The Utilitarian And Kantian Perspective: Prompt #2

1068 words - 5 pages

“Happiness has an intrinsic value in and of itself”, or in other words not dependent on anything else to define its worth (Wetzell PP). Life on the other hand gets tricky. In the context of war, the human life’s value is based on the ability to contribute to the war, whether fighting and carrying out orders as a soldier or collaborating to make strategic plans to reach victory as a general. It is interesting to think that the human life “could have intrinsic value caring about whether or not it is useful to others”(Gray). So to bring it back into to the utilitarian perspective, human life in war is only valuable as a means to happiness. And also the purpose of war according to the hedonistic utilitarian is to maximize “pleasure, satisfaction and lack of pain” (Wetzell PP/Mills 247).

General Marshall’s decision to save Ryan was the morally right decision despite the following objections and deaths of the soldiers who were assigned to transport private Ryan. Based on Utilitarianism, since General Marshall is an agent within an agent, a general in the US army, he is a private utility where “the happiness of some few persons is all he has to attend to” (Wetzell PP/ Mills 249). To be deemed as a private utility one has to be operating under/within a greater agent. Mills proclaims in the Greatest Happiness Principle:

“actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness. By happiness is intended pleasure, and the absence of pain; by unhappiness, pain, and the privation of pleasure. (Mills 243)

General Marshall sends soldiers to save private Ryan for the sake of Ryan’s mother’s happiness, or to prevent further unhappiness and pain after losing three of her sons. Within those of whom General Marshall has to attend to as a private utility, Private Ryan’s mother’s happiness is now harder to obtain since three means that has promoted her happiness are eliminated simultaneously. General Marshall values the happiness of Private Ryan’s mother over the desirable pleasure of the eight soldiers he has to attend to because of his preference in preserving/rebuilding the happiness of a grieving mother who has had her promoters of happiness taken away from her in such a great magnitude.

Mills proclaims that personal preference is how one would distinguish between two decisions of desirable pleasure (Mills 244). On the contrary since Mills addresses the use of personal preference when deciding between desirable pleasures, it has to be assumed that the Utilitarian also uses preference to decide between undesirable displeasures such as: choosing between allowing a grieving mother to lose 4 sons simultaneously or allowing 8 different grieving mothers/spouses to lose their sons/husbands. Preference of undesirable pleasures is simply choosing to prevent the worse option available. Operating under the preference of undesirable displeasures of the Utilitarian, Mills would state...

Find Another Essay On The Utilitarian and Kantian Perspective: Prompt #2

The Fated Donor: A Case Analysis on Kantian Philosophy,Imperative, Will, and Human Dignity

1462 words - 6 pages The Fated Donor: A Case Analysis on Kantian PhilosophyImperative, Will, and Human DignityIt is a common knowledge that Immanuel Kant's philosophy focused in autonomy, rights, and respect. To better understand Kantian philosophy, a case is presented below which can be analyzed in the light of his propositions, particularly regarding imperatives, will, and human dignity. To facilitate the analysis, the arguments of the persons involved in the case

The Wire and Law and Order Paper 2 Prompt

1028 words - 5 pages I imagine that there are hundreds of shows that present crime, and more specific, urban crime. Two examples are Law and Order, which takes place in New York, and The Wire, which takes place in Baltimore. Though the two shows illustrate crime happening in an urban area, both are incorporating court scenes and music; they do so to make two different points: for the audience to figure out a single crime and the other to show the life of Baltimore

Ethics within the Meat Packing Industry, comparison of utilitarian and deontological perspectives

1667 words - 7 pages utilitarian perspective, when employees get injured it can cost the company money. Time away from work, finding temporary help, morale problems, and training new people is expensive."2 Obviously on-the-job injuries favor neither the company nor the employee. An argument could be made that by failing to reform the meat packing process and denying workers the option of filing compensation claims for injuries, the industry can keep their cost margins low

EMU and the british perspective

2777 words - 11 pages member in 2001.In December 2001 inhabitants of the Eurozone could get so-called "starter-kits" containing Euro-coins.In January 2002 also banknotes were introduced and in March 2002 the national currencies became invalid. (Barber and Naimark, 2001)2.THE MONETARY UNIONSince the foundation of the European Monetary Union in 1992 there have always been arguments for and against a single currency.Despite all criticism the Euro is reality in twelve

Prompt: Is Israel’s very survival dependent on the creation of a stable and viable Palestinian state?

