The West Point Cheating Scandal Essay

1597 words - 6 pages

The West Point Cheating Scandal


In April of 1976 it was found that there was a possibility that over half of the junior class at West Point Academy had violated the West Point honor code by cheating on a case assignment. The honor code states "A cadet will not lie, cheat, or steal, nor tolerate those who do." This was by far the largest violation of the honor code in West Point history and presented some unusual challenges to the administration. As the year dragged on it was found that more and more students possibly had cheated on the assignment and was also becoming a public relations nightmare in the press and internally to the Army branch of the United States military.

The honor code at West Point was pointed and harsh in its dealings with violators and this case brought scrutiny, criticism as well as staunch support for the code and how violations were dealt with. To follow the honor code would be to expel all students involved and this would be a heavy hit on the academy. “At this time West Point had been having trouble recruiting soldiers because of the public attitude toward the military following the Vietnam War” The other possibility was to scrap the way the system was supposed to behave to keep the cadets in school and to reconstruct the honor code and the way it handled violations.


The diagnosis of the problem stems from the fact that honor code was a rigid book of rules that all cadets were expected to adhere too. All parties guilty of violations were given the harshest punishment of expulsion. They were 100% aware of what was involved and consequences of actions if violated. The Army and the military in general has always been a place of direct leaders and subordinates and takes in pride in the fact that it is a highly disciplined way of life. More so at the respective academies which were created to train and educate future leaders in the branches.

The academies are based on trust of your superiors as well as obedience to their commands. There is also the possibility of disappointing your colleagues and in turn losing their respect and camaraderie. This in itself is the one of the reasons some say that the honor code and system had been so successful throughout the years.

A change in the code would go against everything that West Point had always stood for and then would hold future graduates to a lesser standard than their predecessors. The code could be seen by many as much too strict and asking young men to adhere to its rules would be asking too much of them. The empowerment and enforcement of the code has always been up to the ethics committee which is made up of cadets itself. This had always been to exert pressure on all students to comply with the code by means of having to face your peers in hearings.

The one part of the honor code that was a staple of controversy was the end that says no cadet will tolerate any action that violates the honor code. This implied...

Find Another Essay On The West Point Cheating Scandal

Exploring the Different Forms and Aspects of Cheating

881 words - 4 pages become a part of our everyday life. Right from the smallest of the kids to the oldest of the men everyone has or have cheated at some point in their lives, the reason for doing so being irrelevant. The impact of cheating can never be estimated but can only be felt by whom who have been cheated. Well Cheating in any form or manner or any situation is not acceptable whether is monetarily or morally as it implies breach of someone’s trust. There are

Cheating In School Essay

581 words - 2 pages Persuasive Essay Cheating In Schools Students today are having more tests to take in school so that their communities and parents can see how much they are learning in school. Having students tested school districts how much they are learning and how much they know before they move on to the next level. Students of all ages are drawn to one point in their lives of thinking about cheating in school and taking the step of actually cheating. Not

Different types of cheating and foul play, and how

1876 words - 8 pages , reaching a certain point spread in a basketball fix may not require a corrupt ball player to do anything but play a normal game".This quote shows that noncontest cheating is very much premeditated and it is not a spur of the moment act like the one stated earlier.The above examples of different types of cheating show that it is very difficult to determine what is cheating and what isn't.Sometimes athletes and sportsman are guilty of committing foul

Student and Teacher Plagiarism

676 words - 3 pages along with the actual text to help with citation. I believe that the decline within ethics led to the increase in cheating on all levels. The current class filled with military members, and other public servants should be a very ethical class filled with students that choose not to cheat versus those that do. This may be an opportunity for an experiment, a chance to see if the main campus has more or less cheating than the West Point campus. I

Are Students Cheating Due to Pressure?

