This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Wealth Of Nations Essay

993 words - 4 pages

The Wealth of Nations

Adam Smith’s famous attempt to explain the nature and causes of the wealth of nations rests on several crucial assumptions about human nature which in turn rely on false universalism and questionable dichotomies.

To begin with, Smith makes roughly three claims about human nature. Primarily, Smith assumes that self-interest is inherent in all human beings. As opposed to animals which rely on benevolence, in opposition to natural pity (Rousseau p. 53), the human “will be more likely to prevail if he can interest [others’] self-love in his favour, and show them that it is for their own advantage to do for him what he requires of them” (Smith, p. 18). Smith later relies on this “self-love” to ground his arguments on the steady base of human nature. More subtly, the “faculties of reason and speech” play a crucial role in Smith’s treatment of human behavior. Although he never openly lists these “faculties” as essential to human nature, his argument relies on this assumption. The step from having some goods and needing others to trading with those who have the needed goods and want the overabundant ones cannot be warranted without a presumption of a rational actor. Similarly, every development towards improved efficiency, if these are anything more guided than random evolutionary steps, require such an actor to instigate it. In the case of the arrowmaker, Smith must assume some force driving the arrow maker to save time and maximize profits. Of course, the concepts of barter, trade, and the rest require speech, or some kind of communication. Finally, Smith instills “a certain propensity in human nature; the propensity to truck, barter, and exchange one thing for another.” (Smith p. 17). This, he suggests, may simply be an extension of reason (Smith p. 17). It is this final, and most specific, propensity of human nature that ensures a vague sense of self interest, coupled with reason and speech, produce a very particular kind of economic system, which he describes in the rest of the book. The three assumptions for the subject as self interested, rational and communicative, and inclined to truck and barter lay the foundations for Smith’s exposition on capitalism.

However, the very formula of suggesting a model of human nature, with as few elements as possible, and from that deriving a full account of the creation and justice (or injustice) of modern society is fundamentally flawed. Initially, the dichotomy of “natural” and “cultured” humans treats the specific as universal. The opposition is not culture versus nature, but our culture versus someone else’s “nature”. Rousseau makes this false neutrality evident with his references to the “natural” Caribs and Negroes (Rousseau p. 41,44,46), and Smith with discussion of landlocked and backward peoples (Smith p. 2,25). The racism inherent in the dichotomy makes it clear just how impossible it is to determine which human behavior is foundational and which is...

Find Another Essay On The Wealth of Nations

An Inquiry into the Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith

798 words - 4 pages 40 years after the publication of Adam Smith’s “An Inquiry into the Wealth of Nations” during the early 19th century, the rivalry between the Capitalists and the Landlords was at its peak. Thomas Robert Malthus had lived through two conflicts one the Industrial Revolution, and the Control of landowners over Parliament. Malthus wrote an essay on the theory of population where he challenged England’s poor laws. On the other hand David Ricardo

The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith: THe Beginning of Capitalism

2680 words - 11 pages amount of freedom and the most effective economic gains of any economic system ever devised (Anderson, 2001). In 1776, Adam Smith created a publication called “The Wealth of Nations,” which was the beginning of Capitalism (Anderson, 2001). His theory stated that the wealth of nations could be increased by allowing the individual to seek their own self-interest and removal of governmental control over the economy (Anderson, 2001). There are

Adam Smith "Wealth of Nations" The benefit of division of labor to society

694 words - 3 pages which was one of the duties of a monarch.Another part of Smith's Wealth of nations that wouldhave appealed to Frederick the Great was the portion in bookFive in which Smith explains that the "division of labor"can be used within the nation itself. Allowing the militaryto exist, and be provided for by the national economy.Since the military would be providing a service rather thana product it could still under the "division of labor

Adam Smith and the Reasoning Behind his Thoughts on the Wealth of Nations

1581 words - 6 pages The power of reasoning allows limitless inquiry into the nature of all things. Adam Smith an “enlightened” thinker utilizes reasoning to examine the wealth of nations, but in acting on this reasoning is he forcing his own sentiments into his argument, or is the reasoning creating the sentiments? Smith offers an exposition for his vision of a laissez faire economy, that is, capitalism in the modern sense. In a wider scope, Smith's account reveals

Free Trade and Globalization in The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith

