The Witches In Macbeth: No More Than An Influence

1774 words - 7 pages

According to Shakespearean scholar, A.C. Bradley, "while the influence of the witches' prophecies on Macbeth is very great, it is quite clearly shown to be an influence and nothing more. There is no sign in the play whatever that Shakespeare meant the actions of Macbeth to be forced on him by external powers." Bradley's argument is valid; the witches provide the spur Macbeth needs to act on his overbearing ambition, but it is ultimately the choice of Macbeth and Macbeth alone to pursue his thirst for the throne - to turn his thoughts into actions. The influence of the witches is indeed no more than an influence, as is demonstrated by Macbeth's initial reaction to their prophecies, his subsequent independent decisions to murder for the kingship, and his own admittance in the end that his actions were of his own doing and not forced on him by external powers.Macbeth's immediate reaction to the witches' prophecies is the first clear piece of evidence that Shakespeare did not intend for them to be anything more than an influence. Upon first hearing their prophecy that he will be king, Macbeth's response is telling: he starts. This reaction suggests that before Macbeth even stumbles upon the presence of the Weird Sisters, he has thoughts of becoming king. Moreover, the suggestion is not simply that he has considered it - for starting is a sign of guilt, of which he would have little if his thoughts were innocent - but that he has considered acting on it - a crucial distinction. The prophecy itself contains little but the mention that he will be king: "All hail, Macbeth! that shalt be king hereafter!" (I, iii, l. 50)1 Indeed, Bradley observes that the witches "merely announced events: they hailed him as Thane of Glamis, Thane of Cawdor, and King hereafter. No connection of these announcements with any action of his was even hinted by them...In any case, the idea of fulfilling it by murder was entirely his own."2 Macbeth reveals in his first soliloquy that he is tempted by the notion of killing Duncan for the crown, and though the idea is firmly rooted in his mind, he cannot act on it. Clearly, the influence of the witches on Macbeth at this stage is important, as it revives and heightens his consideration of taking action to become king - an idea he and Lady Macbeth have discussed at an earlier time. Nevertheless, one cannot credit the witches with the responsibility of his choices simply because they suggested he would become king - his own inner desires led him to act, and he was free to do otherwise. Additionally, the temptations brought on by the witches were within him in the first place. Author Germaine Greer argues, "Macbeth's vulnerability to the witches is not caused by...superstition on his part, but by corrupt desire which moves him to take a false step."3 The desire that Greer refers to is seen by Macbeth as his ambition. This ambition is vital to Macbeth's existence, and again calls into question the true influence of the witches: if it is...

Find Another Essay On The witches in Macbeth: no more than an influence

No Company Has Grown More than Apple

1432 words - 6 pages Through the last couple of decades technology companies have seen major surge in the global brand market. Interbrand, a company that researches and analyzes companies for their value, have shown that in this past year that seven out of ten out of the top ten companies in the world are technology-based companies. Though, no other company has seen greater growth than a company by the name of Apple. Apple is a technology brand known to many in

Lady Macbeth - More Tragic than Fiend

2027 words - 8 pages ). In summary, I do personally feel that Lady Macbeth is much more of a tragic figure, rather than that of a “fiend”. Her actions later on in the play support that, and also I think had it not been for her own personal greed and her naivety in believing in the witches were right, perhaps this play would not have been the same. Whilst she did beg to become this “fiend” and perhaps for a short time was, we later see indeed that it was just a

Nickel and Dimed! The book on how to get by in AMerica while making no more than $8/hour

1644 words - 7 pages on a pedestal over her ambitious goal of "seeing what it's really like," reminding the reader no less than 9 times that she has PhD, apparently to distinguish herself from the average people around her, in case we forget. I think she has an excessive amount of pity for herself. Ehrenreich ruled out various occupations for one reason or another. For example, the option of a hotel desk clerk was eliminated because it involved standing in one spot

"Macbeth" - "The construction of Macbeth in different media for different audiences involves much more than the adaptation of ideas and form."

1323 words - 5 pages were given in their work allowed the construction of Macbeth to flow and have added value. One reason viewers might enjoy Polanski's film on Macbeth much more than any other piece of work on the same Shakespeare production is because he also had a freedom of budget, which enabled him to show and interpret things more dramatically and understandably better in a way. An example of this would be the dreams that MacBeth has about Fleance killing him

Write an analysis of specific scenes in a film or films (at least one scene, no more than three) applying the concepts and terms of one chapter from Understanding Film Theory

629 words - 3 pages Essay #3: Film Analysis and Argumentative Writing12/2 Draft Due 12/8 Final Essay DueAssignment: Write an analysis of specific scenes in a film or films (at least one scene, no more than three) applying the concepts and terms of one chapter from Understanding Film Theory. The chosen scene(s) must be viewable by the professor via the internet or DVD you provide. You can relate the scene you choose to the rest of the film, but the analysis must

