This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Verdict Is In Essay

2368 words - 10 pages

Since its premiere in 2000, CSI: Crime Scene Investigation has been one of television’s most popular shows (Smith). Following closely behind the program in terms of ratings were, and still are, shows like Law and Order: SVU, Bones and NCIS, which during the week of September 30, 2013 was the number 1 show in the country according to Nielsen ratings (Neilsen). Viewers are entertained by these fictional shows, absorbing information as if they portray what happens in real life. On any given day viewers can see reruns of these fictional dramas or they can watch the biographically accurate crime shows like Southern Fried Homicide or The First 48, that feature true stories, but often omit parts of the process involved in solving the case and the trial verdicts (Shelton). Forensic science ties directly into our criminal just system because it deals with the evidence and artifacts created during the commission of a crime. Forensic science and crime based shows on television today seemingly portray our criminal system, but viewers don’t seem to connect that these shows are still a works of fiction
and that sometimes their methods used to solve crimes are far from accurate (Mancini). CSI, Bones, NCIS and other crime dramas have created an explosion in people’s interest in forensic science.

While these shows are very entertaining, they paint highly unrealistic views of how a crime lab and criminal justice system works (Harriss). The methods displayed on these shows are observed by viewers as what would seemingly take place in real life, creating a problem when it comes to the courtroom. This problem is known as the CSI effect, a phenomenon where a juror’s decisions to either convict or acquit a defendant depends heavily on the presence or absence of scientific or forensic evidence. But at this point the existence of the CSI effect has not been proven, but is thought to exist based on hearsay and personal accounts of lawyers and judges (Trask). So if the CSI effect does exist, knowing these shows are fiction why are jurors expressing the desire for more forensic evidence? If the CSI Effect doesn’t exist, what is causing jurors to expect more forensic evidence during trials?

The Opening Statements
In America the accused are innocent until proven guilty. Guilt or innocence is proven by the facts laid out by the prosecution and defense lawyers in a criminal or civil trial. In order to convict an accused party, the prosecution has to prove the offenders guilt beyond a reasonable doubt; in this case a reasonable doubt is anything that makes the person deciding the defendants fate take a second guess. Someone who has been educated in forensic science by watching shows like CSI may second-guess the prosecution more often than not if there is a lack of forensic evidence. Not considering forensic evidence isn’t always necessary to convict and at times is rather difficult to uncover. In his article “CSI: Reality” forensic science expert, Dr. Max Houck, says...

Find Another Essay On the verdict is in

Romance is in the Air Essay

1946 words - 8 pages Bingley who grew up in the same circle as him. Since they had a higher position than the poorer people they become more noticeable to people, especially to women. However, with their aristocracy they become prideful, they feel they can have anything or anyone they want. For example, since Mr. Darcy is an aristocrat, and Elizabeth is in the lower class, he feels like he can have her. He thought when he proposes to her she will immediately accept

love is in the air Essay

806 words - 4 pages The poems “To My Dear and Loving Husband” written by Anne Bradstreet and “How Do I Love Thee? Let Me Count the Ways” by Elizabeth Barrett Browning are both poems about unconditional love and adoration. Even though these women had hardship and trying times in their own lives they were still able to construct these highly regarded poems of genuine love. When comparing and contrasting these two poems I find that one is written to a specific

The Truth is in the Photograph

1103 words - 5 pages life was during The Drought. Even though the photograph is black and white, it is beautifully clear for a photograph taken in the 1930's. There are not many shapes in this photograph, but the shape that stands out the most is the square window. The logs in the photograph are three-dimensional as well as the window. The photograph is very detailed and has a smooth, but sharp texture. The photograph was taken by Arthur Rothstein in 1937 and it is

The Guilt is in the Alliances

1021 words - 5 pages the development and horrific consequences of the Great War. Despite the growing imperialism and nationalism which served as major contributors to the war, it is the effect of these elements in the creation and development of alliances that proved most detrimental in the initiation of the First World War. The remarks and actions of all nations yield conclusive evidence of the presence of imperialistic and nationalistic expansion through words

The Truth is in the Feelings

1177 words - 5 pages the feelings the storyteller is trying to portray to them. But in the end, the point of a story is to invite the listener into the memory of the storyteller and enable them to feel exactly what the storyteller felt. In The Things They Carried, Tim O’Brien uses a combination of “story-truths” and “happening-truths” to invite the listener into his memories and feelings evoked by his recollections of being a solider in the Vietnam War. Throughout

