Therapeutic Vs. Reproductive Cloning Essay

1813 words - 8 pages

For decades, cloning was merely a topic mentioned in the text of science fiction novels. It was simply a fictitious fantasy that proved to only be for entertainment purposes. However, while all those novels and films were being produced, a multitude of scientists attempted to make what society thought of as a dream, into a reality. The science of cloning is the process of making genetic duplicate of an organism. The scientific history of cloning spans more than 100 years dating back to 1885, and still going strong today. In general, there are two main purposes for cloning: therapeutic or reproductive. Reproductive cloning is performed with the intent of making a complete organism. Therapeutic cloning is performed to harvest stem cells for use in medical treatment, such as cloning organs for transplant. There are benefits and consequences for each process that have sparked ethical and scientific debate over the years. With the help of advancements in technology in the future, cloning can provide medical breakthroughs.
The process of cloning has existed for decades. Plants have been cloned for years now, although, cloning was never recognized until February 22, 1997 when the first mammal (Dolly the Sheep) was cloned from an adult cell (“Cloning Dolly The Sheep”). Dolly was named after Dolly Parton, the mammary cell that was cloned after giving birth at the Roslin Institute. The cloning of Dolly sparked much discussion and debate that has stuck around today. Dolly was the first successful reproductive clone. What first started out as the first ever demonstration of artificial embryo in 1885 quickly transformed into the success of cloning animals such as sheep, cows, and mice (“The History of Cloning”). With the help of decades of medical research and experiments, cloning a human is now possible. Because of technological advancements throughout the past few decades, more is possible with cloning, including reproductive cloning. Although controversial and constantly debated, with the help of reproductive cloning, one can clone an organ that an organism may need, causing the organism to ultimately survive longer.
Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer (SCNT) is the scientific name for the process of cloning. Clones made through SCNT are produced the same way; the only difference is what is done with the cloned embryos once they are created. Therapeutic cloning is intended for medical use. The therapeutic process mainly attempts to harvest embryonic stem cells for use in medical treatment, not to duplicate the organism. The embryonic stem cells are cells found in embryos that are currently developing and can be used to produce other cells. The therapeutic cloning process involves taking out the embryonic stem cells from the developing embryo causing the embryo to die. Once this is complete, disease-free cells are then taken from the medical patient and the nucleus is extracted. The cell is then transferred into an empty donor egg stimulated to divide using...

Find Another Essay On Therapeutic vs. Reproductive Cloning


1100 words - 5 pages Scientist are now able to clone human embryos. There are basically two ways to look at this issue: as a medical procedure with the potential to save and create lives or as medical experiments on developing human beings that may harm or end their lives. Cloning, whether for therapeutic or reproductive reasons is a very controversial and complex issue.Scientist in favor of allowing the cloning of human embryos argue that is a new source of stem

Should Human Cloning Be Pursued? Essay

1209 words - 5 pages cell divide into a blastocyst (“What Is Cloning?”). There are two main controversial types of cloning that come from SCNT which are reproductive and therapeutic cloning. Reproductive cloning involves the creation of another life and should be banned. “In therapeutic cloning … there [is no] implantation into the uterus to create a child” (Murnaghan). It is used to create stem cells for medical use and can save lives. The medical possibilities of

Human Cloning Examines the issue human cloning. Debates the pros and cons and the ethical issues surrounding the procedure. Describes political efforts to outlaw the process

1198 words - 5 pages repercussions.The science of cloning is not a new practice. In the 1962, a scientist named John Gurdon successfully cloned tadpoles (Plutonium, 1997). Also, according to the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, the term "cloning" is merely an umbrella term for the three main types of cloning. The three types of cloning are DNA cloning, reproductive cloning, and therapeutic cloning. The type of cloning that's discussed most in the media is reproductive cloning

Therapeutic Cloning

2585 words - 10 pages Cloning is the use of technology to compose a precise genetic copy of a living organism. The term ‘cloning’ can also be applied to copying cells, a gene or a part of DNA (Healey, J 2007). There are two main techniques of cloning: reproductive and therapeutic. Reproductive cloning is the cloning of a human being. Reproductive cloning has a lot of ethical barriers but some scientists believe that reproductive cloning may one day be legal

The Ethics of Human Cloning

1307 words - 5 pages Human cloning is separated into two major categories; reproductive cloning, which uses cloning technology to create a human embryo that will produce an entire human, and therapeutic, which adopt cloning into field of medical practices to find a cure for many diseases (Kass). Reproductive cloning requires a somatic cell, a DNA-less egg, and a surrogate mother; as a result, it creates a new individual with the same genome, or genetic coding. The

