people who make much more. The individuals who make less always want more, as a result, in some cases their behavior leads to crime. If these people had more they could buy something a little nicer than they already have. Now those who have more money than the average person always seem to want

Assess the usefulness of subcultural theories

719 words - 3 pages Section A (How You Planned Answer) (You can include AS) - Essay PlanPargraph 1 - Digital Technology -Samsung smart camera WB5OFWindows Mac - Video EditoriPhone 5sPrezi Website - Evaluation (A2)Powerpoint Presentation/Microsoft Word (AS)Internet for researchParagraph 2 - Creativity -Define creativity (the use of imagination or original ideas to create something)Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi wrote that the creative process normally takes five steps

The Contribution of Functionalist Sociology to an Understanding of the Role of Education in Society

3253 words - 13 pages The Contribution of Functionalist Sociology to an Understanding of the Role of Education in Society Functionalists have constructed two questions to help them research education. The first question is. "What are the functions of education for society as a whole?" and the second question is. "What are the functional relationships between the education system and other parts of the social system". Firstly

Outline and explain two views of the role of social policy in society - Sociology - Essay

369 words - 2 pages Marxists believe that the social policies introduced by the government, such as the Welfare state - as being used to serve the interests of capitalism in multiple ways. Primarily, social policies provide legitimisation of the exploitation of the working class by the minority ruling class. To workers, the welfare state appears to benefit them by providing housing, benefits and support for those struggling to survive. However, Marxists argue that

Marx and Durkheim’s Views Contributed to our Understanding of Crime and Deviance?

981 words - 4 pages Introduction to the Sociology and Psychology of Crime Section A (Sociology of Crime) How have Marx and Durkheim’s Views Contributed to our Understanding of Crime and Deviance? Karl Marx’s Marxist theory and Emile Durkheim’s functionalist theory were both significant in their own ways and therefore made a large contribution to our perception and understanding of how crime and deviance occurs and is dealt with in society. The Marxist theory on

Similar Essays

Deviance, Crime, And Punishment Sociology Essay

437 words - 2 pages Sociology 100-007 Chapter six in “Starting Points A Sociological Journey” focuses on the cause of deviance and crime, how society categorizes it through a sociological perspective. Social paradigms were used to underline the issues. “The question enquired is “why do people break the rules of society or, to put it another way, deviate from our social expectations?” (177). Through a functionalist perspective, Durkheim highlighted that crime is

Assess Functionalist And Marxist Theories On The Role Of Religion In Society. Sociology Essay

900 words - 4 pages ASSESS FUNCTIONALIST AND MARXIST THEORIES ON THE ROLE OF RELIGION IN SOCIETY. Functionalist sociologists define religion in terms of the social and psychological effects it has on individuals in society. Emile Durkheim defines religion in terms of the contribution it makes to social integration, rather than a belief in any God or the supernatural. Milton Younger identifies the functions that religion performs for individuals, such as answering

Assess Marxist Theories Of Crime And Deviance

626 words - 3 pages , as they make healthy workers to earn them profit. Neo-marxism or critical criminology is a newer philosophy, having arisen from marxist theories and social action theories. A Fully Social Theory of Deviance was a book written by criminologists Taylor, Walton and Young that combines traditional marxism with Neo-marxism. Karl Marx claims that crime is inevitable in capitalists society, as capitalism is a criminogenic system. In a capitalist

Labelling Theories' Contribution To The Sociological Understanding Of Crime And Deviance

1575 words - 6 pages of the labelling theorists to the sociology of deviance can be made. Firstly it has to be questioned about the success of the labelling theories in answering questions such as why a given act is considered deviant and/or criminal in some but not all societies or why a certain kind of reaction may identify behaviour as deviant. However, Becker goes some way to explain the underlying problems of labelling theory in his