The Varying Interpretations Of Helen Essay

1325 words - 6 pages

Within the poem The Iliad, written by Homer, there are several tales of the epic battles waged between the men of Greece and Troy. These men fought constantly for ten years. A person might think that a battle that could continue for that amount of time may be about a difference of religion, or perhaps because a king wanted to acquire more land. No, this war was fought for one thing, a woman. No one contests the beauty of the woman named Helen. However, some may question the character of this immortal beauty within the text of Homer’s epic poem. Was Helen a deceitful and scheming woman, a victim of circumstance, or was she simply at the mercy of the Gods? Who was the woman who, as Christopher Marlowe stated, was “the face that launched a thousand ships”?
The motivations behind Helen’s words and actions have been analyzed throughout the years. In one example F. J. Groten, Jr., author of the article Homer’s Helen, clearly viewed Helen as a victim. This view is validated within the poem The Iliad beginning with the speech of Nestor. At this moment, the Greeks are feeling defeated and tired of war and are readying themselves for the journey home. Nestor encourages the men that they should continue their fight and that the treatment of the Trojan women should be like the miseries that Helen has had to suffer. This statement certainly implies that the Greeks feel that Helen was captured against her will (Homer 43).
Groten uses many of The Iliad’s verses to show Helen’s plight. He states that she is “clearly distressed by all the misery for which she considers herself responsible” (Groten 34). Groten’s proof for his explanations of Helen’s emotions is in the making of the tapestry, in which she is creating a piece of art depicting the Greeks and Trojans in battle. Helen’s last appearance in The Iliad is at Hector’s funeral, saying “In all wide Troy who will pity me or be my friend. Everyone shudders at me.” (Homer 205). Her words of lament and regret are moving as she weeps for Hector. As Groten explains, Homer gives Helen the important role of saying the last rites over Hector’s body.
To describe Helen’s attributes Groten often used words such as sensitive, dignified, integrity, and concerned, just to name a few. In the very brief analysis of Helen in Homer’s Helen, anyone who reads it can fully appreciate that Groten felt that Helen was a woman worthy of admiration. However, not everyone feels toward Helen as Groten did. George J. Ryan, author of Helen in Homer, is extremely critical of Helen’s character. Ryan blatantly asserts that, “Helen is wanton, self-centered, deceitful, bewitching, and beguiling” (Ryan 117).
Helen in Homer does not paint Helen as the “victim” archetype as Groten did in Homer’s Helen. Ryan, on the other hand, obviously has no love for this character. Where Groten valued Helen’s making of the tapestry as being “in distress”, Ryan’s interpretation of this same scene is that Helen is seen here in the light...

Find Another Essay On The Varying Interpretations of Helen

Interpretations Of The Fourth Amendment Essay

1148 words - 5 pages was found to be relevant (Find Law Legal Professionals Home Page 1968). Terry vs. Ohio, shows that we still to this day have the controversial issues of the fourth amendment and the meanings that follow with it and its' interpretations. The issue of the fourth amendment is in the news today more than ever before with the use of the now controversial Internet. House Republican Leader Dick Armey says that a new privacy law would be hypocritical when

The Story Of My Life By Helen

655 words - 3 pages The Story of My Life by Helen Keller Inspiration The potency and inspiration of the less-than fortunate never ceases to amaze me. Against physical conditions that would enslave even the strongest of women, Helen Keller challenged her multiple disabilities and became an educated young women in spite of them. Blind and deaf at two, Helen Keller's story of bravery and fortitude and her remarkable relationship with her beloved teacher Ann Sullivan

The Difficult Childhood of Helen keller.

1309 words - 5 pages ENG 1D1Major EssayThe Difficult Childhood of Helen KellerMaria Reyes DiazDec. 3/01Helen Adams Keller was born into a wealthy family on the summer of June 27, 1880, in Tuscumbia Alabama. Helen was a very intelligent girl who was interested in everything around her; at least she was able to enjoy the beauty of nature through vision and the beauty of speech and hearing for the first few months of her life. Helen's life dramatically changed when she

Contrary Interpretations of The Yellow Wallpaper

1581 words - 6 pages Contrary Interpretations of The Yellow Wallpaper    “The Yellow Wallpaper” was first published in New England Magazine in 1892.  Charlotte Perkins Gilman, an advocate for the advancement of women, authored the short story.  She intended the piece to bring to light the inherent ineptitude of the Weir Mitchell “rest cure.”  Though this subject is addressed, many other pertinent topics are broached, ever so subtly.  Other themes in the book

