This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

There Is No Justification For The Terror In The U.S.S.R. In The 1930's

1838 words - 7 pages

There is No Justification for the Terror in the U.S.S.R. in the 1930's I agree more with the statement ‘There can be no justification
for the “terror” in the USSR in the 1930’s. It was motivated
purely by Stalin’s lust for power.’ However, I can understand why
one could say that terror was essential for the survival of the
new communist state or Soviet Union. Stalin used terror to force
the USSR to industrialise quickly, which enabled them to ward off
the threat from fascism and develop into a world power.

Source I, written by Mikhail Gorbachev in 1987 a few years before
communism fell in Russia, appears to be relatively balanced. It does
not accuse Stalin of using ‘terror’ methods, however is does not
overly praise him either. ‘Yes industrialisation… was indispensable..’
saying that Stalin needed to industrialise in the 1930’s to combat the
increasing threat of fascism. However, I believe that although
industrialisation was indispensable it could have occurred without the
use of “terror.” Gorbachev seems to make the point, though, that with
the benefit of hindsight, we can be critical of the way Stalin went
about the rapid industrialisation but, I think at the time, the threat
of fascism, being left behind industrially and preserving the new
communist state was a major concern to Stalin. Gorbachev also
mentioned that the tactics were contradictory to the principles of
socialism, which was a negative. Source I is a reasonably reliable
source because Gorbachev is the leader of Russia, at the time of the
writing, and therefore would have access to confidential files.
However, he could not speak freely to an extent because, as the leader
of the USSR, speaking to harshly about Stalin could be seen as
criticising the communist regime.

Source K partly agrees with Statement B because it states ‘without
terror, who would have failed to notice the clear absurdity of
Stalin’s rule?’ This shows that terror was necessary for Stalin to
remain in power, and I think that Stalin was crucial to the survival
of the USSR in these early days because without Stalin as a strong
leader there might have been a power struggle, which may have made the
USSR more vulnerable when Hitler invaded. Source K states that Stalin
needed to use terror to keep the people ‘obedient’ and more
importantly to make them ‘believe in him’. It seems that in the end
the Source believes he was a ‘ruthless politician’ who was corrupted
by power. Source K is reliable because, Adam Ulam, a historian in
Britain writes it. It is written in 1974 and, therefore, Ulam has
hindsight and large amounts of sources available for him to use.

Source J generally agrees with Statement A because it states ‘Stalin
was convinced that this...

Find Another Essay On There is No Justification for the Terror in the U.S.S.R. in the 1930's

Lynching in the 1930's Essay

595 words - 2 pages the ideas of racism and lynching.The majority of lynchings took place in the south, it is estimated that over 85% occurred in southern states, and another 10% occurred in Border States. The after burn of the civil war caused many slaveholders to become bitter against blacks that had finally received rights. This made it easier for a mob to begin, and a lynching to occur.Lynching was viewed as a normal occurrence that was morally wrong in no way

Ukrainian Genocide in the 1930's Essay

973 words - 4 pages Ukrainian Genocide in the 1930’s In the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, Famine is defined as “an extreme scarcity of food”. In 1932, Ukraine experienced a famine caused by the United Soviet Socialist Republic (USSR). The USSR was controlling most of western europe at the time, including “the bread-basket” a well known, fertile farming area. At the time, Joseph Stalin was the leader of Communist Russia, and the architect of the famine. The Great

Woody Guthrie Life in the 1930's

876 words - 4 pages a living as crop prices dropped. In 1935 the great dust storm called the "Black Blizzard" swept through Texas and left the land barren. Woody decided to move to Los Angeles, where his cousin Jack worked in the entertainment industry. (Gale; "Guthrie, Woody (1912-1967)", American Decades. 2003)In the early 1930's,Woody founded his first band called the Corncob Trio in Pampa, Texas. They played traditional songs for local barn dances, for audiences

Canada's Economic Condition in the 1930's

767 words - 3 pages changed were going to be made. Business and Government leaders all thought that the economy was only in a downturn. And People that studied the statistics all denied the fact that the decline started a few years before. Gradually all Canadians realized that this was no normal downturn in the business cycle. Although prices for goods dropped, salaries hit rock bottom. Farmers could no longer buy new machines, so the men and women were either laid off

Australia In The 1920's and the 1930's

1053 words - 4 pages Section A.A Group in the Interwar Period- The Stolen GenerationThe experience that the aboriginal had was quite significant first of all they were taken from there parents by the order of Government agencies, more than 30,000 children were removed from their parents and families, children and parents would have been crying for each other when this happened between 1900 and 1972.Children of mix decent were most targeted (eg the father is

