The Vaccine Autism Controversy Essay

1143 words - 5 pages

Parents everywhere ponder the question, what causes autism in young children? Since the early 1990s it has been debated whether or not vaccines are to blame for being the causal effect of autism. Numerous studies have been conducted to prove this theory true or false; however, many parents are still fighting the courts that vaccines caused autism in their children. Furthermore, more babies are not getting vaccinated due to the increasing scare being presented on the media about vaccines. The vaccine-autism controversy is the central issue in Jeffrey S. Gerber’s and Paul A. Offits’ article “Vaccines and Autism: A Tale of Shifting Hypotheses” as well as in Andy Coghlan’s article “Vaccines May Have Triggered Autism-Like Symptoms, US Court Rules.”
Gerber and Offits clearly argue that science proves vaccines are not the link to autism. They state three proposed hypotheses about how vaccines cause autism in their introduction and then follow up with numerous studies disproving each of the three hypotheses in their body paragraphs. Coghlan’s article does not come straight out and state that vaccines cause autism; nevertheless, he uses a real-life example of a two-year old girl who received multiple vaccinations, developed autism-like symptoms, and is now being compensated by the U.S. Court for her disabilities due to the vaccines.
In “Vaccines and Autism: A Tale of Shifting Hypotheses,” the title says a lot about the central issues in the article. The writers provide the three main hypotheses that are presented when arguing the vaccine-autism controversy, they are stated by Gerber and Offits as follows:
(1) the combination measles-mumps-rubella vaccine causes autism by damaging the intestinal lining, which allows the entrance of encephalopathic proteins; (2) thimerosal, an ethylmercury-containing preservative in some vaccines, is toxic to the central nervous system; and (3) the simultaneous administration of multiple vaccines overwhelms or weakens the immune system (456).
The writers then talk about the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine and thimerosal to help readers better understand what is being injected into babies and children. Then, as their argumentative strategy the authors disprove all three hypotheses by discussing ecological studies, retrospective, observational studies, and cohort studies that have been conducted to show that vaccines are not the link to autism.
By presenting the hypotheses and then disproving each of them with scientific studies, the authors’ argumentative strategies are extremely strong. When using science to back up an argument it makes readers more trusting to that side of the debate. On the contrary, Gerber and Offits do not provide any studies where a child developed autism shortly after getting vaccinated. If they had used a case study to disprove why a vaccine was not the link to autism in the child in that study, it would have strengthened their writing that much more. Nevertheless, their argumentative...

Find Another Essay On The Vaccine-Autism Controversy

Exploring and Unraveling Autism Essay

2326 words - 9 pages believe that certain vaccines, vaccine preservatives or medications taken to treat side effects of vaccines may cause autism. However, researchers continue to agree that immunizations do not cause the disorder. Since autism is thought to be a biologically-based disorder, in the past, some researchers had suggested that the disorder was the result of poor attachment skills on the part of the mother. This belief has caused a great deal of

Flawed Protection Essay

1144 words - 5 pages . The Thiomersal controversy claims that vaccines containing the preservative Thimerosal contribute to autism and other brain development disorders due to the high levels of mercury.( Autism is a severe developmental disorder that will usually begin at birth or sometimes within the first two-and-a-half years of life. Most autistic children are perfectly normal in appearance, but spend their time engaged in puzzling and disturbing

MMR Vaccine: Examining the Evidence

2563 words - 11 pages word surrounded by controversy in today’s parenting world and the Measles Mumps and Rubella vaccine (MMR) can be distinguished as possibly the most controversial vaccine of our time. Controversial because of the fear that many have that it causes autism along with other hazards. This fear has clouded the judgment of thousands of concerned parents who are making the decision of whether or not to vaccinate their children with the MMR vaccine. These

Vaccines Do Not Cause Autism

3216 words - 13 pages of the public at large to believe anything that medical research reports without questioning the findings. Unfortunately, the media attention such examples of junk science receive aids in convincing many of its truthfulness. The hype surrounding the belief that vaccines cause autism began in 1998 when Andrew Wakefield in the UK published an article in the Lancet linking the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine to cases of autism in


2520 words - 10 pages " . Hooker is on the Board of Directors of Focus Autism. This organization main goal is to put an end to harming children with vaccinations, he also runs the Anti Vaccination Campaign A Shot Of Truth. Hooker continues to bring up anti vaccine conspiracy theories and has many followers to go along with it, One being the actress Jenny McCarty. Hooker is important because, he has resurrected Wakefield's findings, and he is also the person that is claiming

