The Voucher Program Makes All Schools Public

1787 words - 7 pages

A good education is extremely important. However, it seems that schools are more overwhelmed with passing a test then truly educating the students. Everyday people are debating which school is better public, private or charter schools, in the book, Taking Sides by James W. Noll. Fredrick M. Hess seems to be arguing mostly that what makes public education public is that it produces productive citizens in “Should ‘Public Schooling’ Be Redefined”. Linda Nathan et al, seems to disagree with everything Hess is saying. She thinks Hess is confused on what public schools are and how they affect students and the community in “Should ‘Public Schooling’ Be Redefined”. Hess seems to think that “public schooling” is away for educators to pass on their own beliefs. While Nathan believes that the public schools make sure that, the poor students and the minority students get an education. All schools whether they be public or private are obligated to have the same goal in mind, which is giving the students a good education. Public schools get their funding from tax dollars and are open to everyone regardless of the family’s income, social standings or a student’s academic ability or inability. Public schools do not discriminate on who can attend. In addition, they have state guidelines that set out standards and assessments. These standards and assessments are to make sure that the schools are educating the students. However, with the new voucher program every school that accepts students using them would then be a public school. Therefore, when a school admits every student that came its direction it would in fact be a public school. With the voucher program, the private school who accepts the students would need to be accredited causing them to lose the private school title. In that case, if a private school takes every student that came its way then it too would be a public school. With the new voucher program, this would do away with public and private schools.
With the new voucher program, funding for schools will change, as will the unity of a community. According to Nathan “In the past students who have attend public school did not pay for their education” (170). In some cases there are free lunch programs and free book rentals for low-income families. Some of these funds come from fundraisers at the schools, though the majority of the funding comes from taxpayers and the federal government. According to Nathan, some schools have received “increased funding from both state and federal sources” (170), these funds pay for the transportation of students to school. In addition, some of these funds go toward the free or reduced lunches and free or reduced book rental fee for students of a poverty-stricken family. Taxes are not the only form of funding; some of the money comes from different fund-raisers. Clay E. Baulch points out how it does not matter if they come from a poor family or a rich family in “The Pragmatic Path and the Influence of...

Find Another Essay On The Voucher Program Makes All Schools Public

Public Schools Are the Problem, Private Schools are the Solution

1060 words - 4 pages Now more than ever parents in the United States have become very disgruntled with their children’s education. The main reason behind this massive dissatisfaction is that public schools are not living up to parent’s expectations. The standards which the public schools that today’s parents, and their parents, attended are quiet different from the ones their children are now attending. It is widely felt that public schools are not performing

America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not the Solution

1955 words - 8 pages -bureaucratic charter schools would teach students better than traditional public schools because charter schools wouldn’t be subject to the same mandates that the state had heaped upon public schools. Furthermore, traditional schools would be forced to compete with charter schools as they lured thousands of students and millions of dollars away from traditional public schools. Competition from charter schools would then lead to all-around better

The Cost of Funding American Public Schools

1557 words - 6 pages children enrolling in schools due to lack of employment opportunities, there has been great demand in education reform with regards to laws and funding (Grubb). In 1958, education reform was propelled forward by one of the biggest contributors for America’s public education system stemming from the National Defense Education Act (NDEA). On September 2, 1958, the act was signed, initiating a program that poured billions of dollars into the U.S

The Removal of Prayer from Public Schools

4929 words - 20 pages James Bible without commentary or interpretation.”2 This did not please the some 200,000 Roman Catholics within the city who had serious objections to Protestant “non-sectarianism”2. In 1842, New York City attempted to decentralize the issue by mandating that “no sectarian religious instruction was to be offered. All public schools would now educate students in the three R’s and leave religion to the churches.”2 This action

The Practice of Religion in Public Schools

784 words - 3 pages The Practice of Religion in Public Schools The “establishment” or “religion” clause of the First Amendment of the Constitution reads: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof” (Education Week, 2003, para. 2). It is from this clause that the idea of separation of church and state comes. It is also the basis for much of the debate regarding the practice of