"No job is more vital to society than that of the manager." (Henry Mintzberg). Discuss

1273 words - 5 pages . Without a manager to plan, organize, lead and control an organization, what would be the effect on society? Considering a manager's fulfillment of these basic four roles and the impact these have on society will provide us with an understanding that, as Henry Mintzberg stated, "No job is more vital to society than that of the manager."Breaking down the roles that a manager carries out and considering examples will show that these roles are vital to

This Essay will outline The influences of the witches' prophecies, the influence of Lady Macbeth, and Macbeth's ambitions, are they key factors that lead to his tragic downfall

700 words - 3 pages Macbeth, at the beginning of the play, seems to be a very loyal and honorable person. However, his character is changed by the influences of several factors. These factors have an influence on Macbeth, but he is responsible for his own destiny. The influences of the witches' prophecies, the influence of Lady Macbeth, and Macbeth's ambitions, are they key factors that lead to his tragic downfall.The witches (or "weird sisters" as they are often

Subcultural theories of crime are no more relevant nowadays than they were 40 years ago. Discuss

2563 words - 10 pages set by the 'middle class measuring rod'. This emanated as an acute problem of social-psychological adjustment and subsequently, some sought a delinquent way of life as a solution. Evidently, the foundations of his theory are limited to just working class boys and does not take into account other classes and females. Thus, there are real limitations in assessing its relevance nowadays when gangs consisting of more than merely working class boys do

No Child Left Behind Creates More Problems for Students than it does Solutions

2546 words - 10 pages ). There are four main principles to the new plan; Greater accountability for student achievement, greater flexibility for states, districts and schools in the use of federal funds (more specifically Title I funds) and more choices for parents of children from disadvantaged backgrounds and an emphasis on teaching methods that have been demonstrated and proven to work. However and even still, No Child Left Behind creates more problems for students

The Three Witches in Macbeth

1061 words - 4 pages into the play idea of fate and the role with which it has in the play. One can only wonder if Macbeth ever had a chance of doing what was right after he met with the witches. It is however, more realistic to believe that Macbeth was responsible for his own actions throughout the play and in the end, he was the one who made the final decisions. The witches could see the future, they could add temptation, and influence Macbeth, but they could not

Discuss how social and cultural contexts influence children's learning and use of more than one language or variety

2540 words - 10 pages As English becomes more and more of an international language with the establishment of local varieties in different countries, bilingualism and multilingualism has an emergent social and cultural role in children being increasingly expected to master the art of having to speak and converse in more than one language.In this essay, I will begin by discussing how Julian Roux has acquired two languages under the cultural influence of his mother and

Similar Essays

The Witches' Evil Influence In Shakespeare's Macbeth

1326 words - 5 pages with four stressed beats. The rhyme of ‘again’ and ‘rain’ and ‘done’, ‘won’ and ‘sun’ as well as the half rhyme in ‘heath’ and ‘Macbeth’ and the alliteration in the words ‘foul’, ‘fog’ and ‘filthy’ emphasises the unnaturalness of these beings ‘Fair is foul and foul is fair’ this line tells us the anarchy the witches bring to our world. Their purpose in this scene is to create an evil and eerie mood and suggest that they will be the cause of

Macbeth By William Shakespeare, Influence Of The Witches And Supernatural In Macbeth

1024 words - 4 pages meaning to such an audience as one sign of a witch was said to be a red spot on the hands.Without the influence of the Witches and the supernatural, it could be argued that Macbeth would have never committed the terrible crimes that eventually resulted in his demise. More importantly, Shakespeare's audiences would not have been treated to such a visually interesting and dramatically tense play. James I later retracted his belief in Witches and the

Is An Oppressive Government More Desireable Than No Government?

1000 words - 4 pages are1)The preservation of social order2)The fulfillment of fundamental needs.The only way in which to ensure individual welfare is to maintain societal stability while at the same time protecting the individual.My first contention is that an oppressive government is more desirable than no government because government, in any form, provides certain advantages that are impossible for the state of nature to provide.(1)First of all, a government

Parallels: The Influence Of Lady Macbeth And The Three Witches That Changed Macbeth

1250 words - 5 pages only thing to do. Since Macbeth had so much trust in her, he let her sway him into becoming a murderer. However, even though his trust in Lady Macbeth led Macbeth to kill one person, his trust in the witches led him to have many people killed, which shows that his trust in the witches had a far more negative influence on him in changing him into a bad person. Therefore, by trusting the witches and becoming too impetuous with his decisions and