This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Value Of Nature Essay

2286 words - 10 pages

The Value of Nature
Humans project the value of nature because humans are the only beings that are able to produce rational thoughts and are therefore, the only beings that value. Since humans are the only beings that value, they are inherently the only things that determine the value of other things. In addition to my main thesis, I will address where the value in nature originates by explaining the disjoint relationship between humans and non-humans. Expanding on my thesis, I will prove the projection view is correct by showing that all arguments for the recognition view appeal to projection. Projection, meaning, humans project value on to nature rather than recognition, meaning, humans recognize the intrinsic value of nature. The value of nature is a contentious issue that not only concerns environmental ethicists, but also everyday people around the world. As our world becomes more technologically dependent, it seems that we are becoming less concerned with nature. In deciding the future of our planet, it is important that we explore the value of nature and the consequence of destroying it. I will reference and utilize quotes by Holmes Rolston III from his novel, A New Environmental Ethics, as I evaluate the Euthyphro Problem as it applies to the value of nature.
The recognition view of the value nature articulates that humans recognize the intrinsic value of nature. Where does the basis for this argument originate? Rolston defends the idea that if an organism performs behaviors that strive towards their survival, then they are intrinsically valuable. To defend his argument he uses the examples of plants, trees, and dragonflies. In using these examples, he tries to prove that value is recognized, not projected, by humans. I will take the examples that Rolston uses to back up this argument and show how they appeal to projection.
Rolston argues in favor of the recognition of the value of nature by humans. The opposing side of the projection argument would say that since, according to Rolston, “A plant is a spontaneous, self-maintaining system, sustaining and reproducing itself, executing its program, making a way through the world,” a plant has intrinsic value (Rolston 97). This argument is invalid. The validity of the argument can be determined by investigating the evolution of the human brain. In analyzing the track of evolution, its evident that natural selection has been working diligently to produce humans. Evolution has worked rapidly to create and perfect the human brain, in particular the prefrontal cortex. Scientifically, humans have a more uniquely organized prefrontal cortex (area of the brain located in the frontal lobe) than other animals, which is responsible for high-level performance tasks such as planning, reasoning, thinking, and decision-making. This area of the brain is what allows humans to have the ability to make rational thoughts and therefore be ‘valuers’. The prefrontal cortex is the area of the brain that is...

Find Another Essay On The Value of Nature

The Value Of Biodiversity Essay

1237 words - 5 pages were neglected by economic activity ? causing them to become severely degraded. An important step in sustaining these services is to define them as goods and services.The most obvious value of biodiversity is direct extractive uses (timber, plants & animals as food). There are also direct non-extractive uses (ecotourism, recreation). Indirect uses (the role of organisms in pest control, protection against erosion). Optional use (potential use

The Value of Art Essay

2453 words - 10 pages The Value of Art Art can be misunderstood, misinterpreted, and misplaced in modern society. This is especially true in the life of Christians. Many Christians completely disregard art because they think it is a form of self-worship, a waste of time, or simply have no idea how to approach art. Some Christians will even avoid art museums, performances, and discussions because they do not want anything to do with art. Is something wrong with this

The Value of Reputation

1107 words - 5 pages without knowing his true nature and refers to others "Iago is most honest," (2.3.7). Iago is shown to be trustworthy in the past because he has not deceived anyone, and proved his loalty to Othello with several years of service for him. Also being the reason why Othello believes in him. Since Iago has a good reputation and is respected by most, Othello can easily finds Iago trustworthy and believes Iago tells him. Thus, he begins to doubt Desdemona

The Value of Philosophy

1121 words - 4 pages The Value of Philosophy Consider a man that looks to material needs as the necessities of life. He moves through his world in a twenty-four hour cycle of the mundane, never reaching for a less ignorant existence. Bertrand Russell believes that these "practical men", as society deems them, are wrongly named. A meaningful life to this "practical man", certainly does not include the understanding of a need for knowledge. Russell states

The Value of Humanity

1777 words - 7 pages Khmer Rouge, a Communist group targeting many groups. Among them are the ethnic Chinese, the ethnic Vietnamese, and capitalists. Overall, humanity holds a lot of value and the consequences of losing it are severe. Maintaining humanity is important for a many reasons. Most of these have to do with keeping faith in a religion, and not losing hope. A common expression when someone sees something bad happening is “I’ve lost faith in humanity

