The Ways In Which Culture And Identity Are Presented In Search For My Tongue And Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan

2138 words - 9 pages

The Ways in Which Culture and Identity are Presented in Search for My Tongue and Presents From my Aunts in Pakistan

In this essay I aim to discuss the ways in which culture and identity
are presented in 'search for my tongue' and 'presents from my aunts in

The first poem, 'search for my tongue' is written by a woman called
Sujata Bhatt who was born in nineteen fifty six, in Ahmedabad, India.
She emigrated to the United States of America in nineteen sixty eight.
She is a very successful poet and translator of Gujarati and English
and if that was not enough she is now living in Germany.

Search for my tongue is a very unique poem as it suddenly changes from
English to Gujarati half way through. The poem is about language and
the effect of language when living in a different place with people
speaking different languages. The word 'tongue' means two things. The
first is the language one speaks and the other is the more obvious
tongue in your mouth. Although this poem may have autobiographical
content, its concerns have a much wider relevance.

The first paragraph of 'Search for my Tongue' is written in the second
person, which suggests a level of detachment.

"You ask me what I mean by saying I have lost my tongue"

is the first sentence of 'Search For My Tongue'. It is written as a
reply to a question and the word tongue is used as a conventional
metaphor for language. Next she says

"I ask you, what would you do if you had two tongues in your mouth"

the word 'tongues' re-awakens the metaphor by making us aware of its
physical sense. Sujata Bhatt then repeats the words 'tongue' and
'could' several times in the next section, this shows uncertainty.
Among this she includes some ideas of the tongue turning more organic,
with the idea,

"your mother tongue would rot, rot and die in your mouth".

The poem now changes into the first person. It changes from you to I,
and the verbs move into the present tense, which makes the poem more
personal and immediate,

"I thought I spit it out but overnight while I dream,"

she is comparing the tongue to a living thing, ironically it dies at
this point, but comes alive later in the poem.

This is where the poem becomes very unique, as it changes from the
English language to Gujarati. This shows that the dream is unexpected
and uncontrollable. It also gives us, the reader, a chance to see what
she really means as it alienates us from this foreign text, and we are
put in her shoes. We find that the Gujarati text is actually the
translation of the English text below it.

Once the poem changes back to English the poet uses more positive
statements using present tense verbs and the repeated use of the word

"It grows back, a stump of a shoot"

This first line after the translation to Gujarati shows us that...

Find Another Essay On The Ways in Which Culture and Identity are Presented in Search for My Tongue and Presents From my Aunts in Pakistan

Comparing the Ways in Which Billy Casper and Jane Eyre are Presented as Outsiders

2719 words - 11 pages ." When comparing the ways in which Billy Casper and Jane Eyre are presented as outsiders, parallels can be found between the situations both authors use to present them. However, the writing formats and techniques contrast, obtaining different reactions from the reader. The directions the stories end in, too, take different routes. Hines leaves the reader feeling very sorry for Billy. Kes, Billy's only companion is brutally

An Exploration Of The Ways In Which Shakespeare Presents The Developing Relationship Between Beatrice And Benedick.

2234 words - 9 pages they can argue about due to their opposing opinions. In the very first scene Leonato, who is Beatrice's uncle (and also the Governor of Messina), tells a messenger that 'there is a kind of merry war betwixt Signor Benedick and her...a skirmish of wit between them'.Beatrice is known for her sharp wit, and when she reluctantly greets Benedick as he returns from battle, she declares that she "had rather hear my dog bark at a crow than a man swear he

Compare and Contrast the ways in which Priestley presents the attitudes of Birling and the Inspector throughout the play,

1924 words - 8 pages in the pockets of a mere 5% of the population. The rights of workers such as Eva Smith were not taken seriously at all they were looked upon by the factory owners e.g.Birling as humans which were to be used and abused for the employers benefit. The workers feelings were rarely taken into consideration. Employers like Birling only worried about maximising profit this is confirmed when Birling says that his hopes for the future are to" lower costs

Comparing the Ways in Which Priestley Presents the Attitudes of Birling and the Inspector Throughout An Inspector Calls

2265 words - 9 pages Comparing the Ways in Which Priestley Presents the Attitudes of Birling and the Inspector Throughout An Inspector Calls The play An Inspector Calls is set in 1912,"Edwardian England" but written and first performed in 1945. This is very significant because between these two dates humanity witnessed or encountered many times of great suffering such as World War 1, World War 2 and the sinking of the unsinkable Titanic, which

Beginning with line 115, examine the ways in which Chaucer presents Alison in the Miller's Tale.

781 words - 3 pages Nikul Patel 17/11/03Beginning with line 115, examine the ways in which Chaucer presents Alison in the Miller's TaleAlison is representative of many things in the miller's tale, for example she is a catalyst for much of the events in the book, and she is also there for purposes of ornamentation. The first and major appearance of Alison is in line 115 to line 162. This is Alison's description, Chaucer is writing the miller's tale as a parody of

Discuss ways in which Dickinson presents nature in “A Bird came down the Walk”.

