This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Best Immigration Policy Or The Worst?

2623 words - 10 pages

The Best Immigration Policy or the Worst
The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA) is viewed as one of the most important policy implementations in U.S. immigration history. As drafted, IRCA proposed to be a policy to control and deter all illegal immigration into the U.S., but the policy was truly directed at stopping the flow of Mexican immigrants that continues to be the largest immigration flow in the world. Daniel Tichenor writes in Dividing Lines that, “Originally designed as a restrictive enforcement measure, IRCA proved to be surprisingly expansive in both design and effect.” By identifying the unintended consequences of the law, this paper explores why the policy failed. Ultimately, this paper shows that IRCA expanded immigration by creating a greater need for it as well as by unintentionally breaking the traditional patterns of temporal and seasonal migration.
The Objectives of IRCA
The drafters of IRCA developed three objectives: to regularize the status of millions of undocumented migrants, to deter immigration through tougher enforcement, and to prevent the need for immigration. Each objective strived to ultimately solve the “immigration problem” by greatly decreasing the number of migrants coming to the U.S; however, each in fact increased immigration.
The first objective of IRCA sought to regularize the status of millions of undocumented migrants by legalizing those who entered before January 1982, as well as those that performed temporary services or labor, mainly seasonal agricultural workers. This appears contrary to IRCA’s purpose of limiting immigration into the U.S.; however, legislators saw this first objective as necessary. First, amnesty dealt with the problem of the presence of a large unaccounted-for immigrant population that largely participated in the informal economy. By giving these individuals amnesty, their numbers would no longer be considered part of the “illegal immigration problem.” Secondly, this objective encompassed part of a compromise made in order to get the votes needed to pass the law. Even opponents to illegal immigration remained cognizant of the labor power of immigrants. Politicians, especially from agricultural states, knew their constituencies consisted of agricultural employers that would be extremely upset if they suddenly lost their source of cheap labor. Politicians ensured that immigrants would continue to contribute to the labor force of the country by providing them with amnesty.
The second objective, toughening enforcement, proposed to close the doors on undocumented immigrants and reduce their accessibility to work. Section 112 detailed the fines and imprisonment that would be imposed upon anyone who transported undocumented immigrants into the U.S. Further sections detailed tougher border control and restrictions on visa applications. The expectation was that the changes would deter immigrants from attempting to cross the border by making it...

Find Another Essay On The Best Immigration Policy or the Worst?

The best and worst American Presidents

1081 words - 4 pages humiliating public abuse, caused more damage to the prestige of the presidency, or presided over a longer period of sustained prosperity", The American President, Some of the reasons why I chose Bill Clinton as the worst President are: Clinton lied under oath about his involvement with Monika Lewinsky; Bill Clinton limited the right of habeas corpus to one year which will lead to the execution of innocent men and women. Clinton

The Best and Worst of My Boss

595 words - 2 pages Everyone by nature has good and bad qualities. A Boss is no exception to this, therefore, the best boss I've ever had is also in some ways the worst.I currently work alone with my boss and the owner of Heath Sign Company in Athens, Pennsylvania making vinyl and painted signs and graphics. One thing that makes a good boss is respect. My boss has many of the same values and ambitions as myself which makes it very easy for me to respect and admire

The Best of Friends...At Their Worst

896 words - 4 pages benches. Rumors were "buzzing” about the potential candidates for the intense positions of becoming a student council officer. My best friend, Jordan, and I jumped at the chance to make a difference at our school and the lives' of people around us. Yes, we both were looking into the most prestigious position of them all. But there was a problem. I saw Jordan with one leg in her silver ford. I shouted her name across the parking lot, crammed with

the best well worst birthday suprise ever!

