The Western Formula Essay

1307 words - 5 pages

A seemingly traditional approach towards the Western frontier is the reason for John Cawelti's assessment from The Six-Gun Mystique. His description of the Western formula being 'far easier to define than that of the detective story'; may clearly be a paradigm for many authors, but not particularly for Stephen Crane. The standards Cawelti has set forth for a successful Western is quite minimal by thought, but at the same time relevant. Crane signifies a different perspective to these standards. Crane's thoughts for the use of the Western formula are just approaches towards the west, from the introductory setting to the coarse grin one cowboy would make towards another. These do not in fact relate to Cawelti's Western formula. Crane's deviation from the formula western signifies his deeper approach towards issues such as human existence and morality—the ethical code that we follow for success. Crane perhaps does this because he personally finds more significance in the inner meaning of an issue rather than its surfacing argument.
Cawelti's Western formula holds a strong assumption that men are assertive and women are insignificant. He is standardizing the black and white of the West. There is an unequivocal struggle between good and evil—and guns and violence can only solve that. Jane Tompkins standpoint on a Western seems to be a middle ground between Cawelti and Crane. She recognizes that violence is a central theme to a Western, but as well explains how we think of violence. In this day of age, we as a society have prohibited violence as a means of solving problems—Crane does not directly follow this in his stories, but definitely questions it. Cawelti on the other hand marks violence as the only answer—another black and white circumstance.
'This radical discrepancy between the sense of eroding masculinity and the view of America as a great history of men against the wilderness has created the need for a means of symbolic expression of masculine potency in an unmistakable way. This means is the gun, particularly the six-gun'; (Crane 299).
Tompkins makes us aware that a stereotypical Western will hold two men as the key factors and a struggle between them. Where Crane tries describing macho cowboys in 'The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky,'; he directs more of the theme towards the role of a woman and how it plays against male violence. This is ambiguous towards Cawelti's feeling for women to be insignificant to a Western life—as if they are just there for minimal diversity and show.
Stephen Crane shapes 'The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky,'; entirely around the bride and how she will enter a new life in the small town of Yellow Sky. The only instance of a possible Western formula is as a cowboy by the name of Scratchy Wilson points a gun at Jack Potter, the husband and town marshal. However, when Scratchy realizes that Potter had gotten married, he put down his gun and walked away. 'He moved a pace...

Find Another Essay On The Western Formula


2074 words - 8 pages According to some of its critics, popular culture is superficial, formula-based, mass produced for cheapness and standardised. Using examples, explore the strengths and weaknesses of this argument.The growing presence and popularity of Reality TV is the perfect example of the dumbing down of popular culture in recent years. Viewers derive their entertainment from the voyeuristic nature of such programmes, gaining pleasure through watching others

As a Western construct, can nationalism satisfy non-Western movements? Does it then possess good or bad qualities?

1513 words - 6 pages Nationalism cannot be seen as either 'good' 'bad', as the notion of 'good' 'bad' characteristics depends upon the position of the observer. Nationalism is a Western construct which has been variously justified and used for different purposes wherever it is found. It will be argued that nationalism, while possessing neither absolute 'good' nor 'bad' qualities, can never be completely progressive. Even in its anti-colonialist form it derives from


3183 words - 13 pages average of those values. • It doesn't matter which value you use as the "start" and which as the "end" - you get the same answer either way! © 2007 Thomson South-Western The Midpoint Method: A Better Way to Calculate Percentage Changes and Elasticities • The midpoint formula is preferable when calculating the price elasticity of demand because it gives the same answer regardless of the direction of the price change. 2 1 2 1 2 1 2 1

"Midnight's Children" by Salman Rushdie as a Post-Colonial Novel

1432 words - 6 pages postmodernism isa reaction against modernism, post-colonialism is an attempt to show the irrelevance ofthe western division of pre-modem, modem and postmodern to non-Western societies. Inevery field, postmodernism attempts to reverse, extend or project the movement ofmodernism. This could be seen in the postmodern return to history, in its ethic ofindeterminacy, or in the rediscovery of intuition and imagination in preference tomodernity's techno


830 words - 4 pages song was written and first performed by artist Carl Perkins, who played music primarily in what is considered the “rockabilly” genre. Rockabilly found its origins in the 1950's, combining the sounds of western music such as “hillbilly” or country with the sounds of what was considered at the time rhythm and blues. Rockabilly eventually “evolved” in a sense into what can be considered the earliest rock n' roll music, such as Elvis Presley. This was

Red Bull, A success-story.

