The White Lie Essay

1103 words - 4 pages

The White Lie

People are always talking about the white lie and how this kind of lying doesn't hurt other people. Other people feel that any lie is one that should not be made. No matter what individuals have to say about lies, Socrates feels that it is necessary to create a noble lie so that his vision of the just state, or kallipolis, can be created. The Myth of the Metals, Socrates myth, in no way contradicts his definition of justice in The Republic.
The so-called noble lie that Socrates puts together is called the Myth of the Metals. This is created to explain to those in the city the reason for their class position. It is brought about when Socrates is talking to Glaucon and they are arguing the manner in which the warriors, or guardian, class should be raised. They conclude that guardians should not obtain or own any possessions' as it will make each other jealous. In order to calm the guardians urge to obtain gold, the Myth of Metals will be told to them. In the Myth, it is said the upbringing that the guardians had received, had only been a dream, and they were actually made in the center of the earth, the mother of them all. Everything that they owned including weapons and craftsman's tools were also created in the same manner. When the time was right, their mother delivered them to the surface so that they could protect her at all costs (414d). This part of the myth describes why the citizens of the kallipolis will defend their land. It still does not satisfy the guardian's urge to obtain wealth.
The second part of the noble lie will further explains how the jealousy will be controlled. Socrates will say that "the god who made you mixed some gold into those who are adequately equipped to rule, because they are most valuable. He put silver in those who are auxiliaries and iron and bronze in the farmers and other craftsman (415)." This distribution of metals in their blood will convince them that the class they are in is destined to them. It is possible that a child of gold or silver blood will be born to those of copper or bronze blood. In that case, the child will be recognized and raised by the designated class. The same is true vice versa. Because of this noble lie, Socrates will be able to control and keep the designated classes in their places.
The question to be asked is, does this lie follow Socrates' belief of what justice is? To look at this we must first discover what is Socrates' definition of justice? After setting up his ideal state, there are three distinct classes of people. Each of these people is best suited for doing his or her job in their area of skill. One cannot perform this task to the fullest however, if it is not the only task that he or she does. For example, a steak knife is best suited to cutting steaks. If it were designed to also spread butter, it would not be as good a steak knife for cutting steak. ...

Find Another Essay On The White Lie

Lying as an art form. Essay

1164 words - 5 pages overcome this problem.This essay will examine several ways that a person can maximize their chances of telling a successful lie, and more importantly, getting away with it. It is one thing to be able to lie, without a few moral concerns, but quite another to make the other person believe you. The three areas examined are: Truth, Preparation and Manner. By combining the techniques outlined, an effective, and convincing lie.TruthWhile the notion of

What lies do you tell? Essay

769 words - 3 pages lie is: something said or done with the purpose of some type of advantage or benefit to the culprit. And there's not just one type of lie either, but many different kinds used in many different situations. Essentially, lies fall into three major categories: small white lies, embellishments, and the dreadful "look-your-mother-straight-in-the-eye-and-not-tell-the-truth" type of lie.Small White Lie is the youngest of three brothers. He's seemingly

What the world would be like without LIES.

1024 words - 4 pages lot of trouble with employees and even a white lie is impossible to execute. Due to the fact Fletcher was unable to lie, he wounded people's egos, hurt people's feelings, lost a secretary, almost lost his job as a lawyer, and even received a traffic ticket. It was absolutely chaos for Fletcher within 24 hours all due to the fact he was unable to lie.What if everyone in the whole world was like Fletcher Reid? Perhaps it would be a great thing

Plato's View on Lying

1507 words - 6 pages had one natural quality that tell do best, the lie actually resembles the truth making it a verbal lie. I think that Plato is right in some respects and wrong in others. I agree that in one case lying may be beneficial. When you lie to not hurt someone's feelings. Telling a white lie, for example when someone asks if they look fat in this outfit, to not hurt their feelings, if it did make them look fat, it would be alright to lie and say, "oh you

Taming of the Shrew Essay

1288 words - 5 pages Danielle Robertson Essay #3 Shakespeare Taming of the Shrew Shakespeare's play, The Taming of the shrew, illustrates Twains point in "The Decay of the Art of Lying" that judicious liars are beneficial. Not in every case can a lie be beneficial but in certain cases such as to help someone, to make another person feel better about themselves or even in some cases to bring people together. Though these lies, sometimes known as "white lies" are

