Theory Of Knowledge: 'a Historian Must Combine The Rigour Of The Scientist With The Imagination Of An Artist.' To What Extent, Then, Can The Historian Be Confident About His Her Conclusions?

1231 words - 5 pages

In history as in all other areas of knowledge it is undoubtedly hard to reach specific certainties. In order to evaluate the conclusions, all ways of knowing are to be applied. The philosophy of history, or historiography, is to be addressed when evaluating these results. It is concerned with the concepts, methods and theories used in history: the study either of the historical process and its development or of the methods used by historians to understand their material.1It has been said that both history and science are about finding the causes and effects of events: this is where the scientific method applies to reaching conclusions in history. On the contrary, it has been interpreted that history is about creativity an imagination: bias being an important problem facing an historian. Inevitably there has been the historians own individuality added to each piece of history he complies and as E.H.Carr observed: 'Study the historian before you begin to study the facts'. If a historian is to combine a scientifically rigorous method with intuitive creativity, how close to certainty will his conclusions get?By addressing the reliability of scientific method in providing certainties and truths it will help clarify how far the historian can be confident with his conclusions when adopting the 'rigour' of a scientist. The scientific method is based on observation, reason and experiment: here a conclusion reached will be based incidentally on reason. For historians this will be impossible to achieve because one cannot re-create a situation from the past. Scientists are able to use sense-perception, their sight for example, when observing an outcome of any experiment: they can see that gravity works because the apple falls. A historian can only employ this method with the use of probabilities, where probability is used to define what the historical evidence and sources are most likely to suggest. However, natural sciences today use probabilities to a large extent too: for example the discovery of 'quanta' has contradicted the conception of the continuity of the infinitesimal calculus2. Hence, this emphasizes that even though this part of scientific method used in history can help bring more certainties, they can never quite be reached. However, it can be argued that a scientist can preserve objectivity towards the phenomena he is studying, whereas the historian can never be completely objective3. A man who assembles the apparatus for his experiment becomes a part of the experiment, thus showing that subjectivity will always be present. Hence, even adopting the rigorous, very much based on instant sense-perception scientific method, it will not always bring the historian to confident conclusions.A common feature of both history and science appears to be the idea of causality. Scientists would often look for one sufficient cause, which is inappropriate when reaching a conclusion in history. When we say that an illness was caused by a virus, for instance, we...

Find Another Essay On Theory of Knowledge: 'A historian must combine the rigour of the scientist with the imagination of an artist.' To what extent, then, can the historian be confident about his her conclusions?

To what extent can Hitler and his foreign policy be blamed for the outbreak of World War two?

1293 words - 5 pages Abyssinians but this was not enough for Mussolini. This of course was a scandal and it also made Hitler realize that the League of Nations will not be an enemy but just a small organization trying to keep peace. America took part in the Treaty of Versailles only to put it together and when it was done they just left and isolated themselves. Although it was the American president himself who came up with the idea of the League of Nations but he

Handlin vs. McNeill - Should history be interpreted with strictly facts, as suggested by Oscar Handlin, or should the historian incorporate his own perspective as according to William H. McNeill?

651 words - 3 pages known and verifiable facts as opposed to using verifiable facts as the basis for their own interpretation, influenced by their own group, experiences, beliefs, and personal motives. Through implementing a strict examination of history, historians can successfully detect and eradicate bias in their writings, allow the government as well as individuals to gain an insight into the past in order to secure and progress the future, and grasp the

Through different methods of justification, we can reach conclusions in ethics that are as well supported as those provided in the natural sciences. To what extent do you agree?

932 words - 4 pages and data analysis. There are several ways of justification such as reasoning, observation, reliable source, memory, emotion and revelation. If a knowledge claim is supported of several ways of justifications mentioned above, it can be said to be well justified. Any scientific theory must be based on a careful and rational examination of the facts. In the scientific method, there is a clear distinction between facts, which can be observed and/or

The kind of knowledge Plato has in mind in his theory of forms is not the kind of knowledge needed to rule a city.

1963 words - 8 pages is essentially equating human beings to mechanical objects who must perform their duties as a way of being subservient to the "Philosophers" like himself, thereby unnecessarily creating and inflating a prestigious position for himself. Is this what he considers to be moral? In his theory he denies that people can have desires and opinions that are outside the realm of their 'place', unless of course, they constitute "immorality".Distinct roles

IB Theory of Knowledge: Consider the extent to which knowledge issues in ethics are similar to those in at least one other area of knowledge.

1674 words - 7 pages better yet, the term "mass" - we find there to be a knowledge issue at hand.How is it possible then to reconcile these knowledge issues that act on language? A set of rules or limitations must be set so that language does not become a potential KI when examining an AOK. When dealing with ethics, for example, it is beneficial to locate the term causing the issue and attempt to reach consensus as to its definition. In the case of "murder", the

"The Life of Edgar Allen Poe" Assignment: Read an extended bibliography. Then write an essay in which you explor how the author's works are a reflection of his/her life.

