Things They Carried Essay: A Cultural Studies Approach To Enemies

592 words - 2 pages

A Cultural Studies Approach to "Enemies" in The Things They Carried  

 

Two men who fight over a jackknife in "Enemies", a chapter in Tim O'Brien's work, The Things They Carried.  A cultural studies approach to "Enemies" allows the reader to look much deeper into the meaning of the events that unfold in "Enemies".  The fight over the knife could very well reflect the events occurring in society during that time. 

        In short, "Enemies" is about two men, Lee Strunk and Dave Jensen, who are battling not only in a war but with each other.  They were viciously fighting about a missing jackknife.  A question that the reader might ask themselves is, why were they fighting over a jackknife? Did it have some special sentimental meaning?  These questions cannot be answered; they can only be left to wonder.

        Vietnam was a very mentally and physically strenuous war to fight.  At any given point any soldier could snap.  That is exactly what happened in O'Brien's short story.  Young men were basically thrown into a war zone and were expected to kill hundreds and thousands of people (some even innocent people) and not be phased by it.  That is just unrealistic.  Imagine waking up every morning and not knowing who you were going to kill that day or even if you were going to live through it.  Not many people have the mental capacity to continue day after day after day and not be phased by this.  Some of them must have been like walking zombies, trained to kill.  Not knowing why or how.  This mental strain is almost unimaginable for most youths today.

        After one considers these facts, they can begin to see why the brawl occurred.  The two characters...

Find Another Essay On Things They Carried Essay: A Cultural Studies Approach to Enemies

The Things They Carried: A Soldier's Burden

1009 words - 5 pages In “The Things They Carried,” Tim O’Brien brings to light the effects of war on soldiers, both physically and psychologically. The title of the story would lead the reader to believe the story is only about the provisions and apparatus a soldier would physically carry into war. After reading the entire story, it becomes evident that there are many burdens seen and unseen that soldiers face during times of war. In this story, O’Brien uses motif

The Things They Carried Essay

1581 words - 6 pages presented to him by his preacher father and an old hunting hatched wrapped in distrust for the white man courtesy of his grandfather. The author describes Kiowa in a nostalgic state laid out using his father's bible as a pillow. His exquisite and detailed description of Kiowa's interaction with the bible and how it feels and smells gives the reader an exclusive outlook. Clark argues that the things they carried were excessive and that the American

"The Things They Carried"

2145 words - 9 pages ; she has become a warrior. O'Brien says, "She was dangerous. She was ready to kill."(O'Brien 110). Smiley states that "women who never go to war are not innocent so much as they are ignorant of their own capacity for violence." (Smiley 604). Mary Anne is a symbol of how the war can change a woman. From a visibly feminine woman, she becomes fascinating with killing, abandons her boyfriend and becomes a part of Vietnam."The Things They Carried" is a

The Things They Carried

1707 words - 7 pages The Things They Carried, written by Tim O’Brein, is a story told through the eyes of members of a United States Army troop trudging their way through the Vietnamese country side and jungles during the Vietnam War. Each man has a specific job and so they carry specific belongings that they need to fulfill that job as well as a few mementos from home. These men also carry unseen baggage that is all too real to these men, their families and

The Things They Carried & A Soldiers Sweetheart

1203 words - 5 pages , “Sweetheart of the Song Tra Bong.” This is a story where love and war collide after a soldier brings his sweetheart to his Vietnamese post. On the whole, this chapter in The Things They Carried is far superior to the film, The Soldier’s Sweetheart, because it has thorough descriptions of characters’ feelings, including symbolism concerning objects and important events. When the audience is able to draw it's own story around an author's narrative, the

The Things They Carried

1515 words - 7 pages In The Things they carried, Tim O’Brien uses a large list of things a soldier carries. Weather it be a good luck charm, chewing gum, gun/ammunition or recreational drugs. This displays a window in to the emotional burdens that all soldier bear. One major burden for these poor soldier is confronting the tension between reality and fantasy. We see the tension in LT Jimmy Cross with his infatuation for Martha. Each day when the soldier made camp or

The Things They Carried

2795 words - 11 pages emotion associated with combat” (Van Ells 1). The fear of war begins for a soldier before they even get deployed. Every soldier hears the horror stories of war but never really understands till they are in war themselves. In the short story, “The Things They Carried” all the soldiers are constantly dreading every second. For example it is not good news when a high command orders the soldiers to search the tunnel before having to blow them up. No one

The Things they Carried

1053 words - 4 pages afraid of retribution from Strunk for not sticking to their pact. Strunk though the bitterness of being a cripple and the whole might confuse compassion for weakness. Most of the stories in `The Things They Carried' start off with descriptions of rugged, strong, silent, fighting soldiers. However the stories reveal that the soldiers are individuals with different experiences which influence the way they react to tragic and violent situations

The Things They Carried - 1000 words

1000 words - 4 pages "The Things They Carried," is a fiction story-telling book about the Vietnam War by Tim O'Brien that describes the physical and emotional burdens the men carry not only during their time in Vietnam but also years after leaving the warfront. The book is a series of stories told with O'Brien as the main narrator. O'Brien tells of the journey he takes alongside his unit, revealing his fight for courage and decision to commit to the serving in the

The Things They Carried - 641 words

641 words - 3 pages The Things They Carried by Tim O'BrienIn the short story The Things They Carried by Tim O'Brien, the author explores human nature and the emotions that are carried with them. This emotional baggage is represented by the love that a soldier feels towards a girl back home. It is contrasted by the everyday things they carry while at war. Ultimately this story deals with the theme of growing up and taking responsibility.One of the clever aspects of

the things they carried

1095 words - 5 pages Wars tends to be the matter of historical record and soldiers are considered as emotionless machines just obeying the orders in the war. Nobody cares about the individual soldier who actually fights in a war. "The Things They Carried" by Tim O'Brien is about a soldier who is trying to communicate with civilians and tell them what he went through before and during the war. At times there is recitation of the uninteresting items

Similar Essays

Things They Carried Essay

1188 words - 5 pages were thin and arched like a woman’s” (O’Brien 124). O’Brien makes the description about the dead man to make it personal. The poem by Thomas Hardy does not give an illustration about the man that is dead. I believe that The Things They Carried chapter was more effective because it shows that the person that dies is personal and not just a solider from the opposing side. 2. When Tim O’Brien starts with a description of the man that dies in “The

The "Things They Carried" Essay

1302 words - 6 pages in life, such as standing up for Linda, many choices later on would be easier to make “I should’ve stepped in; fourth grade is no excuse. Besides, it doesn’t get easier with time, and twelve years later, when Vietnam presented much harder choices, some practice at being brave might’ve helped a little.” (221). Big part of the things the soldiers do are done out of the same reason that made Tim go to war, “Men killed, and died, because they were

Things They Carried Essay: Strength In The Things They Carried

981 words - 4 pages changing from being a weak man who can't focus on what he has to do, to a man who now realizes his job, and will make damn sure to get it done right. Both of the points of view are valid arguments. Both are well thought out and have good evidence to back them up. So which one is the right one? Well, that's the great thing about short stories like "The Things They Carried," they are open to interpretation. The reader is the one to decide what it

The Things They Carried Essay

563 words - 2 pages Chandy Thorn Thorn 1Cynde DelauderEnglish 11130 September 2014"In many respects, Tim O'Brien's The Things They Carried concerns the relationship between fiction and the narrator" (Friedlander 1). The story that O'Brien writes is not a true story, however he can relate to it because he was an active participant in Vietnam. Tim O'Brien wrote much more than a war time story. Tim O'Brien wrote a Story, of pain, hardship, love, and the heavy burdens