The Morality of Lying in Contrast to the Philosophies of Kant

2329 words - 9 pages the idea of lying. Omitting unintentional lying (i.e. expressing a misconception, or otherwise unwittingly speaking an untruth), deliberate lying takes many different forms. For this paper, it is necessary to distinguish several of those forms, which vary in severity. First, there is the simple white lie, which is defined as “a trivial lie that is told for diplomatic or well-intentioned reasons.” These are typically inconsequential responses made

The Moral Development of Huckleberry Finn

1034 words - 4 pages encounters Judith Loftus, he lies, telling her that he is a girl by the name of Sarah Mary Williams, and later that he is a runaway apprentice called George Peters (69). Huck continues lying for himself, reflecting the depth of Huck’s descent while with his father; however, the lie also helps Jim, so Huck displays a tiny amount of selflessness. Farther down the river, Huck lies to several men and tells them that Jim is a white man who has smallpox (101

Marlow's lies

827 words - 4 pages Marlow’s Dark Lie In the novel, Heart of Darkness, written by Joseph Conrad, Marlow lies to Kurtz’s fiancée at the end of the story when she asks him to repeat his last words to which he responds that his last word was her name. Kurtz’s fiancée, also referred to as the Intended, was comforted by his response and wept in triumph; however, she believed in an illusion because she never knew what Kurtz became in Africa. The author uses character


667 words - 3 pages the quote by Nietzsche, is the incident in The Crucible when the courts of Salem are in session, and Goody Proctor is brought into the courtroom and queried of her knowledge of her husband having an affair with Abigail Williams. Goody Proctor knew of the occurrence, yet she lied to the judge. This white lie was an attempt to save the honor of her husband, who had already confessed unbeknownst to her. Since John Proctor had said that his wife was

The Life and Writing of E.B. White

2332 words - 9 pages New Yorker was a recounting of an accident at a Manhattan restaurant, in which a glass of buttermilk was spilled on his suit. The waitress, White related, "was a little girl, so I let her blot me. In my ear she whispered a million apologies, hopelessly garbled, infinitely forlorn. And I whispered that the suit was four years old, and that I hated dark clothes anyway. One has, in life, so few chances to lie heroically" (White, E(lwyn) B(rooks)(1899

Analysis: Essays About Lying

1375 words - 6 pages question. “Most ‘little white lies’ belong here, well-intentioned deceptions designed to grease the gears of society. In this context people want to be fooled. No one expects and few would welcome, searing honesty at a dinner party”. There are many examples in history of lying to benefit others: the Underground Railroad, the Holocaust, or any revolution to overthrow unfair rule. Imagine the result of such events without the ability to lie

Similar Essays

A White Lie In The Heart Of Darkness

1381 words - 6 pages A White Lie in the Heart of Darkness “He cried in a whisper at some image, at some vision, – he cried out twice, a cry that was no more than a breath – ‘The horror! The horror!’” (Conrad, Heart of Darkness, pg112)1. After returning to Brussels, Marlow pays a visit to Kurtz’ intended and brings these final words of Kurtz with him. When asked to reveal Kurtz’ last declaration, Marlow offers this: “‘The last word he pronounced was

Living Behind A White Lie As An Afghan American Muslim Woman

1097 words - 4 pages Living Behind a White LieI am an Afghan-American Muslim woman. Afghan woman are a minority of a minority. A very small percent of Afghan women have an education and don't get to be successful because the culture discourages independence for women. In fact, this happens not just in Afghanistan, but in the United States as well. In fact, it happens in my own family. My cousin has an arranged marriage and has been denied an education by her husband

The Way We Lie Article By Jennifer Ericsson

1476 words - 6 pages lie’ is it’s just a small lie, only meaning to boost up other people whereas, when it’s not a white lie, the lie is usually used to protect, oneself in a situation. Although white lies are said to never be told they at times can save relationship(s), even giving good complicates to people to make them feel good about herself and , and plus everyone lies why should you be looked down upon when others tell white lies as well. For those with

Commonly Used Forms Of Lying Essay

982 words - 4 pages Commonly Used Forms of Lying The whole truth and nothing but the truth. If these were words to live by then some of us be in trouble. Most people make a habit out of lying on a daily basis. Everyone tells a lie every now and then. Most lies are those little white lies, the ones to keep out of trouble, and the stupid ones that make no sense. There are little white lies that are told to keep from hurting someone else's feelings. These