Theme Betrayal On “Flowering Judas” Essay

1776 words - 7 pages

Judas Iscariot, the disciple, hanged himself from a tree after betraying Jesus Christ and giving him a kiss. The tree in which Judas hanged himself is known as “Judas Tree,” mainly found in Southern Europe and Western Asia. In the short story “Flowering Judas” written by Katherine Anne Porter the title is related to this religious event of betrayal, murder, and denial. The two main characters in this short story are Braggioni and Laura. Braggioni is a cruel, powerful leader of Marxist revolutionaries in and around Mexico City. Laura is a beautiful American women, age 22, who took up residence in Mexico. Braggioni, Braggioni’s wife, and Eugenio also perform certain actions that make them betrayers, however Laura is Judas the betrayer in “Flowering Judas.”
Starting off, Laura betrays her students who she teaches. The students in her school love her and are enthusiastic about learning from her teaching. “Children [write] on the blackboard, ‘we lov ar ticher’” (Porter 1695). But Laura does not put all her commitment and passion to her teaching. As stated by Sister Mary Bride, “Even though she was a teacher, she had no love for the little children who crowded around her each morning with fervent greetings and festooned her desk with flowers. They ‘remain strangers to her’” (129). A teacher is supposed to love her children, to be part of them, and to focus in her children. With the lack of eagerness and dedication to accomplish her activities as a teacher, she is making less of herself and betraying her students.
Additionally, a young man appears in Laura’s life that sings outside her bedroom window, writes poems to her, and follows her around town to demonstrate his passionate love for her. Porter states, “She tells herself that throwing the flower was a mistake, for she is twenty two years old and knows better” (1696). As stated by Peter G. Christensen, “the flower that she flirtatiously throws at a young admirer had been used as evidence of her tampering with men’s emotions” (254). Laura is only misleading him and expresses the wrong intentions by throwing a flower to him. Also, a “Captain who had been a soldier in Zapata” also desires the love of Laura, even though it defeats his masculine figure as a soldier. But Laura refuses to unlock her heart to this brave and daring soldier. Laura blocks everything and anything that attempts to reach for her heart. Sister Mary Bride states, “Laura does not merely reject illicit love; she rejects all love. She rejects life. She is the essence of negation” (129).
Continuing, Laura betrays love in her life by rejecting all men who intend to reach for her heart. “But [Laura] cannot love them back. [Laura] is loved and desired by men, but can feel nothing for them” (Gottfried 139). Laura pictures a “revolutionist would be lean, animated by heroic faith, a vessel of abstract virtues” (Porter 1692). Laura pictures a revolutionist as a Christ figure. The total opposite of what Laura thinks about Braggioni,...

Find Another Essay On Theme Betrayal on “Flowering Judas”

Flowering Judas Essay

1074 words - 4 pages Flowering Judas Katherine Anne Porter's short story "Flowering Judas" is a story of betrayal and psychological imbalance. The two main characters in the story are Laura and Braggioni. The story is set in Mexico during the revolution and helps portray the characters' true motives behind being a part of the rebellion. Both characters have similarities and differences, which they express in the story. Also, each character has a sort of super

Original Analysis of Poems

812 words - 4 pages critical to success. The end of the poem tells of the chameleon’s hideaway. the poem reads, “Called into the hanging garden/you sit there, almost unseen/as dusky shadows climb/the blooming Judas tree” (20-23). Judas was one of Jesus’ disciples, but he betrayed Jesus. This betrayal lead Jesus to his crucification. Judas was also a chameleon, and Komunyakaa uses this allusion to highlight his theme. Judas was successful in a sense; his goal was for

Sculpture: The Betrayal and Arrest of Christ

971 words - 4 pages body and face are facing forward. His right leg crosses over his left leg and he has sort of a stunned look on his face. Possibly, because his ear has just been cut off and Christ replacing it is surprising to him. In the very center is the kiss of Judas. Judas has his back facing the viewer with his left arm around Christ's right shoulder and holding his robes in his right hand. He is about to kiss Christ and show the Romans that this is

Paul Gauguin: "Agony in the Garden".

1234 words - 5 pages "Agony in the Garden", with numerous precedents in the history of art; the theme of agony in the garden typically represents Christ after the Last Supper and immediately before his betrayal by Judas Iscariot and his arrest by the Roman soldiers in the Garden of Gethsemane. (1) "Agony" (from the Greek agon, or conflict) refers to the struggle within Christ as he grapples with the divine and the human sides of his nature. (1) Here we find Gauguin's

Religious themes within the film The Matrix. film directed by The Wachowski Brothers

1750 words - 7 pages when Judas (one of the 12 disciples) gave out confidential information about the whereabouts of Jesus, which in the end led Jesus to his death on the cross. This point is proven in the New Testament of the catholic bible. Matthew 26:14 -16 is when Judas agrees to betray Jesus and in Matthew 26:47 -50 is when Jesus is arrested.When Judas agrees to betray Jesus he goes to the Chief Priest and asks, "what are you willing to give me if I hand you

Disparity between "Passion of the Christ" and the Bible.

