The Vaccination Autism Debate Essay

1801 words - 8 pages

The vaccination-autism debate originated from the studies of a British medical researcher named Andrew Wakefield. Wakefield had claimed to discover a connection between the vaccination for measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) and the development of autism and gastrointestinal disease in young children. (Hansen) He published his findings in a British medical journal and this started a large controversy amongst many scientists, doctors and citizens all over Europe. Many of who insist that there is no relation between the disease and the vaccination while others stand firm behind the beliefs of Wakefield. This dilemma soon spreads from the UK across the ocean and into North America. The decision of whether or not to have their child vaccinated became a very difficult one for many parents with conflicting beliefs on the matter. As medical researchers continued to study the topic many came to the conclusion that the link between vaccinations and autism and bowel disease were false. While at the same time many were convinced that the relation was so obvious that no children should be exposed to the vaccine. It was soon discovered that the data Wakefield had used in his study was fabricated and there was in fact no connection between the vaccinations and autism in young children. After years of debate many firm believers in the connection will not accept that the information they trusted was a lie.
The sources that I used in my research of the debate include different newspapers such as the Times, Sunday Times, US Newswire, The Guardian, The Week, Salon, USA Today, CBS News and the Pittsburgh Post-Gauzzette. I also used the online news station CNN. The search terms that I employed during my investigation varied from things as specific as “public reactions to 1998 Lancet article by Andy Wakefield” to much broader terms such as “vaccination-autism connections”. I used the University library’s database to search for most of my news articles, as it was easy to filter out the other websites that were not from newspapers. The time frame I looked at was from 1998 when Wakefield’s first study was published to 2011 when his studies were found to be false and it was made widely known that he was paid to release these results. (Retracted)
In 1998 the vaccination-autism connection was first brought to light by the medical journal “The Lancet”. (Murray) Doctors from the Royal Free Hospital of London conducted this study and it stated the discovery of a bowel disease that is associated with the measles virus, which can lead to autism. (Deer) The authors of the original report admit that their results do not prove a direct connection between the MMR vaccination and autism but the lead researcher Andy Wakefield does not recommend the idea of taking the MMR vaccination as one and instead would rather it be taken as three separate vaccinations, one for each illness. (Murray) He believes that when all three are given in one vaccine it causes a shock to the...

Find Another Essay On The Vaccination-Autism Debate

Vaccines Do Not Cause Autism Essay

3216 words - 13 pages that they did not prove an association between the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccination and autism. They also state that if there is a causal link between measles, mumps, and rubella vaccination and autism, a higher rate of autism could be expected since the introduction of the vaccine in the UK in 1988. However, they state that there isn’t enough data to prove that there was a rising incidence of autism. The paper concludes by stating that

Vaccination and kids - Community College - Research Paper

1096 words - 5 pages polio virus which is mutated SV-40 virus and 100,000,000 people were infected worldwide with SV-40 virus. After several years virus SV-40 was announced harmless for humans. Some parents’ do not understand that refusing the vaccines endangers their children. 3. Although, parents declined their children vaccination because some scientists link vaccines with autism and every parent wonders about vaccines safety. In 1998, British gastroenterologist

Autism And MMR

1988 words - 8 pages between the opposing sides; does the MMR vaccine cause Autism. Numerous scientific studies show there is no link between the MMR vaccine and Autism (Coalition, 2013), the original study by Wakefield in 1998 claiming to have found a casual link has been retracted, while the community suffer the effects of anti-vaccination in the community, due to the fear of the community, originating from exaggerated news stories in the media ("A case of junk

Peripheral Tolerance

980 words - 4 pages consequently. The link between autism and vaccinations was further disproved in a scientific study by the Institute of Medicine in 2004. Regardless of the release of this study, anti-vaccination groups, such as the Vaccination Liberation Group, still attempt to stop parents from vaccinating their children for reasons such as that vaccination is not natural. Such a state of mind adopts the “appeal to nature” logical fallacy in which because something is

