Thinking In Terms Of Maslow's Hierarchy Of Need And Vroom's Expectancy Theory Answer The Following Question: Does Pay Motivate?

1889 words - 8 pages

Motivation is not a 'one-size-fits-all' topic and often the role of personality differences, and in particular an individuals 'thinking style', is often overlooked. Everyone has their own personal motivators, intrinsic and extrinsic, two general themes seem to run through most of the research I have completed, expectancy and equity, these theories argue that whatever the remuneration employees need to be fairly treated, fairly rewarded and where performance related pay comes into discussion, that all employees should be in possession of the ability to perform the task for the performance-related pay to be effective. However, Victor Vroom (1), who based his studies on extensive 500 research investigations, concludes that there is no all-embracing motivational theory. Handy (2) suggests that the research for the definitive solution to the motivation problem, only a part of which is a fair rate of pay, is another endless quest for the Holy Grail in organisational theory. Porter and Lawler (4) emphasised that the expectancy theory is just a framework of requirements for motivational strategies. Equity and expectancy theory do not provide managers with a direct recommendation, but with a model within which performance-related pay schemes can be operated willingly and successfullyMaslow's hierarchy of needs is one of the earliest theories, (1) and translates into the "What's in it for me?" theory; Maslow suggested five levels of need:1. Physiological: biological needs such as food and drink2. Safety/security: a secure and non-threatening environment3. Belongingness: social needs, a sense of attachment and affiliation4. Esteem: both self-esteem and esteem from others5. Self-actualisation: the need for self-fulfilment, achieving potential.Maslow suggests that once a level of need was satisfied, it no longer acted as a motivator and the next level of need had to be brought into play in order to motivate the individual. According to Maslow the level of need we all strive for is Self Actualisation, but he also suggests that none of us achieve this. Maslow's theory is popular because it is simple to understand and seems to be common sense; however it has been proved to have several flaws and to me this theory does not offer any practical advice to managers in order to motivate their teams.The fact is, motivating people at work is a very complex issue and, to really be able to use motivation techniques effectively, leaders, and managers need to understand the principles behind some of the leading theories in this area.Money as a RewardDepending upon how it is handled, money can either be a great motivator or a great de-motivator (5). Financial rewards can be cash incentives, raises, or bonuses. Cash incentives can motivate employees to meet a difficult goal, but they could also possibly cause employees to compete against each other instead of working together (6) Other flaws money has as a motivator is that its impact is short-lived, it becomes an expected...

Find Another Essay On Thinking in terms of Maslow's Hierarchy of Need and Vroom's Expectancy Theory answer the following question: Does pay motivate?

Drawing on both expectancy and equity theory, identify and discuss the main factors that are likely to influence the effectiveness of performance-related pay schemes in organisations.

1165 words - 5 pages performance. Another possibility arises when employee thinks that employer's opinion towards him is negatively or positively biased. This will affect his perception of the link between performance and reward, instrumentality. In that case performance pay is unlikely to change worker's driving force significantly, if at all. However, one can argue that the most important factor of all in Victor Vroom's expectancy theory is the idea of valence. "The

Crime and Punishment: Do you agree with the moral "crime does not pay"? Refer to at least two texts in your answer.

1929 words - 8 pages The saying that “crime does not pay” lies at the heart of a great deal of literature and many films. It appears in a large number of fairy tales and children’s story. This is to teach children from an early age that it is wrong to commit a crime, no matter how small, and that every criminal is eventually punished. Of course this is not true, many crimes, especially smaller crimes, are never punished. This can either be because no

Crime and Punishment: Do you agree with the moral "crime does not pay"? Refer to at least two texts in your answer.

618 words - 2 pages Organised crime is Britain's fourth-largest industry with an annual turnover in excess of £20 billion. The biggest players are the international syndicates - the Mafia, the Triads, the Colombian drug cartels - all of which are organised like multinational corporations with presidents and vice presidents at the top and poorly-paid shift workers at the bottom.So far as home-grown talent is concerned, in the 1960s and 1970s it was simple. You

A Proposal to Review How David McClelland’s Need Theory and Manpower System Help us to motivate our staff

2311 words - 10 pages manpower system is not appropriate, we need to make the change. Objectives Due to face different problems, so we need to develop some of the ways to motivate our employees to raise our company's competitiveness. In this review I will suggest the following two goals.  explain the methods of motivating - David McClelland’s Need Theory to our staff and  Describe how use the new manpower system to increase our staff's motivate and efficiency

How does power refect the choices people make? Refer and link to Monatna 1948 by larry watson, and 2 other texts of videos to support your answer to the question

1153 words - 5 pages . 'Uganda's Stolen Youth' is a feature article that shows the lack of power that children have, in third world countries. It uses large headings and quotes throughout the article to emphasise, communicate and persuade the key idea easily. 'Remember the Titans,' staring Denzel Washington is a movie that explores prejudice and the changing values of a football team and the community they live in. The visual text and feature article both have common

Write a short piece about your own social identity. Drawing on this, answer the following question: 'Critically evaluate the claim that 'collective social identities are both inclusive and exclusive'.

