Theories Of Resurrection Of The Body Are Logically Incoherent.

2706 words - 11 pages

Resurrection is a Christian, materialist view that the body rises after death in a physical form, with the main evidence of this being the resurrection of Jesus Christ. Resurrection is central to the Christian faith as it marks the start of Christianity from the Jewish scriptures. There are many differing views about the plausibility of resurrection. Some may believe that resurrection is only based on theories, therefore not proved beyond doubt, and that these theories don't make sense. Hard materialists such as Hume will support this view, saying that death is the end and the decomposing body is evidence of that.However this opinion may not necessarily be true. The base of many theories of resurrection is the bible, which suggests that talk of physical resurrection of Jesus is logical as there is recorded evidence through the accounts of Luke, Matthew, Mark and John. These accounts can be seen as evidence that theories of resurrection are logical because they are classed as eye witness accounts. Matthew reported that Jesus appeared to the disciples and said "peace be with you". They came up to him, took hold of his feet, and worshiped him.' (Mathew 28 V9) Mark also says that Mary saw a man in the tomb and he said 'You are looking for the Jesus of Nazarene, who was crucified. He has risen!'(Mark 16 V6) but Mary was too scared and didn't tell anyone. Another source of evidence was Luke's statement when Jesus appeared; 'They gave him a piece of cooked fish, which he took and ate' (Luke 24 V41-43). Then finally John said Jesus appeared to Thomas, saying 'put your finger here; see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it into my side' (John 20 V27). These accounts support a Christian materialist view that Jesus' resurrection was physical as he could eat, be touched, walk, speak and breathe. They are considered as evidence as they are written historical accounts. The evidence must be reliable; would they risk their lives for made up stories?Not only is there evidence for the existence of resurrection, but the concept of it appears to make sense through John Hick's eschatological verification. John Hick formulated three points that show how something can be verified. In his conclusion he said that life after death can be verified if you are still a conscious being after death. It can never be falsified because you are dead. This theory is illustrated by what is known as 'the celestial city'. Within this story there is an atheist and a theist walking down a road. One thinks that there is a celestial city at the end and the other thinks there is nothing, they will find out which one is right at the end. The theist view will be verified but the atheist view can never be verified as they will not be conscious beings. Therefore resurrection theories are logical as they can never be proven wrong but can be proven to be true.John Hick also formulated replica theory, as another way to prove that resurrection is logically coherent. This theory states the...

Find Another Essay On Theories of resurrection of the body are logically incoherent.

God’s Existence and the importance of the resurrection to Christianity

1518 words - 7 pages transcendent being, it would be a perfect utopia. On the other hand, we know that God did not create us as perfect human beings. Instead, Romans 8:23 says we await the redemption of our resurrected body. Also, God did not create a perfect world, but a word described in Genesis 1:31 as “very good” (Copan, 87). The resurrection of Jesus Christ is one of the most important aspects of Christianity. It announces to the earth that Jesus is the Son of

Are Theories of Dividend Payment Applicable in the Real World

1957 words - 8 pages Introduction Dividends are the distribution of profits in the company. It depends on the type of dividend policy made by companies. Dividend policy will affect the behaviours and attitudes of investors towards the company. Many economists or financial experts have constructed different theories to interpret the effects of a dividend policy to the society. But these theories are contestable since they are not tested in the real world. Managers

Techniques of the Body

6056 words - 24 pages bed, these are very ordinary, everyday techniques that we take for granted and perceive as something natural, but often they are technique’s we have been taught to do. Marcel Mauss in his work Techniques of the Body (1934) is regarded as the first piece of work to outline a systematic anthropology of the body (Synnott 1993). It aims to show evidence that most everyday body techniques differ between people raised in different environments, as

Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities

1310 words - 5 pages Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities      Resurrection is a powerful theme found throughout the plot of A Tale of Two Cities.  Many of the characters in the novel are involved with the intertwining themes of love, redemption, and good versus evil.  The theme of resurrection involves certain aspects of all of these themes and brings the story together.         Dr. Manette is the first person to experience

Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities

1048 words - 4 pages . Manette, and both Charles Darnay and Sydney Carton. The first occurrence happens when the book introduces Jerry Cruncher. Cruncher’s grave-robbing incidents directly exemplify the theme of resurrection. He literally raises corpses from the dead; thus, he holds the name of a “resurrection-man.” He executes this activity nightly, in order to make money by selling the dead bodies to scientists that use them to perform research on the body parts and