Vaccine Essay

821 words - 3 pages . McTaggart links the appearance of learning disabilities, autism, and hyperactivity to the beginning of the mass vaccination programs (1). Thus, vaccination is directly related to many diseases, in which some are still unknown. McTaggart adds that the mumps vaccine has proved to be a direct cause of seizures, meningitis, deafness, and encephalitis. (6). These are extremely dangerous and unrecoverable diseases. Dr J Anthony Morris, an immunization

autism

1287 words - 6 pages Vaccination and other perceived causes One of the highly contested and controversial debates in the past surrounding the cause of autism is vaccination. Those who firmly believe that vaccination is the culprit desperately cling on to whatever proof they have. Although it cannot be denied that the first symptoms of autism appear right after the child receives the first series of vaccinations. There are those who disagree vehemently

Major Canadian Health Concern – Unvaccinated Children and the Spread of Preventable Diseases

1442 words - 6 pages The debate over vaccinations causing autism is a very important health risk facing our country today. There is a misconception that these two things are related which this essay hopes to dispel. The current threat of unvaccinated children, due to parental concern over the risk of adverse effects from vaccination including autism or religious choice is a major Canadian health concern and results in misconceptions, outbreaks, and general false

The MMR debate: A review of the Primary Evidence

6575 words - 26 pages association between autism and childhood immunisation with the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine.The passing years have seen a number of media campaigns initiated by the government in an effort to calm the hysterical press and confused families, and to once again restore faith in the MMR vaccine.This paper sets out the facts about autism and measles, mumps and rubella and goes on to critically review the primary evidence surrounding the 'MMR Debate

Autism Spectrum Disorder and Interventions

1306 words - 5 pages thoughts spread drastically and parents began to worry that the measles and mumps vaccination and the children’s diet was the cause of autism. However, there was no evidence for those notions but parents still held on to the belief that the diet and or vaccinations were responsible for causing autism. The reason for the idea of the measles and mumps vaccination causing autism was that autism would develop in children around the same time when the

Refutations to Vaccine Linked Autism Claims

1019 words - 5 pages The Anti-vaccination movement is a growing number of people that mistrust the use of vaccines. The movement blame vaccines, or their ingredients, for the increase of autism throughout the past decades. Although this movement has rapidly gained support throughout these past years, there is very little scientific evidence to prove that their claims are true; in fact, there is a lot of peer reviewed research that concludes that a lot of anti

Myths About the Measles-Mumps-Rubella (MMR) Vaccine

2066 words - 8 pages we continue with our current program. While the MMR vaccination is the safest way to ensure that we do not have an outbreak, the vaccination has been a source of controversy over the years. At one time, the MMR vaccine was thought to be unsafe because not only does it overwhelm your immune system, but also the vaccine contained toxic additives, and was thought to be linked to Autism. Studies have since proven that there is no link between the

Similar Essays

The Vaccination Autism Debate Essay

1456 words - 6 pages Before the rise of the vaccination-autism debate in 1988, the safety of the MMR vaccine was put in doubt because of its negative effects related to Urabe mumps stress that would result to meningitis. A case had been presented before a court in Britain in the 1980s indicating that the MMR vaccine caused Urabe mumps strain. The adverse reactions of the MMR vaccines was brought before the American and the Canadian authorities because of the reports

The Debate Over Vaccination Essay

732 words - 3 pages “Immunization Is a Question of Science, Not Faith: How I Evaluated the Immunization ‘Debate’ “, by Chanda Cooper-Warren. Her article appears on the website www.quackwatch.org, and is written with the authority of a concerned mother without any medical credentials listed. Warren believed that, “A medical issue should be judged by science”, and any claim on the subject had to be based on valid scientific data from a reputable source (Cooper-Warren

The Influenza Vaccination Debate Essay

2331 words - 9 pages Mandatory Influenza Vaccinations for healthcare providers can be a controversial topic for some and may propose a challenge to some provider’s ethical values and beliefs. The topic of mandatory vaccination for influenza (“flu”) has been widely studied and debated among professionals over several years. It is apparent that there is some movement towards a mandatory vaccination for influenza by healthcare institutions as the benefit out weighs

The Link Between Autism And Immunization

946 words - 4 pages study, it was found that the children with autism had received no more exposure to thimerosal prior to birth than children without autism. The Dukehealth.com article also raises concerns about the reoccurrence of disease outbreaks due to the lack of vaccination. A piece run in The Daily Beast also brings about this point, as it explains how Maryland school officials are suing parents who refuse to vaccinate their children. The article states that