Theoretical Perspectives On Iraq War 2003

2624 words - 11 pages

In this paper, I intend to analyze Iraq war of 2003 from Realist and Marxist/ Critical perspectives. I intend to draw a conclusion as to which theoretical framework, in my opinion, is more suitable and provides for a rational understanding of the Iraq War. While drawing comparative analysis of two competing approaches, I do not intend to dismiss one theory in entirety in favour of another. However, I do intend to weigh on a golden balance, lacunas of both theories in order to conclude as to which theory in the end provides or intends to provide a watertight analysis of the Iraq war.
Followers of Realist school of thought argue the case of 2003 Iraq war from the standpoint of power and Security. The Bush administration’s rationale for launching a pre-emptive attack against Iraq was based on two misleading assumptions: firstly, Iraq had or was developing Weapons of Mass Destruction (along with Iran and North Korea) and secondly, that it was aiding and protecting terrorist organizations like Al-Qaeda. Such a conjecture based on unsubstantiated evidence helped Bush administration conjure up a dystopian situation which justified 2003 invasion of Iraq under the pretext of “security maximization”. This explanation was given in pursuance of the realist assumption that States’ as rational actors always act in accordance with their national security interests.
However, failure to procure any putative weapons of mass destruction in Iraq forced Realist apologists to invoke the concept of “offensive Realism” to explain the Iraq war of 2003. They argued that Iraq’s acquisition of uranium and aluminum tubes posed a “Security Dilemma” to the U.S. and her allies. According to Wheeler and Booth, security Dilemmas exist when States’ are uncertain about the intention of another State with regard to its military capability. Iraq’s potential to develop WMD s was a sufficient threat to call for a pre-emptive military strike. This is consistent with the principle of Self-help which necessitates augmentation of States’ power capabilities in search for security. The term “Power” is often defined in political realism parlance as an “ability of the State to do what it wants to do.” Mearsheimer has argued that “great powers maximize their relative power position”. This means that U.S. which is a great power in the west would seek to exploit opportunities to gain more power at the cost of other states.
In this regard, it is important to note that following the demise of Soviet Union and end of the cold war, the bipolar international system has transformed into a unipolar system represented by U.S. hegemony. This was a significant shift in the international distribution of power as this means that U.S. is no longer obliged to follow a policy of deterrence or containment against threatening rogue states. The termination of bipolar system disturbed the system of checks and balances which implies that had Iraq been a Soviet client State, the...

Find Another Essay On Theoretical Perspectives on Iraq War 2003

War on Iraq Essay

749 words - 3 pages destruction. "The administration allegations are based mainly on words of a few Iraq defectors and UNSCOM records showing that five to ten percent of Iraq's former illegal weapons arsenal remains unaccounted for."(cooperative search) Experts believe these unaccounted weapons were either destroyed during the first Gulf War or have been degraded and no longer pose a serious threat.Di Benedetto 3In a speech to an audience at the Suffolk Law School

The Unjustified War on Iraq Essay

557 words - 2 pages The Unjustified War on Iraq The Bush Administration was impatiently unjustified in the attack on Iraq. The justification the Republican council offered was no more that an attempt to eradicate the blame infused by poorly made, hasty decisions and forceful actions. Liberal magazine, The Nation, publishes many liberal perspectives on the actions that have been taken in prevention of major military action. Although action was necessary, the

Against the war on Iraq

1222 words - 5 pages 2003. Most of the US forces are currently in the process of moving to the Al-Udeid Air Force Base in Qatar. The advocates of attacking Iraq say that the military overthrow of Saddam Hussein is part of the campaign against terrorism and is needed to prevent Iraq's development of weapons of mass destruction.There are, of course, viable alternatives to war. The most effective means of addressing the threat of Iraqi weapons of mass destruction is to

President Bush's War on Iraq

3196 words - 13 pages President Bush's War on Iraq Introduction: Since the war on Iraq began on March 20, 2003, at least 1,402 coalition troops have died and 9,326 U.S. troops have been wounded in action. This is no small number and the count grows daily. One would hope, then, that these men and women were sent to war with just cause and as a last resort. However, as the cloud of apprehension and rhetoric surrounding the war has begun to settle, it has

On War Against the Iraq War

1821 words - 7 pages In March of 2003, the United States along with the United Kingdom and a few other countries sent troops to Iraq. Within weeks the regime of Saddam Hussein was defeated and the capital city of Iraq, Baghdad, had fallen in war. That war, although ephemeral in form, continues on to this day. After what can be objectively seen as an eight-year war, it is time to bring an end to at least the overwhelming majority of our military presence in Iraq