851 words - 4 pages Prompt: Is Israel’s very survival dependent on the creation of a stable and viable Palestinian state? Let us have ambitions; ambitions to move beyond the violence and occupation, to the day when two states, Palestine and Israel, can live together side by side in peace and security. ~King Abdullah II. In the country of Israel there are two conflicting ethnic/religious groups, the Israelis and the Palestinians. Israelis have most of the power

The Help and the Interactionist Perspective

1909 words - 8 pages In relating to the characters of The Help, the Interactionist Perspective is the major outlook on the world of sociology, which focuses on the concrete details of what goes on between three characters in their lives, how they connect to one another, why they do and believe in what they do. The Interactionist Perspective summarizes whether the three characters have evolved or regressed throughout the movie. The Help occurs during the segregation

The Conflict Perspective of Deviance and Deviants

1009 words - 4 pages The Conflict Perspective of Deviance and Deviants Works Cited Not Included ·     When it comes to the conflict perspective and deviance, researchers have discovered one of the most influential lines of theory and research (Quinney, 1980; Chambliss and Seidman, 1982; Swaaningen, 1997; Arrigo, 1999). Marxist criminologists see deviance as a product of the exploitative nature of the ruling class. Deviance is a behavior that the rich and

True and Fair from the Accountants' Perspective

1754 words - 8 pages “From the accountants’ perspective, what does ‘true and fair’ mean? In your opinion, is the true and fair requirements useful, or necessary?” Accounting is the measurement procedure and communication of financial information (Needles and Powers 2013) that allows companies to report on the economic performance of their business. It is these reports which bring the concept of ‘true and fair’ into play. True and fair is a central concept related

Conflicting Perspective Julius Caesar And The Pianist

983 words - 4 pages audience as expected to place emphasis on determining the impacts of our actions on society and individuals. Option 2: Julius Caesar Paragraph (Substitution for Antony Speech or Not) ? The scene with Calpurnia’s Dream is a key event that is portrayed by Shakespeare to show to the Elizabethan Audience, as to how the vulnerability to manipulation impacts leads to undesirable consequences. The Dramatic Irony seen from the conversation ‘And know it

Comparing and Contrasting the Psychodynamic Perspective and the Behaviourist Perspective in Accordance to Internet Addiction

1537 words - 7 pages and weaknesses of both the psychodynamic perspective and the behaviourist perspective. This essay will then shift focus to internet addiction – what it is and how it can be explained. An intervention will then be developed for an individual suffering from internet addiction based on the behaviourist perspective. The psychodynamic perspective, as pioneered by Sigmund Freud, revolves around three main ideas. These ideas explain that an

How does The Old Man and the Sea and the Green Mile prompt the audience to view the human condition? - English - Essay

836 words - 4 pages In what ways do Hemmingway in The Old Man and the Sea and Darabont in the Green Mile prompt the audience to view the human condition? Ernest Hemmingway and Frank Darabont both prompt the audience to view the human condition in the novel “The Old Man and the Sea” and “The Green Mile”, respectively. Both Hemmingway and Darabont show us the struggle and suffering of the innocent, the inevitably of death, as well as life and redemption. Ernest

Similar Essays

Leadership And Ethics Course, Through Military Discussing Ethical Decisions As They Relate To Utilitarian Teleologist, Kantian Deontologist And Decision Making,

3080 words - 12 pages protection. Additionally the Kosovo Liberation army is pressuring a male interpreter for information regarding the police. The threats have been entirely directed at the interpreters and not towards the other locally employed staff.AimThe aim of this essay is to discuss the morally right thing to do from the aspect of a utilitarian teleologist, Kantian deontologist and the reasoning behind their decision whether or not to obey the order or to

Traditional And Utilitarian Approaches To The Euthyphro Dilemma

1842 words - 7 pages Traditional And Utilitarian Approaches To The Euthyphro Dilemma In the Euthyphro, Plato describes the proceedings of a largely circular argument between Socrates and Euthyphro, a self-declared prophet and pious man, over the nature of piety and even of the gods themselves. The issues raised in this dialogue have been reinterpreted and extended to remain relevant even with a modern theological framework, so much so that the central issue is

The Utilitarian Philosophies Of Jeremy Bentham And John Stuart Mill

2070 words - 8 pages Compare and contrast the utilitarian philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. Which do you think is the more convincing moral theory, and why?In terms of Utilitarianism, this assignment shall outline the philosophies of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill. It shall firstly illustrate the ideas of Bentham and then follow on to compare and contrast those of Mill. To continue, the assignment will view the failing qualities in both the

Kantian Peace Theory: Insight Ino The Future Relations Between The United States And China

684 words - 3 pages of Kantian Peace theory, that “The Civil Constitution of Every State should be Republican,” we become rather vexed with the case of China. According to the prompt for this essay, the authoritarian government has not been as strong as it is since 1949. This quandary shows that even with the advent of modern communications, the internet, and social networking, the Great Firewall of China still manages to keep control of the flow of information