Public Schools - Sex Education in the Classroom

1855 words - 7 pages into the schools. We as a society can no longer ignore the need for both education and prevention measures to be readily available to all teenagers, no matter what our personal views about the subject may be.   Although we have most of the knowledge and resources needed to solve the problem of teenage pregnancy, we have failed to do so. Despite the growing public concern and the plethora of reports with endless statistics, there has been

The Constitutionality of Prayer in Public Schools

751 words - 3 pages Many people agree against prayer in public schools, while others think that people should be able to express their religion in their own ways. In public schools, they are not allowed to hold prayers at all during the school day due to the mixed religion students that are attending the school. Over the past few years, this has become an extremely controversial issue in our nation. Many people find it proper to pray in school but many people also

Creation vs. Evolution in the Public Schools

1573 words - 6 pages inability to prove either concept, most public school systems promote evolution as a scientific fact. Many students who lack firm beliefs about the origin of life believe what they are taught without giving any personal thought to the matter. Instead of robotically absorbing biased information, schools should present information about evolution and creation to students and promote a ‘self-deciding’ approach to learning rather than forcing

Blood Makes All the Bad things go away

1690 words - 7 pages "Enraged, sad, lonely, stupid, worthless, irrational, crazy. I can't stand what I think because I sound like such a whiner, so self-involved. During I feel very focused and full of anticipation. I purposely hold my breath as I cut and let it out when I'm through, so I breathe out as the blood runs out. I feel so calm. All the noise and stupidity in my head is gone, I feel like I'm floating... I feel stupid because I feel like I don't have a

The Changing Face of Public Housing. HUD's HOPE VI Program.

5721 words - 23 pages America.Land ValuesThe problems with public housing go far beyond the physical dilapidation of many housing projects. First, public housing has come to be dominated by, as well as to encourage the formation of low-income single-parent households, with all the social problems 'that such families bring. At the same time, because the land on which public housing stands is designated for a single, unchanging purpose, it creates what could be called a

Recruiting and Hiring Excellent People         The Certified Public Managers Program

1474 words - 6 pages Recruiting and Hiring Excellent People The Certified Public Managers Program was an excellent learning opportunity. As a new Public Manager within Maricopa County Department of Transportation, the program confirmed some business theories that I believe in and attempt to model. Every class brought incredible insight into managing people in a public organization. My daily logs seem to reflect the importance of my work group in giving me feedback

Similar Essays

The Special Education Program In The Public Schools

1949 words - 8 pages Abstract This paper provides information of the Special Education Program in the Public Schools. It analyzes the life of a child with disability and their educators. It also analyzes the advantages and disadvantages of the Special Education Program. Individuals who are not aware of the special education, or have a child in special education, will find this paper quite informative. It allows individuals to determine who are

The Cleveland School Voucher Program Case

1511 words - 7 pages private schools), gain political/constituent climate (community support), and overcome information asymmetries (marketing of voucher program), all mentioned in by Salamon as management challenges that typically accompany voucher system operations. This case paper will first provide a synopsis of the pilot school voucher program implemented in Cleveland. It will then explore the three challenges that arose in the case. Lastly, the paper will

The Internet In Public Schools Essay

697 words - 3 pages Internet is a good example of this, and we should all take a much closer look before we decide whether the Internet has a purpose and a place in the public schools of tomorrow. Education is merely preparing students for the future. But what is the future? No one can say with certainty. But by taking a quick look around us, we can guess that the Internet will play a prominent role in our future. If we look at the stock market, for example, we can

Creationism In The Public Schools Essay

989 words - 4 pages Should Creationism Be Taught In Public Schools? Most people agree that one of the main purposes of education is to teach HOW to think, not WHAT to think. Why is it then, that children today are not given the chance to decide for themselves what they believe is the origin of the earth and all its organisms? Evolution is taught as a scientific fact in public schools today, something not to be questioned. A student at Bronx High School of Science