1477 words - 6 pages line between good and bad. Another scene involving the devils occurs after Judas betrays Jesus and the guards capture him. As Jesus is held prisoner in chains being beaten on his way to face Caiaphas, he is tossed over a bridge and suspended in the air by the chains. Under the bridge, however, is Judas, who stares Jesus in the eye, and begins to feel the guilt of betraying him. This guilt inevitably leads to his suicide, but as Jesus is pulled back


528 words - 2 pages a want for power which leads to betrayal of the king. In act I, scene IV the king says, "There's no art to find the mind's construction in the face: he was a gentlemen on whom I built an absolute trust." (Shakespeare 11). Through this irony we can see betrayal. The king is telling Macbeth he could not see the man's betrayal on his face, and yet Macbeth is once again doing this to the king. This is one quote in which we can see the theme

Lent Sermon

1858 words - 7 pages offers that when Judas came with assistance by way of betrayal “they were delighted” – check. What we know about their action after is that they discussed how they might do away with Christ…but as to the why? The religious leaders, Luke says, “were afraid of the people”. They were afraid, of the image of riot-filled streets and Jesus-followers wreaking retribution on them; or maybe more, of the image of worship and adoration, religious-life

Meeting Judas Iscariot

1744 words - 7 pages , but the fog was digging into my mind, as images of my friends and family seemed to pass before me. I feared that breathing would cause my memories to leak out along with the expelled air. Just as I began to panic, the boat hit something solid, and I felt Judas pull me out of the boat. I collapsed on the dark earth, thankful to be out of the boat, and the fog. My lungs filled with burning air, yet my memories stayed put. I looked up; we were at

An Essay on Katherine Anne Porter

1936 words - 8 pages Porter and her short story Flowering Judas. The Jilting of Granny Weatherall. Prod. Robert Geller. Perf. Geraldine Fitzgerald, Lois Smith, and William Swetland. Monterey Home Video, 2005. DVD. This is a film production of Katherine Anne Porter’s short story. Katherine Anne Porter. New York, N.Y.: Films Media Group, 1986. TCCD Streaming Video Collection. Web. 26 Nov. 2011. This is a

Holocaust: Hitler's Final Solution

1240 words - 5 pages ; then he is the evilest person in the world. For it is obvious Jesus Christ was the greatest human being to ever set foot on Earth, and if you would destroy him you would in due form be the most devilish. So now Christians who hear and tell this legend apply the worst person in the world to the Jewish race. Blaming not only Judas for the betrayal of God's only begotten son, but the whole Jewish race. Probably, the most justifiable inspiration

Similar Essays

Theme Betrayal For Flowering Judas Essay

1472 words - 6 pages , threatened, and reestablished” (Gottfried 134). The two main characters in this short story are Braggioni and Laura. Braggoni is a cruel, powerful leader of Marxist revolutionaries in and around Mexico City. Laura a beautiful American women, age 22, who took up residence in Mexico. The most known theme in Porter’s short story “Flowering Judas” is betrayal. Laura, Braggioni, Braggioni’s wife, and Eugenio are all guilty of betrayal. Starting

Literary Analysis Essay

1566 words - 6 pages not the body and blood of Christ but the buds of the flowering Judas, an action that symbolizes her act of betrayal. The influence of James Joyce is readily evident as well, not only in the theme of moral paralysis but also in technique, including symbolsBraggioni represents the potential of sexual violation. His fat body, encased in expensive clothes, calls attention to the power he has over Laura. As he strokes the guitar and the pistol and

Peter In Da Vinci's Last Supper

1399 words - 6 pages God will be forgiven of their sins. This is what the Eucharist represents. The bread is Jesus's body broken for man, and it symbolizes Jesus's sacrifice on the cross. From a secular viewpoint, the Eucharist means nothing, so the main theme is obviously Jesus's announcement of the betrayal. Jesus already knows that Judas will betray him and accepts it because the betrayal is but one part of God's plan. The reactions of the apostles as seen in the

"A Good Man Is Hard To Find" By Flannery O'connor

667 words - 3 pages and meanness are meaningless. Even the Grandmother fails to guide the Misfit to goodness, she finally finds her true self when she dies "her legs crossed under her like a child's and her face smiling up at the cloudless sky" (O'Connor 565). She smiles because may be she has find eternity and she returns to her innocent stage and joins with God.Opposite from O'Connor, Porter in "Flowering Judas" portrays Laura's role like a nun. She is a