The Validity Of Creationism And Evolution

3644 words - 15 pages

The Validity of Creationism and Evolution

Abstract: This paper discusses the validity of both creation and evolution and examines whether they can interact with each other. Besides doing my own research, I have chosen to interview four people extensively involved in either Christianity or biology. I specifically picked interviewees who strongly supported either evolution or creation to get both sides of the issue. Two of the people were from United Christian Fellowship (UCF): Andrew Larratt-Smith, leader of UCF, and Ricardo Dawkins, UCF small group member. I also interviewed two biologists: Paul Matsudaira, MIT Biology professor, and Bettina Bauer, a post-doctoral fellow in the HST department. Paul considers his religious beliefs in between agnosticism and Catholic. He was baptized in the Roman Catholic church but has not thought about God extensively. Bettina is neither religious nor anti-religious. She says that if God really exists, it would not change her life. From these interviews, I hoped to gain a better understanding of creation and evolution and examine whether they can co-exist.

Creationism is based on the belief that God is the intelligent Designer who created our universe and the natural things in it. It is derived from the two stories of Genesis. The first of the stories (Genesis 1:1-2:3) states that God created the heavens and the earth, light, water, vegetation, animals, and then man in the image of him. In the second account (2:4-2:9), God made the heavens and the earth, water, man from the dust, and then vegeta-tion and animals. Clearly these two accounts differ from each other in terms of order. The response I received from creationists (Andrew) was that the Bible must not always be taken literally. Genesis as a book is highly symbolic and was written to show God’s order and purpose in the world. The first account is poetic and chronological, while the second account focuses on creating humans and giving them authority over creation. This view would resolve the conflict between the two stories. However, more conservative creationists (Ricardo) believe that the Bible must be taken literally. To explain the difference of the two stories, they reason that the two accounts are indeed the same in order. Genesis 2:19 says, “the Lord God had formed out of the ground all the beasts of the field and all the birds of the air.” Although the creation of man from the dust had been mentioned before this verse, it does not imply that birds were created after man, because God had formed the beasts and the birds. Thus both Genesis creation stories do not necessarily contradict each other.

Those who do not support creationism (Paul and Bettina) do not see any basis for accepting it. As scientists, they need evidence and sufficient proof to believe such a theory. On the other hand, both Paul and Bettina are not vehemently opposed to creationism. They see the Bible as a contemporary publication, written centuries after the...

Find Another Essay On The Validity of Creationism and Evolution

Evolution, Intelligent Design, and Creationism in Schools

822 words - 4 pages Evolution, Intelligent Design, and Creationism in Schools Human beings are curious by nature. Science exemplifies this inherent nature that most people feel at least to some extent. Science is the art of asking why. Why does the moon sometimes look like a perfect circle, a semi-circle, or disappears all together? Why do things fall to the ground when they are dropped? Why can a chair support a person against the force pulling him or her down

Creationism and the Classroom Essay

916 words - 4 pages Creationism and the Classroom      The American classroom is suffering from a major deficiency. The science curriculum supports one theory of evolution and no other theory as to how the existence of the universe has come to be. This narrow-minded approach has kept many young minds from seeing a very broad picture of this world.      Scientific creationism should be included in our public school

The Theory of Creationism

1298 words - 5 pages died. If you find yourself questioning the fact of Creationism, then consider the fact that your non-belief is what makes you a Godless heathen. At this point, you might as well go and live with a pack of wolves, because they are Godless too. Of course we need not forget that Creationism is constantly taking the country by storm. In a recent poll, it was discovered that 85% of the country believe that evolution does not exist (Gallup), and that

Validity of the Constitution

1353 words - 6 pages liberty (Doc. E). Hence, the immorality of slavery would appear paradoxical to the promise of freedom. As can be seen, the Constitution was flawed with concepts that were diametrically opposed, driving an ideological wedge between the Union. The validity of the Constitution was further questioned legally and authoritatively. The supreme court was seen as the final arbiter of law, but Dred Scott v. Sandford heavily tarnished the court's

The Validity of Plutarch

3232 words - 13 pages The first century AD gave birth to Plutarch of Chaeronea. He was born into the Greco-Roman world during the Pax Romana, a time of peace that which had not been seen in all of the country's history. Plutarch, coming from an upper-class family, was able to get a good education and find a purpose to his life1. Philosophy was his calling and he was brilliant in his work. An aficionado of the works of his forefathers in thought (from Zeno to