Fascism in the 1920's and 1930's

1152 words - 5 pages that were stamped labeling them. Their businesses, homes, and their private belongings were taken away from them. In 1941, an order was made to annihilate all the Jews, it stated, "All Jews without exception are to be destroyed." In today's society if there was another depression like in the 1920's, and 1930's, it would take a lot for this world to turn to fascism. We have seen what happened in the past, and I don't think that anyone would

Soviet Women in the Early U.S.S.R

2455 words - 10 pages were women (Kurganoff 40) . Beginning in the late 1920’s, women gained rights in various areas. They acquired the right to own property, act as heads of households, participate as full members in rural communes and were paid as individuals rather than as part of a household for collective farm labor (Warshofsky Lapidus 60) . In regards to family law, changes in property relationships and inheritance laws weakened the family as an economic unit and

The League of Nations in the 1930's

890 words - 4 pages In the 1930's, there were two crises that happened in Manchuria and Abyssinia, which extremely embarrassed the League of Nations, and finally in the end, no more countries relied on the league it anymore. The crises were provocative to other countries and inevitable as Japan and Italy, they both were both in the league's security council and could have vetoed any action against them. In 1929, the Wall Street market crashed and countries

The World and Literature Changes in the 1930‘s

1126 words - 5 pages During, the 1930’s the world was in a time of great depression, with economic and political uncertainty fueled after the stock market crash in 1929. Many US banks failed, mortgages were foreclosed on homeowners. Croplands in the Midwest lost their topsoil and were ruined during the Dust Bowl drought, with many farmers relocating to California. Unemployment affected a large part of the work force, leaving a population of long-term joblessness

Havoc From the Dustbowl in the 1930's

952 words - 4 pages try and conclude why there was such an increase of mini fires and rain loss. Among these reporters was Robert E. Geiger, a commentator for the Washington D.C. Evening Star, who testified what happened on Black Sunday. April 15th, 1935, the day marked down in history as Black Sunday because of the sudden lack of sunlight in the sky. People looked up and saw nothing but a void, empty darkness swallowing the world. This was the commencing of the dust

This is a combined report about diferent guys in the mafia around the 1920's and 1930's

1805 words - 7 pages . Charles was arrested and locked up. While he was in jail his wife filed for a divorce. After that Charles vowed never to be arrested again. After Charles got out of jail and robbed another store he headed from the West to East Liverpool. He found it was safe to stay in a town called "Toms Town," (Kansas City). Hired Guns, murders, and successful mafia's hung out there. Here in "Toms Town" he learned how to use the machine gun. He also got

Similar Essays

How Plausible Is The Claim That There Is No Moral Justification For Warfare?

1149 words - 5 pages other governments had foreseen what the Nazis would do, they would probably have been right to invade Germany to remove Hitler in the early 1930's. This would have avoided far worse calamities that actually took place.Another subject to be considered, once a war is underway, is are there any moral restrictions on the numbers or kinds of deaths that may be brought about in pursuit of victory?"Killing must be necessary for a military objective

No Sugar By Jack Davis: Exposes The Mistreatment Of Australian Aborigines During The 1930's

1335 words - 5 pages written by Jack Davis in 1985, is one of these stage dramas. Jack Davis brings issues and even expresses his own ideas about issues such as the injustices of Aboriginal treatment during the 1930's, to life in No Sugar very well because No Sugar is a revisionist text, and therefore offers a new perspective of an Aboriginal point of view, on events which occurred during the time of the issue at hand. No Sugar, the revisionist stage drama written by

Entertainment In The 1930's Essay

761 words - 4 pages person who became famous in the 1930’s, there were many musicians as well. Some of the most famous musicians were Bing Crosby, Duke Ellington, and Harold Arlen. “Duke Ellington and his band were well known for playing genres of music such as the blues, gospel, and of course jazz.” (Walker n.pag.) Some of Bing Crosby’s most popular songs were "Swinging on a star","I'll get by as long as I have you", and “If I had a talking picture of you". (Walker

Radio In The 1930's Essay

1131 words - 5 pages Has anyone ever wondered how radio communications changed society during the 1930’s? According to the research done by the Education Foundation, many people believe that the most important development in the radio at that time was entertainment; this is entirely false. In fact, radio communications not only made an impact in the way people received their news, but also brought together a nation that got out of a brutal depression. Together, the