This Essay Argues Against The Insanity Plea. It Gives About 5 Points/Arguments That Prove The Defense Faulty, And Tell That It Should Be Abolished From Court Rooms.

1081 words - 4 pages

Crimes are committed everyday, by many different people all over the world. Crime is something that seems impossible to defeat, with some crimes more magnificent than others. These crimes are all inexcusable and those people who commit crimes should be punished. The punishment should fit the crime, meaning that, if you do something extreme, like murder someone, you should not be allowed to defend yourself by reasoning of insanity. No crime, especially a murder should go uncharged which is why the insanity plea should be abolished. It allows for the "mentally insane" people to go virtually unpunished for their crime. For hundreds of years civilized courts have recognized that, when a person who is mentally unstable is accused of a crime, it is a special circumstance and they must be deal with in a different manner than a sane person would.Granted the opponent must have some valid points and arguments, but arguments that oppose the insanity plea use much stronger and logical reasoning.One reason the insanity plea should be abolished is that it imposes a threat on the safety of the innocent and sane, American public. A large number of Americans feel that the insanity plea should be erased or altered to protect their own safety. One idea would be to prevent the use of the insanity plea when more extreme cases such as murder are on trial. Using the insanity plea in a murder case and getting away with it shakes the security of American people. Would anyone like to know that a murder who had left the mental institution after pleading mentally insane would be walking shoulder to shoulder with them or someone they loves out on the streets. This is a great fear behind the insanity defense because many non-guilty verdicts have set the violent offender free and he committed another violent crime.Another fault of the insanity plea is that mistaken diagnosis is a very real and serious possibility. Whether the mental symptoms are diagnosed by observation and evaluation, or by performing tests and taking x-ray pictures, there is an uncomfortably large margin of error.Malfunctions of the brain still remain a mystery in the scientific world, and if they are not understood a sane person posing as insane could be mis-diagnosed. Of course, what is sometimes known as mistaken diagnosis is simply the doctor being bribed to declare the offender insane. When one doctor or a number of doctors declare their patient is insane it gives the jury no reason to believe he is not insane, which leaves the man free as a bird.Most of the testimonies given in court when there is an insanity defense is being used, are given by medical doctors and psychologists. The average juror who has not been through medical school and attained his degree in medicine cannot always understand the doctors' testimonies.While the jurors are still trying to comprehend what the doctors have said, things become more confusing. The doctors often have different views and opinions on the same matter, and all...

Find Another Essay On This essay argues against the insanity plea. It gives about 5 points/arguments that prove the defense faulty, and tell that it should be abolished from court rooms.

The Insanity Defense Part I When is the insanity plea a reasonable and

866 words - 3 pages defect of reason from disease of the mind' as to not realize what they were doing or why it was a crime" {The Washington Post. 27 Feb 1998. John P. Martin27 October 2004. .Most people believe that the insanity defense should be abolished because many criminals now use it to escape crime, and because it is now being rampantly used; part of this is true, but should the insanity defense be abolished because of the act of a few scheming criminals? what

Regardless of the nature of the disease, 'palliative care' should be available for all dying people. Identify and briefly evaluate some arguments for and against this assertion.

1860 words - 7 pages In this essay I shall firstly give a description of what palliative care is. I will discuss the modern hospice and the history of care provided in early hospices. Secondly I shall review the care that people with incurable diseases receive. In order to do this, I will gather evidence from course materials and other literature to examine the expanding hospice movement, and look at the arguments for and against the expansion of palliative care

Boiling Points and Democracy Arguments for and against puplib judicial nomination

928 words - 4 pages Supreme Court nominees. Likewise, Paul Martin, successor to Jean Chrétien and new Prime Minister of Canada, has pledged to formulate a tactic to involve parliament in the appointment process of Supreme Court judges. Martin's Liberal proposal is a form of mutual satisfaction. Acknowledging that some secrecy needs to be amputated from the limbs of the selection process, although protecting appointed judges from questioning by the House of

This essay argues that the legal age to drink in the U.S. is to low. It supports this with explaining how it would help binge drinking, and gives examples.

870 words - 3 pages the alcohol.From researching this issue, I believe that it would be beneficial to lower the drinking age to 18. Eighteen year olds are seen in the eyes of the law as adults. They are allowed to vote, make large purchases, apply for and receive credit, begin a credit history, and fight in combat. Yet, they are legally unable to purchase or consume alcohol. I feel that there should be a consistent definition of being an adult. If, an individual is

Can and Should Sociology be Value Free. this essay is about the aim of sociology that is to be value free and whether it can and should achieve that aim

2145 words - 9 pages behaviors and society thus making it prone to personal views and value judgments. He recognized that values would influence the choice of topics for study. The reason for his claim was, sociologists had to choose from the vast knowledge in sociology to be studied. Inevitably, this will result value judgments to be made. Weber also believed that once a topic has been chosen, researchers should be objective in conducting experiments and proving their

This essay is about the upsides and downsides of capitalism and why it isn't the utopian government that many people believe it to be.