In the Beginning is the Word

950 words - 4 pages The most meaningful thought for me is “In the beginning is the word.” Like we talked about during the class, the word is really powerful, even though it is just the smallest unit of sharing meaning. Strangers begin a conversation by just a word, maybe Hello. I think the most difficult part of a communication is the beginning. People fear to be the first one to speak, or they do not know how to speak. That is also why people always talk with

The Princess Is In The Dungeon

752 words - 4 pages heart. Picking up the sword and red crossed shield, forward is the only answer. Crossing the dwelling corner, grants another look upon the fair maidens, pure white, skin. Reaching off into the distance with a gallant run, the hands couldn't meet. Only the meeting of a grand, ferocious, green dragon appears. With sword in hand, and a shield that becomes the aegis against fire, the battle commences. One great breath of fire, blocked by the

The catcher in the rye is hold

1218 words - 5 pages Everyone has to make choices about what is important to them during life, and often, the time when this is hardest is the teen years. In The Catcher In The Rye , author J.D. Salinger epitomizes the growing pains of these teen years. The main character, Holden Caulfield, is a sixteen year old boy who has many ideas and values typical to teens. He also has characteristics that for teens are not necessarily normal. Salinger uses a train of thought

jealousy is the theme in the necklace

2772 words - 11 pages inflamed in him a craving to perceive the colonies split up and sovereign from the British Crown. The Age of Reason encouraged Paine to state, "Independence is my happiness, and I view things as they are, without regard to place or person; my country is the world, and my religion is to do good" (Paine). The pamphleteer Thomas Paine was an attacker of conventional religion, and this was Paine's "Antidotes to Deism". To efficiently disprove the

The Verdict on Albert Camus’s The Fall

2817 words - 11 pages The Verdict on Albert Camus’s The Fall As if to mock the crumbling principles of a fallen era, “The Just Judges” preside over a solemn dumping ground of earthly hell. This flimsy legion of justice, like the omnipresent eyes of Dr. T.J. Eckleburg in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, casts a shadow of pseudo-morality over a land spiraling towards pathos. But Albert Camus’s The Fall unfolds amidst the seedy Amsterdam underground--a

Unanimous Verdict vs. Majority Rules Verdicts

901 words - 4 pages than that used in a criminal trial. Another important difference is that the verdict does not have to be unanimous, meaning that a judge will accept a majority decision of a civil jury.Unanimity has long been considered as essential and fundamental part of jury trials. Unanimous decisions refer to the nature of the decision reached by a jury. All jury members must be in agreement as to the innocence or guilt of the accused in criminal cases or

Similar Essays

The Verdict Of Tom Robinson In Lee's To Kill A Mockingbird

2158 words - 9 pages The Verdict of Tom Robinson in Lee's To Kill A Mockingbird A closer look at the ways of the South during the time period 1925 through 1935 reveals the accurate representation of society in Harper Lee’s To Kill A Mockingbird. Many of the fictional events occurring in the novel are closely related to actual historical events that took place in the South during the time period in which the book is set. Most importantly, the trial of Tom

Leroy Reed Verdict Essay

708 words - 3 pages turning in his gun when requested by the sheriff. The last piece of convincing evidence was that Reed was not carrying the gun on him. Reed was looking to become a private investigator, which led him to purchase a gun, but when he was at the courthouse, he did not have the gun on his person. Reed was not a threat because his gun was at his house. MORE The problem with my position to acquit Leroy Reed is that I am ignoring the law because I believe

Verdict Of Life Essay

819 words - 4 pages In the novel Of Mice and Men, John Steinbeck attempts to translate ideas on ethical dilemmas and complex aspects of human nature into a story about the lives of two field hands who travel around together during the Great Depression. George and Lennie, the two laborers, are different from other men in the book. George is of average intelligence, while Lennie is mentally handicapped. Since they have known each other as long as they can remember

Slavery Is In The Past Essay

1952 words - 8 pages of the cries of pain and misery; the rocking of the floor eventually puts you to sleep. A long time has passed. Your days consist of sleeping in your own filth, eating a disgusting porridge, and rarely seeing outside your hold. But one day the hold is opened and bright light blinds you. You are lifted to your weakened legs and led outside. The land is alien to you, and white men are everywhere. You are paraded in front of a great throng of white