4321 words - 17 pages '.(Giddens, 2001 p.247)Some sociologists would agree that ethnicity stresses some sort of cultural distinctiveness. What concerns me is that if ethnicity stresses cultural distinctiveness then we would all be classified with this label. The answer to my own question is not. In Britain it is most often associated with minority groups only as:'A population whose members believe that in some sense they share common descent and a common cultural heritage

Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs

1068 words - 4 pages no unimaginable, unexpected or unfamiliar dangers will ever appear." (p. 380). In both of these situations, the abnormal mind is searching for a way to meet the need for safety and does so the only way it deems possible, which appears as abnormal behavior.. After meeting the physical needs through the first two steps of Maslow's hierarchy, the human need for belongingness, friendships, and love emerges. This need causes us to seek familiarity

An essay about Flannery O'Connor's short story titled, Revelation. The question: To what extent does Mary Grace initiate Mrs. Turpin into a new way of thinking? Critical Analysis. (500 words)

1295 words - 5 pages God reveals to her, disappointment and confusion consume her perfect mind. She still does not see a need to change.The story begins with Mrs. Turpin entering a doctor's waiting room with her husband, Claud, who has been kicked by a cow. As she and Claud wait, she takes a hard look at the other people in the room. As she views the waiting patients, she categorizes each one. She notes a woman she labels white-trash, a young red haired woman who

Abraham Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs

1595 words - 6 pages other four. This is the highest level of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. People at this level are self-aware and concerned with personal growth. They are less concerned with what other people think and more concerned with fulfilling their own potential. Unlike the lower levels this need is never fully satisfied. As a person grows psychologically there are always new opportunities to learn and grow from. Theory Application to Teaching In my

In-Depth Summary of Expectancy Theory

1300 words - 5 pages In-Depth Summary of Expectancy Theory In today’s organization, there is a need for ways in which to effectively motivate employees. Expectancy theory addresses the underlying issues that are associated with the belief that a performance or outcome is attainable. Developed initially by Edward Tolman and Kurt Levin, introduction of the theory into the workplace was not achieved until quite some time later by Victor Vroom (Bradt, 1996). It is

International Relations Theory: Changes in the Hierarchy of International Politics

1786 words - 7 pages "Should international relations theory be held accountable for explaining fundamental changes in the hierarchy of international politics and the emergence of new actors?" It seems absurd to answer that international relations theory should not be in the business of explaining fundamental changes in international politics. However, this response paper will argue on both edges of the question. First, it actually does make sense to attempt to hold

Similar Essays

Maslow's Hierarchy Of Need Essay

1603 words - 6 pages Maslow's Hierarchy of Need INTRODUCTION Many managers are puzzled by the question why some workers doing easy job remain dissatisfied, while others engaged in performance of complicated tasks are completely satisfied? What should be done for the people to work better? What stimulates their desire to work? Only knowing what are the main factors stimulating a man to act, what kind of motives lay as a basis of a man’s activities, one can

Motivating Employees With Maslow's Hierarchy Of Needs, X/Y Theory And Expectancy And Contingency Theory

1105 words - 4 pages Hierarchy of Needs (Maslow's)Maslow theorized that if he could figure out what made productive people work, he could apply the technique to motivate others, thus creating the hierarchy of needs (Peak, 2007, p. 38).A. Example: Success depends on motivation, Peak (2007) cites Sam Walton as a unique example because he "solicited-and valued-employee input" when he went to his store and talked with the night laborers inquiring about their physical

Maslow's Hierarchy Of Needs Theory Essay

2775 words - 11 pages theory is also known as Maslow’s hierarchy of need theory.This theory is defined as the individual needs,that is the steve jobs needs.And then steve jobs needs are divided in to five levels,the levels are self actualization, esteem ,social ,safety , physiological.Safety and physiological has great important.   CONCLUSION Steve jobs is a level three leader and his leadership and

Common Management Theories: Abraham Maslow's Hierarchy Of Needs Theory And Douglas Mc Gregor's Theory X And Theory Y

1287 words - 5 pages During the 1950's early management theorist, Abraham Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs theory and Douglas McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y, represented a period in the development of motivation concepts. A comparative review sets a foundation for practicing managers, who chose regularly to use their terminologies in explaining employee motivation. Even though these theories are now heavily disputed and there validity called into question, they are