This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Virtues Of The Vices Of Virtue Ethics By Robert Louden

2086 words - 8 pages

In this essay I will consider the objections to Virtue Ethics (VE) raised by Robert Louden in his article entitled On Some Vices of Virtue Ethics which was published in 1984. It is important to note at the outset of this essay that it was not until 1991 that the v-rules came up in literature. So Louden is assuming throughout his article that the only action guidance that VE can give is “Do what the virtuous agent would do in the circumstances.” I will be addressing Louden’s objections with the benefit of knowing about the v-rules. First of all, let us discuss what VE is. VE is a normative ethical theory that emphasises the virtues or moral character, thus it focuses on the moral agent. It differs from Deontology which emphasises duties or rules, and Utilitarianism which emphasises the consequences of our actions.

Louden opens up his article with this statement “It is common knowledge by now that recent philosophical and theological writings about ethics reveals a marked revival of interest in the virtues. But what exactly are the distinctive features of a so-called virtue ethics? Does it have a specific contribution to make to our understanding of moral experience? Is there a price to be paid for its different perspective, and if so, is the price worth paying?” This opening statement gives us a taste of his thoughts about VE already. Louden goes to raise his objections. I will consider the objections he raises under the headings in his article, those being ‘Agents vs Acts’ , ‘Who is Virtuous’ , ‘Style over Substance’ , and ‘Utopianism’ .

Agents vs Acts
Louden opens this section with this statement: “… it is commonplace that virtue theorists focus on good and bad agents rather than on right and wrong acts.” This is a good thing is it not? Many people can do good things, but that does not make them a virtuous or good person does it? A classic example is a shop keeper, the shop keeper does not short change people on principle (this is a good act), and the reason being he does not want to lose customers he wants to keep them. Surely a proper motivation would be that it would be dishonest to short change someone. The point is that in determining what is moral; one must examine ones character to find out. Deontology tells that the morally correct thing to do is to apply moral rules for guidance, this is all well and good, but it fails to tell us whether the person is a good one or not. Is the deontologist motivated by his will to follow certain rules or is he motivated to do the right thing by his heart? Utilitarianism tells us that what is moral is the action which brings about the greatest good for the greatest number. Again what I said in regard to Deontology applies here. It fails to tell us what persons we ought to be. In 1984 the only action guidance was “Do what the virtuous agent would do in the circumstances.” While this might be hard to understand, we have since then come up with a number of v-rules to assist us in determining what a...

Find Another Essay On The Virtues of the Vices of Virtue Ethics by Robert Louden

The Virtue of Generosity by Aristotle

1408 words - 6 pages In Nicomachean Ethics, generosity is the third virtue Aristotle examines. He directly addresses the idea of generosity to be the mean of wealth, meaning anything whose worth is measured by money. As presented by Aristotle, generosity is the intermediate of wastefulness and ungenerosity, wastefulness being the excess and ungenerosity being the deficiency. This virtue however, does not come naturally; generosity can arise through habit and takes

Virtue of Aristotelian Ethics Essay

3683 words - 15 pages relatively simple. It does not require the sort of nuanced conceptions of virtues that virtue ethics demands. This is generally seen as an asset, Kantian ethics can be applied equally well by anyone who has an adequate understanding of that system. But while the categorical imperative can be applied in any ethical consideration, merely following an algorithmic procedure does not increase our knowledge of why certain behaviours are more desirable

Aristotle - The Nature of Virtue NOTES - Ethics - Assignment

1163 words - 5 pages , and we say happiness is these activities, or the best one. How is Happiness Achieved? · Is happiness acquired by learning, or habituation, or by some other form of cultivation? Or is it a result of some divine fate? · Even if it is not sent by the gods, but instead results from virtue and some sort of learning, happiness appears to be one of the most divine things. If happiness comes this way, it will be widely shared; for anyone who is not

The Virtue of Discrimination

1119 words - 4 pages are still distinctions to be made (86). Robert Keith Miller presents a convincing argument for the necessity of discrimination by using a comparison and contrast argument to appeal to the readers emotions in his article “Discrimination Is a Virtue”. Robert Keith Miller was a writer for Newsweek in 1980. As a writer for a nationally renowned magazine, he can be trusted as a professional journalist. Miller writes his article

Ethics - Virtue of Patience

1366 words - 5 pages , successful person. The present day provides impediments which I believe I can overcome by way of morality and virtue. I have chosen to work on more patience in my life. According to Aristotle, for every virtue there are two vices. One is in excess and the other being deficit. Patience is a deficiency in my life. In having barely any patience, I am often stressed out and make more of simple situations. Aristotle would call this vice