Creationism: The Center of Our Universe and Life

2226 words - 9 pages practices and beliefs they all agree that the universe, earth, and life were created by a higher power and or creator. The majority of creationist believers are of a Christian faith, “In the US and UK, significant groups of Christians believe that evolution is an unproved theory which may devalue religious belief” (BBC). Most creationists believers believe the biblical description of the earth and mankind as fact, “Creationism teaches that life on Earth

The Validity of the Cosmological, Ontological, and Teleological Arguements

1331 words - 5 pages probabilities, and the slim chances that life and even the entire universe had to come into existence in the first place. It has been argued that natural selection has been resposible for the evolution of life, but this theory does not explain certain aspects of the universe. "Since natural selection is a biological principle and not a principle of chemistry, we must appeal to other principles to explain why living things came from the nonliving."5

Evolution over Creationism for the Public School System

2562 words - 11 pages “On one hand, you’ve got kids going to Sunday school, and they’re telling them that God created them, and then they go to school and they’re being taught that man evolved from an ape” (White, Gary). The argument has taken the better part of a century, as to if creationism or evolution should be taught in public schools (Vedantam, Shankar); and no closer have we came to deciding which idea or more appropriately which theory should be taught to

The Absurdity of Scientific Creationism

3010 words - 12 pages trust the Bible when it talks about morality and salvation? [i]@ It is no wonder with sentiments like these that the backlash against evolution has been so strong and lasting; nonetheless, it has not been until the last few decades that such a debate has moved from the pulpit to the laboratory. With a more educated and well-informed army of Christians, who believe in creationism, the scientific evidence for evolution has now come under assault

The Validity Of Personality Tests

630 words - 3 pages The Validity of Personality TestsWhen looking online for a personality test, I came across one in which the test itself suited my character. It was titled, "Which Cartoon Character Are You?" The test was structured efficiently and humorously just as is my approach to most aspects of my life. The test consists of multiple choice questions with answers that are each given different values unbeknownst to the subject. When the subject finishes, the

The Validity of The Evolutionary Theory

1396 words - 6 pages every life form is the creation of a supernatural being, to reinforce the validity of the evolution theory. Gould undermines creationism by emphasizing its misused concepts of theory and popular philosophy, proving that it is not science. Besides denouncing creationism, Gould also provides theoretical examples as evidence to prove evolution is a theory. Despite their different approaches, both Darwin and Gould effectively prove the existence of

Similar Essays

The Monkey Trial Disputes The Theory Of Evolution And Creationism

1018 words - 5 pages The Scopes Trial, which was also known as ‘The Monkey Trial’ or The State of Tennessee vs. Scopes, was a very popular legal dispute in court that was between the theory of evolution and creationism, and played a major role which shaped the 1920’s. What was just as popular was the interpretation of the case, if not more than the actual result of the dispute. This case received world-wide attention and the media coverage produced many different

The Debate Between Evolution And Creationism

2250 words - 9 pages If the question was posed as to what is the debate between creationism vs. evolution consist of, the thought that it is ‘“God did it” vs. “Natural processes did it,”’ (Scott, 2004) may arise. Science cannot absolutely prove or disprove Creation or Evolution. Yet scientist and the remainder of society use creationism and evolution to prove our existence. Creationist believe in the Christian account of the origin as recorded in Genesis

Evolution And Creationism Debate With An Analysis Of Galileo

1204 words - 5 pages with one another. Scientists believe that evolution proves the creation of the earth, where as creationists believe that a supreme being created the earth. This debate has even reached the bottom as to argue whether creationism can truly be a science. Another debate is whether the earth is the center of the universe, which has been heavily discussed for more than a millennium. This is based on the findings of Aristotle, Copernicus, and Galileo

Creationism And Evolution Taught In Schools

2124 words - 8 pages Creationism and Evolution taught in schools Introduction: The education of evolution and creationism in the public school system has been debatable. Charles Darwin published his conclusions of evolution in 1859. This altered the teaching of science in the public school system intensely (Armenta, 1). Several court cases have been filed against the teaching of evolution. Because of the religious conservative legislators a ban was placed on