Post Colonial Interpretations of Shakespeare’s The Tempest

1945 words - 8 pages Post Colonial Interpretations of Shakespeare’s The Tempest “…do we really expect, amidst this ruin and undoing of our life, that any is yet left a free and uncorrupted judge of great things and things which reads to eternity; and that we are not downright bribed by our desire to better ourselves?” – Longinus Since the seventeenth century many interpretations and criticisms of William Shakespeare’s The Tempest have been recorded. Yet

Dr. Faustus Essay: The Role of Helen of Troy

1189 words - 5 pages The Role of Helen of Troy in Doctor Faustus    To adequately describe the role that Helen plays in Doctor Faustus, it is necessary not only to look at the scene in which she features, but also all the instances that Faustus takes some form of pleasure from physical and sensual things. We need to do this because this is what Helen is symbolic of; she represents the attractive nature of evil in addition to the depths of depravity that

Helen of War: Epistles of the French Revolution

1554 words - 6 pages Helen Maria Williams was a woman ahead of her time. While writing letters home to England during the French Revolution, the turmoil and political upheaval around her closely mimicked the turmoil she was experiencing personally. An outcast amongst her friends, Williams’ observations and desolation are apparent in her Letters Written in France, in the Summer of 1790, a collection of her writings to friends and family still in England. As a woman

The feminist and Marxist interpretations of Alice's Adventures in Wonderland

1024 words - 4 pages control. She is perceived to be a slave because others (mainly men) are taking control of her and her body. Her right to be her own height at her own will is taken away and she is stuck with the height that she gets. These limitations exist because of her lack of knowledge, portraying her as a slave. Contrasting feminist interpretations can be seen though Alice’s character, reflecting upon the society of the Victorian era. The Queen of Hearts mainly

Modern and Ancient Interpretations of Alexander the Great

1570 words - 6 pages proficiency and are almost always made with a degree of personal bias, with historical interpretations of issues like his spread of Hellenistic culture and lack of succession planning significantly varied depending on the overall purpose and context of the writer.Throughout antiquity, Alexander's success has been judged by both modern and ancient writers and attributed to his strong ability as a military leader. This however is where the consensus ends

The Varying Faces of Death The meaning of James Joyce's short story The Dead

861 words - 3 pages The Varying Faces of DeathJames Joyce's "The Dead" exhibits the capacity of another's death to dishearten one in his future relations and experiences. This short story also gives voice to the emotions of a husband. This husband's wife's romantic tie to a man who died years ago, forces him to realize that there is a chapter of his wife's life in which he plays no part. In the story this man not only comes to grips with such a realization, but

Identifying the Impact of Varying Temperature on the Metabolic Rate of M.Musculus

1119 words - 4 pages The purpose of this experiment was to identify the impact of varying temperature on the metabolic rate of M.musculus. It can be drawn from the results of this experiment that temperature does appear to have a significant effect on metabolic rate of M. musculus. The results of this experiment are consistent with general concepts of animal physiology. These include that within the thermoneutral zone of an endotherm, metabolic rate remains constant

Similar Essays

Varying Interpretations Of Helen Essay

760 words - 4 pages Helen. However, some may question the character of this immortal beauty within the text of Homer’s epic poem. Was Helen a deceitful, scheming woman, a victim of circumstance, or was she simply at the mercy of the Gods? Who was the woman who, as Christopher Marlowe stated, was “the face that launched a thousand ships”? The motivations behind Helen’s words and actions have been analyzed throughout the years. In one example F. J. Groten, Jr

Varying Interpretations Of Heart Of Darkness And Apocalypse Now

2657 words - 11 pages Varying Interpretations of Heart of Darkness and Apocalypse Now     The true meaning of varying interpretations comes alive when one compares the two film versions of Heart of Darkness by Joseph Conrad. Heart of Darkness and Apocalypse Now have the same basic outline and underlying themes, however the plots, characters, settings, time, purposes, and points of view differ enough to create two extremely different effects and two entirely

The Life Of Helen Keller Essay

3067 words - 12 pages change dramatically. In February 1882, when Helen was nineteen months old, she fell ill. To this day the nature of her ailment remains a mystery. The doctors of the time called it "brain fever", whilst modern day doctors think it may have been scarlet fever or meningitis.Whatever the illness, Helen was, for many days, expected to die. When, eventually, the fever subsided, Helen's family rejoiced believing their daughter to be well again. However

The Murder Of Helen Jewett Essay

1413 words - 6 pages the country’s interior. The adolescents came to compete for work in the recently industrialized world. In New York the large influx of youths produced a new adolescent subculture that promoted deviant and licentious behavior throughout the city. The book “The Murder of Helen Jewett” by Patricia Cline Cohen discusses a community of business workers known as clerks. These young businessmen were one faction of the latest society and a