Discuss the various theoretical perspectives on Aggression, including the research supporting and refuting these perspectives

2954 words - 12 pages may lead to murder, it is still represented as instrumental aggression.Theoretical Perspectives on AggressionIn studying these types of aggression, a number of theoretical perspectives which have sharply contrasting views concerning the nature of aggression, the factors influencing its occurrence, and the forces from which it stems have been proposed. Psychologists have focused on four main ideas, which these opposing theoretical perspectives seem

Why did George.W Bush win the war in Iraq in 2003

1514 words - 6 pages concept of Hussein planning an attack on the United State's seemed plausable and that Bush invaded the middle-east on claim's of WMD. This then point's and support's the idea that the reason for Bush invading Iraq in 2003 was to over throw the rule of Saddam Hussein and control this part of the middle-east and to stop the war of terror.In October 2001 the U.S. invaded Afghanistan, and this marked the beginning of its Global War on Terrorism (GWOT

Bush's speech before the War on Iraq

1101 words - 4 pages March 19, 2003 - The first day of the War on Iraq; a day that can be viewed as the beginning of a nightmare for many innocent people across the globe. Depending on an individual's country of citizenship, one might view either the American troops or Iraqi troops to be the freedom fighters or terrorists within this conflict. The War on Iraq placed strains upon, and caused heartache for the innocent people within the two nations. Through the

Various Perspectives on War in Homer's Iliad

2043 words - 8 pages Various Perspectives on War in Homer's Iliad         The Iliad is a story of rages of Achilles and the War of Troy. Thanks to the techniques of the author, Homer, The Iliad is very colorful, romantic, and it makes the readers imagine the ancient Greeks and their times of war. Homer is believed to be the author of epics other than the Iliad, although their authorship remains uncertain. Historian believes that Homer probably lived in

Compare and contrast the 1990 Gulf War to the 2003 Iraq invasion. Did the position of Arab regimes differ?

2892 words - 12 pages Compare and contrast the 1990 Gulf War to the 2003 Iraq invasion. Did the position of Arab regimes differ?The Gulf War in 1990 and the invasion of Iraq in 2003 both had a profound impact not just on the countries directly involved - primarily Iraq and the United States (US) - but also on the geo-politics of the world. Arguably, the War ended in a stalemate because the Iraqi regime that had started the War by invading Kuwait remained in power

The Realist and Liberalist Perspectives on International Relations and US Policy Stance Toward Iraq

1765 words - 7 pages The Realist and Liberalist Perspectives on International Relations and US Policy Stance Toward Iraq There are two prominent stances in International Relations. The schools of thought are commonly referred to as realist and liberalist. There are various names that they are called, and they can also be split further into subdivisions. However, for the purposes of this question I will just refer to the main schools of thought

Similar Essays

Media Coverage In The Vietnam War And The War On Iraq (2003)

890 words - 4 pages were many misleading pictures and stories like the `Napalm' incident. As for Gulf War II, many of the information and statistics contradicted. For example, within a 24-hour period, one newspaper revealed that there were 320 cruise missile strikes on Baghdad, while another reported 750 (Knightley 2003). Furthermore, a number of pictures and headlines were rather misleading. (Refer to Appendix B) Evidently, the coverage in both wars were rather

War On Iraq Essay

1036 words - 4 pages please the United States and the rest of the World. Saddam Hussein made a bold statement saying, "I'll die in Iraq." In the Toronto Sun on February 27, 2003 ('I'll die in Iraq', page 2) he stated that he would rather die in Iraq than leave his country. Saddam isn't scared of the U.S. He never mentioned anything about not going into war with the U.S. Also, Saddam has destroyed small fraction of his missiles. He destroyed exactly four. In an article of

Was The 2003 War In Iraq Justified And Necessary?

11254 words - 45 pages Assignment aim.My aim in this assignment is to provide an objective view of whether the 2003 war on Iraq is justified.History of Iraq. For map see appendix 1. Weapons Of Mass Destruction (WOMD)Iraq is a country that was created after world war 1, by the then coalition. It neighbours with Turkey, Saudi Arabia, Iran, Syria and Jordan. It is split, pretty much in two by the rivers, Tigress and Euphrates. Habitation and life along these two

War On Iraq Essay

744 words - 3 pages Winning a war with Iraq is not the problem. Getting rid of Saddam Hussein is not the problem either, we can probably achieve both missions, although the cost may be more that expected.The problem, is what happens after we have 'won?'To roll the credits back a notch, lets look at where we are in Afghanistan after 'winning.' The National Army we put in place dares not venture outside Kabul. Vice President Qadir was assassinated on July 6th and