Suffering Death and Resurrection of Jesus Christ

1158 words - 5 pages Suffering Death and Resurrection of Jesus Christ Suffering, Death, and Resurrection are three key beliefs for Christians. They are closely linked together as Jesus suffered died and was resurrected. A modern day example of someone who suffered for their beliefs and for other people is James Mawdsley. After hearing about the terrible conditions in Burma, while backpacking in New Zealand. James decided to

Theories of the Enlightenment

1210 words - 5 pages they held to be sacred and at the center of life and, by the sixteenth century, books were printed in mass quantities throughout Eurasia. Leading scientists and theologians, such as Galileo Galilei, began to argue that both Scripture and science can be right with the latter helping to better interpret the former. (AR 2) Born out of the revolutionary ideas of Galileo, and many others, were the hopeful theories of the Enlightenment. However, when

The Theories of Education

2763 words - 11 pages The Theories of Education This essay is going to look at the Functionalist, Marxist and Interactionist theories of education and outline the key points; it will also provide some criticism in relation to each of the theories. Although the theories are mainly very different, they all have the similarity of suggesting that a person’s social class will contribute greatly to how well they will do at school and also on how

Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities

1258 words - 5 pages Resurrection in A Tale of Two Cities     In A Tale of Two Cities, by Charles Dickens, many characters are given second chances as their lives are resurrected. The central heroine woman, Lucy Manette, is responsible for the resurrections of Sydney Carton and Dr. Alexander Manette's lives. She gives them inspiration and love to help them recover from their seemingly hopeless states. In turn, Carton gives up his own life in order to save

What role does resurrection play in bringing together the plot of the story?

974 words - 4 pages Resurrection is a powerful theme found throughout A Tale of Two Cities. Many of the characters in the novel are involved with the knitted themes of love, salvation and good versus evil. The theme of resurrection involves certain characteristics of all of these themes and brings the story together.Dr. Manette is the first person in A Tale of Two Cities to experience resurrection. He is taken away from his wife and then imprisoned for eighteen

How relevant are the early theories of Mass Society in today’s media environment?

2116 words - 8 pages of this situation and manipulates the ‘masses’. This essay will discuss how relevant the early theories of mass society are in today’s media environment, as there have been vast changes in terms of society as well as the media. Before this discussion, the concepts of mass society need to be examined in order to understand the reasons why scientists were concerned for society and how theories were developed around these ideas of society to

Similar Essays

The Resurrection Of Christ Essay

2071 words - 8 pages The Resurrection of Christ is one of the most questioning studies of scientists. Also Theologians have been stuck on this topic as well. Without the Resurrection, the Christian’s faith would be futile and Christians are not Christians. Indeed, there are several theories that tries to prove the Resurrection to be false. The Swoon, Theft, Wrong Tomb, and Hallucination theories are false because Christ did, in fact, rise from the dead. The

Evidence Of The Resurrection Of Jesus

1561 words - 6 pages witnesses to this event and they proclaimed that Jesus was the Son of God. In addition, Jesus body was not in the tomb on the third day. When Mary, one of His followers went to visit the tomb, it was empty. Shortly after Jesus appeared and told her to spread the news to the disciples. Resurrection With the resurrection Jesus proves that He is God. There is no history of any other religious leader that resurrected from the death. By Jesus doing this it

Resurrection Of Jesus Essay

1723 words - 7 pages possibly triggered by their anguished longing for his presence. Other theories are the following: the no body theory, the no tomb theory. The no tomb theory is what the remainder of this paper will consider as it is the key question in the search for the proof of Jesus' resurrection.The no tomb theory is a central question to the answer of the question if Jesus was indeed resurrected and people witnessed him. The no tomb theory put forth by

The Role Of Resurrection In A Tale Of Two Cities

1340 words - 5 pages resurrection along with many other themes. In the novel, the heroes and heroine use sacrifices to resurrect someone important in their lives. However, through the process of resurrecting another, some characters are also resurrected themselves. The two most important characters in relation to the theme of resurrection are Doctor Manette and Sydney Carton. In the three books of A Tale of Two Cities, Charles Dickens explores the theme of