997 words - 4 pages “Beep Beep” went the ear piercing beep of Amanda’s alarm clock. As Amanda slowly opened her fresh morning eyes she was startled by the sight of her family all with balloons and presents. “What is all this?’’ Amanda replied excited. “Its your birthday Amanda happy 12th!”. Amanda rapidly swung out of bed threw on her birthday best faster than cheetah hunt can go around 10 times and then grabbed her birthday presents. “I wonder what it

Immigration, Policy and The State

2372 words - 9 pages with whether Canada should indeed increase the amount of immigrants that come into the country or whether it should keep the average at the level it is now or even decrease it.HistoryWhen one looks at Canada's culture and society it is clear that they have been shaped by immigration. At the beginning, Canada's immigration policy was shaped by hopes of expansion and growth. People came into rural, farming areas and built their lives out of the ground

The United States Immigration Policy

1503 words - 7 pages the United states but do not conform and change to be Americans. Instead of setting aside their old traditions todays immigrants are bringing their own cultures to America. Before 1965 the United States immigration policy was based on the quota system in which the U.S. limited the immigrants based on a quota or limit. In 1965 however, the United States congress passed a new immigration policy based on family reunification. This new policy

The Worst of Both Worlds, and the Best of Neither

2044 words - 8 pages The Worst of Both Worlds, and the Best of Neither Helga Crane's racial mixedness as a mulatto in Nella Larsen's novel Quicksand divides her socially, emotionally, and geographically, and suspends her in a perpetual "in between" status. Her uncanny role results from a combination of qualities that simultaneously identify her with, and distance her from, each side of her ancestry. Helga's identity becomes taboo because it leads her

Honesty Is The Best Policy

704 words - 3 pages Honesty Is The Best Policy The main message of his presentation was to teach the class the importance of Honesty. He pointed out that there are several different aspects of honesty. The common misconception is that honesty only involves not telling a lie. This is not the case as Brett pointed out, honesty involves telling your friends the truth even if it means hurting their feeling, having academic integrity, and acting in good faith.The first

Is honesty the best Policy?

622 words - 2 pages really no way you could cheat on those because you had to learn the information right away, and take the quiz without time to create a way to cheat.I agree with just about everything the authors had to say, they make a good argument for both cases on which to cheat or not to cheat. It seems the University's that hold a large emphasis on their honor code had a much lower percentage of students cheating than the schools who think they can't do anything

Barbie: Feminism's Best Friend or Worst Enemy

961 words - 4 pages Barbie: Feminism's Best Friend or Worst Enemy Ask any five year old American girl who Barbie is and she will most likely run into her bedroom and grab Barbie off the shelf. She will frill up her mini skirt and try to make her walk in her tiny plastic heels. Excitedly, she will hold her up for you to admire. A tiny miniature woman will stand in front of you, only about six inches tall. Her long blonde hair accents her sparkling blue

Heroes reflect the best and worst in human nature

1048 words - 5 pages Essay Question: Heroes reflect the best and worst in human nature Introduction It is accurate that heroes reflect the best choose word, thesaurus! and worst in human nature. The themes of how compassion after destruction results in love, and sacrifice to survive, portray the best and worst of human nature Repeat?. The novel Ender’s Game by Orson Scott Card, and the film Frozen directed by Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee, both explore these themes

Similar Essays

Andrew Jackson: The Best Or The Worst

958 words - 4 pages On December 23, 1814, Andrew Jackson rode his way into history. His victory over the British on that day made him into a national hero. Jackson used this popularity to ensure his victory over John Quincy Adams in the election of 1828. But who was the real "Old Hickory?" Was Andrew Jackson the courageous, honor bound "man of the people", or, as his opponents liked to think, was he a hot tempered, poorly educated farm boy? This essay will present

The Worst Best Job Essay

1868 words - 7 pages . Like I said trimming is the best worst job, because it can be really hard, really boring, and really hot; however, we always have a good time. Trimming has been hard and sometimes a real pain, but I would not trade my years of trimming or any thing. I learn how to keep at something even if it is hard, and how to deal with bosses, and how to deal with difficult people. These are skills that I will have for years to come.

The Best And Worst Of Times

1048 words - 4 pages “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times...” and so they were in the small town of Maycomb, Alabama (Dickens 1). In Harper Lee’s classic novel To Kill a Mockingbird, set in the small town of Maycomb, it was indeed the best and worst of times for the character Scout as she recounted the tales of school years and summers that affected her as she grew up through the course of the novel. Just as any child growing up, the adults that

The Best And Worst Of Television

757 words - 3 pages Television? Is there a best or worst of television? Actually, there's both. Television has its ups and downs, or its bests and worsts. The best being sitcoms, or situation comedies, shows like, "Friends" and "The Fresh Prince Of Bel Air," and the worst being talk shows, such as "The Jerry Springer Show." These sitcoms depict everyday life. They produce family values and warm the hearts of the viewers. It also provides laughs and situations