The Value of Philosophy

745 words - 3 pages "The Value of Philosophy?"Question 5: Some students feel that philosophy is worthless because it does not yield definite results. How would Russell respond? Russell says the value of philosophy is in its uncertainty. What does he mean? Do you agree?Often times before I had attended college, I felt that philosophy was a useless study. I did not see the point of asking sometimes ridicules questions and arguing over them. You know the questions I

The Value of Trees

949 words - 4 pages sunlight and water. Sunlight gives the tree energy, and water saturates the roots forming them deeply. Deeply formed roots are able to stand throughout all the effects and actions of nature/environment. My roots are my faith and my mother. Simply having a relationship with Christ stimulates root growth. The full development of my roots occurs when I have devoted my time to saturate them by studying His word and depending solely upon Him. Some people are

The Value of Philosophy

880 words - 4 pages As a concluding thought in his book entitled, The Problems of Philosophy, Bertrand Russell wrestles with the value of philosophy and why philosophy should continue to be studied. Philosophy’s value must be sought after, he states, in order to truly understand its importance. In order to do so, one must rid his or her mind, first, of any practical prejudices such as material needs like food only being for the body’s nourishment

The Value of Philosophy - 1533 words

1533 words - 7 pages To understand the value of philosophy, one must look at its origins. Linguistically the word philosophy comes from the Greek term philosophia, meaning “the love of wisdom.” Wisdom can be defined as the quality of having experience, knowledge, and good judgment. Ultimately philosophy can be defined as the love of having experience, knowledge, and good judgment. When one hears the term philosophy questions such as “what is the purpose of life

The Value of Life

1141 words - 5 pages Imagine if you went on a vacation with a friend and somehow ended up on a jungle island fighting for your life! That’s what happened to Rainsford, the main character in Richard Connell’s thriller, The Most Dangerous Game. During this “vacation” Rainsford learned just how valuable a human life is . The value of life is the main theme in this story, but it is also important in the world around us and in my own personal life. In the story, The

The Value of College

1326 words - 5 pages The idea of a college education is the standard path for a student after high school, but differences in opinion would question its value. Parents constantly remind their children about the importance of college, and how it can lead them to have a successful future. Millions of students attend college whether it be at a community or a university, with the goal of pursuing a degree that only college has to offer. The amount of successful

Similar Essays

The Value Of Nature Essay

2183 words - 9 pages of Myself, and When I Heard the Learn’d Astronomer, illustrating the value of nature. Another Romantic author, Emerson, has written an essay, Nature, which also reflects the importance of nature. As these authors write their literature about nature, they illustrate the importance that it brings to oneself, community, God, and those relationships. It is important for modern readers to value nature, as the Romantic authors did, because it is there

Value Of Nature Essay

2206 words - 9 pages Albert Einstein, a German-born theoretical physicist, once said, “Look deep into nature, and then you will understand everything better” (Wilkes). Einstein refers to nature as a portal into the unknown. Initially, a person can find the answers to any question within nature. Furthermore, nature can help a person to look at the greater purpose and reflect. This idea supports the Romantic authors as they write about the value of nature. Walt

“In A Prosperous Society, Value Is Predominantly Of An Intangible Nature.”

681 words - 3 pages . The opposite case is witnessed with ‘Arm & Hammer’ where the brand is negatively perceived by consumers because of unsatisfied and displeased customers. In both cases the tangible value of the product, the physical product, affects the intangible value of the product, the brand name. So more importance is put on the tangible value. In a prosperous society of today, value is predominantly of an intangible nature since ample products are available

“ In A Prosperous Society, Value Is Predominantly Of An Intangible Nature.”

667 words - 3 pages Skills: Value" In a prosperous society, value is predominantly of an intangible nature." (Marketing Manager)In our modern society, differentiating products and services from competition has become essential for firms. Consumers benefit from a large variety of products in their efforts to satisfy their needs and thus, intangible values, such as quality, customer service and style, have become key determinants of consumption choices. Firms