MMR+ Autism

2520 words - 10 pages " . Hooker is on the Board of Directors of Focus Autism. This organization main goal is to put an end to harming children with vaccinations, he also runs the Anti Vaccination Campaign A Shot Of Truth. Hooker continues to bring up anti vaccine conspiracy theories and has many followers to go along with it, One being the actress Jenny McCarty. Hooker is important because, he has resurrected Wakefield's findings, and he is also the person that is claiming

Vaccinations and Their Possible Link to Autism

1131 words - 5 pages ). The activated immune system produces a reaction which eventually causes immunologic memory and a heightened response to future exposure (Bauman, 2012). This means that the patient will be sick for a shorter period of time or that they will not become sick at all. That said it is believed that immunizing children could potentially cause autism through the action of the various chemicals within the vaccine (Ratajczak, 2001). This paper will

The Rise of Autism

1963 words - 8 pages are aware of it, there is still room for opportunities to live a normal life. Many parents find it hard to deal with their children experiencing autistic behaviors. Luckily, the government provides aid for children living with disabilities, such as autism. Taking advantage of the numerous assistance, can help all the families experiencing this issue, live a happier and healthier life. Works Cited Allen, Arthur. Vaccine: The Controversial


1287 words - 6 pages understand the mystery behind autism, they try to retrace their steps, trying to figure out where they went wrong. Vaccination seemed to be the only variable to which they can place the blame. All this can be attributed to Andrew Wakefield. He is a British medical researcher who published a study in 1998 which indicated that there was a direct correlation between autism and the mumps, measles, and rubella (MMR) vaccine. However, an


1686 words - 7 pages person in mind and assumptions being made about the person” Paul Issacs. Hopefully what I will see more of in my time of teaching is more understanding and more acceptance of those who are different around us. Works Cited Baron-Cohen, S. (2009). Does Autism Need a Cure? The Lancet, 1595-1596. Shute, N. (2010). Desperate For an Autism Cure. Scientific American, 80(6). Silencing Debate Over Autism. (2007). Nature Neuroscience, 531. Stokstad, E. (2003). Vaccine-autism link dealt blow. Science, 1454. Wadman, M. (2011). A Voice For Science. Nature, 28. What is Autism? (n.d.). Retrieved from Autism Speaks:

Vaccines Are Not the Cause of Autism

804 words - 3 pages in children, researchers currently recognize that the increase in autism claims are not vaccine linked. Koch (2000) affirms that, “drugmakers and health officials say there is no proof of a causal relationship among vaccinations and severe adverse reactions and that maintaining public health demands widespread mandatory immunization.” Without the value of vaccinations, the human race in the present day however, would suffer the complexity of

Similar Essays

How The Media Perpetuated The Autism Vaccine Scare

1697 words - 7 pages 2Correlation ≠ Causation: How the Media Perpetuated the Autism-Vaccine ScareIn his book, The Culture of Fear, Barry Glassner describes an America lead by misguided fears: "Valid fears have their place, they clue us to danger. False and overdrawn fears only cause hardship" (xxiii). Such is the case surrounding the claims and controversy between vaccination and autism. While much is still not know about the causes of this disease, in the late

Cervical Cancer And The Hpv Vaccine Controversy: Where Are The Men? Where Is The Money?

1800 words - 7 pages to 26, some critics state that children may become involved in sex at a very young age. Medical experts suggest, on the other hand, that young boys and girls should be vaccinated at the age of 11 or 12, to protect them before they become active in sex (Stein, 2009). This raises the controversy that the vaccine will promote promiscuity. This will become consent for premarital sex. As long as congressional funding for the FDA decreases and funding

The Link Between Autism And Immunization

946 words - 4 pages A recent spike in the number of diagnoses of autism spectrum disorders has also brought to light the controversy that exists concerning the link between autism and immunizations. In a piece published by CNN, Jenny McCarthy depicts her son’s recovery from autism. In it, she claims that autism is an entirely environment illness, and states that vaccines are a major trigger of the disease. A Newsweek article printed in 2005 discusses the search for

Should There Be A Mmr Vaccine

1769 words - 7 pages IntroductionIn this case study I am going to evaluate if the MMR vaccine should be used and whether it is safe for children to be vaccinated. Since 1988, there has been a big controversy about the safety of the MMR vaccine and its perceived link to bowel disease and autism. The MMR vaccine safeguards patients from deadly diseases such as Measles, Mumps and Rubella, reducing the risks of children transmitting the deadly disease and lowering the