The War Of Freedom Of Expression

1935 words - 8 pages

'Taking on anti-Semites and Holocaust deniers in the sanctified courtroom environment is like responding to someone who calls your mother a prostitute. The right to freedom of expression can be described as a war. It is a war that has lasted for centuries and may last for centuries more. It is a war between freedom of expression and social intolerance. In this war there are many battles. The battle on which this brief essay centers itself is the battle between freedom of speech and laws limiting that freedom; more specifically the ability to spread hate propaganda and the 'hate laws'. Included in the essay is a brief outline of one skirmish that has taken place (Keegstra ). Those who fight on the side supporting freedom of speech do so for several reasons. Braun declares that it is a basic democratic right to voice your own opinion . Douglas Christie has gained notoriety for his vigorous representation of high-profile, controversial clients, charged under the hate laws. He advocates freedom of speech for two main reasons: a) he finds it abhorrent that the state can legislate thoughts and words, and b) he often agrees with the views held by his clients. Others such as Noam Chomsky, a brilliant intellectual, argue not for the views expressed, but the ability to express them. Lining up on the other side of the battle you have: Derek Raymaker, David Kilgour, Victor Ramraj, and Bruce Elman. They argue that there is definitely a moral place for laws regarding hate speech, whether they are criminal or not. There was recently a new development in the Canadian war for freedom of expression. Introduced in April 1982 was a new and important strategic battleground.With the Charter of Rights and Freedoms the war could be won or lost by either side. It was not long before the Charter saw battle.In 1984, Jim Keegstra was charged with violating section 281 of the Criminal Code of Canada (now covered under section 318-320). Keegstra was a respected school teacher and mayor of the small town of Eckville, Alberta. This was no borderline fanatic; this was an elected official charged with promoting hate. However by the time Keegstra's trial rolled around he was no longer the mayor Eckville and his teaching license, revoked. The problem was, the very nature of s. 281 lent itself to legal debate under section 2 of the relatively new Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The defense counsel Doug Christie lost no time in challenging the legislation's constitutionality. In response, Crown prosecutor, Bruce Fraser, stated that Keegstra was being charged with promoting hatred; not expressing it. The Crown also stated that freedom of speech is not an absolute right . On November 5, 1984, Mr. Justice Quigley of the Alberta Queen's Bench wrote an eighty page decision upholding the constitutionality of section 281. In his decision he stated 'It is my opinion that s. 281.2(2) cannot be rationally considered to be an infringement which limits 'freedom of expression' but on the contrary...

Find Another Essay On The War of Freedom of Expression

Freedom of Expression on the Internet

3977 words - 16 pages agree with Ernest Boyer who said “A college…is an open community, a place where freedom of expression is uncompromisingly protected…”.[xi] 2.Other Schools The National University of Singapore uses different servers for staff and students, where the student server has a more limited access to the Internet.[xxx] The University of Michigan provides for no filters on Internet access and has extensive university policies regarding proper use

Freedom of Speech and Expression

1257 words - 6 pages foundations of democracy, but at the same time, freedom does not imply anarchy, and the right to exercise free expression does not include the right to do unjustified harm to others. Freedom of expression is also known as an American form of human rights that is intertwined directly to the Bill of Rights of the United States Constitution as well. This freedom was granted as the first written constitution of the democratic government for the United

Uniforms and Freedom of Expression

1256 words - 5 pages Does wearing a school uniform really make a difference in the learningprocess? Ever wonder what is the purpose of wearing a school uniform in thefirst place? If all of the students are dressed alike, it seems like it would bepretty tough to express your freedom of expression through attire. Manystudents, parents, and administrators have different opinions on the strictenforcement of a wearing school uniform. Some religious students might notbe

The Right to Freedom of Expression: R. v. Keegstra

3315 words - 13 pages Introduction Entrenched within the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms lies the fundamental rights that Canadian citizens share. The primary freedoms recognized within Section 2 of the Charter, such as the freedom of speech and expression, are necessary for a free and democratic society. Yet, a crucial conflict of rights exists within the system when the freedom of expression is used to perpetuate willful hatred against a certain

Freedom of Speech and Expression and Responsibility

1668 words - 7 pages caught up in the fears of the times that he was willing to use the power of his money to protect the world against a film. When people are caught up in the movements of their time, all people must be extra zealous to guard and encourage freedom of expression. Otherwise, a mob mentality reigns, and people rush to do things that are not thought out and often regretted later.   The founders of our country knew from experience how important free

Should Artists have Total Freedom of Expression?