1217 words - 5 pages of isolation can also be seen in The Cask of the Amontillado, in which a lonely Fortunato is left to die in a tomb after being tricked by his love's father. Just as Poe began to settle into his new foster parents' home, his foster mother died due to a drowning incident. Poe was apt to feel as though he were abandoned in the world with nobody that he could relate to and, likewise, many of his characters experience lonely deaths much like that of

Descartes claims that his existence of a thinking thing is the one certain truth, which can serve as the foundation for all other knowledge.

931 words - 4 pages a certain truth has become to the foundation for not only Descartes, but also modern Philosophy in general. It is evident to everyone that thinking is a characteristic of a human being and even more evident that thinking directly insinuates existence. Can I exist without thinking? If I could exist without thinking, then what must my existence be? Furthermore, criticism against Descartes argument would be irrelevant because it is impossible to

The idea that each person in society must be free and able to express his/her opinions taken from "On Liberty" by John Stuart Mill

1153 words - 5 pages liberties and their rights are being violated by an overzealous government. Mill recognized this problem and published an essay titled "On Liberty", in 1859, which spoke of the idea that each person in society must be free and able to express his/her opinions. Contrary to Mill's beliefs, Edmund Burke, another political philosopher, stated that to have order and less chaos, a monarchial government is necessary. He argued that there would be less

How well does Wordsworth succeed in listing our human sympathies in The Lyrical Ballads? To what extent can you see a developing philosophy in his poetry?

751 words - 3 pages Thorn", is described as a "wretched woman", who sits alone beside an "aged thorn" atop a "heap that's like an infant's grave in size" - this portrayal of Martha at the start of the poem sets up her character as being grim and dark, someone to be feared ("I have never heard of such as dare approach the spot when she is there"). The language Wordsworth uses seems to have the intent of causing readers to dislike and ostracise Martha based on scarce

IB Theory of Knowledge Essay: 7. "In order to find out how things really are, one must understand the filters through which one perceives the world." Discuss and evaluate this claim.

1577 words - 6 pages . According to the natural sciences, the perception of reality is the interpretation by the brain of our sensations brought forth by our sensory apparatus. Different species of animals have different sensory apparati and therefore have differing perceptions. Our sensory apparatus as well as our brains act as filters of reality, only assimilating what can be perceived through the senses. For example, an eagle has a much clearer physical view of

Evaluate to what extent a) expectancy theory and b) goal theory can explain motivation at work.

863 words - 4 pages . Tunnel vision can arise when an employee is majorly focused on one objective that other aspects of his job are forgotten producing lower performance (PSU, 2012). The goal theory is based around one’s intellect with no concern for the involuntary mind so an individual may carry out a task with no ability to recognise what is motivating them. Ultimately, the theory does not take the ‘why’ perception into consideration; therefore, goal setting not

Similar Essays

To What Extent Has Arno Mayer (Historian) Understood The 'holocaust'?

2799 words - 11 pages an attempt to explain what was the 'Holocaust.' However, its mystery lies hidden in the understanding of it. Recently, Jewish American historian Arno Mayer has emerged as a possible candidate to solve this genocidal riddle. Mayer, who escaped the wrathful clutches of Nazism, utilises both is Jewish background and his current historical knowledge to fertilise his interpretation of the 'Holocaust.' He argues that the Judeocide ('Holocaust') was a

Compare And Contrast Knowing A Friend To Knowing How To Swim, Knowing A Scientific Theory And Knowing A Historical Period. What Conclusions About The Nature Of Knowledge Can You Reach?

1423 words - 6 pages we can understand, they are trying to survive, "survival of the fittest" as we know. Contrary to man, his/her decisions are problematic, he/she chooses future at the present.Finally man's history can be written when he/she meets another man, now man can be called a historical creature. "Being in a historical period, man with the help of his decision is able to change himself and the historical period, where he lives in, and participates in it", by

Comparison And Conclusions About The Nature Of Knowledge Between Knowing A Friend And Knowing How To Swim, Knowing A Scientific Theory And Knowing A Historical Period.

1037 words - 4 pages reason plays apart in both. By proving a scientific theory you reason that it is knowledge because it was proven, "scientifically," both with facts and logic. And with those allows us to believe that what we have learned is the truth.Both finding a friend and proving a scientific theory show that we need knowledge about what we are trying to accomplish. Friendship on the basis of trust involves both people knowing that they can depend on each other

Discuss The Extent To Which Trade Theory Can Be Used To Explain The Competitiveness Of Locations.

3091 words - 12 pages ability to produce a certain good with fewer resources than the trading partner. Here is an example of how the Theory of Absolute Advantage worked. Assume labor is the only factor of production. It can be used for the production of either food or cloth.Output per labor hourFood ClothUS 12 3Mexico 6 9Suppose workers in the US produce 12 units of food or 3 yards of cloth in an hour's time; Mexican workers can produce 6 units of food or 9 yards of