1793 words - 7 pages the right of life, freedom and property" . This also happens to be the role of a Capitalist government in any society. A capitalist government does not interfere with its society unless someone is infringing the rights of someone else. Capitalism is good in that it best represents human nature whether human nature is morale or not. Humans survive based on their ability to reason through situations and beyond the idea of justice most people believe

Socrates-not perfect- I got a A- at UC Berkeley on it Essay on how Socrates arguments are contradictory and can be proven faulty. This essay proves a few of Socrates arguments faulty.

1249 words - 5 pages many of his points due to considering his argument "absolute". Instead of leaving room for plausible error in his theory, he instead chooses to conclude it is "right" and final. Ironically, Socrates preaches the fact that he knows nothing and that he considers himself to be unwise. This said, however, Socrates then gives himself too much credit in The Crito and for someone that admits not knowing everything. He sure seems to deem his argument correct and not needing for correction, which ultimately is why his argument is faulty.

This Essay deals with the Civil Rights movement. It talks about events that define that era.

648 words - 3 pages Luther King Jr. wanted the same things for his people that were stated in the essay by Stokley. Through his efforts, some of those things were achieved, but not from a fight by the people against the movement.The anti-Civil Rights movement could be greatly defined by the writings of the FBI in an attempt to overthrow King and his supporters. They were becoming seriously concerned that the movement would cause a major uproar among King's rivals which

Abortion should NOT be illegal. This is a persuasive essay that shows the good that could come out of an abortion and why it should continue to be legal for women to CHOOSE to have an abortion

985 words - 4 pages commit crimes." If the child was expected and was planned, most likely the parents will take the proper precautions in having a baby, such as getting financially situated and having a nice home in a good neighborhood.Abortion can be very necessary in special cases. Consider this: a 12-year-old girl is walking home from her school, and she is raped. After a doctor's checkup, she finds out that she is pregnant. This is a twelve-year-old girl, should

Killing Our this essay is about juvenile capital punishment. It explains why capital punishment for juveniles should be abolished.

801 words - 3 pages Massachusetts in 1642 (Cothern). This punishment seems to be from another time, but executions of kids still happen in 23 states today. It is condoned by some as justice and order, but others argue that it takes life away aimlessly. In 2001, 65 people were executed for the crimes they were convicted of in the United States, many of them for crimes they committed while they were still minors. 361 people have been killed for crimes they committed

This essay states that the death penalty is an effective punishment in some respects. It gives both fact and statistics and proves a very good point.

1426 words - 6 pages someone kills anotherthey should be punished. This process cost over 400,000 of dollars.I would say my that money is well spent. If it is going to stop a crazyman from killing again then so be it. I don't know if it is immoralor cruel. I do know that no human should be able to play the part of Godor the Devil. People are suppose to live and die, we can't make someonelive if there no life. We can stop someone from dying when there alive.Were not

Similar Essays

The Insanity Defense, "Innocent By Reason Of Insanity", Should Be Reformed Or Abolished

1909 words - 8 pages States, or it should be abolished in all criminal cases.The controversy over the insanity defense comes from the many different interpretations of insanity and the different notions of how to deal with those people who are truly insane. The insanity and incompetence defenses are considered by many to be defenses by excuse, where a defendant may argue that he/she should not be held criminally liable for breaking the law, as they were mentally ill

Gay Marriage Why It Should Be Legal, And The Arguments Against It

1597 words - 6 pages Gay MarriageWhy It Should Be Legal, And The Arguments Against ItThey say that America is the land of the free; the freedom to privacy, the freedom of speech, and especially the freedom of religion. In today's society, homosexuality is everywhere you go. You can find it in books, in the media, and especially on the television. Homosexuality is quickly being the norm of today's world. Obviously there has been a much greater acceptance towards

Against The Insanity Defense. Essay

1238 words - 5 pages (Paquette 2002:77).All of these reasons suggest that the best alternative, when it comes to the insanity defense, is abolishment. This doesn't mean that it should be eliminated altogether, but that improvements need to be made, or a new type of insanity defense needs to be created to eliminate the deficits of the current insanity defense (Linhorst & Dirks-Linhorst 1999:71). Without some sort of change the insanity defense will not be supported as

Dying With Dignity Is About The Whole Process Of Pas Ph. Assisted Suicide. It Gives Good Arguments On Why Pas Should Be Permitted In All States.

994 words - 4 pages have a therapist to help them make the right decision.The physician should have papers mandatory for the patient to sign. This would insure that that is what the patient wanted, and would keep the doctor out of the danger of possible lawsuits.In closing, I think that PAS should be permissible only under the terms as stated above. Before making your decision of which way to go, think about living a life of pain, and maybe even embarrassment, only