730 words - 3 pages Discuss ways in which Dickinson presents nature in "A Bird came down the Walk".It is never made clear whether Dickinson's love for nature stems from her scientific education or from her love of God. Some believe that Dickinson felt closest to God when surrounded by his creations in the natural world, or at least preferred it to the oppressive "heft" of the church's "Cathedral tunes" in another of her poems ["A certain slant of light"].Dickinson

Examine the different ways in which Shakespeare presents issues connected with the marriage and male relationships in the play "The Taming of the Shrew".

1169 words - 5 pages that's why Baptista Minola (father of Kate and Bianca) was encouraging Kate to get married. The consequences were something the father didn't want to happen to Kate. If Kate had not of got married to Petruchio, Kate would of gone to a Nunnery or she would of become a "Spinster". To examine the different ways in which Shakespeare presents issues I will explore 3 scenes from The Taming of the Shrew and relate the male and female relationships in

Examine the ways in which Shakespeare presents issues connected with marriage and male/female relationships in the play The Taming of the Shrew.

848 words - 3 pages as encouragement for Katherine to finally comply with Petruchio's demands: he has tamed her. This shows the audience a socially acceptable Elizabethan marriage in which the female has little say in what happens, she must comply however unrealistic the demands may be. These attitudes extend beyond marriage and demonstrate the social roles of men and women in the late 16th century.As a romantic comedy "The Taming of the Shrew" focuses largely on romantic relationships as they ascend towards marriage, and in doing so, provides an insight into the opinions and attitudes towards males, females and marriage in the Elizabethan era.

Explore the ways in which Williams presents dramatically the relationships between men and women in 'A Street Car Named Desire' as a whole.

908 words - 4 pages in the end the only way they, or at least he, can resolve the feelings is through a sexual and animalistic manner. Williams presents this scene as if Stanley had been overcome with anger, Williams needed Stanley to resolve this relationship in the only manner he could. Williams could not in fact show the rape scene, or even heavily allude to it because of the Hayes code, which leaves a lot to the imagination. It is my belief that in some way

Ways in which Lifelong Learning can Contribute towards the New Global Culture and New Knowledge Society

1421 words - 6 pages Introduction: In this essay, ways in which lifelong learning can contribute towards the new global culture and new knowledge society, facts about lifelong learning and how the educator deals with the learners will be discussed. What is learning? Learning is defined as obtaining a new ability or knowledge. For example: leaning to ride a bike, learning to walk, learning a new language, and so on. What is lifelong learning? According to the

An exploration of the ways in which pride is presented in William Shakespeare's "Much Ado About Nothing"

2090 words - 8 pages "Much Ado About Nothing" is a highly successful play, and one of the reasons for this is because of the way in which the themes are explored and presented by Shakespeare. As well as its light-hearted elements, such as the comical exchanges in the "merry war" between two central characters Beatrice and Benedick, and the highly varied exploration of the values, tests and rewards of love, there are also the more contemplative areas, such as the

Similar Essays

A Comparison Of Two Poems Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan By Moniza Alvi And Search For My Tongue By Sujata Bhatt

1107 words - 4 pages and society. In 'Presents from my Aunts in Pakistan', the poet takes to the English culture almost instantaneously (e.g. fashion) even though she is subconsciously aware that she is Pakistani. In 'Search for my Tongue', the poet almost forgets her foundations and adjusts well. But, she finds her vernacular tongue towards the end of the poem which makes her feel guilty and angry at the same time for forgetting it

Moniza Alvi's Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan

976 words - 4 pages Moniza Alvi's Presents from my Aunts in Pakistan Moniza Alvi was born in Lahore, in Pakistan, the daughter of a Pakistani father and an English mother. She moved to Hatfield in England when she was a few months old. She didn't revisit Pakistan until after the publication of her first book of poems, The Country over my Shoulder, from which this poem comes. The poet says: 'Presents from My Aunts... was one of the first poems I wrote

Analysis Of The Poem Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan By Moniza Alvi

733 words - 3 pages “Presents from my aunts in Pakistan” is a poem written by Moniza Alvi. The poem talks about the melee of living in two different cultures. Throughout the poem the writer depicts her puzzlement and frustration of being torn between two cultures. Moniza Alvi explains her awareness of all the challenges that she will undergo for being multicultural. After receiving presents from her aunts, Alvi realizes that she didn’t know much about her other

Comparison Between Half Caste By John Agard And Presents From My Aunts In Pakistan By Moniza Alvi

1079 words - 4 pages the moral of the two poems.The author of Half-Caste, John Agard moved to England in 1977 this was at early adulthood. His parents were mixed of race, his father black and mother from Portugal but was born in Guyana.The author of Presents Form My Aunts In Pakistan, Moniza Alvi moved to England at a very young age, the same as John Agard both her parents are mixed of race, her father is from Pakistan and her mother is English. We can tell that the