924 words - 4 pages Should Artists have Total Freedom of Expression? Laws about obscenity, libel, slander and official secrets restrict freedom of expression, yet society’s understanding of what is offensive often needs to be clarified by the courts. Personal freedom requires the exercise of judgement even if law limits it. Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights states, “Everyone has the right to freedom of expression. This right shall

Freedom of Expression and Racist Hate Speech

697 words - 3 pages In this paper I lay out the main argument that Caroline West makes in her article “Words that Silence? Freedom of Expression and Racist Hate Speech.” West considers the minimal conditions necessary for speech to be considered free. West also considers how racist hate speech, if operating in particular ways, might undermine free speech. Her focus is on whether the moral and political benefits of racist hate speech speech outweigh the costs

Freedom of Expression and Rap Music

1153 words - 5 pages track of our lives. The number one killer in creative speech is censorship. Censorship in music is a topic that has brought about much controversy in the past two decades. "Preventing or punishing speech?is a clear violation of the First Amendment." (Censorship. Opposing Viewpoints by, Greehaven Press page ). Congress shall make no law? abridging the freedom of speech or of the press". Swearing in music has become a more common thing to hear

Argumentation of the case involving Tinker and the Des Moines School District over freedom of expression

1274 words - 5 pages Tinker vs. Des MoinesDuring the 15-year period that encompassed the Vietnam War, protests were at an all time high. Demonstrators marched outside public offices, government buildings and any other place they felt their voices would be heard. Often, the demonstrators were arrested and fined for violating the law. But on some occasions, the law was on the side of the protester.This is true for several cases throughout history. One of the cases

Freedom of Religious Expression of Contemporary Korean Women

1627 words - 7 pages Mandate of Heaven awarded to the current ruler (1-167). The Mudang were viewed as “Women’s possession cults there were thinly disquised protest movements directed against the dominant sex” (2-26). This negative reputation coupled with the fact that women were stripped of rites of inheritance resulting in the loss of their religious rites and social standing during this period of time lead to the oppression of women and severe lack of freedom of

Freedom Of Expression And Action In Libya After The Libyan Uprising

2049 words - 8 pages Libyan society should protect individual rights to free expression and action, especially given its current political situation. To do this, a brief discussion about Libyan uprising put forth by Thomas Hobbes and Polybius and the concept of freedom of expression and action from the perspectives of Aristotle and Cicero will be discussed. Even before, there have been a prolonged opposition to Gaddafi in the city of Benghazi. And this later

Similar Essays

Mill's Freedom Of Expression Essay

1305 words - 6 pages pleasure such as drinking and gambling, which will bring lower utility. He is concern on individual freedom of expression, thinking that such libertarian ideal in a person that had brought to the Enlightenment of Europe is disappearing within society in the 19th century England and the Western world. This paper will convey Mill’s arguments for freedom of expression and its acceptance. Freedom of expression according to Mill is the essence of

Freedom Of Expression Essay

2612 words - 10 pages Freedom of ExpressionNo other democratic society in the world permits personal freedoms to the degree of the United States of America. Within the last sixty years, American courts, especially the Supreme Court, have developed a set of legal doctrines that thoroughly protect all forms of the freedom of expression. When it comes to evaluating the degree to which we take advantage of the opportunity to express our opinions, some members of society

Freedom Of Expression Essay

691 words - 3 pages Freedom of Expression Freedom of expression, and open access to media, are as fundamental to the survival of Progress as the sun and rain are to the survival of planet Earth. Yet censorship remains a traditional response of any group that finds itself offended at another's message or creative indulgence. The argument that because they serve the "public interest," media should willingly accept a moral arbiter to decide what will and what

The Limits Of Freedom Of Expression

3227 words - 13 pages Introduction The aim of this essay is to critically examine the limits of freedom of expression. The limits or constraints of free expression, in most cases, refer to the abuse of free speech, which may cause harm or offence. The essay focuses on defining what types of expression, or more specifically, speech is regarded as the limits of freedom of expression. The essay is divided into two major parts, the evaluative and the extensive part. The