National Academy of Sciences: Human Cloning

954 words - 4 pages The National Academy of Sciences (NAS) made headlines when it issued a broadside that would, if followed by Congress, grant an open-ended license for biotech researchers to clone human life. True, the NAS recommended that Congress ban "reproductive" cloning, that is, the use of a cloned embryo to produce a born baby. But it also urged that human cloning for purposes of experimentation--often called "therapeutic" or "research" cloning--remain

Is Human Cloning Legal?

1287 words - 6 pages Human cloning has not been legally used in humans because many people and experts are still discussing its effectiveness, worthiness and effect on humanity. Human cloning, also known as human genetic engineering, can be divided into two main types, which are therapeutic cloning, growing cloned tissue from individual, and reproductive cloning, genetically identical copy of an individual. Human cloning have drawn people’s attention because people

Human Cloning Goes Global

874 words - 3 pages mother for development, is favored by many scientists. Therapeutic cloning, as distinct from reproductive cloning, will lead to unprecedented medical advances, say researchers. The human embryo is cloned, then used only for research or therapeutic treatments.   The object of reproductive cloning is to implant the cloned embryo into a surrogate mother and permit the human child to develop. Reproductive cloning is defended as a means of

Human Reproductive Cloning Should be Banned

1053 words - 4 pages Human Reproductive Cloning Should be Banned The issues concerning human reproductive cloning are shrouded in controversy, perhaps overshadowing the true advantages of cloning technology. Therapeutic cloning, which is often misunderstood as reproductive cloning, is less controversial than the latter as it does not involve the creating of an individual being. Instead, vital stem cells are extracted from human embryos, in order to generate

Cloning: The Benefits and Where to Draw the Line

2257 words - 10 pages ). Although the process of cloning is still developing, it is quickly becoming a reality. There are two distinct types of cloning: reproductive and therapeutic. Both processes can be achieved using the same technology called nuclear transfer. Nuclear transfer is defined by the Encyclopedia Britannica as “the introduction of the nucleus from a cell into an enucleated egg cell (an egg cell that has had its own nucleus removed).” This process can be

The controversy over cloning

2551 words - 10 pages procedures, as well as the rationalization behind both sides of each issue. The definition of cloning, found at, states that cloning is to "make multiple identical copies of a DNA sequence" or "to reproduce or propagate asexually." In order to fully understand the 'cloning' debate, one must differentiate between the two controversial types of cloning, which are described by this definition. Reproductive cloning and therapeutic

Similar Essays

Reproductive And Therapeutic Cloning Essay

1599 words - 6 pages Reproductive and Therapeutic Cloning Cloning is defined as the “creation of an exact copy of a living matter, such as a cell or organism” according to Encarta encyclopedia. The copies produced through cloning have identical genetic makeup and are known as clones. Scientists use cloning techniques in the laboratory to create copies of cells or organisms with valuable traits. Cloning is a controversial topic because new areas of science

Reproductive And Therapeutic Cloning: Dolly The Sheep

1606 words - 6 pages that the plasmids that have been used can also be used to change the genetic constitution of other organisms (1). Through the process mentioned above there has been an increase in the methods in which DNA, Reproductive and Therapeutic cloning and the processes that happen in order for cloning to occur. DNA Cloning occurs when the DNA cell is replicated, an organisms DNA is taken and placed in a Vector also known as plasmid. This self

The Ethics Of Cloning Essay

1717 words - 7 pages persons body (Cloning, 2011). According to one source, a long term solution to organ shortage is in fact an increased funding in therapeutic Cloning (Nelson, Rosenberg, Weiss, & Goodrich, 2009). Reproductive cloning referred to as “Dolly” cloning due to one of the most famous cases of this type of cloning, the cloning of a sheep called Dolly (Barnes). When it comes to this form of cloning it is perhaps one of the most controversial of the three

To Clone Or Not To Clone Part 2

794 words - 3 pages cloning: reproductive cloning, recombinant DNA cloning and therapeutic cloning. In this essay I will briefly describe the different types of cloning, why scientists pursue their research and why the public oppose cloning research. These issues have yet to be resolved and they raise public opinion on the morality of laboratory creation. When the media report on cloning in the news, they are usually referring to one type of cloning called