1554 words - 6 pages Are Students Cheating Due to Pressure? Academic cheating has always been frowned upon by society and reasoned as the easy way out. From a teacher's point of view, cheating may be unethical. On the other hand, from a student’s viewpoint, cheating may be the necessary survival skill in school. Society has always been solely focused on how terrible cheating is but it has never considered the pressures that essentially cause students to cheat. Many

The future of this world

1348 words - 5 pages only in the area of the student's interest, however, students currently are supposed to tackle all kind of attributes. The pressure on students to get high score on SAT is immense due to the SAT playing a pivotal role for college admission. This pressure, as Kadaroo refers in the article "SAT cheating scandal", encourages students to cheat. There are also other reasons why student cheat. As Ed Dante argues that "English-as-second-language student


921 words - 4 pages , student cheating becomes a hot topic and vital issue (Ken, 2008). The causes of student cheating relate to all aspects of daily life. Personal attitude, surroundings, and the stress from parents are three common causes that cause the cheating motive of student. To begin with, personal attitude is direct element which causes student cheating. With a lazy attitude, some students are unwilling to study hard. They spend more than ninety percent


2044 words - 8 pages Canadian society, the Olympics has brought out cheating through drug use for individual athlete's financial gain. Nonetheless, the scandal taught Canadians a sad lesson on Olympic values. What used to be innocent games that were about honesty and sportsmanship is now about dishonesty and cheating for the sake of financial gain rather than the respect and praise of Canadians.Similarly, scandals on corrupt judges in the Olympic Games have also

The Insider Trading Scandal

1311 words - 5 pages The greatest scandal to hit Wall Street in more than half a century began on May 12, 1986, when Dennis B. Levine, a young investment banker, was charged by the Securities and Exchange Commission with having made $12.6 million in illegal profits from "insider"' information. Levine, in return for leniency (two years in prison), assisted the prosecutors in building cases against other violators, and in short order four more young Wall Street


1115 words - 4 pages reader is supposed to believe that his quotes accurately represent his views on the matter at hand. Clayton’s essay is primarily pathos due to the amount of quoted ideas. The essay starts off quoting a freshman at University of Texas: “’Cheating is an answer. It might not be a good answer, but none the less it is an answer.’” (20) Clayton goes on saying that the student does not believe in cheating but was only trying to prove a point. Clayton


4317 words - 17 pages A magnificent pastime of our nation has been stricken with a terrible cancer. Baseball, a game immortalized by children, treasured by families, and adored by many others, is suffering from a great wound. The infection not only damages the athletes of the sport but corrupts the name of the sport and the people who follow it. The excessive use of cheating is destroying the game of baseball.Throughout the Twentieth Century, the national interest of

Similar Essays

Cheating Exposed Essay

523 words - 2 pages point, the cheating related survey, and video clips with the help of interviewers and interviewees.Methods:The Journalism of R.O.A. class created an eleven-question survey to examine the statistics of cheating done by the students of River Oaks Academy. The survey consisted of two demographic questions and nine that concerned the nature of the students cheating rituals. Most of the survey's questions steered toward a specific subject such as, Math

College Cheating Who Is Affected Essay

625 words - 3 pages students admit to collaborating with others on an individual assignment" (Brennan, 2006, 48-52). However, when this collaboration reaches a point of copying on homework or even tests, the extent of cheating is no longer under control. However, it remains true that cheating on homework is often easily detectable, but cheating on tests, especially multiple choice tests, is nearly impossible to pick up without close monitoring of the students. Cheating

Cheating To Success Essay

2026 words - 8 pages whenever somebody copies someone else’s work, or tries to pass off somebody else’s work as their own. Could the cheating be unintentional? As Laura Tillman says many students have different definitions of cheating and may not even realize that they are doing it. All of this access to technology has made students doubt what they consider cheating. It can’t be cheating if it’s available to everyone right? At that point it is just taking advantage of the

Academic Cheating Essay

1583 words - 6 pages , (ex: teacher, hair dresser, cook, waitress, etc.) As time has passed and the workforce changed, so has the role of the woman. More women are entering the workforce in jobs that were previously dominated by men. Studies show that women have taken to cheating to remain competitive with the men. (McCabe & Trevino, (Jan./Feb.1996) What We Know About Cheating In College, Change, 29) Overall, whether you cheat or not will be determined by the type of person you consider yourself to be, honest or not.ReferenceMcCabe, D. L., Trevino, L. K., (1996, January/February). What We Know About Cheating In College. Change, 29-33.Carrell, S. E., Malmstrom, F. V., & West, J. E.