The Virtue of Bravery

1219 words - 5 pages The Virtue of Bravery In this essay I will be describing the virtue of bravery. I will first define what Aristotle thinks virtue is, explain the virtue of bravery, and then finally reflect this virtue on my personal experience in the Shaw neighborhood. Aristotle breaks down virtue into four aspects which are: a state that decides in mean, consisting in a mean, the mean relative to us, which is defined by reference to reason(1107a

The Virtue Of Silence

989 words - 4 pages THE VIRTUE OF SILENCE      Of all the virtues that most men and women disregard, it is silence. People go about in their everyday lives not even noticing the beauty of one's "inner silence." Try an experiment: Close your eyes. Tune out the sounds from everything that's surrounding you, and focus on what is going on inside you. Take a deep breath and just listen. How many inner voices did you hear? Most people

Demonstrating the Virtues of the Just Life

833 words - 3 pages Demonstrating the Virtues of the Just Life The character of Socrates in Plato’s Republic is a curious one. Socrates is rarely satisfied with widely or casually accepted statements, and is fearless in taking on enormous topics for debate. One such topic that Socrates tackles early and often in the Republic is that of justice and the just life. It takes little time for Socrates to begin an attempt at demonstrating to two of his

The Vices of Human Nature in Homer's The Odyssey

579 words - 2 pages The sum of all human traits is defined as human nature, meaning the excuse for our vices, and the flaws of mortal life. In Homer's The Odyssey, the main character Odysseus demonstrates these flaws throughout his journey, constantly struggling through the eternal fight for realization of life and death, and is weighed down by the never ending power struggle of nature versus mankind. In The final chapters of Odysseus's quest, the reader

The essay is about all of the rioters vices in the rioters tale of the cantanbury tales by chaucer

637 words - 3 pages expect your face? Why live so long? Isn't it time to die"(Chaucer 75). The attitudes of the rioters are horrible they tell an old man to die just for a greeting. The old man is astonished and answers back "Do more harm to an old man than you, being now young, would have another do when you are old'- if you should live till then"(75). One of the rioters is so fed up by what the old man says that he accuses him of being a killer of young men. He

The Evil Virtues of Greed and Corruption

928 words - 4 pages In the novel, Animal Farm by George Orwell, tactics such as,“ the ends justify the means” play a vital role in developing the storyline. Animal Farm is set during the Russian Revolution and Orwell uses animals, such as pigs and horses, to portray Joseph Stalin and his loyal, yet blindsided followers. Napoleon, a pig who takes the position of Stalin in the novel, leads the other animals in a battle against the humans to free themselves from

Similar Essays

The Ideas Of Virtue Ethics Essay

1631 words - 7 pages this radical departure from virtue or classical ethics is unnecessary. He says that philosophers go along with MET because of scholarly convention. The modern theorist would say that METs are needed since nature dictates ethics and the time we live in is problem-plagued, quite possibly from problems created by technology and social change, we need new ways of solving problems. Pincoffs claims this argument fails for two reasons; one, many classical

Explain The Theory Of Virtue Ethics

1022 words - 4 pages being based on arguably incoherent ideas about the after-life. It is a system, which can be easily applied and understood by all. It fits into a variety of philosophies, and religions, which both do and don't include God. However, there are a few problems with Virtue Ethics. Ones of these which has been pointed out by MacIntyre is that although a virtue is the 'golden mean' between two vices it cannot be applied to all virtues. Virtues such as

Vices And Virtues: Ethical Dilemmas Of A Fading Man

2387 words - 10 pages Tyler Rutland Dr. Belzer History 2000 April 10, 2014 Vices & Virtues: Ethical Dilemmas of a Fading Man When Sidney Stewart was freed in Manchuria in 1945 after 3 years of imprisonment by the Japanese, the 6’3 American weighed 65 pounds (Goldstein). Stewart was an Army private stationed in Manila in 1942 when they were overpowered by the Japanese. The 21 year-old wasn’t the killing type of soldier. Of course he killed when required, but he

The Virtues Of The Populace Essay

1208 words - 5 pages and constancy and moderation of every word and action” (39). Cicero offers no specific caveat for the virtue because it is superficial by nature and false seemliness results from the successful simulation of the other virtues. Therein lies the danger of the public gentleman, and in that regard, wisdom among the populace ensures justice within the political administration. On Duties serves as Cicero’s advice to his son, Marcus, so that he may