1011 words - 5 pages marketing their product outside of Asia, the brand decided to target young professionals, rather than factory workers. The original formula was altered for westerners. Some ingredients were removed, and a carbonation process was added to fulfill “Western Tastes”. The drink was also changed from a glass bottle to a unique package of a narrow 8.3 ounce can for $2 a pop to introduce a hip and cool image. For Red Bull, the brand is not a logo, a

The Change Diffusion Process: Why New Coke Was No Replacement

1591 words - 6 pages . As New Coke faded it had only a 3 percent market share by 1986. For the public, dissonance was resolved by the company's effort to bring the original formula back as "Coca-Cola Classic", confirming consumer's preference for the product. Re-invention did occur slightly as New Coke was renamed "Coke II" and is sold in the Mid-western part of the country.The innovation of New Coke was created with the best intentions to compete against another

Cole Vs. Confusianism

1123 words - 4 pages early direction of self discussion leads to the way Western culture and philosophy portraits women and men. Females are seen as being closer to nature, more physical, more emotional, more motherly; they are seen as passive observers of the history and subjects of orders. On the other hand, males are seen as makers of the history, orderly, rational individuals. Looking back at the MAN to the MIND as WOMEN to the BODY formula one raises the

Stephen Crane's The Bride Comes To Yellow Sky

1040 words - 4 pages Stephen Crane's "The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky" Stephen Crane's "The Bride Comes to Yellow Sky," as well as his other Western stories, owe much to Mark Twain's approach to the West. According to Eric Solomon, "both authors…used humor to comment on the flaws of traditional fictional processes" (237). While employing parody of the Western literary tradition, Crane also uses realism to depict the influence of the East on the West. In "The

Ancient Chinese Medicine How was medicine practised in Ancient China? What methodes did they use?

542 words - 2 pages combinations became necessary and more complex as experience showed that some herbs cancelled out the effect of other herbs. It was also discovered that the medicinal properties of many herbs required certain other herbs to be present to act as a catalyst.The healing power of the ingredients found in these natural herbal formulas has never been doubted by most Asians. The difficulty in utilising many of these ancient formulas has been determining which formulas work with the individual person. TCM describes a formula based upon the individual being treated as opposed to Western practices where treatments and preventatives are tested for their effectiveness on a group of people.

Should Canada adopt Proportional Representation?

947 words - 4 pages compositions between them. Canada, Great Britain, and the United States use single-member plurality, while continental European liberal democracies generally use proportional representation (PR). To ensure increased fairness and as a step in reducing western alienation, Canada should shift from the plurality system to PR.The single-member plurality system, sometimes called "first past the post (FPTP)," is the simplest of designs. A country is divided

Similar Essays

The Western Formula Essay

1337 words - 5 pages A seemingly traditional approach towards the Western frontier is the reason for John Cawelti's assessment from The Six-Gun Mystique. His description of the Western formula being "far easier to define than that of the detective story" may clearly be a paradigm for many authors, but not particularly for Stephen Crane. The standards Cawelti has set forth for a successful Western is quite minimal by thought, but at the same time relevant. Crane

Circumference Formula Essay

1170 words - 5 pages . Western mathematicians did not surpass the Tsus approximation until around 1600. Works Cited “Circumference of a Circle - Derivation." Derivation of the Formula for the Circumference of a Circle. Math Open Refrence, n.d. Web. 28 Oct. 2013.. "PI." PI., n.d. Web. 28 Oct. 2013. . "Johann Heinrich Lambert." The world of π. N.p.. Web. 11 Nov

Ethical Issue Of Employer And Employee Rights

1222 words - 5 pages philosophy takes into account the moral wisdom and value of the role of ethics in daily activities. Moral legalism includes the following principles, of which most standard Western ethical theorists follow (Holmes, 2002) Organizational ethics initiatives have not been effectively implemented by many corporations, and there is still much debate concerning the usefulness of such initiatives in preventing ethical and legal misconduct. In this paper, I

Greek Archaic Sculpture Essay

570 words - 2 pages that the personal virtues of affluent individuals become the underlying subject of archaic statues temples and sanctuaries.Formally the Kouros statues follow a carving formula that divides the human body into proportionally pleasing geometric entities. The stylization of the different figure planes along with the rigid poses allow the sculptor an easy way to create the human figure since all he has to do is follow a well established traditional