1255 words - 6 pages licensing rules (“Investopedia,” n.d). Removing such barriers allows international trade occur easier and countries are able to put to practice the comparative advantage aspect in relation to other economies. 
 In Adam Smiths paper “The Wealth Of Nations” paper by Adam Smiths projects the view on international trade as not a zero sum equation resulting in being beneficial to all parties involved eventually. By enacting a policy of free trade Smith

The Distribution of Wealth

1110 words - 4 pages Everyone has his or her own ideas of how wealth should be distributed properly. Some people believe wealth should be left to family, left for public services, or become the property of others. Others believe that people should not have excess wealth, resulting in non-existent class distinctions. An alternative view is that wealth is not distributed; instead, the wealthy continue to grow wealthier while those in poverty can not escape it and fall

The Destruction of Wealth

736 words - 3 pages Joe, it suddenly causes what was once a friendly relationship between Pip and Joe to crumble apart, leaving Pip feeling very guilty about his actions. Now that Pip is a gentleman, he feels that his social status and wealth will take care of his problems. He also thinks that being a gentleman will make life much easier for him. It was not until later on he finally realizes the consequences of being one. "My lavish habits led him [Herbert's] easy

Redistribution of the Wealth

812 words - 3 pages In most of the world wealth is inherited and poverty is difficult to get rid of. Until the philosophy, which raises the rich to be in control of the poor and the poor to never have the opportunity to get educated and become rich, and have equal access to the resources of its own nation, the poor will always be poor and the rich will always be rich. Sadly that seems to be the case in most other countries even to some extent in America. In this

The Misery of Wealth

666 words - 3 pages . Miss Havisham, to begin with, demonstrates the classic example of living a lie. Made so obvious, Dickens has even written her past into her name, Have-a-sham. Miss Havisham fell in love with the scoundrel, Compeyson, who only wanted her for the wealth Miss Havisham had inherited. “Miss Havisham was now a heiress... This man pursued Miss Havisham closely... she perfectly idolized him. He

The League of Nations

1569 words - 6 pages of league falling apart, because they were starting to loose power because other nations had people coming into stronger power and places like Italy were starting to ignore the league.The 1920s had been times of prosperity and democracy. But, after 1930, there was a great depression. Countries now wanted to increase their wealth at other nations' expense. Fascist governments which believed in the survival of the strongest came to power in

The League of Nations

1292 words - 5 pages The League of Nations was created during the conference in Versailles, France, 1919, when Woodrow Wilson, the president of United States came up with fourteen points. The League of Nations was a point of Woodrow Wilson's fourteen points. It was created to stop wars by working out the problems with each other, to improve the world, to get rid of weapons, and to enforce the Treaty of Versailles. The League of Nations wasn't welcomed in the United

Similar Essays

The Wealth Of Nations Essay

1072 words - 4 pages heavily influenced by his mentor, Francis Hutcheson, and his friend, David Hume. Apparently, Smith was almost expelled from Oxford for having Hume's work in his room (Heilbronner, 1999). And Smith's A Theory of Moral Sentiments is a rework of “Hutcheson's theory of a moral sense” (Herman, 2001). Heilbronner writes about The Wealth of Nations that “there is a long line of observers before Smith who had approached his understanding of the world

Adam Smith's "The Wealth Of Nations"

650 words - 3 pages The Wealth of Nations was written and published in 1776, and during this time was the beginning of the modern age. New products and ideas were being introduced that are still heavily used today. Manual labor and trade skills were probably the only form of employment and bartering was the only form of business. Many of us today take for granted what’s available to us in regards to goods and supplies. But in the 18th century there were no

The Wealth Of Nations: A Revolutionary Work On Economics

1344 words - 5 pages Adam Smith’s The Wealth of Nations is one of history’s most revolutionary works on economics, with basic principals that remain applicable to today’s business world. Smith wrote it in an effort to transform the way Europeans created and sold products and to promote the concept of a free market. The book was a catalyst for change, quickly spreading throughout the world new and revolutionary ways to improve the financial systems of Europe by

Laissez Faire In The Wealth Of Nations By Adam Smith

869 words - 4 pages Smith theorized that the economy could be run entirely by consumer interest in his book The Wealth of Nations. Smith has become labeled by many as “the father of modern economics,” however his policy is quite simple, there should be a hands off policy by the government. This means no government interference so that the marketplace will involve only private businesses and consumers. In this way the businesses will be dependent upon the consumers and